News
Expert: Nuke attack won't destroy Israel
Eyal Ben
Published: 13.05.06, 20:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
55 Talkbacks for this article
1. Israel will never be nuked, Persia will though
(05.13.06)
2. Holocaust denial
sk ,   USA   (05.13.06)
"“Denying the Holocaust is a kind of defiance; it is like the skinheads in Sweden who yell ‘Heil Hitler’ even though they do not really believe in the Mein Kampf." Arabs & Persians deny the Holocaust largely because they want to deny the main secular justification for Zionism, which is that Jews cannot trust others to provide security. If no Holocaust happened, Israel is not necessary. I would an "expert" would have made this simple point unassisted by me.
3. No need to nuke Israel to terminate it. It will collapse on
(05.13.06)
its own. Just like it waws created in unusual circumstances. This entity will find its termination becuase it is not built on just. Sooner or later, the will drown in the sea of Arabs.
4. #3: we need more Crusaders!
sk ,   USA   (05.13.06)
Maybe, Muslims should just be defeated and forcibly converted to Christianity (those who survive) whenever or wherever they cause trouble.
5. Mahmood has underestimated...
Avi ,   Jerusalem   (05.13.06)
the Jewish will to survival. The Jewish state will continue to exist and recover even if Tel Aviv is nuked.
6. #4 You joking right?!?!
(05.13.06)
For a Israeli supporter, I really hope your joking
7. Ahmadinejad is a genius
Mohammed ,   Iran   (05.13.06)
His letter to Bush was a masterstroke. He has beaten the necons at their game.
8. #4 Read history my friend ... The crusaders are extinct ..
Saladin ,   Homs   (05.13.06)
Any new ones will meet the same fate ...
9. nuke Iran NOW - better them than us !!!!
Moshe ,   Beit Shemesh   (05.13.06)
10. #6, #8
sk ,   USA   (05.13.06)
#6: Only half-joking. Jews cannot forcibly convert Arabs to Judaism (Halacha forbids missionary work completely). So, what to do with the Arab Muslims? Bush is trying to democratize them. I voted for him twice, and I wish him luck. But what's the backup plan? One would be massive aerial bombing, taking out whole militaries, leaderships, and, when necessary, bunches of civilians as in WW2 Japan. Rome applied this model successfully. If Israel had, no Arab would dare to attack an Israeli walking anywhere in his land. Anyway, military destruction focuses the attention of the loser. Another plan would be to forcibly defeat Islam and replace it with a different religion, just as Mohammed and later Muslims forcibly converted others to Islam. #8: When was the last Arab army that defeated a Western army? Anyway, I keep hearing that the US is a Crusader. I'm thinking that this might be something to consider.
11. 3 The nameless scolded dog strikes again with his Hate BS
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.13.06)
not even the guts to use a name Always the same
12. Israel can retaliate very nicely--hit Mecca
sam ,   potomac usa   (05.14.06)
If a Muslim state attacks Israel with nukes--let Israel attack the seat of the problem--Mecca---and turn that silly stone into a cinder
13. Dont nuke anyone....
Lior ,   Eilat   (05.14.06)
....just send the boys to kill the camel lover. No more camel lover, no more problem. And whoever replaces the camel lover will think twice before they do or say anything stupid
14. #11 How do you know thats the same person?
Gabe ,   Tel Aviv   (05.14.06)
Anyone from anywhere can post as a hidden nameless person, so please next time dont do Lashon Hara, we dont know who is really behind the message.
15. #9 Wouldnt you call what Abraham/Sarah did as "converting"
(05.14.06)
When they went around villages telling of the true one Almighty and "converted" them to Judaism, wasnt that "converting". We 100% do not allow conversion by force as whats the point, it has to come from the heart. But can you give referances to where its 100% no matte what in any form? There will be a time when Edom and Ishmael fight, read Gog Magog in Ezekiel.
16. 7 Mohammed, Iran: and YOU - You are a freak
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.14.06)
one of these days you wish you were not born
17. An easy solution to Iran
(05.14.06)
Israel should nuke Iran before it developes nuclear capability.
18. If Aryan-IRan uses Nukes, tens of thousands of Arabs die.
David ,   Boston, USA   (05.14.06)
The Evil Arab Empire has alot more to fear from Hamas the Aryan-IRanian than Israel. You will have tens of thousands of Arabs West of Aryan-Iran die from Nuke fall out. It will only hasten the end of the Evil Arab Empire and allow Israel to grow to its rightful size, not this reduced sized West of the Jordan.
