News
Gazan after IDF attack: Dad died in my arms
Ali Waked
Published: 10.06.06, 00:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
97 Talkbacks for this article
61. Dear, dear little girl !
Marcel Abel ,   Thoiry, France   (06.10.06)
sk, USA, your indecency has no limits. "Boo Hoo" is it your humane way to console a little, crying girl on her dead daddy, a girl who has lost her whole family in a few seconds. Whatever her nationality : she is not responsible for the insanity of men. Please God comfort Wiham and take her family to your paradise. Please my Lord help her through hard times, heal her physical and moral injuries and those of all victims, Israeli or not. Good luck little girl on the road to Peace and Love.
62. Missile
tony ,   paris   (06.10.06)
hey Palestinian,,,Do you really think that if a missile was fired,at those poor people ,There would have been survivors??,A missile does MUCH,more dammage ,than what we saw on the beach..have you forgotten the Thousands of Lies ,your GRREAT,LEADERS,have told the world,every time an incident like this happens,Yes it is very sad that these palestinians have died,but you people show such disrespect for human lives,One cannot but think that this incident,is yet once again a BIG LIE,of the Hamas,You guys have been using these beaches,to fire quassams on Israel,Could'nt one of these Exploded causing these unfortunate deaths.. When proof of these killing incidents,on behalf of the terror factions come to light,We do not hear condemnation from you,Or is it OK to kill your own people???"Accidently"? I am sure that the Hamas are using you Palestinians yet once again;to get what they want,Even killing you,by any means to blame the Israelis..Has'nt Hamas refused the referendum,proposed by Abbas??I am really sorry to say this,but this Incident comes at a very convenient,time for them,Does'nt it???
63. Investigation??
tony ,   paris   (06.10.06)
Just one question.When have the Palestinians,lanced an investigation into "one "of their "MISTAKES"or "Work Accidents"??,I am sure that if the Palestinians were Sincere???they will see that these shells are part of the Qausams and other artillary,constantly fired at Israel;And like Mr Johnson said,THE PALESTINIANS HAVE ONLY THEMSELVES TO BLAME,AND THEIR LEADERS,WHO ARE THE REAL RESPONSABLES FOR THIS UNFORTUNATE INCIDENT. The Palestinians have from day one,fired these rockets into Israel,from the evacuated terretories..Must Israel just sit back and wait until ,YOU decide to stop firing???Do you think that the Israeli's are that stupid..The only unfortunate ones in this ,are you Palestinians,for not having enough courage and GUTTS to put a stop to these Terrorist factions..Isn't it "VERY CONVENIENT" for the hammas ,that this incident should happen now,especially when ABBAS is calling for a referendum,????This Incident has the HAMMAS Brand,and I'm sure you Pals,are aware of it,but Its easier to put the blame on Israel,than shake a fingre at the Hammas....and not until at least ONE Palestinian stands up and says STOP,To Hammas,will there be peace, You Pals will fire a few quassams & Israel will replique with Missiles,etc,etc,,etc,and we all know who will loose in the end...
64. missile??
pierre ,   belgique   (06.10.06)
Surely if a missile landed and did all that "Dammage",would'nt we see a BIG hole or something???and why such a dramatic picture of that girl screeming,little children doNOT react like that ,One can clearly see that something has occured,and people have died,but,this is clearly a very "STAGED scene,"yet once again buy the Palestinians.. The Palestinians are calling this a Crime against Hummanity,Then what do we call A Palestinian,suicide Bomber,blowing up,a restaurant or a bus full of Israelis????A simple Terrorist attack??? Has'nt the world seen enough of these supposed"Israeli terror attacks"to know that the Hammas is quite capable of sacrificing their own to get world sympathy..I guess not..For they have succeeded,yet once again,to pull the blinds over our eyes???
65. who bourght this cancer to our region
AHmed ,   Haifa   (06.10.06)
you jews have created a killer state with no morlaity what so ever. You kill and kill and kill. you think you are superior and this allow you to kill and say it is not our fault. your are a disgrace to humanity, you are a shame to our nations, you should be ashamed of lack of human respect.
66. IDF: Israel disgrace fore
kamal ,   Ejerusalem Palestine   (06.10.06)
It is amazing what we read from jewish people. I see so much hate like you were hated , I see so much extremism , the same one you suffered from , I see so much disgrace to palestinian live , the same one you suffered from . Wake up,. you have lost all senses and became simply a state of murdereds
67. I prefer not to comment, eahhhhhhhhhhhhh
atmawi ,   Historic Palestine   (06.10.06)
68. For 155mm artillery shell, thats a mighty small crater
(06.10.06)
69. to Ahmed
mona ,   russia   (06.10.06)
Why are you leaving in Israel if you so hate this state?
