News
Court approves Shavei Shomron fence
Efrat Weiss
Published: 30.05.06, 16:48
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
28 Talkbacks for this article
1. too bad about the trees
jf ,   nashville   (05.30.06)
I love trees...I love fences even more.
2. Good choice
Antonio ,   Haifa   (05.30.06)
I've heard there aren't many fences in Jordan. These Arabs need to consider moving.
3. There are 22 Arab states where the Arabs claiming to be
Roger ,   USA   (05.30.06)
Palestinian will love to live in.
4. DOOMED
DANIA ,   usa   (05.30.06)
JUST READING THE ARTICLE AND THE COMMENTS ON IT ... YOU ARE A DOOMED NATION BECAUSE GOD IS JUST AND THAT IS INJUSTICE.
5. Israel is killing the two state solution.
(05.30.06)
Not sure its so good for Zionism and israeli security.
6. Up the wall, as fast as you can
(05.30.06)
7. 4 DANIA : Qualified for the precious DOLT Award
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.30.06)
if there is anyone doomed - It is you and your stupid BS just a question - why would you come to a Jewish Israeli Website ? do you suffer from Gasssss and cannot blow air on your own Hate websites ?
8. #5 The Pali's are killing it with constant daily attacks
Jason   (05.30.06)
9. 5 Nameless Bug: Arabs are responsible NO terrorism NO Fence
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.30.06)
Palestinian Arab terrorism has forced Israel to build that protective fence. The international organisation Doctors of the World has qualified the attacks by Palestinian terror organizations against Israelis as "crimes against humanity". The report also concludes that "the Palestinian Authority cannot deny any responsability, at least because of it's ambiguous attitude towards those groups until now." The security fence is a passive means to stop Palestinian terrorists from reaching Israeli civilians. The fence does not constitute a border and it's route is not final. Israel did not want to build a fence, and resisted doing so for more than 35 years. It is building now because Hamas, Islamic Jihad, and the other Palestinian terrorists have left Israel no choice. It is these groups who are to blame for the fence. Fences can be moved - Dead Jews cannot be resurrected. But in general the IDF should have stepped in and cleaned the terrorism out in the first 3 months of the Intifada - but Israel has not yet wanted to show their entire forces - since it would have decreased radical the Arab population.
10. #5, there ARE two states: Israel and Jordan Palestine.
David ,   Boston, USA   (05.30.06)
No need to continue this experiment into creating another Arab Palestinian state when there already is a rather large one. Finish the fence and make the border. Two states: Israel with its eternal undivided capital of Jerusalem and Jordan Palestine with Amman as its capital. This works for everything and is the way things are going. In less than a decade this will be the permanent reality.
11. #10 It will never happen
Ron ,   USA   (05.30.06)
Be realistic.......
12. As the ghetto walls expand,
Ellen Prescott ,   Southsea, Hampshire   (05.30.06)
so will the boycotts from moral nations. Israel continues to wall the Palestinians into Bantustans where they are starving and being bombed on a daily basis. Where tanks bombard through at the latest hours of the night. School children shot to death for 'posing a threat' to the occupying forces. Where soldiers break into houses and force the inhabitants out by gunpoint so that they can watch football. These accounts can't describe even 1 per cent of the cruel oppression that the Palestinians are suffering, whilst Israelis live richly off of the American tax dollar. It's time for this injustice to stop. Soon, I hope that other nations will follow Britain's role and boycott any Israeli who contributes to or supports Israeli apartheid. We must also boycott Israeli products, and corporations that profit from the Apartheid system. http://geocities.com/ellen_southsea Israel: Stop oppressing the Palestinians
13. it will not stand forever
(05.30.06)
like your Parlev defence line which you called it that time the strongest defence line in the history and fall with some water pumps in the Yom kibur's war this one will fall too soon or later .... no security without giving back the stolen rights ... the history say this ... take it or leave it
14. #5 the Arabs already killed that back in 48',u lost, move on
Efraim ,   Israel   (05.30.06)
15. 12 Ellen: You are perfect Subject for a Lawsuit for Racism
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.30.06)
16. Ellens webpage
Mikael ,   New Zealand   (05.31.06)
You claim to be a Professor but you can't even spell Hello? maybe you should return to high school. And your claim to be a humanitarian certainly doesn't extend towards Jews. You, Ellen, are a phony!
17. Ellen Prescott an ISM member - that explains it all
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.31.06)
Look at the links she supports: http://geocities.com/ellen_southsea http://www.geocities.com/ellen_southsea/links.html LINKS she supports: Islamic Human Rights Commission http://www.geocities.com/ellen_southsea/www.ihrc.org.uk MPACUK http://www.mpacuk.org/ Amnesty International http://www.amnesty.org/ Directorate General of Human Rights http://www.geocities.com/ellen_southsea/www.humanrights.coe.int/ International Solidarity Movement http://www.palsolidarity.org/ Stop the wall http://www.stopthewall.org/ The Guardian Newspaper http://www.guardian.co.uk/ University of Portsmouth http://www.port.ac.uk/ Inminds http://inminds.co.uk/ Boycott Israel Campaign http://www.inminds.co.uk/boycott-israel.html
18. Was that a picture of Ellen?
Christopher ,   UK   (05.31.06)
Or a picture or Peter Pettigrew from Harry Potter?
