Travel
The Temple Mount on foot
Ron Peled
Published: 21.02.06, 09:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
19 Talkbacks for this article
1. playing games of deception
Fares ,   USA   (02.21.06)
israel is trying to project to the whole world that the alaqsa mosque is the dome of the rock (the golden dome )..so when they destroy the mosque the israeli criminals will show the world on TV that the dome is intact ..beautiful ,golden .. 1.4 muslims know the trick ,it is part of our teaching in preschool how the israeli are trying to trick us .
2. warning
sameer ,   al quds   (02.21.06)
stop such stuped allegations, the muslems never built mosques on holly place for others, the place is completely islamic with all buildings and yards, be sure any stupid action in the mosque will be the begining of the end of ,,,,,,,,,
3. Alaqsa mosque is the second mosque built to worship Allah
(02.22.06)
between it and the Kaabah in Mecca 40 years. Kaabah in Mecca was built by Ibrahim and Ishmael. For more information, see: http://www.alaqsa-online.net/
4. To all Muslims; Jerusalem belongs to the Jews!
Daisy ,   USA   (02.22.06)
Mecca belongs to the Muslims! Jerusalem has been the center of Jewish life thousands of years before the Muslims came and occupied and destroyed hundreds of Jewish holy sites. God gave the Jews Jerusalem and that is the final word!
5. Muslims above me, keep your twisted lies to yourselves
(02.22.06)
The mount of the house is the holiest place to us since 3000 years ago when King Shlomo built the temple house on it, which was destroyed by the Persians and later rebuilt by the Roman governer of provincia Judea and destroyed by the same Romans in 70 ac, the venoumos propoganda dripped to you since you were kids cannot change it. "it is part of our teaching in preschool how the israeli are trying to trick us . " Thanks for admitting you and all Muslim fundamentals are nothing but brainwashed tools, incapable of thinking and progressing, what else did they teach you in preschool? that the yahud make bread from the blood of Muslim babies? cant be too far.
6. Photos of Evidence of Jewish Ruins on Har ha-Bayit
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (02.22.06)
To grind an ecumenical axe by stating that "There are no Jewish ruins on the face of the mountain" in the same page as acknowledging Herod's walls and stones is contradictory and vacuous. There are photographs, from the well-known Biblical Archeology Review, proving the Jewish ruins on the mountain -- as well as proving the bulldozing and deliberate destruction and removal of Jewish ruins by Muslims of the Islamic Waqf from Har ha-Bayit, particularly the eastern wall predating Herod's addition to the north of the "Seam," can be seen at http://www.netzarim.co.il/Museum/Sukkah01/Sukkah01.htm For an Israeli newspaper to collude with Muslims in their attempt to disprove the ancient, indigenous Jewish presence on Har ha-Bayit is at once disgraceful and laughable. Paqid 16, The Netzarim Israeli Orthodox Jew www.netzarim.co.il
7. Mecca and al-Aqsa
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (02.22.06)
That Islam believes in Avraham is because their only pre-6th-century C.E. documentation is the Jewish Bible. If Muslims reject the Jewish Bible then Islam has no basis. However, if Muslims accept the Jewish Bible then it invalidates Islam. Displacement theology is strictly for the ignorant masses controlled by dictatorial human clerics. Before the 6th-century C.E., the Kaba was a pagan temple and the Arabs practiced paganism. That's the record according to all of the pre-6th-century documentation. Google that. There is no connection between the Kaba and "Ibrahiml" Get out of Islamic ignorance and insist on the earliest extant documentation and logic. You'll learn a lot -- that you don't want to know. Paqid 16, The Netzarim Israeli Orthodox Jew www.netzarim.co.il
8. Islamic Lies
Shaka ,   New York   (02.23.06)
Muslims not only lie to the world but have begun to believe their own lies. The truth is that the Temple mount is only important to Islam because they are jelous that God chose the Isaac and the Jews instead of Ishmael and the Arabs. Their whole religion seems based on changing the facts bible so that they are no longer the illegitimate sons of God. The same goes for the temple mount Mohammed never came to Jerusalem and any real muslim scholar will tell you that. The only time Jerusalem was important for the Muslims was when either they did not control it or they where making a political point. All Muslims know that Jerusalem is the holy place of the Jews even Muhammed Knew that. When Muslims try to disconnect Jews fromt the most holy site in Jeudaism all know that they are liers. It is if Jews build a temple in mecca or medina and say that it is holy to Jew it is Upsurd. Muslims that are reading this should know they hurt themselves with this issue and even Muhammed knew that Jerusalem is holy to Jews. So stop the lies.
