News
7 killed by IDF artillery fire
Ali Waked
Published: 09.06.06, 22:29
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
168 Talkbacks for this article
61. Azram # 43
Nachash Tsefah ,   Tel Aviv   (06.09.06)
Mabruk Azram Thank you for recognising that Israel is only doing what the 'Palestinians' should be doing for themselves: getting rid of terrorists who make life unbearable for both sides. Israel does not want to do this; we would prefer that you honour your agreements and keep order yourselves - but if you will not do so, we will act, and act strongly and decisively. Please control your own people; impose order; stop the terrorism that comes from your towns and cities; stop the Jew-hatred in your media and education systems; encourage your people to build a country and to co-exist with us. If your people would try that, you would find that Israelis are willing and bold partners in peace. And Ellen, piss off and go play in the traffic (again) - this time at rush hour!
62. Re#61
Ron   (06.09.06)
U are kidding, U've been a very peaceful people since 1948!!! U are killing Palestinians all over the history.I've been watching the shamed act of your terrorist army that killed 8 people from the same family while they were sitting on Gaza beach.I do not find word to discribe this barbaric act. I am now 100 % sure that Israel and El-qaeda =Israel....
63. #10, #26
David ,   NY City, USA   (06.09.06)
First of all, I do not think comment #10 was written by the real "Ellen", who I implore all Jews to simply ignore, and combat with silence. Read the comment again; the tone is obviously ironic. But as for comment #26: bravo!
64. Newsflash for everyone...
DR ,   Florida, USA   (06.09.06)
Killing known terrorists is NOT terror. It is not Israel's fault that these cowards hide among women and children. That's their own fault...blame the scum that do this. Israel, like any country defends her citizens from these vile creatures. I don't know why people like Shmellen Testiclecot side with the terrorists??? I guess some people hate Israel so much, that no matter what we do it is wrong.
65. richard Hitchings and "Zionist murder"
Kate ,   London   (06.09.06)
The hypocrisy from Hitchings, the board's resident manual labourer, is truly breathtaking. Let's examine the brutal record of the British over the last seventy years: complicity with the Nazis in the Holocaust via numerous channels, tens of thousands of innocent Germans murdered by the RAF at Dresden, thousands of innocent civilians killed in Malaya, thousands of civilians killed in Kenya, a brutal and bloody suppression of a nationalist uprising in Northern Ireland, thousands of civilians dead as a result of the illegal bombing of Serbia by the RAF, over hundred thousand dead in Iraq as a result of an illegal invasion by Britain. Hell, if the world wanted justice, it would have had to lock up half of the British armed forces. And Hitchings has the gall to complain about this unfortunate incident in Gaza!
66. Parallel with Dresden
Moe ,   Londonistan   (06.09.06)
I hate it when people get embarrassed when our enemies are slaughtered. The problem with Bomber Command in WW2 is they only killed 750,000 Huns in air raids. They should have killed more. Dresden was controversial with liberal twats only because it was an exception. If the IDF now start to get apologetic because a few less PA citizens in the world then Heaven help us all.
67. This is a Holocaust!!!!
Ellen Prescott ,   Southsea, Hampshire   (06.09.06)
68. EVERY SANE PERSON HATES DEATH ANY DETH especialy CIVILIANS
Nebojsa Yitzchak M ,   Toronto   (06.09.06)
BUT!! BRINGING OWN CIVILIANS TO THE HARMS WAY is responsibility of CRIMANAL THUGS THAT ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR EVERY DEATH THEY CAUSED. Launching the misiles against the Jewish CIVILIANS from the crowd of its own civilians is cowardly, and despicable and perpetrators are holding a full responsibility. By Geneva convention if "RED CROSS" SIGHN IS PLACED OVER THE ROOF OF AN HOSPITAL it is to be treated under Geneva convention as a civilan hospital and should not be targeted BUT! If someone places a weapon on it A N Y W E A P O N to shoot at oposing side at its moment it become a L E G I T I M A T E T A R G E T. State of Israel has primary DUTY to defend its CIVILIANS against the wanton threat of murderous thugs which have no regards to their own civilians and use them for shield and propaganda purposes. Those thugs are the lowest life form on this planet. They deserve no consideration but JUSTICE.. and only JUSTICE. All those civilian causalties and their blood spiled is of their doing and should be held accountable for every drop of it. IAF and IDF should be commanded for swift and long overdue action against the continuos murderous attempts on Israeli CIVILIAN POPULATION. IDF has no option but DUTY to defend its population.