70. I'm such a bad fellow (36, 61)
sk ,   USA   (06.10.06)
36: " I think your name "sk" explains how your twisted mind works ..."sick "man . "Dehumanization of the enemy is necessary in war fighting" this is what you wrote in your email. I'm sure the Germans used the same language when they killed 6 milion Jews.How ironic..... " No Allan, no irony. I am sure that ALL armies dehumanize their enemies, whether German Nazi armies or Alliance armies. However, not all armies are dedicated to gathering together, imprisoning, gassing, and then incinerating an entire people. I don't want to kill the "Palestinians"; I just want them out of my country. 61: Sorry that you are moping about the moppet. Don't worry, though, there's a great chance that her father's doing perfect well. This looks like a pallywood production (see link below) - and not Pallywood's best work, I should add. Carefully staged, with cameras and lights being moved to capture the action, a WAY overacting girl, and (it seems) a dead man beginning to rise at the end (I think some of the ending has already been removed. Guard the orginal videos with your lives!). http://www.seconddraft.org/movies.php I find it most odd that this happens the day after the successful IAF strike on the terrorist. Hm, trying to change the subject? Bottom line, Marcel, I don't believe this story, it hasn't been sourced at all except for allegations by a girl, and it doesn't fit the facts so far evident. Finally, under no circumstances will I convulse in a paroxism of grief when people who would gleefully kill me are killed instead. I say this even if the footage and the event were real.
71. There is no sign of an artillery shell on the sand
(06.10.06)
Anyone who's witnessed a shelling can tell that 155mm shells leave huge holes (something like 1.5m deep and 3m in radius) in the sand, they burn all of the area and leave black marks on the ground, I dont know what it was but that's definatly not an IDF artillery shell.
72. SHAME OF YOU AND STOP THIS PROPAGANDA CONTRA JEWS
AVINU   (06.10.06)
So all of you have forget tel aviv bombings -- no one cried for Jews ? forget Daniel WAlz died like in his father arms ? But that palestinian subhumans put on fire their own children and you cry for them ? Nice pretending , Oh and bring almost result every one cry for them ? i am cring for Daniel Walz ! Thank you IDF for your excellent job , that is your holy duty to defend your people Dont forget Sderot and other places Jews have been sacrified every day Bush is right Israel must defend herself .
73. Hello...any sane human being left on earth?
Ramzi Sfeir ,   Bethlehem, Palestine   (06.10.06)
hey hey hey! For all those of you who are claiming that this is a Setup, and that the idea that this girl is screaming like that is the proof, and especially to the person who claims to work in psychology, i suggest that someone takes away his diploma because for every action there is a reaction and this girl lost 3 members of her family last month and now she lost her parents and brothers and sisters, what you , psychology expert don't understand is that some children become adults VERY soon(especially during war time) and this girl is one of them, i shall remind you that Its quite traumatic to see your family killed around you and not to scream like that, its idiotic to assume that everyone should have the same reaction when facing the same event!! Every person has a different reaction! Stop denying reality! What happened was a huge mistake and a huge crime and no matter how you try to justify it, it is a crime ! You don't have any right to question the sincerity of this little girl ! You owe her a lot , a lot! You : ISRAEL, Hamas, the Palestinian Authority! I guess that everybody owes her a huge appology, and it will never be enough! Have some humanity, accept this tragedy! ACCEPT IT , it's horrible when you question the tears of a child, israeli or palestinian! IT IS HORRIBLE and by doing this, you are crossing a big big Red line! Take a minute, close your eyes and think about all the children who became orphans during these bloody years! BEG FOR FORGIVNESS! we all owe them an apology and much more than that! All those who justify such acts are MURDERERS and i repeat, whether israeli or palestinian, jew or muslim or christian or budhist, we all have the MORAL obligation of feeling responsible for this Tragedy! ENOUGH WAR! ENOUGH BLOOD!
74. We are sorry
Michael Steiner   (06.10.06)
Nothing can assuage the pain these children are feeling but every Israeli and Jew the world over feels sincere and deep remorse over the incident. While I am sure it was not done intentionally, my heart nonetheless rends. Hadil, Latifa and Wiham: we are truly sorry and hope you will find it in you to forgive us one day.
75. no shame
Michael ,   Haifa   (06.10.06)
The values of those of you, who spew out your hatred here condoning the killing of innocent people by a regular state army, are no different from those of the murderous terrorists who kill innocent Israelis. Can't you get it through your thick skulls that all killing of innocents is evil and that there can be no justification whatsoever for it ?
76. I call Hamas to act with retraint...
Kofi Anan ,   Darfur   (06.10.06)
77. To # 42 Yehu Ben Zohar -- thank you
Avinu   (06.10.06)
Thank you so much for words of truth . Hashem bless you .
78. Kuwaitai to Adopt Hadil
richard Hitchings ,   methil   (06.10.06)
for this little girl.... Didnt Kuwait expel 300 000 Palestinians en masse after the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait ... No Doubt they tortured and murdered many before driving this unfortunate People to a Grim Oppresive Future in Iraq.
79. # 73 Ramzi, Yes Ramzi
yakov shani ,   IL   (06.10.06)
I am sane and you know I am, but you do not respond. Perhaps it is because you know that my sanity compells me to state the truth for which you have no answer. Sachtein Ya Ramzi.
