News
Rabbi: Vote Shas or go to hell
Ilan Marciano
Published: 19.03.06, 11:34
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
53 Talkbacks for this article
2. Shas
Avraham ,   Netivot   (03.19.06)
When will the Shas Torah sages learn to shut up. Every time they make statements like this they make themselves look like fools.
3. Religion
Danny ,   Tel Aviv   (03.19.06)
I believe in G#D and I try to obey Judaism as much as I can. However all these religious figures and scandals make me distance myself from them (NOT JUDAISM). They are the self proclaimed religious are just making me SICK!
4. I usd to think...
Dorothy Friend ,   Tel Aviv   (03.19.06)
...only Christian Holy Rollers talked like this.
5. So I guess I'll go to hell.....
Jerusalem,Israel   (03.19.06)
6. AMEN & HALLELUYAH ;-)))))
(03.19.06)
hehehehe
7. Extremists !
Hiram ,   Tel Aviv - Paris   (03.19.06)
Statements of this kind reflect : -abuse of religion to achieve personal power -emotional blackmail on simpleminded citizen -dangerous similarity with Islamism and its dictatorial leaders When is Yosef and his clique going to visit Iran ?
8. ynet
bobo ,   boba   (03.19.06)
wasnt there a story about Shas last week with a headline reading, Vote Shas and go to heaven? can u please exlpain to me whats new here. I am baffled.
9. As the song goes
Dorothy Friend ,   Tel Aviv   (03.19.06)
Put a nickel in the box and you'll be saved, Put a nickel in the box and you'll be saved, Put in a dollar sixty seven and you'll surely go to Heaven, Put a nickel in the box and you'll be saved!
10. Shas sucks
Francois ,   Paris   (03.19.06)
Baadani means give money to Shas parasites or go to hell.
11. It will be a hell of a situation
Richard ,   New York, USA   (03.19.06)
if the Shas party is sitting in the Israeli government. Their ignorant remarks are a disgrace to the nation.
12. The mad mullahs at it again
Michael Steiner ,   EU   (03.19.06)
These kooks would be really great fun and totally risible were it not for the fact that they're likely to garner quite a few seats next week. Who votes for these crypto-Wahabi lunatics?!? Was Ayatollah Ovadiyah there, too? As a Sephardi Jew, I disown these freaks.
13. My vote goes for Shas...
Abdullah ,   Kuwait City   (03.19.06)
14. Kleiner - you should LIKE shas
Moshe ,   Beit Shemesh   (03.19.06)
POINT #1 : most of Israel HATES the suicidal left wing policies that you seem to like. Shas-stitutes are willing to sell their right wing votes to the left for $$$$$ - this is how we got shas-lo in 1992 and about 1,500 innocent dead jews (thanks to Yossi Belin and the shas-stitutes). POINT #2 - Kleiner - you're sephardic? Hard to believe! Usually sephardim have MUCH more common sense than what you seem to have and "academic" ashkenzim are willing to espouse views that contradict all common sense. Maybe your lack of common sense comes from living in Eurabia.
15. Hell is better..
Linda   (03.19.06)
Than sitting with these idiots in heaven
16. Media bias
Micha ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (03.19.06)
The news media love to quote the great Sephardic leaders out of context. It is such a pity that so many of the readers of Ynet are so gullible. Please do not take what you read at face value. If you really want to know what men like Rav Ovadia are saying you will first need to hear them in Hebrew. Secondly, you will need to have some understanding of the halachic sources to which they refer. Rav Ovadia is a truly great man with an intellect far greater than any of the journalist who write for the various Israeli news media. He does not make silly statements. It is the news media who does that when they misquote him. The media distorts the truth when they sensationalize things such as this. Please try and understand that the media is not free of bias.
17. Worst elections campaign ever
Efi ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (03.19.06)
Least convincing elections slogan I've ever seen
18. 14 Moshe
Common Sense   (03.19.06)
Using childish jibes like Kleiner and "Eurabia" shows _you_ to be the only Kleiner around here---an intellectual kleiner. Grow up!
19. Shas
Dr D ,   Switzerland   (03.19.06)
The State of Israel should respect the ultra ultra orthodox Jews living in Israel and reserve for them an enclose area to live in surrounded by high walls for each sect. Living for centuries in ghettos and having the neurons filled up with talmudic and cabalistic chochmah they are a total lost case for a modern dynamic and productive society. Religion is a free option for free people in a democratic state and they, the ultra ultra orthodox, should appreciate already the ban impose on part of the country of freedom of movement on Sabbath and the very generous approach of the state concerning their low tax and low participation in the army. It look to me like all the effort made by Shas are with the only goal to continue to ensure a free ride living in Israel for they members and followers and this is shameful. In the other hand we are all very grateful to ZAKA. Their member are truly the sommum of our Jewish and Israeli and Zionist society as they all volunteers . Dr D
20. Too naive
Meir ,   Beit Shemesh   (03.19.06)
Firstly, to Abdullah of Kuwait City. Keep your nose out of Israeli politics, and try to bring some democracy to your own little dictatorship. Now regarding Shas, as a religious Jew, I find Shas attitude too naive. So they have an explanation why people who they don't agree with or consider evil, suffer. So then, why do religious people also suffer then? I mean, Rav Kaduri also suffered. Shas's attitude is too naive. Suffering cannot and should not be considered as a black and white punishment for wrong doings. It's more complicated than that.
