News
Hamas: Terror attack act of self defense
Roee Nahmias
Published: 17.04.06, 15:54
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
48 Talkbacks for this article
1. And when the IDF responds
Arie   (04.17.06)
We can expect the following: UN: Annan will receive cash payments from hamass for his support at which point he will push for a condemnation of an "Israeli overreaction" France: Suha will invite Chirac to her royal palace after which he will issue the expected IslamoFrench condemnation Russia: Will by now have forgotten that hamass trained chechen terrorists massacred over 300 Christian boys and girls and find a way to condemn Israel Eurabia: Will scream for a boycott of Israel for having the audacity to protect itself England: The Parliament will relegate Livingstone to be their spokesman who will in turn invite hamass to town for a victory celebration of smoked pork Egypt: Is grateful that now everyone is condemning Israel rather than looking at how they have been butchering their Coptic Christians
2. "Legitimate attack"
Isac ,   Florida   (04.17.06)
If as Hamas claims the suicide bombing was a "Legitimate attack", than Israel should send fighter bombers and bomb civilian areas in the Palestinian territories. An eye for an eye. Makes sense, doesn't it?
3. Abbas
Arie   (04.17.06)
This caused no "higher damage to the palestinian people." The palis voted FREELY to have a terrorist led regime rule them. This is their course of action will, if Peretz and Peres are kept out of the equation, will be met with a proper IDF response. Of course, then the palis will scream about collective punishment. But remember - they voted collectively for the terrorists and now they will face the outcome.
4. Time to liquidate Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh
michael ,   tel aviv   (04.17.06)
Hamas agrees with the attack so it's time for Israel to get serious. There are no gray areas any more - the PA government condones terror attacks ! How many Israelis have to die because of political correctness. Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh should pay the price (a very small cost for so many wounded and dead Israelis) with his life. Michael
5. Well, that's it then.
(04.17.06)
The Palestinian ruling party has supported and endorsed the attack. This constitutes a perfectly valid casus belli under any relevant law for an all-out war against the Hamas government.
6. legitimate Palestinian resistance
David ,   Brooklyn, NY   (04.17.06)
"....Waspi Kabaha, said that the "the attack was carried out in the context of the legitimate Palestinian resistance and as a response to the violations of the occupation and its crimes." This goes to show us how legitmate the Palestinian people are. They can not act like civil human beings and take advantage of generious efforts of ISRAEL to help them build their own state. Instead they murder innocent people and claim it was in self defense. !
7. G-D Calls it MURDER
Lisa Rivera ,   New York   (04.17.06)
8. #2 "Legitimate attack"
(04.17.06)
No, you got it wrong. Eye for eye means that Israel should send suicide bombers to Palestinian territories.
9. to linda
ramallah ,   ramallah   (04.17.06)
Yes Linda when killing childredn and civilian in Gaza for the past two months also called murder, and the bad thing it will continue. Israel started first
10. Sorry pal you got it wrong
Isac to #8 ,   Florida   (04.17.06)
It is against the jewish religion to commit suicide. The Barbarians live on the "other side".
11. #9
dave ,   Washington DC   (04.17.06)
But it will fit with the jewish religion that you army killed 5 kids and more than 15 people during the last 2 weeksm that's ok... The is the real barbaic acts,killing is killing with sucide bmbers or with tanks and shelling , kill kids and civilian and u should expect the people to do the same
12. suicide
jj ,   canada   (04.17.06)
Nothing has changed. They are still sacrificing their children to baal or molach by throwing them into the fire.Untill they stop, war will continue.
13. # 9
(04.17.06)
You stupid Arab, "Israel started it first", try 1948 you stupid brainwashed Arab. Glorify your killing some more.
14. #5
enzo ,   london,uk   (04.17.06)
I couldn't put it better than you! Exactly what I wanted to say. The PA are unable to curb these terror attacks? Well...there is only one option left then! Invasion!
15. The scum of the earth...And to you ramallah...
Yonatan ,   USA   (04.17.06)
"Israel started first " You sound like the rest of those spoiled brats. I used to say that when I was 5 years old. You and your people are SICK!
16. Dear Mr. Minister
yakov shani ,   afula   (04.17.06)
Can I come and blow you and your family up in the name of self defense? Please Mr. Minister, let me do this, but without you complaing to the UN or your Arab leaders for help.