80. SHAME !!!!!! of you Michal Haifa # 75
Avinu   (06.10.06)
I see you have no shame ! I like to defend anything even hoax ! stop Propagana contra JEWS we are in pain because of people like you ! It is not too much noise , condem , sorry ,apology WHEH JEWS DIE ??????????
81. TO #75 MISTER MICHAEL NOSHAME
AVINU   (06.10.06)
Michael Noshame did you read last news ? no ? OK, i read for you : ROCKET LANDS ON GAZA HOME 4 PALESTINIANS HURT -- WERE INJURED WHEN ROCKET A I M E D AT I S R A E L LANDED ON THEIR ON BEIT LAHYA < but they really mean you palestinian-lover ,THAT was their Qassam sending to you . 4 palestinian are hurt will you cry ?
82. AVINU
Michael ,   Haifa   (06.10.06)
you are precisely the thick-skulled moron I was referring to in my previous remark
83. Yakov ya yakov...
Ramzi Sfeir ,   Bethlehem, Palestine   (06.10.06)
yakov you are sane...i am sane....but we have a few different conceptions of reality! I am not trying to put the blame on anyone specifically i just would love to see every side recognizing it's mistakes Without putting a part of the Other side in the story! We make mistakes you make mistakes and we have to recognize it! And Yakov , I have nothing to worry about, i reply when i think that my answer will be constructive, in your case, you want me to say that palestinians are to blame and i will not say it, thats why i prefer not replying! Remember my theory about equal grounds for everyone ?
84. Once more - ALL STAGED
HAWK - EYE ,   blue sky   (06.10.06)
if there was an explosion of any kind... and I say again IF AT ALL - it was caused by a mine whose cover in form of a plate is clearly seen on the scene of the "explosion"... Rags STAINED with "blood" are no evidence to an explosion,,, sorry- next time you try to stage a theatrical piece - you have to be a "little more" convincing... - NO CRATER, NO SHRAPNELS ... Next time, prepare a crater in advance and bring some shrapnels.
85. EMET
YELED ,   ISRAEL   (06.10.06)
how are we going to explain this to our children when they grow up?thats if any of them survive and if their hearts arent full of hate. why is it we can control the sucesses but not remedy the failure? toda raba shaitan.
86. Pallywood, the day after
sk ,   USA   (06.10.06)
Last time I commented directly on Ynet's resident "Palestinian," Ali Waked, my comment was not printed. We'll see if this was an error or censorship. If this was one big staged event, Ali Waked should be fired. And there's no need to stop there. Who hired Waked? A journalist is supposed to uncover facts, not to perpetrate frauds on the public. And now we find that the "Pals" are not disclosing info that would clarify the details of this incident. http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3260996,00.html Hm... If this turns out to be a fraud, will we hear any apologies?
87. Dear sk, USA
Marcel Abel ,   Thoiry, France   (06.10.06)
I know you are a GOOD fellow. My point was just your wording. Your are probably better informed than me : I would rather you were RIGHT, a little girl amid her family again, full of overwhelming joyfullness and filled with happiness. You know I am not the last to blame the killers (terrorists) of Israelis, especially when "human" bombs spread terror and death. Everybody knows here on the site my profound, sincere empathy with Israelis. I am one of your regular readers and your postings have helped me often -except those sometimes a little too polemic, even a bit aggressive against my faith as a Catholic, but sincere, loyal confrontation will bring us MORE LIGHT as Goethe whispered at death's door - to work out reality in its various components. I am SORRY if my wording (indecency) was felt inappropriate according to new points I might not have considered. Of course I may have been too much focusing on the tragic aspects of that trying scene : a moppet giving vent to her boundless despair. I do agree with you on your main concerns and next time I will not separate form and content. But would you admit it remains to be evidenced if it was a making of special visual effects. You have now thrown me into confusion. As I want to be confronted with facts, study their facets in the Descartes way (Discours de la méthode) and then try to make as appropriate conclusions as possible. « One needn't fear to handle the truth roughly; she is not invalid. » Woodrow Wilson in Address, 1918. You did it and you are probably right : perhaps I let language be too much the dress of thought (Samuel Johnson in Lives of the Poets). I thank you very much for the link I will not miss to visit and meditate. Yours truly. Marcel Abel (France).
88. #87 (Marcel Abel)
sk ,   USA   (06.10.06)
Thank you for the kind words, Marcel. I haven't thought of Descartes in twenty years, but I share your admiration for his astounding _Discourse_. I really should read Johnson as well.
89. It wasn't us after all!
Jim ,   Atlanta, USA   (06.10.06)
Guess what, we are not the monsters the liberal press makes us out to be after all!
90. Messed up story
DPC ,   England, UK   (06.11.06)
How come the family invited a red crescent ambulance and camera crew to their picnic? LOL.....don't tell me the little girl used a mobile phone to call the press, red crescent, etc whilst all her family were dead (and presmably waited HOURS - after the ambulance had to pass through israeli check points - before eventually climaxing into a fit of inconsolable anguish? To all those "pallywood-theorists", i checked cnn's video and i didn't see any dead people walking...you might have been reading the new testament too much. However, the story is a load of rubbish, that much is clear.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article