News
IDF strikes in Gaza again
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 11.06.06, 12:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
28 Talkbacks for this article
1. The BBC isnt pushing the story much. They know something???
Alan ,   SA   (06.11.06)
Why didnt Israel wait for enquiry to complete its findings before commenting..That Beach Scene was a Pals Production by Vistavision and Dolby...Olmert must capitalise on this story during his Eurabian Safari(not that it would help anyway against such Jewhaters!)
2. baruch hashem
(06.11.06)
am yisroel chai
3. These are senstive days
Sam ,   Canada   (06.11.06)
It's either make peace or these tragedies are going to continue on both sides. That's the simple message for Israelis and Palestinians. I see a greater readiness to stand on principles than to make the effort to work out solutions.
4. gentile comment
alterkocker ,   spain   (06.11.06)
Why do you not state in your terms that you will not accept comment from any gentile or any (self-hating) jew? 'Will not' because you are incapable, for one reason or another, of accepting any criticism, no matter how fair, reasonable and well intentioned, not only of Israel but of any jew anywhere in the world. Other people's frustration at your refusal to listen and take notice is one reason for 'anti-semitism'. Another is the way you bleat, calumniate and fulminate against your critics or anybody you consider has done you some wrong, however slight, whilst behaving with such ferocious and wicked brutality against those weaker than yourselves. You thus make all worthwhile (objective) impossible. at people's attitude towards youthe
5. alterkocker , spain
(06.11.06)
cause you are plain & simply wrong
6. #4 alterkocker
Ram ,   London   (06.11.06)
Not everyone posting on this site is articulate nor self controlled, and it would be fair if you did not reach your conclusion based on their postings. Some of these people have lost dear ones to suicide bombers and vent their feelings in a democratic way. Wheter you understand the true Israeli/Palestinian conflict is doubtful to me simply because you quote " whilst behaving with such ferocious and wicked brutality against those weaker than yourselves". The Palestinians are much weaker then the Israelis. Has that stopped them from attacking Israel incessantly? Every day Israel stops would be suicide bombers and is the victim of qassam attacks. Have you no advice for the Palestinians on this foolhardy actions? Anti-semitism is not the result of Jewish or Israeli actions. This is a deeply institutionalised phenomenon that you can educate yourself in by research in the internet. Israel has proved itself time and again to be receptive of criticism be it from gentiles or Jews themselves. Just read the news and you will find that even the prime minister's daughter voices her opinion which one hopes contradicts that of her father. True democracy. Best wishes.
7. "Assassinate"
stefano ,   usa   (06.11.06)
A point of grammar and connotation for the article's author and Y-net's editor: "the Israel Defense Forces renewed targeted assassinations"." "Assassinate" is an inappropriate word for this and similar situations, since it carries a connotation of killing a prominent person, and also in a treachorous or suprise way. But in fact, those killed are not prominent people, just foot soldiers; the IDF actually is engaging enemy combatants during or immediately before/after military action; and the IDF is telling them they will do so in advance.
8. gentile comment
alterkocker ,   spain   (06.11.06)
See what I mean, folks?
9. #7 Your interpretation of "Assassinate" is brilliant. 10/10
Alan ,   SA   (06.11.06)
Thats why BBCand similar Jihadi agenda stations use this word.How can one soldier "assassinate" another soldier.Rubbish int it!
10. Alterkocker and criticizing
Sam ,   Canada   (06.11.06)
if you want to criticize you are going to have to learn to take criticsm too. "If you can't take the heat ,get out of the kitchen"
11. Why not
yakov shani` ,   IL   (06.11.06)
try firing a few dozen out of date 155shells into some empty fields. It might be very effective. Who knows? it might even solve the problem !.
12. gentile comment
alterkocker ,   spain   (06.11.06)
Interesting you mention Palestine. Why do you always talk about your own as being 'dear ones' when you never refer to killed Palestinians as being anyone's dear ones? As far as informing oneself from the 'news' or the internet, is concerned, it depends who is producing the 'news' or information. Do you not even know that much? Perhaps you should read these news and internet sources you refer to, less, and then you might be better informed. To help you understand 'anti-semitism', you have to realise that someone has to be likeable or lovable to be liked or loved. NO MATTER WHO THEY ARE. It is not a case of deciding to like or dislike and then imposing it upon something or somebody. And the contrary applies. People are generally liked if they are likeable and loved if they are lovable, etc. At least that is the way it is for the rest of us. When you people decided to poach the word 'anti-semitism' and use it uniquely for yourselves as a means of defending yourselves by destroying the critic and not the criticism, you made a very silly mistake. Why must a criticism of Israel, justified or not, always be regarded as anti-semitic, as anti-jew? Let me know where on the internet you could find a rational explanation for that?