17. The illegitimate wrong
JP ,   Israel   (04.17.06)
18. The Palestinian legitimate right?
JP ,   Israel   (04.17.06)
It's time for international courts to send Hamas leaders to jail, where they belong: http://web.amnesty.org/library/Index/ENGMDE020032002?open&of=ENG-ISR "The attacks against civilians by Palestinian armed groups are widespread, systematic and in pursuit of an explicit policy to attack civilians. They therefore constitute crimes against humanity under international law. They may also constitute war crimes..."
19. As if the palestinian teritorry are free areas...
Palestinian ,   Palestine   (04.17.06)
Do what ever you want..
20. The attack
Emma ,   Australia   (04.17.06)
Islam has become the world's greatest curse. This is a religion that oppresses women and aims to destroy other faiths. It is a most intolerant religion that is anti western values and culture. It aims to impose bigoted, narrow minded, fanatical religious concepts upon the whole world. It promotes a death oriented culture. It honors suicide bombers. It is anti intellectual and opposed to creative ideas. It oppresses minority groups.
21. Downright Disgusting
John ,   NZ   (04.17.06)
to brainwash a young man to commit suicide is disgusting and to kill innocent ppl in the process is abhorent. The state who sponsor and advocate this act is a coward.
22. Response
Muhammad ,   Montreal   (04.17.06)
1. Haniyeh wouldn't have joined Hamas if he was scared for his life. 2. Hamas agreed with the attack but did not commit it. The US supports the occupation of the WB and GS but is not occupying them. 3. Stop acting as being a prophet #7. 4. Obey to what God told you to do. 5. The IDF does worse than the suicide bombers and the IDF is the occupier. Point final (period)
23. Oh they are SO asking for it!!!
Edan ,   Beer Sheva   (04.17.06)
They just continue to do and say the wrong things. Their days must be numbered.
24. An other proof
Hiram Al Masry ,   kom Ombo   (04.17.06)
Yet an other proof of the unwillingness of terror groups and Hamas to pursue the road to peace.
25. #22 Muhammad
Yonatan ,   USA   (04.17.06)
There would be no occupied territories if the Arabs had not attacked Israel. Don't even try to compare the IDF to you terrorists. YOU attack civillians purposely. If the IDF killes civillians, it's unintentional. Not to mention the IDF doesnt hide in residential neigborhoods where innocent people might get hurt. You and your kind have NO concept of honor, but you understand cowardice VERY well. You folks also need to look up the difference between a resistance fighter, and a scumbag terrorist. You're all SICK, SICK, SICK.
26. Stop the War, Nuke Iran (END)
(04.17.06)
27. yahood retaliation:missels (technology) we got belts &bombs
samer hirzallah ,   toronto,canada   (04.17.06)
this is a response to number 10...suicide is also forbidded in islam...but when it comes down to this..its considered jihad...and fighting for your country and ppl...its all retaliation to what the jewish army is doing...during the past 2 weeks 18 palestinans died...with your missel striking on areas considerd to be "missel launching areas for palestinans"...you guys have been using this non sense excuse...for the past 20 years!!? dont think after 20yrs all those areas would be covered by now!! i mean plaestine is not a huge country...espically after you thiefs took over...this will never END its been 60 yrs...come one the only way is peace...i know easier said than done...but if you guys talk to our Democratically elected govt Hamas...and stop screwing around with money barriers...and #14 what the hell do you think has been going on for the past 60 yrs.. invasion maybe!?!?!?! get ur facts right
28. to #21
samer ,   toronto,canada   (04.17.06)
ok brainwashing young men huh!? its because these young men...arent living like how young men should live...they are living in poverty, dirt, fear, unease, i could keep going on for hours...what about the innocent 4500ppl who have died since the 2000...get ur facts right and look at both sides and compare...trust the only difference u'll see...is that your jewish and we're muslims...study these religons and u'll see the relevance
29. 11 dave, Washington DC: Terror attacks don't equal to
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (04.17.06)
Selfdenfense of a State which is legal - which naturally may bring collateral - Versa a terror attack that is an intentional aim at civilian population - so Don't try that stupid statement - You just are a Liar Intentional direct terror attacks as today in TelAviv is - NOT selfdefense study law and terrorism These were Intentional murder attacks. and not collateral in any self defense - don't try to bring Lies In Memory of the 123 Israeli Kids Murdered by Palestinian Terrorists Between October 2000 and September 2004 http://goldwater.mideastreality.com/israeli-children.files/fullscreen.htm move forward with Left Mouse click to each section Not to forget : http://www.jr.co.il/terror/israel/index.html
30. 22Muhammad, Montreal:What are you in Canada - another Hate
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (04.17.06)
Monger rebel trying to recruite for the Jihad sounds like - hopefully the new government will start to deport your likes
Next talkbacks
Back to article