News
Sources: 3 Palestinians killed in Gaza blast
Ali Waked
Published: 27.05.06, 07:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
60 Talkbacks for this article
1. Death finds the Palestinian's in their home
Marcel ,   Florida   (05.26.06)
The cult of death Palestinains who teach their children to hate and kill Jews are a cursed people. Even after a dud artillery shell fired by the IDF did no damage the children of the cult of death brought it into their home as a trophy toy to play with. Instead they recieved upon thermselves what they7 intend for Israel. This is an example of the justice which will fall upopn the Palestinian people as a whole.
2. Probably terrorists
Caligula's Horse ,   Solomon's stables   (05.26.06)
What would normal people do with an artillery shell, they probably wanted to use the shell's explosives to make bombs or rockets of their own and it exploded when they tried to defuse it, there is no other logical explanation for why people would bring explosives into their home and play with it until it blows up.
3. Kassams are still being fired so this is to be expected !
michael ,   tel aviv   (05.26.06)
4. Zionists at it again?
Mike ,   Atlanta, USA   (05.26.06)
The Mossad may have paid these children to take the so-called dud into their homes. Can anyone provide evidence to the contrary? =)
5. Every day, innocent Palestinians are murdered by Israelis
Ellen Prescott ,   Southsea, Hampshire   (05.26.06)
on a DAILY BASIS! Just imagine, a 54 year-old farmer murdered, what on God's green earth did he do to deserve being bombed? Ploughing his fields to grow food to feed his family? Was that his crime? My heart is bursting with sorrow, and will anybody acknowledge this MURDER? Will anybody be punished for this cold-blooded crime? Who will remember this man, this farmer, who died simply because of the nation he belonged to. Palestine, don't you cry - We shall never let you die!
6. The dumbass picked up a bomb, what do you expect
(05.26.06)
7. #4 Mike
Jon C. ,   Minneapolis   (05.26.06)
does mossad even operate in the occupied territories?
8. The Arabs claiming the Palestinian identity
Bill ,   USA   (05.26.06)
get a taste of their own medicine.
9. racist mentalities
(05.26.06)
1,2,3,4,6 your racist rotten mentalities wil turn against you one day.
10. 5 Ellen everyday the Palestinians try to murder Israelis
ann   (05.26.06)
I agree with you for once these kind of tragedies happen way too often.But they would be happening if the Palestinians did not support terrorists and murderers who want to destroy Israel and annihalite the Israeli people.The terrorists sadly with the support of the majority of the Palestinian population place themselves in civlian areas.The Israelis are not going to put the lives of their enemies civilians above the lives of their own wives and children. When the lives of their families are at stake they will try to stop the people who are trying to kill them. Also,you don't really know if that was an Israeli shell that killed those boys and their father it might have been one left over by the Arab terrorists.Everyday the Israelis soldiers and intelligence thwart terrorist attempts to kill Israeli civilians sometimes the numbers are as high as 100 attempted terrorist attacks in one day. Just today a Palestinian stabbed an Israeli man in the neck.after the Israeli tried to assist him when his car broke down.Also,the Palestinians tried to plant a bomb at a Hebron kindergarten, thankfully it did not explode.Yet none of this matters because the lives of Jews do not matter at all to people like you.
11. #5 Ellen, the answer is so simple.
The Truth   (05.26.06)
When the Palestinians stop firing Qassams randomly into Israel in order to kill innocent people then Israel will stop firing artillery in order to stop them. It is soooo simple that even someone as blind to reality as you can see it.
12. A useful thing...
The White Shadow   (05.26.06)
...this unique method of 'Palestinian' bomb disposal.
13. @What they learn from their leaders
Arie   (05.26.06)
The palestinian kids are taught that martyrdom and playing with munitions is expected of them so whythe surprise that they picked up a shell to play with?
14. #9 If We Are Racist Because We Care More About Jewish Lives
(05.26.06)
Then We Are Racist Nobody gives a damn about Jewish lives except our own. Our allies are only temporary. Man has tried to remove us from this Earth thousands of times over, we are going to do everything to defeat our enemies. I feel sad for you unknwn as you are blind by your own hatred for Jews and will be stabbed in the back in the end by your own Moslem friend.
15. #9 are you aware..
Vorax   (05.26.06)
..that your message is even uglier? every man is racist, preferring his own stock, no matter what you choose to declare in words. ask yourself - have you ever did something DESPITE your racism? your post #9 definitely doesn't count.
16. " Twisted Story "
Nick ,   USA   (05.26.06)
And they want us to believe this, the shell was there unexploded and the teens carried it to their homes, Maybe if your talking about teens in part of earth that never seen a shell before, those kids have seen it and known about it since they were 2. Not only Israel is killing the innocent kids with random shelling, but it also fabricating stories to dehumanize them..I believe all other news sources rather than this lie...
17. If you find a live artillery shell, what is your response?
Howard ,   Pacific Coast, USA   (05.27.06)
(1) What a cool trophy! I will be the envy of my neighbors! We will hang it over the firepplace! (2) HAMAS pays good money for explosives! Let's bring it home and call them! (3) This thing is a freaking bomb! Stay away from it! Call the security forces to dispose of it! They brought an artillery shell into their HOUSE?!?
18. #5 Ellen - Innocent Palestinians ....
Robby ,   San Jose, USA   (05.26.06)
No one said this 54 year-old farmer was killed intentionally. Even your friends at Al Jazeera did not accuse the Israel of murdering this man. It was an unfortunate accident resulting from several circumstances. However, unlike when a Palestinian kills a Jew - I'll bet there will not be a school or street after the soldier that fired the shell.
