Jewish Scene
Remembering Ilan Halimi
Judea Pearl
Published: 19.03.06, 13:14
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
8 Talkbacks for this article
1. Jewish culpability
Mike ,   Atlanta, USA   (03.19.06)
Judea presents a well-written appeal and critique. But rather than castigate the European media in particular and the culture in general, I think we could better serve our collective interests by motivating the exit of all Jews from Europe. As the premier slaughters of Jews, Europeans cannot bottom out in their depravity. Jews who live among European (including British) goyim should know better. How many Jews need to die before we learn that Europe will never protect our rights (because it does not want to)?
2. emotion is not a substitute for facts
david ,   T-A   (03.19.06)
(1) tarek ramadan has been expelled from france, a long time ago (2) during the november riots, not =one= religious claim or antisemitic attack (3) the hooligans had tried to abduct jews and non jews , jews ''because they were rich'', which is the most archaic antisemitism and has nothing to do with the media (4) listen to the representatives of the french jewish community before speaking in behlf of them.
3. #2 ....hold on a damn minute here
Rex ,   Tel Avi Israel   (03.19.06)
Jews live where they choose. They should not ever be chased from where they live. It is not up to the Jew to be chased out but to those who chase them, they must be brought to justice! Mike in Atlanta, to prevent Jews for the millionth time to be chased from their homelands is the duty of the world. There are billions more of non Jews to every one Jew.
4. A wonderful eulogy
Elle ,   NYC   (03.20.06)
Reminding Jews that we need to look after one another because no one else will.
5. #2 David, try to walk with a kipa in the streets of Paris...
Ezra ,   Canada   (03.20.06)
- France has long ago turned against Israel - France has more than 5 millions muslims hating Jews - France had 25% people voting the antismistic leader Le Pen I don't know any young french Jew thinking his future is in France. Already 5.000 Jews leave France every year. Let us hope the others follow quickly before it is to late...
6. Heartbreaking!
Gerd ,   Germany   (03.21.06)
7. # Ezra, is wrong; #3 David is right
Didier Spaier ,   Paris France   (03.24.06)
Ezra, please don't talk without knowing. I leave in France since 1949 and won't leave, period. If some of my compatriots are racist: 1. There are a lot more racists in Israel 2. Most are Anti arabs -- as in Israel 3. I was never exposed to racism from muslims or Arabs
8. No words can describe the sadness I
Hebrew girl ,   USA   (01.28.07)
feel after reading this. It reminds me of another precious life that was prematurely extinguished- that of 16 year old Daniel Wultz last year. May the memory of all three live forever in our minds.
Back to article