News
Israeli professor: UK boycott justified
Ynet
Published: 31.05.06, 13:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
118 Talkbacks for this article
31. this idiot ate her self on the last questioned she answered
(05.31.06)
32. Boycotted by YNet
richard Hitchings ,   methil   (05.31.06)
I demand to Know ...WHY I have Been Boycotted by Ynet... My Tuppence Worth is certainly more Sane that much of the Drivel that you allow to be Published in this Forum.
33. why are palestinians so important???
alvaro ,   capital argentina   (05.31.06)
i never heard people talking about the real problems in the world, example AFRICA. come to Argentina if you want to see bad living conditions (or go to any arab country), why are palestinians so important??? maybe because the issue here is to bring down the jews. Always Anti-semitism, at least right wing people and nazis admit it, left wingers blame Israel, so its always the same.
34. Magnificent example!
Ram ,   London   (05.31.06)
The proof of true democracy! If this enlightened, ultra educated, rightous, intelligent, bold and politically correct person lived amongst those she is protecting and spoke against them, how long would she last? She is from the Chomsky branch of Yiddishkite that stir the fire of and gives credence to the growth of anti-semitism that is flourishing worldwide. This group of people are lost to Judaism and seek short lived recognition and glorification by those ready to embrace anyone who will give them reason to justify their inbred anti-semitism. History has chronicled the deeds of traitors for centuries. Nothing has changed. These are todays traitors except, todays traitors have earned the right of "freedom of speech" due to the progress of distorted "human rights" laws instigated and applied by the lefties themselves. Why Ynet should wish to air these people's betraying qualitities is beyond me.
35. Tuppence? Mr. Hitchins, you overvalue yourself!
Ram ,   London   (05.31.06)
36. Ynet is simply putting its opinion through her mouth!
naro ,   nyc   (05.31.06)
Ynet is simply putting its opinion through her mouth! This woman is utterly unimportant and irrlevant, not deserving of a major article. But Y-Net which is too nervous to give its anti-Israeli, pro boycott, stand is expressing it through this interview. An old trick!
37. This proffessor...
Ramzi Sfeir ,   Bethlehem, Palestine   (05.31.06)
This proffessor is blamed for living the true democracy! The Democracy that allows everyone to criticize his own government without getting insulted ! Israel might be Democratic...but apparently, it's people who post talkbacks over here are NOT! Democracy has some sacred rules, and one of them is the RIGHT TO SAY WHAT YOU THINK ABOUT YOUR OWN COUNTRIE'S POLICIES WITHOUT GETTING INSULTED AFTERWARDS! And democarcy means being able to be part of any political party , left or right! All those who dared to insult Proffessor Giora don't know anything about Democracy yet they claim that they want to export it all over the world! I SAY : NO THANKS!
38. Why do the sanction only the Israelis?
(05.31.06)
The current Palestinian government is controlled by a terror organization, why do they not boycott the Palestinian academic institutes? Do they agree with the current Palestinian governmnet policies? This is all BS, it's clear antisemitism.
39. Levi's accusations
Rustum ,   London, UK   (05.31.06)
Kindly stop stating what you think I believe and where you think I get my news. I read English, Hebrew and Arabic (oh my god, he's so polluted!!!). I do not "pick" on Israel but I certainly have issues with people who disdain, demean and humiliate their fellow citizens - and it's certainly easy to find many of them in these pages - Gabrielle Goldwater, Linda Rivera and a whole long list of Arab/Moslem paranoid haters. As for this squalid syndrome of forcing everyone to condemn things, I'll state again that I condemn violence. As for your other squalid accusation that I probably belive the terrorist attacks in Britain were carried out by Jews - that is totally scurrilous on your part, uncalled for, below the belt and unworthy of a response. As for criticising the "Arabs" - well that's a bit rich. When South Africa was a deeply entrenched Apartheid state, the racist white population screamed for years about how the country would be a blood bath, how they were surrounded by petty dictators, etc, etc ad nauseum. What happened? No bloodbath. A flowering of democracy. They are still surrounded by petty dictators and the external "threat" was simply a smokescreen thrown up by the ruling clique to keep their non-whites under control. I wonder if you see any parallels.
40. Kate's abode
Rustum ,   London, UK   (05.31.06)
I wonder why you still live in London after your heart-rending list of British atrocities. Unfortunately, you are screaming fire far too much. You say the British collaborated in the Holocaust and then that they carried out a genocide at Dresden. What drugs are you taking? Mind you, most of the accusations you level against Britain, could just as easily be levelled against Israel. "Her bombing of countless innocent civilisans in Serbia/Lebanon; her illegal invasion of Iraq/Lebanon/Egypt... Her absolute cruelty in putting down uprisings in Malaya/Gaza/West Bank.. the racism and brutality she displayed in her traetment of the Roman Catholic population/Christians and Moslems. Oh dear, oh dear, oh dear. You cannot have it all ways. If you are going to condemn dear old Britain for those activities then you need to spread your net to include the government of the State of Israel since 1948.