19. Reminder, Israel was being re-created LONG before Holocaust.
David ,   Boston, USA   (05.14.06)
Some Jews has never left, others had been moving back for over a century. Arabs and Aryan-Iranians just like to make excuses and ignore historical facts. The land, the cities, the native people, all Jewish. Arabs were just the latest invaders.
20. Israel's show of weakness feeds Islam
Marcel ,   Florida   (05.14.06)
Since Israel's enemies learned they could not defeat them by war they embarked on the peace scheme to destroy Israel,this with the help of the west. This stratdegy has worked well ,as the average israeli help's in his own demise for any semblance of phony peace . The festering wound of Oslo has brought more damage to Israel than all the pervious wars put together ,yet Israel continues down this suicidal path because of their delusion's of peace. There is no hope for peace with the followers of allah. Only their total defeat will bring true peace. Israel has grown tired of defeating her enemies, now choosing national suicide by appeasment. The greatest wound is that it has weakened Israel enocuraged Israel's enemies that their victory is near. Those in Israel who surrender and retreat for peace are bringing about the opposite result. War is the endgame of their appeasment for peace.
21. to #3
jason white ,   afula,israel   (05.14.06)
We will not "drown in the sea of arabs".That is one polluted sea that we will dry up someday. The arab countries were not founded under odd circumstances? They were built on justice? arabs do not know the meaning of justice! Finally any people arab or human who live under "royalty" have no honor or pride. Democracy is the only way to go.
22. HOW ABOUT LOTS OF NUCLEAR FALLOUT SHELTERS, LIKE SWITZERLAND
PROTECT THE JEWS ,   IN ISRAEL   (05.14.06)
23. AGREE WITH #9, NUKE IRAN NOW,DON'T FORGET MECCA & MEDINA TOO
PUT END TO ISLAMIC ,   FANATICS FOR GOOD   (05.14.06)
24. beginning of the end for the iranian madman
debra ,   usa   (05.14.06)
long before israel is supposedly nuked by the iranian nutcase, the maniac and his underground nuclear factories will be irradiated and blown to dust by israel's own nuclear weapons. there is not going to be a second holocaust for the jews. when we say NEVER AGAIN we mean it. if the insane president of iran wants to tangle with israel and the jews, his days on earth are numbered. the countdown has already started.
25. Israel is allowed to have nukes, but Iran isn't?
Ellen Prescott ,   Southsea, Hampshire   (05.14.06)
Now isn't that a bit biased? As long as Israel possesses an extensive array of nuclear weapons, I don't see why it is wrong for Iran to seek nuclear power. Causing WW3 by aiding Israeli dominance in the middle east is something that I, and most of the world, find appalling. It's time to let everyone have their fair share. Israel isn't better than any other nation (quite the contrary, in fact) and it certainly does not qualify for any special treatment or privileges. Let's not forget that Iran has actually allowed UN inspectors to inspect its facilities, whereas Israel refuses to comply with the international community, thus making itself a pariah, and continuing its illegal nuclear programme. Let's be fair, we must challange BOTH Israel and Iran on their questionable nuclear facilities, or neither!
26. The guy is not an expert on nuclear issues, he is...
Ron ,   LA   (05.14.06)
... good lefty self promoter, just read this... http://frontpagemag.com/Articles/ReadArticle.asp?ID=22104
27. #8 We are lucky to have stupid anemies...
Ron ,   LA   (05.14.06)
28. Now, how can we believe him if he wrote DIS?...
Ron ,   LA   (05.14.06)
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3238797,00.html And "DIS" is frum histerian...
29. Ron Wiseman, PhD sez:
Ron ,   LA   (05.14.06)
Kleinberg sez: Uhh... uhh, I’m not at all certain that I am not a nutty professor. “If we take Bin Laden, he is an example of a relatively mild threat ...Iran is not Bin Laden, nor is it Iraq.” Russia is not Mao and psycho historian is not a rocket scientist. As an historian I can say only this:” Today is not yesterday , this is that but that is this, diz is fer sur. Ron Wiseman, PhD sez: Hmmm...The spontaneous nuclear combustion problem escalates as more and more “new historians” go back to holding in all their farts. Meanwhile, the ozone layer continues to deplete as other “scientists” refuse to hold in their farts for fear of nuclear combustion. As we all know, the cause for all of this is some “political spino- historians” who calls themselves nuclear scientists. Ron Wiseman, PhD is a self-taught nuclear historian in Interplanetary Earth and Martian Studies (IEMS) Currently he is Los Angeles co-director of the strategic affairs unit at IEMS, a joint Earth-Martian organization.
30. To #4
Muhammad-Ali ,   Montreal   (05.14.06)
Crussaders were the enemies of the Jews too.
Next talkbacks
Back to article