News
Officials: Civilian deaths in IAF attacks down
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 07.03.06, 12:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
26 Talkbacks for this article
1. the title says it
(03.07.06)
"nothing can be guaranteed; this is a war" which the palestinians have voted and ignited for. now face the consequeces.
2. Don't hide behind your children and women
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (03.07.06)
Geneva Convention: Article 28 states that "protected persons may not be used to render certain points or areas immune from military operations," nullifying the Argument that the IDF violates Intl. Law.
3. If it is war,why should .......
Khalil ,   Nablus   (03.07.06)
the israelis cry for their civilian victims ???/?Ofcourse the answer is clear...the palestinian blood is cheap
4. #3
G ,   shomron   (03.07.06)
There is a huge difference between accidentaly killing civilians (who are not so innocent as hamas is in power thanks to them) and purposely targeting civillians which the arabs do with great joy.
5. Khalil: You intentionally will hit babies via snipers
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (03.07.06)
you intentionally hide cowardly behind your children - send them up front - hoping that they get killed - and can be used for your vile propaganda You have NO respect for human lives one bit - not even your own USING children: YOU do http://switch3.castup.net/cunet/gm.asp?format=wm&s=F2A8DD0D6B8149268348A1EF7EE27449&ci=13673&ClipMediaID=19647 Children training: http://switch3.castup.net/cunet/gm.asp?format=wm&s=224A060FE93541A2A905E1FB334F30B7&ci=12948&ClipMediaID=18959 Ask for Death: http://www.isratv.com/video/filmpmwadsl.asx The Ultimate Childabuse: http://judaism.c.tclk.net/maabuDAaa0OIUa6KtLde/ Only animals behave like this: You are not even respecting your own
6. Israel - Committed to Lose the War
Marcel ,   Florida   (03.07.06)
Instead of going in to finish the jihadists off on one fell swoop ,Israel does it in a small negligable manner that keeps the failed status quo going. The never ending war stratdegy of Israel's corrupt politicians is because they are controlled by the global superpower which supports the Arab agenda against Israel. This is why the U.S. makes sure that their corrupt politicians in Israel do not go in a defeat the enemy once and for all. These piecemeal removal of a few terrorists at a time are acceptable under the Bush doctrine of 'Israel defeated by the Palestinian's' as they feed the illusion that Israel is doing somewthing . Deception ,but no victory . The Jews are not permitted victory by the globalist . Salah Bardawil, Hamas spokesman, said ; "We are not seeking immunity or mercy from Israel. We are in a confrontation. The side that is most steadfast is the side that will survive," he said Israel is steadfast in retreat and rewarding the terrorists and this is the stratdegy of losers. Something that the U.S.,E.U. and U.N. is quite comfortable with.
7. Khalil: Face Reality of your ideology
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (03.07.06)
http://www.pierrerehov.com/
8. Marcel , Go Home you foolish Goy
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (03.07.06)
Never a single good word you have..... why come here when all you do is spew HATE
9. Justify
Libyan Guy ,   Italy   (03.07.06)
Israel can justify always the killing of arabs but as you said (its a war). so don't blame Palestnieans, because they don't have hi-tech war planes or an organized army, like you do. anyhow, your dirty occupation can't, won't and will never win the will of freedom and the days are to show you this fact ... israel is getting smaller and smaller, less and less and its up to you to decide for the future of your children, teach them how to respect others ...
10. And You Still Want To Vote For Kadima
Zev ,   Israel   (03.07.06)
HAMAS LEADER: WE WANT TO CHANGE THE RULES OF THE GAME... Hamas’ top leader said that his group “wants to change the rules of the game” by refusing to recognize Israel as the Palestinian leaders Hamas deposed in January’s election had. He called the idea of ending the campaign of violence “unrealistic.” Khalid Mash'al gave an interview to Al-Arabiyya after returning from a visit to Moscow in which he said that the Palestinians had gained nothing from the Palestinian Authority’s recognition of Israel. Mash'al said the Road Map peace process “does not exist anymore.” He said it was “abandoned by the sponsors.” Referring to Israel’s Gaza pullout, its future plans for withdrawals from the West Bank and its determination to set final borders, Mash'al said, “What we now have is a unilateral disengagement plan.”
11. Libyan Guy ,Italy: You Westend of an Eastbound donkey
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (03.07.06)
go and learn facts about terrorism your own country Lybia included
12. Lybian Fool: Reality for Your and Their ideology
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (03.07.06)
Ask for Death!" The Indoctrination of Palestinian Children to Seek Death for Allah – Shahada 7 MINUTE VIDEO http://pmw.org.il/asx/PMW_AFD_short.asx Full 25 minute video http://pmw.org.il/asx/PMW_AFD.asx
13. IAF attacks..
John Antex ,   new york, usa   (03.07.06)
Keep up the great work Israeli Air Force and not to worry about collateral killings. Hey Khalil, the arab blood being cheap, for what the arabs contributed to the betterment of society, it's worhless.