41. #32
NP   (05.31.06)
Perhaps you should try posting on a palestinian news paper website. (Wait... do they have news papers?) .. WAIT, do they have INTERNET?! :P
42. #37 an arab is telling me about democracy? LOL
Jonathan Levi ,   Jerusalem Israel   (05.31.06)
How about you first bring democracy to your people before you criticize mine. In any event Ramzi I think you should protect your families honor the arab “democratic” way because I think I just saw your sister cheating on her husband so why not go and do your "honorable" family killing and after you've done your “democratic” arab duty come back here and respond to me about how terrible we Israeli’s are. HYPOCRIT.
43. #37
Ram ,   London   (05.31.06)
Democracy works both ways! You can voice your opinion, and so can those who oppose it. But then, I do not expect your ilk to understand this.
44. Rustum the Rostrum.
(05.31.06)
45. BRAVO Ms Giora
Sabra   (05.31.06)
somtimes Israel need to change ... and not always change the World
46. She is no worse than Sharon and his cronies
N B Shalom   (05.31.06)
If belief in Hashem and his Torah that Israel belongs to the Jews and we have no right to give away even one Iota is lacking then one can expel thousands of Jews of Gush for terrorist , opinions of this naive professor are here. At the end we will all recognise that our Bitochan is in Hashem Echod. Right now many are seeing it just see how many are returning to true Yiddishkeit.
47. Well said, Ram (34)
Tahl ,   Israel   (05.31.06)
I hardly wait to see this highly-educated, ultra righteous professor, come to Balata to live amongst those she sympathizes so much with. I bet she wouldn't last a week, probably much less. This professor, much like prof. Pepe of Haifa University, or Noam Chomsky, despite his intelligence - would go down in the trashbin of history.
48. Interview with Rachel Giora
Tom Lakatos ,   Toronto, Canada   (05.31.06)
Quoting Dr. Giora: "It's hard to express revulsion and shake off criminal acts through cooperation with those who we oppose. Cooperation in the case is mistaken and blurs all of the evil." I expect Dr. Giora will do the honorable thing and resign her position at the University of Tel Aviv. This would be consistant with her stated position.
49. Israel the only democratie in ME?
Sabra   (05.31.06)
if Israel the only democratie in the Medel East and you deeply believe in that it is shamefuul to compare with Iran China or Saudi Arabia or Sudan ......
50. YOU FORGOT TO ACCUSE HER WITH ANTI-SIMITISM
(05.31.06)
51. Good hope
(05.31.06)
Hope we see more like her maybe oneday we can have peace ... Cheering to Professor Giora
52. @ J. Levi, 25/42
David ,   London, UK   (05.31.06)
It is clear that you are passionate about your religious/cultural identity, Mr Levi. There is certainly nothing wrong with that, and IMHO, it is in fact generally a good thing. What is regrettable is your intolerance -- indeed, a seeming hatred -- of those who differ. You "LOL" at the notion of an Arab who knows something of democracy; you generalize the reprehensible acts of a few extremists to a population of millions; and you ridicule via ad hominem responses those who express their reasoned opinions. "Bigot" is defined as: "One who is strongly partial to one's own group, religion, race, or politics and is intolerant of those who differ." Regardless of whether the British academics supporting the boycott are bigots, placing yourself within the definition will not help you advance your cause -- rather, doing so leads the very accusations of hypocrisy that you distribute to be returned to the sender. If you want to make a difference, open your mind, try to understand where others are coming from, and engage in constructive dialogue. Otherwise, your diatribes may help you internally validate your perceptions of anti-semitism, but that is likely all they will accomplish.
53. Apartheid can never be right.
Jim ,   London UK   (05.31.06)
It seems a significant number of people support the aparthied of Arabs in occupied Palestine. They need to be aware that this won't be permitted by the civilised world. If they don't like being boycotted then they need to stop their support for racist oppression.
54. Ms. Giora have some guts and resign
aaron ,   ra'anana   (05.31.06)
how can you take that dirty money from the great satan of the occupation, Israel ???
55. 25Jonathan Levi : Well said indeed -Thanks
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.31.06)
56. 32 Little Hitchings You obviously failed the terms of use
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.31.06)
57. 32 Hitchings:Your tuppence is worth NOTHING but A Rubel only
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.31.06)
and only may be
58. 39 Rustum: Levi is right and YOU wrong and simply a JOKE
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.31.06)
59. 40 Rustum: Stop posting Crap go and do your homework for
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.31.06)
your school lessons OK get of the PC and get off Jewish websites spewing BS
60. Bravo Rachel Giora
Thameen Darby ,   Jerusalem, Palestine   (05.31.06)
Rachel Giora is a brave Israeli. She understands that occupation is bad for both the victim and the victimizer. She has the moral courage to speak up. There is Hope. Free Palestine.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article