69. WHY APOLOGISE - ARE WE SO STUPID
Sid Emess ,   JERUSALEM   (06.09.06)
THEY SEND ROCKETS, SUICIDE BOMBERS, ETC TO KILL US CIVILIANS AND WE MUST APOLOGISE?? ARE WE TOTALLY MAD OR STUPID? SHOULD WE SIT AND BE TARGETS UNTIL THEY KILL EVERY ONE OF US IN ISRAEL. SINCE OSLO HOW MANY CEASE FIRES, AGREEMENTS GUARANTEED BY INTERNATIONAL POWERS ETC - NONE OF WHICH WERE EFFECTIVE. THE PA PEOPLE SHOULD GO TO JORDAN WHICH IS 75% OF MANADATORY PALESTINE - THERE SHOULD BE A TRANSFER FROM GAZA AND THE WEST BANK THERE - JUST AS SHARON DID TO HIS SHAME TO THE JEWS OF GUSH KATIF AND N.SHOMRON AND AMONA. WE SHOULD HAVE LEARNT "SPARE THE ROD AND SPOIL THE CHILD" IS SO TRUE
70. SHELL FIRE FROM THE HEROIC ISRAELI NAVY KILLS
(06.09.06)
SEVEN PERSONS OF ONE FAMILY MEN , WOMEN AND CHILDREN PICNIKING ON A GAZA BEACH DECORATIONS FOR BEING ON TOP OF THE WORLD'S TERROR NAVIES. WHAT A SHAME. ISRATERROR.
71. #11
Ram ,   London   (06.09.06)
How smart are your brothers attacking an enemy they know to have guns, aeroplanes etc. as you put it? Think about it!
72. #24. No more intifadas
Ram ,   London   (06.09.06)
It appears the Israeli government is finally building up courage do deal with this scourge as it should. Whilst collateral damage is regretted the Palestinians will have to accept this risk if they persist with their attacks.
73. #67
Jane   (06.09.06)
I beg your pardon? I BEG YOUR FREAKING PARDON! You are a seriously psychotic Jew-hating wretch. A Holocaust? Oh you are a disgrace to what purports to be humanity.
74. BAN ELLEN
(06.09.06)
75. Collateral damage...
Ram ,   London   (06.09.06)
Funny how when Palestinians massacre Jewish women and children we don't hear Abu Mazen's vociferous rebuke of his terrorist friends. It is the norm to expect collateral damage in war. How many of the 60 million people killed in WW2 were civilians? Abu Mazen has made a grave mistake. He kept his mouth shut while his pals were firing kassams at Jews but called it a massacre when the Israelis hit back. What did he expect? I do not understand why Israel should stop shelling the terrorists in Gaza. Surely this should only happen when the Palis promise to stop firing kassams and keep that promise. In this case Israel stopped shelling while the Palis have threatened to send suicide bombers on top of firing kassams. Bad decision by Israel. Terrorist liquidations must go on.
76. WELL DONE..ARABS WANT WAR..THEY GET IT...PERETZ COWARD
(06.09.06)
77. Re: "This is a Holocaust!"
Kate ,   London   (06.09.06)
No, a Holocaust is what the British collaborated in when the Germans and Austrians with the active assistance of most of Europe murdered many millions of Jews. That you could even compare the two things things shows beyond question that your only purpose on this board is to engage in virulent Jew-baiting.
78. WHAT PROOF IS THERE THAT IT WAS ISRAELI EXPLOSIVE?Prove it!
Alan ,   SA   (06.09.06)
79. KEEP CARPET BOMBING
MARK ,   USA   (06.09.06)
80. #49 Ellen Prescott and innocent victims
Kate ,   London   (06.09.06)
"However, when we gave Jews land, we created another problem and victimised an entirely innocent third party; The Palestinians." As another poster has pointed out this is utter nonense, but the truth is that if the gentiles of Britain hadn't effectively collaborated in the genocide of the Jews, then there would have been no Holocaust and no need for an Israel. I can assure you that after that Holocaust it is not Israel's right to life which should be questioned but the evil continent which we both unfortunately call home.
