News
Palestinian man murdered child
Efrat Weiss
Published: 28.05.06, 19:55
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
53 Talkbacks for this article
31. To #22
Joan ,   Haifa   (05.28.06)
There were no Palestinians till we came along? That's an interesting statement since the Romans coined "Palestina" for this area. I believe they were referring to the ancient "Plishtim," or "Sea People."
32. And what ''our'' government will do ? NOTHING !
(05.28.06)
33. Arab - USA
Tsedek ,   Israel   (05.28.06)
I agree with you.
34. Not just him
jason white ,   afula,israel   (05.28.06)
Have the animal that hired this illegal worker sit in jail with him.But make sure they never see or hear from their families for the rest of their lives.
35. Yehi Zichra Baruch
gabriela ben ari   (05.28.06)
36. # 34 Jason
yakov shani ,   IL.   (05.28.06)
Ah Jason !! You are naive, no your not, I am cynical. We both know that they will have regular family visits,cigarettes, drugs, apple pie with fresh cream, conjugal rights and who knows what else.
37. She would be alive if Rabbi Kahane was PM, too bad the
Bunnie Meyer ,   Santa Monica, CA   (05.29.06)
Knesset doesn't understand that Israel is supposed to be a Jewish state, not a melting pot of Jews and terrorists.
38. #37 someone put drugs in your carrots bunny??
Jonathan Levi ,   Jerusalem Israel   (05.29.06)
There's a reason no one liked kakahane, he was a disgrace to the Israeli right. He spat on the Mizrachi communities so why would anyone give a s$#t about dirt like kakahane??? He was no rabbi but an imposter bent on murder. I’m a rightist and I always take the toughest stands on the Arabs but people like kakahane turn even on their own so to hell with him where he belongs. Actually the girl was Mizrachi so if she were alive she'd probably be thrown out of Israel because losers like Kahane don’t view the Mizrachi as Jews. In any event this criminal who murdered the girl should be jailed for life without ever seeing the light of day. Put him in a cell with some hardened Jewish criminals with rightist inclinations so we can see how tough he is when having to deal with someone above the age of eight.
39. Israel has no death penalty, unlike Muslim countries
Howard ,   Pacific Coast, USA   (05.29.06)
It is worth asking the following questions -- since he murdered not one but two innocent Jewish children. How many Palestinian kids might he have murdered? And how many times might he have abused his 8 children? If this man only murders Jewish kids, then stop complaining about the headline. He is a terrorist and a coward, and he made a choice to be a Palestinian criminal rather than a generic criminal. If he is an "equal opportunity murderer", he's a threat to any kid who comes near him. REGARDLESS of whether he kills Jews or Jews and Palestinians, he is a pedophile and a child murderer. Lock him up and throw away the key. Of course if he's killed Palestinian kids too, I suppose Israel could always deport him to the PA, where Hamas would presumably put a bullet in him. Or they might appoint him their minister of defense...
40. Bad Apple
ابو العبد ,   Tulkarem   (05.29.06)
Kids are red line pal should not accross(pals will not act like IDF). but i have to agree that I am in love with the headline "Palestinian man murdered child.
41. Unfortunately, in Israel Jewish child's life is as worthless
AK   (05.29.06)
as for the BBC or the Guardian. Can anybody imagine the international outcry if this deliberately targeted, raped a murdered Jewish child were instead an Arab and the murderer a Jew? Can you see the world’s news outlets showing the photos of the tiny girls for months, every hour on the hour. But since this child is Jewish, to the world at large her death does not matter. Israel does not have death penalty and judging by the past behavior, regardless of a Court verdict, the murderer will be released as "a good will gesture" demanded by our government and the EU in no time at all. Obviously limousine liberals like the Olmerts and “the man of the people” Peretz don't really give a heck about this poor little girl, or any other Jewish child and they will have no problem okaying more permits for the PA Arabs to enter Israel.
42. debbie, this child was targetted
AK   (05.29.06)
The child's murder was a political, hate crime. The murderer cannot, must not be excused by you blaming the parents. By the same token, you could blame the parents of the teens murdered at the disco, the parents of the Miami boy, whose parents brought him to Israel. No, it doesn't make sense to blame victims. Yes, good parenting does not include letting your children ran around after dark this days, but the parents didn't murder her, that animal did.
43. Could you name a Jew who deliberately
AK   (05.29.06)
targetted an Arab little girl, raped her and murdered her? Yes, not all Arabs are homicidal depraved barbarians, but why do you just condemn the crime and leave it at that?
