News
Al-Zahar wants 'Palestine from river to sea'
Ali Waked
Published: 05.04.06, 15:48
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
91 Talkbacks for this article
31. Why should they worry?
Shai ,   Israel   (04.05.06)
Iran has said this for years. The PA and Arafat said it when nobody else was looking (in Arabic). This is not new. The only thing they've done is remove "deniability" from those who claim not to see (actually, refuse to see) the solution to the Arab Israel conflict as allowing one side or the other to win the conflict, once and for all. Unfortunately, the evidence of the last decade proves that the only way this conflict will end is when one side is so severely defeated that they walk away. There is no compromise that can possibly result in peace, because the Palis are so caught up in their concept of "just" peace that they refuse to accept the very basic tenet of all compromise, and that is that there are more than one view of what's "just" and nobody ever gets all of what they want.
32. About the money .. who told u to start an intifada?
yiftah ,   israel   (04.05.06)
33. #30 You insulted my pet chimp!
BeachBum ,   Israel   (04.05.06)
I have a pet chimp, and he doesn't like to be compared to arch-terrorists. My chimp is friendly and will share his bananas with you.
34. #29
DR ,   Florida, USA   (04.05.06)
Yes, we see how peaceful your people are when we catch a teenager strapped with explosices at our checkpoints. Don't you get that the check points are there b/c you continue to teach your children to hate and kill and become martyrs? You're whole culture is based on violence and resistance by force and you expect Israel to sit back and do nothing? Get real. Palestinians had other choices besides Fatah and Hamas, but your culture and system did not let it happen. This is the proble my friend. We understand that there are many Palestinians that wnat peace and are suffering b/c of their leadership, but there are still too many who want war, and that's exactly what you get.
35. #33 LOL!!!
DR ,   Florida, USA   (04.05.06)
36. 24 Linda Rivera : Stop your CAPS how many times did we ask
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (04.05.06)
37. we do not need hamas to recognize israel
Joe ,   NYC,USA   (04.05.06)
38. #29- Did you read what you wrote?
Arie   (04.05.06)
"You have to know that most of Palestinians looking for peace and 2 states solution but Israel refused that, Hamas doesn’t represnt the palestinian " You ELECTED them FREELY therefore they represent you . You KNEW what they stood for. So now sit back and watch your dreams of a State deteriorate into a fantasy that will never be. You FREELY chose anarchy war and poverty over peace. Now go a wallow in the pig sty you chose to live in!
39. You Know...
David ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (04.05.06)
I hate to admit it, but now that you mention it, he does kind of remind me of a Planet of the Apes poster.
40. Hamas - from the river to the sea
Simon ,   C-Town, South Africa   (04.05.06)
Marcel - stop writing cr-p ! You know this will never happen.END
41. abba eban
peter ,   amsterdam, NL   (04.05.06)
"The Palestinians never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity". Things don't change very much...
42. lol #39 !!
(04.05.06)
43. #26 you asked:
Tal ,   Israel   (04.05.06)
why is no-one coming out against this mad Hamas crazed guy? Because there is no one. However world leaders try their best to portray something quite the opposite. How bankrupt and void of scruples is that! BTW: On this YNET Opinion piece http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3234104,00.html #1 asked Ray Hanania an honest question and he did not have the courage to answer it. (he does however respond to other comments in past opinion pieces!) So why did he not answer it? Because he couldn't NOT because he choose not to. What this boils down to is a people who are unwilling to look hard into the mirror. A people whose leaders do not stand up to terror because they themselves harbor terror. (however you will not here one politician from the West admit that!) A people whose leaders inculcate a climate of hate and lies. So now we have Hamas who truly exemplifies the agenda of how Palestinians feel toward Israel and still the west is on purpose refusing to see it. I take my hat off to Hamas (cough sputter....) for at least being honest. Having said that it is high time the world understands that Hamas speaks for the majority of the Palestinian people including Abbas whom Bush calls a man of peace. At least Hamas has the balls to say the same thing in English they say in Arabic. I invite the world to wake up before it is too late. There is no difference between Fatah and Hamas and everything in between except one speaks with truth and the others are consumate liars. All ARE EVIL!!! That is the bottom line we must shove down the throats of every leader who has bullied and pushed Israel relentlessly and unjustifiably just so the 'street' (which vows to inhillialate them as well) could be pacified.
44. I want a Club Med Resort from the Jordan River to the Med.
(04.05.06)
Lots of Bikini Clad women. Just the thing that Allah hates most.
45. lol!!!
Michael Steiner ,   EU   (04.05.06)
These morons obviously have no intention of getting their heads out of fantasy land (a.k.a. their asses) any time soon and joining the rest of us in the real world. Granted, we have our own freaks who keep screaming about an Israel from the river to the sea, for much the same reasons, but at least they're a tiny minority among us...