81. HOW DOWE KNOW IT WASNT A WORK ACCIDENT/KASSAMfalling in sea
Alan ,   SA   (06.09.06)
82. Here's an example of British media bias
DPC ,   England, UK   (06.09.06)
"Israeli forces today attacked the northern Gaza Strip with a series of air strikes and artillery fire, killing at least nine Palestinians, including six civilians who had been enjoying a family picnic at the beach." Guardian UK ....gosh, I suppose Al Zarquawi was just innocently having a nice family picnic too. Could anyone with a brain seriously believe the IDF would just - being "evil jews" - go and purposely harm innocent children? They're shields for the terrorists. Palestinians see children as cannon fodder or shield cover.
83. to all the Jews that condone this
mike ,   san diego   (06.09.06)
Im 100% supporter of Israel and IDF, my best friend made an aliyah 2 years ago and is now in the Golani infantry, half of my family lives in Israel. ..so it bothers me when some here lament that there werent more casualties and death. We are not palestinian, we are not arab, we are not terrorists. Wishing for death is wrong, its against everything Jewish and everything that is right and true. There were kids, little kids that were hurt and maimed and killed here, not ideological terrorists, but little kids, playing on a beach!! I realize this was an error, unclear what happened yet, but it sickens me to hear fellow Jews saying sickening stuff, that usually comes out of a mouth of a Hamas supporter. The Israeli army is the most humanitarian army in the world, this is a fact, but we have to admit that even the most highly trained professionals make mistakes. Its human.
84. This is the fault of the Palestinians...stop bombing Israel
David ,   Boston, USA   (06.09.06)
If Palestinians didnt bomb Israel daily from Gaza, none of this would have happened. Choose peace and prosperity instead of incitement and murder.
85. This is an attack vs. innocents.
Joe ,   Brooklyn, NY   (06.09.06)
When people tell me that Palestinian terrorism is justified because of the occupation, I tell them, as you all should, that violence against innocent civilians is never justified. I can't believe that people on this talkback seem to justify an attack against innocent Palestinians on a beach by bringing up Palestinian terrorism. The bottom line is that if Palestinian terrorism is always wrong because it is always wrong to target innocent people, then this beach attack by the IDF is wrong and unjustified for the same exact reason.
86. jıhad terrorısts hıt paLs accıdentLy
(06.09.06)
87. there ls no and there was no a state paLastanlan
(06.09.06)
88. 65 Katies "Unfortunate Incident"
richard Hitchings ,   methil   (06.09.06)
is of course the multipal murders of Gaza Concentration Camp Inmates....... If such an Incident happened in Golders Green...... You May be sure that the Perpetrators would be brought to Justice.... In the Zio Entity it was an "Unfortunate Incident".. "A Deviant Shell"
89. #67, Ellen the revisionist. Yyou know what a Holocaust is?
David ,   Boston   (06.09.06)
How disgusting are you to compare this to the Holocaust? You should be ashamed as a Brit for being part of the killing of Jews during the Holocaust and ethnically cleansing Palestine of its Native Jews in the early 20th century. As for this incident Look at the facts. Israeli has far superior fire power, yet when Israel attacks terrorists very few civilians are killed unless the terrorists are such cowards they hide amoung civilians. Most of the IDFs defensive responses are pin point accurate. On the otherhand, when the Palestinians attack Israeli civilians they kill as many people as they can. They have no mercy, no honor, no humanity. There is no comparison on morality. The IDF has the high ground by far. While not perfect, it is exemplary.
90. How can Britian/America/UN/ETC Complain About This!!!
(06.09.06)
How dare they insult the Israel regarding this when they have the odacity to invade Afghan/Iraq/Kuwait/Vitnam and kill "civilians". The only ones that will care and help us in the end are Jews. Our allies are only temporary. Am Yisroel Chai!!!!!!!!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article