19. 20 chickens were killed by a qassam last week, and
Bunnie Meyer ,   Santa Monica, CA   (05.27.06)
this week a "palistinian" is killed by artillary fired at the lauch site of a rocket. Those were Jewish chickens and they were supposed to be slaughtered in a kosher and very quick action to minimize pain. The qassam is not kosher and does not kill quickly. The farmer was killed quickly by the artillary shell. When animals or people die, Jews still do it the correct way, the 'palestinians' still do it the hard way. And that is your kashrut education for the week.
20. Ellen; Hamass spokewoman.
Palestiniansareamyth ,   USA   (05.27.06)
Typical lies of an Arab propagandist. The Arabs intentionally murder Jews not the other way around. The "Palestine" you speak of has never existed!
21. #5: This Family Worthy Of Darwin Award
emanon ,   USA   (05.27.06)
22. #5 Ms. Prescott: no condemnation of Palestinians?
Howard ,   Pacific Coast, USA   (05.27.06)
What do you have to say about an Israeli who was bigotry-free enough to help a Palestinian motorist in distress, & to give him his own bottle of water -- and the Palestinian repaid these acts of basic humanity by stabbing the Israeli? Are you going to condemn the Palestinian? Next time an Israeli refuses to stop to help a Palestinian in distress for fear of being attacked, will you condemn that Israeli? As for the 54 year old farmer -- I am sad that he died. I blame the terrorists who used him as a human shield so that they could bomb Israeli civilians, because the IDF was firing BACK at those attackers when they fired this shell. Have you no condemnation for Islamic Jihad terrorists, who deliberately set up their rockets in his fields/village and endangered him? Do you think they asked him if they could do so? Do you think he would have dared to say no if they had? Of course, there would be no Israeli shells in Gaza at all if Gazan Islamic Jihad were not rocketing Israeli schools and homes daily. What happens in Jenin or Ramallah does NOT need to result in destruction in Sderot and Gaza. Have you no condemnation at all for Islamic Jihad? PIJ in Gaza is not resisting any occupation by rocketing school children; Israel is no longer in Gaza at all. PIJ in Gaza is carrying out acts of terror simply because it is being paid to do so. 54 year old farmers do not need to die. The clearest signs that a person is an extremist are: * S/he believes that one side is always 100% good and right and justified, and the other side is always 100% evil and wrong and unjustified. * S/he believes that when "his/her side" does something wrong or evil or stupid, it is always the fault of the "other side." * S/he believes that his/her cause justifies any action, no matter how repulsive or insane. Personally, I believe that Israel does make mistakes and that there are some Israelis (including some who post here) who take disgusting positions. I have seen no sign at all that you have a similar sense of clarity and realism about Palestinians. And by failing to see them as real people, who can be both right and wrong, smart and stupid, you are guilty of idealizing the Palestinians, which does not help them at all; rather, it encourages the worst of their number and makes the job of their moderates nearly impossible. The Palestinians need their friends to give them a dose of realism, rather than granting unconditional support for acts of insanity.
23. #5
Rick S. ,   L.A.   (05.27.06)
Tell us, Ellen, do you also shed these big crockadile tears for Jews who are INTENTIONALLY blown to bits by your Pali friends while riding in buses, eating pizza, enjoying a Sedder meal, etc, etc, etc? What a bleading heart idiot you are.
24. Why they took shell to home -explanation
Benjamin ,   TA Isreal   (05.27.06)
It's really simple - they were intending to saw it, get out explosive by boiling it in the water and probaly sell it. Or just give it to militants. Extracting explosive from dud shells is a technique used by insurgents all around the world from times of WWII
25. #20 "Palestiniansareamyth"
Majid ,   surrey, uk   (05.27.06)
you foolishly quote "The "Palestine" you speak of has never existed! " this statement is completley false. The Israeli/ Palestinian region has been called Palestine since the 10th Century. Thats 1000 years. according to wikipedia's history of jerusalem: Under the early centuries of Muslim rule, especially during the Umayyad (650-750) and Abbasid (750-969) dynasties, the city prospered; the geographers Ibn Hawqal and al-Istakhri (10th century) describe it as "the most fertile province of Palestine", while its native son the geographer al-Muqaddasi (born 946) devoted many pages to its praises in his most famous work, The Best Divisions in the Knowledge of the Climes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Jerusalem
26. #25 According to "Arab" geographers, you missed that bit:-)
michael ,   tel aviv   (05.27.06)
'the geographers Ibn Hawqal and al-Istakhri (10th century) describe it as "the most fertile province of Palestine"..
27. how can we make peace with such people!!!!!!
Palestinian ,   West Bank   (05.27.06)
what we notice when we raed talkbacks from israelis is the huge amount of hatered and none sense of humanity.If you dont know these kids were killed because they collect shells or parts of shells to sell for few shequels to fight HUNGER.Several weeks ago Ynet had written a long report on this subject.I am so sory for you Ynet to allow such people to write such miserable words and finally they tell us that the israelis are kind and humans!!!!!!! how can we make peace with such people!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
28. answer to #27
Benjamin ,   TA Isreal   (05.27.06)
If you will not make peace with us you will be looking at the defencive wall. And if your life is so hard, why don't you stop demanding "right of return" ? You will not get it in any case, short of nuclear war. So just accept the reality and we can start serious talk. All the rest can be solved. And if you still don't trade this meaningless slogan for peace and quality of the life that mean your life still not hard enough.
29. 4 Mike,Atlanta: You read too many conspiracy stories
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.27.06)
30. 5 Ellen Prescott: What about the Israelis that get murdered
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.27.06)
by Arabs ??? You are SICK ....... why don't you move to Gaza - they love people like you there - they kidnap them Now wake up you silly girl - get off your drugs
Next talkbacks
Back to article