44. #8, the headline is factual. Nothing racist there.
AK   (05.29.06)
Now, the nationality of the murderer is relevant because: 1. The murderer was motivated by hate towards Jews; 2. You Arabs commit murder against Jewish children quite often: note those two boys murdered and mutilated; the baby girl shot by sharpshooter; the children murdered in their cribs; shot in a car at point blanc; the list goes on and on... wasn't a 14 year old just knifed in Jerusalem yesterday or the day before? 3. If the roles were reversed, you would be the first running through the street behind the coffin, shooting in the air, while the family of the victim would be tearing their clothes off while screaming and wailing; the UN, EU and President Bush would be issuing personal statements expressing outrage against the crime and sending condolences to the victim’s family. All the while the press would be having a 24/7 coverage of the event, while “civil right” groups would be inserting themselves right in the middle. No, the article is quite mild, all things considered.
45. #10 sameer
AK   (05.29.06)
"every killer must be killed, this is the islamic rule, let us be brave enugh and applye this rule to all killers who ever the victim or the criminal, not to say good killer and bad killer. " sameer God save us from your brand of the law. Self -defense would you punish by killing? How about executioner, would you kill him too? Besides, we already know how Islamic justice works. Thank you, no.
46. 19, but they do not target the relatives of the criminal
AK   (05.29.06)
Not yet, but should you try blowing up buses and malls, we'll see.
47. To #36
jason white ,   afula,israel   (05.29.06)
I worked for awhile in prison and I know what goes on there. They have more vacation time than most of us,they have very good food,they have a gym and instructer{not the Afula country club,but nice}.A beter looking shul than any here in Afula.Free medical and dental care.Free education.And the National Insurace Institute sends their families money each month and helps pay for the children's education.
48. Israel should have the death penalty
Jerusalem,Israel   (05.29.06)
for monsters like this! Fry or hang him and then cremate the body! This evil bastard will rot in hell for all eternity!
49. to BAD APPLE 40
gabriela ben ari   (05.29.06)
IDF NEVER kills palis kids, YOU use them as shields, so IDF needs to get through it. That's your mentality of hating your own spices I thought the suicide bombers at pizza shops, cafes, buses and bar mitzvahs were your own islamic invention and breed. IF talking about killing civilians Correct me if I'm wrong. Good you like the headline, not for the pleasure you admit deriving, but because some other arabs (albeit more sensitive than you) still found it difficult tosee the nationallistic urge behind the murder, you put it loud and clear for all to agree
50. You are the masters in this issue !!!
shukri ,   jerusalem   (05.29.06)
I think this person is an addict . I heard from the arabic news bulletin in Radio of israel that he killed another person from the same family that he was working in selling & buying heroin and other illegal drugs so the problem is a criminal act that can happen anywhere in this small world specially in this countru & USA.
51. #50 Why especially in Israel?
AK   (05.29.06)
U.S. is a country of almost 300 million people and many illegal immigrans from underdeveloped countries, but israel has smaller population than an average city. No, this was one attrocity too many and drugs are not going to explain this. say that the man was warped and depraved pedophile, but please, no excuses.
52. #51 why bother with 50?
Jonathan Levi ,   Jerusalem Israel   (05.29.06)
They love to make excuses for their murderers. Remember, in their eyes they are always right. Murdering is ok when your arab because in their warped minds "allah" sanctifies anything they do. They'll make up any excuse they can and most likely soon they'll be saying the murder was a Jew in disguise because that’s just how reliable arab news is. #50 stop making excuses for a pedophile and just admit that the guy deserves to rot in hell because if he were Jewish I’d be just as harsh. It doesn’t really surprise me though that some of the arabs are fighting hard to lessen the blame on this guy instead of openly condemn the act. A proud and great nation you arabs truly are when all you can do is defend pedophiles.
53. Honor the Holy Child Lipaz Himi
Brana ,   USA   (05.29.06)
"Remember what Amalek did to you, on the way, when you were leaving Egypt, that he happened upon you on the way, and he struck those of you who were hindmost, all the weaklings at your rear, when you were faint and exhausted, and he did not fear G-d."Devarim 25:17-18. Lipaz Himi was the holy child of a holy nation. The mother of Lipaz Himi is right; this animal did not strike at one of his own kind--he struck at Israel. The Palis are not a nation, and they must not be given that distinction. He trespasses into a country that is not his, he kills, he commits adultery, he steals, he bears false witness, he covets. He bribes, he puts a stumbling block before the blind. Justice must and will be done.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article