14. its simple #2
tony ,   PARIS   (03.07.06)
Khalil;.the answer to your question is very simple.The Israelis cry for the loss of their children,when they are blown to pieces by your fellow terrorist "brothers".For every human life is sacred.so when the Idf retaliates after your terror atacks,,the IDF does all possible ,not to hurt civiliens,,no matter what you think,But unfortunately,you people ,have such little value for human life,these,murderes hide behind your children ,the old and the unarmed ,so when they get killed,in "cross fire".You can so "proudly",accuse the israelis of purposly,aiming at these unfortunate,civiliens.and let me remind you ,that it is YOU who say that YOU ARE PREPARED TO SACRIFICE 1000,PALESTINIANS,TO KILL EVEN 1 JEW.So please don't start blaming the Israelis,by saying"THE PALESTINIAN BLOOD IS CHEAP"You are practicing what you preach.
15. Justifie???
tony mark ,   paris   (03.07.06)
Lybyan guy living in Italy.I wont even bother by replying to your ????artical.but I would like to point out ,the last sentance of it."TEACH THEM HOW TO RESPECT OTHERS."Is'nt it amazing how one very seldom,Practises,what one preaches..
16. highlights the different morality standards between the two
mike ,   usa   (03.07.06)
israel avoids civilian deaths, regrets when they happen. palestinians seek out the weak and defenseless and celebrate in the streets when they are slaughtered (in the name of the religion of "peace", mind you).
17. #16 - yeah, let's highlight some more
(03.07.06)
Israel targets only terrorists and have kille over 2600 innocent civillians. Hamas targets civillians and has killed about 1,000. Maybe Hamas has more sophisticated weapons or something.
18. #8 Gabby
Marcel ,   Florida   (03.07.06)
Which home would you like me to go to ? I see you are at home in the belly of the beast ,UN European Headquarters - Geneva . Why is that your home ? Are you a globalist who is working for the election of the new Israeli puppets who do the bidding of the Quartet of hell and not Israel ?
19. gabrielle goldwater
wanda ,   montreal   (03.07.06)
perhaps i'm taking the bait here, but i find your methods of arguing extremely sad: every comment thread i read, you're there shouting down other comments: you daren't debate, but instead insult and recite racist and cardboard rhetoric. for example, in this thread: a child and 2 teens were killed (the teens weren't of majority, so they were children too) BY AN AIR STRIKE. you say they hid behind children? how do you hide behind a child, when you are in a car? you're a victim when it means undermining another's argument, but a self-righteous bigot when justifying your own. you might not want to apply the geneva convention as conveniently as you do. it'll bite you. terror prevention through use of terror? don't make me laugh. these are more like two mafiosa locked in a perpetual exchange of reprisal hits. gabrielle, i think you are a mobster.
20. 17 - glad you agree
mike ,   usa   (03.07.06)
2600 "innocent" civilians? how many of those "innocent" civilians were engaging in terrorist activity, actively helping the terrorists, and/or actively engaging in combat activity? it seems to reveal the wide extent of terrorism and support of terrorism within palestinian society, no? or is the election of hamas by vote an accident?
21. #20 mike
(03.07.06)
"2600 "innocent" civilians? how many of those "innocent" civilians were engaging in terrorist activity, actively helping the terrorists, and/or actively engaging in combat activity?" NONE. ZERO. NIL. That's why i said "innocent civillians" and not terrorists. Innocent civillians, like the two that got killed yesterday, or the 7yr old that got shot for wearing a backpack, that sort of thing. Clear enough?
22. a society that rejoices
Michael ,   Austin, TX   (03.07.06)
when their children blow themselves up and others with them has no right to complain.
23. JEWISH ARMY
(03.07.06)
every jew that immigrates to ISrael has to join the army-right/ so ARE there any 'civilians' in Israel- really/ if all of you are in the jew army?
24. 21 - why is your problem with that?
mike ,   usa   (03.07.06)
so you are saying that the terrorists should be left alone if they are smart enough to always surround themselves with civilians? if osama bin laden was in gaza surrounding himself with "innocent" civilians he should not be touched? and israel should sacrifice lives in order to kill or capture these murderers? surgical strikes that result in civilians being hit are categorically different than terrorism targeting civilians and can't be compared by a body count. why is it morally reprehensible to you that israel is not perfect while not a word about the palestinians stated goals of killing as many jews as they can? it's interesting that you argue about comparing body counts in this war and nitpicking the morality of surgical strikes while ignoring the huge antimoral vigor of the islamists.
25. #23
(03.08.06)
You get drafted when you're 18 and you end your service (usually) at 21-22. Before and after that you're a civilian.
26. #19
Linda   (03.08.06)
How they hide behind kids? By travel with them in the same car, by living in houses with lots of kids, by walking with kids. Many times Israel did not strike because they knew there are kids, but not always you are lucky. And second I do not think if Jews would sit with kids it would makes a differents for the other side, they like to kill all Jews, never mind if they are men, children and women
Back to article