9. Temple Mount
Gershon ,   New York, USA   (02.23.06)
Disgusting; can't a Jewish newspaper at least see SOME Jewish value to the Mount instead of describing it as though it were Mecca?
10. the Waqf has tried to erase Jewish outcroppings
bob ,   potomac md usa   (02.24.06)
For decades ,the Waqf has been paving over indications of The Second Temple--photogrphic evidence of these vandalistic acts have appeared in Biblical Archeology Rerview in articles by real scholars--not publicists. --but despite the Muslim attempts , signs of the Jewish Temple comiplex are still there--So your whole argument is incorrect.
11. ron715@netvision.net.il
Ron Cantrell ,   United States   (02.27.06)
Since there was no mosque in Jerusalem in Muhammad's time, where could he have gone on that night journey??? According to Islamic sources in Egypt, he went to Medina, not Jerusalem. Let's try to get the story straight and use some logic.
12. Where have all the Muslims gone?
Daisy ,   USA   (02.27.06)
They can't handle the truth.
13. 2 - & mosque in istanbul turkey is built on a what? a CHURCH
mike ,   usa   (03.10.06)
sameer, you just sound like a terrorist - threats and misinformation. must be a genetic thing.
14. why fighting in here :-) i enjpyed the article!!!
Sam, USA   (03.12.06)
15. Muslim Buildings on Temple Mount Should Be Removed.
Michael ,   Bella Vista, AR, USA   (03.18.06)
The buildings there are there for political reasons not because there is anything important to Islam there. Lets be honest, Allah is not YHWH. Why do the Israelis allow people who worship an evil entity called Allah to be at the most sacred of places? Also the arabs are removing artifacts and probably destroying history with their digging at the site. If it were up to me, I'd bulldoze those buildings and send the parts to mecca.
16. Jerusalem belongs to the Jews!
Leslie ,   San Pedro, CA   (07.20.06)
Amen! I don't recall David buying the land and wanting to build "The Temple" on the Holy site to honor Allah. But rather the ONE True GOD.
17. al-aqsa didn't exist when mohammed was alive.
(07.28.06)
Al Aqsa was built 93 years after mohammed died. He never ascended into heaven from that spot. MUSLIMS ARE EITHER LYING. OR MISINTERPRETING THE THEIR QURAN. I personally believe muslims are lying to lay claim to jerusalem for ideological and political purposes.
18. Jerusalem is for Jews, Christians & Muslims. Get over it!
Zechariah Goldberg ,   Australia   (08.29.07)
Look, lets face it - Jerusalem has become a place for all three faiths for centuries: Judaism, Christianity and Islam. We know that the original inhabitants of Jerusalem are Jews and that Israel is our Promised Land, and we've got our own country and able to administer it. Now we just need to stop playing dirty politics with other communites, particularly with the Arabs, and live coexistently them. Not all the Muslims in Israel are Arabs anyway, some even have Jewish ancestors and what makes them different is their Islamic faith (eg Joseph Cohen and his family). You have to let go off the past in making Israel the land wholly for Jews only or there is never going to be peace. Leave the Dome of Rock alone. Leslie, what are you talking about? The Muslims are worshipping the One true unseen God like the Jews. The Koran never said that the Al Aqsa was built during the time of Muhammad. It just said that Muhammad ascended to heaven with a flight animal called buraq from a rock, accompanied along with Angel Gabriel - which is what I believe is the rock which is now in the Dome of the Rock. In fact, the Quran refers to the "sites established by Abraham and his progeny as houses of worship to Allah centuries before the revelation of the Qur'an." [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Aqsa_Mosque#Islamic_Background] The Muslims and Arabs trying to get the Jewish of the territory in Israel and vice versa is more of an extremist political movement, using religion as a motive to achieve their agenda. This is why Caliph Omar Al-Khattab didn't want to pray at the destructed Temple of Solomon because he knew that if he did it, Muslims would start claiming the area only for them. Anyway, that's the past and the Dome of Rock has been built as a mosque. The only problem now is just the stubborn and extreme Arabs and Jews wanting the whole area separately for themselves. The Dome of Rock could have been shared with the Jews - perhaps certain section of the mosque is dedicated for them to pray. Sharing is caring, greed = war. I guess that'll solve the problem. Shalom.
19. Re: every mosque faces Mecca
Ron Ardell ,   Surrey, UK   (08.20.08)
I believe this is not quite correct. The very first mosque was buit with a mihrab on the wall facing Jerusalem. There was some falling out with the local Jews, and a new mihrab was added - facing Mecca. I recall that this is called the "mosque with the two mihrabs".
Back to article