19. By the way Ellen - the Islamofascist boycott site -
Andy   (05.31.06)
on your pathetic website give all of us on Ynet ideas of where TO shop. Pass the diet Coke, please.
20. #16
Ellen Prescott ,   Southsea, Hampshire   (05.31.06)
In the Oxford Guide to English Usage, Hallo is specified as the correct spelling.
21. Ellen is a hideous monster
Yael   (05.31.06)
22. ellen of 'ampshire
Harriet of Hertford ,   co.il of course   (05.31.06)
How about saying goodbye instead.
23. muslim complaints against the wall are another example of
Bunnie Meyer ,   Santa Monica, CA   (05.31.06)
the rule in the koran that any lie may be told if it advances islam. Anything that the terrorists can say against the Jews furthers the cause of the cult that believes in sending inaccurate rockets to the sky hoping they will fall on innocent civilians. The British were bombed twice, during World War Two and just a few months ago by muslims. The bombers had the same level of hate an the same lack of humanity. Build that wall and let the suicide bombers go back to masturbting their bombs on THEIR side of the wall.
24. 20 Ellen:Real Dic. say Hallo =Halloo which means
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.31.06)
Anexclamation to invite attention Also Hunting cry to a dog To cry out But Ellen as we all know : Hallo = German to Hello Have we hear Your true Nature of a great german neo you know what ? Sounds like Actually ..... Hunting cry to a dog . is the most suitable when one see your picture
25. Ellen: You obviously have never been tothe region it shows
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.31.06)
Your lack of comprehension is showing only that you dispise Jews and Israel - Jews being murdered is for you just a little nusance - but it is only Jews - as long as those Arab friends of yours are able bodied and alive to carry out terrorism - that's your only worry. Facts: your so called Ghetto Wall is in Reality: THE ANTI-TERRORIST FENCE It is not forming a Ghetto - Jews and Arabs live on both sides: The anti-terrorist fence Israel is building does NOT encircle the West Bank, like some people pretend. It just runs along the Israeli so called Armistice Green Line. The West Bank - better known as Judea and Samaria - has another border with Jordan. Palestinian Arab terrorism has forced Israel to build that protective fence. The international organisation Doctors of the World has qualified the attacks by Palestinian Arab terror organizations against Israelis as "crimes against humanity". Now since YOU call yourself a humanitarian - doesn't concern yourself - or do YOU solely ignore crimes against Jews and don't find them important in your humanitarian program ? The report also concludes that "the Palestinian Authority cannot deny any responsability, at least because of it's ambiguous attitude towards those groups until now." Security Fences can be moved Israelis murdered cannot be resurrected. Human Lives have to come always before people's inconveniences - surely as a humanitarian youwill agree. The security fence is a passive means to stop Palestinian Arab terrorists from reaching Israeli civilians. Small children and women. The fence does not constitute a border and it's route is not final. A section of the fence is made up of a cement wall. But that section is only 7 km long, on a tolal of 170 km ! And it is built on Israeli territory ! It was erected in an area where Palestinian Arab snipers from Kalkilya and Tul Karem fire on cars passing on the Trans-Israel highway. Don't you think it is important to prevent terrorists from murdering Israelis - being a humanitarian - that should concern YOU. This type of wall exists on European highways as a sound barrier. The remaining 163 km of the security fence are made up of an electronic barrier, much like the one already in place around the Gaza Strip, and along the borders with Lebanon, Syria and Jordan. These fences never stopped the signing of peace accords between Israel and it's neighbours. Moreover, they can be moved easily and their route has been changed following those accords. Now Fences exist everywhere in the world - since it is the quality of the neighbor who will call for fences. You know that YOU in the UK have fences to protect your properties. Israel did not want to build a fence, and resisted doing so for more than 35 years. It is building now because Hamas, Islamic Jihad, and the other Palestinian Arab terrorists have left Israel no choice. It is these groups who are to blame for the fence. it is these groups that should cause your concern as a humanitarian - since real HUMANITARIANS - embrace - also Jews in their protection - They don't make differences for ethnic races. YOU though - YOU make racial differences - that is called RACISM
26. Ellen + others refuse to see Ground Reality: FACTS: in
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.31.06)
videos: http://www.idf.il/media/fence-eng.wmv Israel Security Fence - Ministry of Defense http://www.seamzone.mod.gov.il/Pages/ENG/default.htm http://www1.idf.il/dover/site/mainpage.asp?sl=EN&id=7&docid=32589.EN
27. Ellen You are A Pipe Line of Hate see the video
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.31.06)
http://www.conceptwizard.com/pipeline_of_hatred.html
28. Surviving Palestinian Arab Terrorism Facts
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.31.06)
Surviving Terrorism http://www.cat2002.org/credit/surviving%20terrorism.asx The Ultimate Childabuse by Palestinian Arabs of their own children: http://judaism.c.tclk.net/maabuDAaa0OIUa6KtLde/ Ask for death: http://www.isratv.com/video/filmpmwadsl.asx When the Palestinians say "End of occupation",What do they mean? http://www.frontpagemag.com/media/slideshowimages/slide1.html
Back to article