13. I am not Jewish and I think alterkocker
DANNY ,   America   (06.11.06)
Is just dumb. I feel bad for him, for being mentaly short as well as short sighted. Hey fool, your not seeing the whole picture, but with 1/2 wits and 1/2 facts you tell US anything. NOT... You got it all wrong.
14. Did anyone notice
Isac ,   Florida   (06.11.06)
how surprisingly quick the TV crews where at the scene filming this place? It all seems to odd. Let's wait until all the facts come out!
15. "When you people decided to poach"
(06.11.06)
you ppl. as a derogatory generalizing expression for all Jews or Israelis Altenkocker or Alter Nazi well understood
16. Golda would have ended this long ago
Marcel ,   Florida   (06.11.06)
The sissey men who rule Israel are more worried about worthless PR . This has made them slaves to world opinion instead of defenders of Israel. This trash should be run out of office and replacce by those who understand the value of a defeated enemy.
17. Altenkocker
Craig Trsitram ,   Western Australia   (06.11.06)
Its easy to spout off when you are not on the receiving end of violence, remember genocide stopped in 1945 or so we are told, do we as Israelis just roll over and take another beating, I don't think so
18. alterkocker is a fool
curt ,   Philadelphia, PA   (06.11.06)
Alterkocker provides criticism of Israel's actions without suggesting alternatives. Alterkocker should learn that uses big words does not bolster an argument. The days of Jews being weak and getting slaughtered by anti-semites are over. Jews and Israel are going to defend themselves, whether against hostile peoples like the arabs or ignorant anti-semites such as alterkocker. Hey alterkocker, I see you are from Spain. Europe has lost all right to preach to the Jews about morality after you tried to wipe out world jewry in the worst genocide in the history of mankind. You can now crawl back into the hole from which you came.
19. When HAMAS killed 20 Pal kids, there was less noise from PA
me ,   here   (06.11.06)
20. 13. I am not Jewish
alterkocker ,   spain   (06.11.06)
Christ! Look at the sort of stuff that is coming out now! All one needs with you people is to give a little tweak.
21. Hate, hate, and more hate
alterkocker ,   spain   (06.11.06)
As an exercise to prove or disprove a point several of my associates and I have been debating, I commented on one of your articles today. The amount of hatred it unleashed is staggering. I have never seen or read anything quite like it. 'Never again' is right. Goodbye, fellow human beings.
22. #4
(06.11.06)
Why don't you criticez the Palestininans with this much vigor when they send their murderers to the heart of Israeli cities to deliberately target and murder innocent men, women and children? Your discrimination is digusting.
23. #20
Allan ,   Delray Beach, FLA   (06.11.06)
When you stir a hornests' nest be prepared to be stung. You stirred it, now you're getting stung. Take it or go away!
24. I don't get it? you said something...
DANNY ,   America   (06.11.06)
about "accepting any criticism" Oh and you did so well today, Hypocrite . You couldn't see truth if it blew up some of your trains. Oh I forgot it wasn't the Jews who did that. Never mind. You couldn't see lyers if they blew up a bunch of your trains.
25. alterkocker , spain
(06.11.06)
nothing that came out of you was objective, you will have to accept that ppl. react to your nazi and islamic style hate
26. I have never seen or read anything quite like it.
(06.11.06)
you must be on the internet since 2 days ??
27. Alterkocker? thats a VERY unfortunate surname
(06.12.06)
28. Palestinain coup
Hilda ,   USA   (06.12.06)
Once again they have proven that they are masters at the media. o begin with Israel must know that the Media is NEVER on Israel's side. They are left wing to begin with and bleeds only for anyone who is not Jewish. So when they get a meaty story like this one, they run with it. So what happens, Israel appogogizes and agonies ove what what NOT THEIR FAULT in the first place. This is another el Duro affair where the Palestinines killed their own and then profits from it by laying the blame on the Israelis. This girl is the next poster child. One picture is worth a thousand words, they say and this proves it. Just as the elDuro picture was a hoaz , this is also an attempt on furthering anti Israeli feeling and it has succeded beyong their wildest hope. The Israeli deaths from the constant barrage don't count at all. After all Jewish blood remains the cheapest blood in the world. and the Olmert Peretz combo don;t help one bit because they will not fight back a war the way it should be fought.
Back to article