21. Knowing God
Sam ,   USA   (03.19.06)
Why do Rabbis think that they are modern day prophets to whom God explains what he does and why? Perhaps these Rabbis ought to do a bit more studying and remember that our holy texts and sages teach us that there are no prophets today.
22. #21
Dorothy Friend ,   Tel Aviv   (03.19.06)
I said that when they did the comparison of dead children and "spoiled" mezzuzahs in Petach Tikva some two decades back. Self appointed profits that worship a god that kills innocent children because someone didn't know the parchment got moldy.
23. # 20 MEIR
GEORGE SAMI   (03.19.06)
MEIR , I THINK YOU ALSO , ONE LITTLE DICTATOR. YOU CAME HERE TO LIVE IN THE MIDDLE OF THE ARABS, AND AMONG THEM , BUT YOU REFUSE TO TALK TO THEM, HOW THEY WILL UNDERSTAND AND ACCEPT YOU?? The only peoples who benefit from the religions are the rabbis , the priests , the CLERICS – and all other servants of the temples . RELIGIONS ARE POLITICS COVERED WITH BELIEVES TO EASE CONTROL TO THE PUBLIC…
24. vote shas.....
Connie ,   USA   (03.19.06)
I don't have the time right now to read this whole article. I will read it later todaybut it this rabbi sounds no different than the comments Pat Robertson made about Ariel Sharon's stroke. The media pounced all over him.I believe nothing in the middle east happens by chance.He was just part of a continuel plan for Israel.The end of that plan is her triumhing over all her enemies.
25. Vodoo
Ronnie ,   Hod Hasharon   (03.19.06)
These Shas Rabbis are turning to Vodoo more and more and to Judism less and less.
26. Athiests talking hypocrisy, as usual
yehuda ,   new york usa   (03.19.06)
So many athiests, are as usual showing their hypocrisy! Why do Poratz and Zahava, seem so concerned, that a Rabbi said, that if they do everything they could to abolish the Torah from the "jewish state" might be risking their eternal future? Perhaps they should meet with various Rabbonim, ALL of whom will explaim to them the masorah from Har Sinai, the importance of Tamud Torah and Yeshivos, the need for Mikvaos for Taharas Hamishpocha, instead of breying like druggie jackasses "all drugs available" discos? As Hagaon Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik told Ben Gurion, "Please don't force us to choose between Toras Yisroel, and Medinas Yisroel, since their is no doubt which we will choose. We lived thousands of years without a medina and we couldn't live 2 seconds without the Torah! (PS Ben Gurions son married a shiksa)! I hope that Deri will beome the PM some day, since he represents the best of of two educations! (Ponivitch by Rav Schach z'tl , and Shas by Rav Ovadia Shlita! Then we'll have a Jewish State, (not some commie trottsky , or ben gurion ) state. While I wish Sharon a refuah shleima their are many explanations why he's a vegatable. NY neorulogists, give medical explanations, about inadequate medical care, others give spiritual explanations! Only Hashem really knows!
27. Jewish mullahs in Jerusalem talk from their... again.
Andy   (03.19.06)
Sharon actually brought gifts of strength and wisdom to the people of Israel. These Shas morons only take, take, take. What an embarrassment to the Jewish people they truly are. Just like I see Iranians of good faith cringe with what's coming out of Tehran these days.
28. GREAT FASHION - WITH THE GOLD LEAFFY DESIGN
andrew ,   miami, fl   (03.19.06)
I WISH ALL ORTHODOX PEOPLE WOULD DRESS LIKE THE GUY WITH THT E GOLD DESIGNS - THE ORTHODOX ALWAYS LOOK LIKE THEY ARE GOING TO A FUNERAL - SO EVIL LOOKING
29. Huh?
Shai ,   Israel   (03.19.06)
Oh, I get it. If I don't vote for Shas, I'll go to Hell. There, my representatives will actually show up for Parliamentary sessions, and earn their college degrees. Besides, it's not such a bad idea to scare the devil out of our enemies? :-)
30. Rabbi Baadani the snake oil man
mike ,   gedera   (03.19.06)
If heaven is full of Shasniks, Id rather go to Hell
Next talkbacks
Back to article