46. to # 37 .we do not need hamas or the arab country's
todd ,   usa   (04.05.06)
47. what?
andy ,   Dublin   (04.05.06)
Where did that come from? Last I heard the Israelis were still shooting civilians, starving babies, etc.?
48. Racist
Andy ,   Dublin, Ireland   (04.05.06)
When you say that both possibel parties in the country you are stealing are evil - are you not echoing nizi rethoric, or is it simply racism?
49. #29 Are Pals crazy..Voting for party they don't support?
Alan ,   SA   (04.05.06)
... Raed, as soon as possible, you must go to see Dr Bashar Assad of Syria.. He is an Eye Doctor (very good, London Training).. He will also check Palestinians Eyes so that next election (very soon) they will see the Voting Paper better.
50. #29
tony ,   PARIS   (04.05.06)
RAED,PLEASE;you are beating around the bush again..This SHMUCK,you Palestinians voted for,has nothing to do with what you jabbered about in your talkback,Why don't you for once and for all be honnest,and say ,that you all made a mistake,by voting for this terrorist faction..All that the Hamas will bring you ,is more misery,and suffering,This has nothing to do with border check points and the crossing into Israel of Palestinian civiliens..Why cant you speak the truth once of and for all..Stand up for your rights,because as long as the Hamas refuses to recognise Israel,you will never ,and I mean NEVER have a moments peace.You Palestinians,refuse to end your suicide bombings,and the latest one that occured,near Kidoumim you murdered four people ,including the 15 year old son of a friend;of mine,and that is why you will continue to suffer,the retaliations ,of the IDF.and suffer,the consequinces,of your very bad choice,of choosing the Hamas as your government.So ,if you want peace,YOU have to take a real look,at where YOU want to go,and what YOU will leave in heritage for your children..STOP BLAMING THE ISRAELIS,FOR YOUR MISERIES,AND DO SOMETHING CONSTRUCTIVE FOR A CHANGE.
51. 50 tony, PARIS : Very well said indeed
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (04.05.06)
We al have at some time lost a friend or a child of a friend - wife - husband and all Very few Jews that have not been touched one way or another by the terror attacks We don't accept any of this Islamic terror any more
52. The endless cycle
Josh ,   Jerusalem   (04.05.06)
Hamas is going to crash so fast they wont even know what hit them. The unfortunate thing is that Fatah will take their place, which is even worse for Israel because they are better at lying to the world.
53. Andy you Antisemite...
DR ,   Florida, USA   (04.05.06)
Anyone so dumb as to side with a culture of terror and murder must hate the state of Israel and the Jews. There is no way in hell you actually believe the stupid things you posted. Israel Does not target civilians like the IRA or the Palestinians themselves. The IDF goes after terrorists and those who launch rockets into Israeli neighborhoods. Thes cowards hide among civilians and that is why we see collateral damage, but you are wrong about the IDF. Are you also arguing that Hamas and/or Fatah are actually good for the peoole there? Get real man. You must be drunk!!!
54. Keren
For peace   (04.05.06)
"this Israel government is a bunch of un-brained asses..." Takes one to know one Keren.
55. Zahra
For peace   (04.05.06)
"we are waiting the beldoozers to destroy evry thing but not the soule of palestinians." No Zahra...you people are destroying yourselves and you can't even see it.
56. Post 30
Michelle   (04.05.06)
Trust me when I say this. NOONE BELIEVES A WORD when Palestinians speak. They say one thing to the world and they say the opposite to their own people.
57. To No. 36
(04.05.06)
Meeeooow!
58. #54 #55
(04.05.06)
are you the messiah or what? shut up already... get real!
59. WHY Jump in his case #29
Nick ,   USA   (04.05.06)
You guy's rushet to shut this man up, and jumped into accusation that the entire palestinian peaple elected hamas that means they need war..such childlish approched , look at yourselves, you will be lead by Kadima, how much os the votes did they get 20%-30%, will that means that kadima openinan applies to all JEW"s ...wake up guys...at least be more moderate when you hear somebody talking peace..Maybe A word you dont understand..and he is totaly right, Israel action brought Hamas to Power and no telling what else it will bring...this is just the beginning......
60. From wherever to wherever!
Ram ,   London   (04.05.06)
From the river to the sea or from the mountains to the valleys should only be as a result of necessity. Israelis will be happy to accept a 2 state solution but, the Palis as you can hear time and time again, do not want to share the land with the Jews. They want the Jews out of the entire area. Israelis would be stupid not to consider all options to guarantee their security. With the present warmongering attitude of the Palis they may just have to consider the river to the sea option. It would be a perfectly acceptable consideration to offer individual Palis a lump sum to move to Jordan, Egypt, Lebanon or Syria. All options must be considered in order that Israelis rid themselves of this costant aggressiveness by their sworn suicidal enemiy.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article