News
No shrapnel found in Gaza victim's body
Meital Yasur-Beit Or
Published: 20.06.06, 18:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
46 Talkbacks for this article
1. this is another reason why israel is morally superior
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (06.20.06)
israel admits when wrong is done. palestinians lie AND try to cover it up. typical.
2. The "Ellens" of the world will not listen.
Tahl ,   Israel   (06.20.06)
No, they would just find some twisted, bizarre way, in which they would twist this story (which works in favor of Israel's image) into some more crap on Israel. Israel haters never let the facts of the story get in the way of their hateful agenda.
3. More proof it was a qassam
Arie   (06.20.06)
4. shrapnel removed? Maybe there was none to begin with
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (06.20.06)
It is doubtful that Palestinian emergency medics or surgeons could remove all the shrapnel without seriously harming the patient.
5. to #1
(06.20.06)
itseems you are a believer in super races. good luck you rotten racist hater of humanity.
6. to #5
ron ,   Newark, NJ   (06.20.06)
# 1 said only thaht Israel is MORALLY superior, not that they believe they are a superior race. Moron.
7. ellen/olivia what's your explanation?
(06.20.06)
8. Please stop
(06.20.06)
upsetting certain poeple here.Not nice of you writing these articles showing us in even in a slightly positive shade. Not good for the morale of that lot. You have to say at least three times a day Israel is rotten, in order to keep them happy. You'll throw them off balance with this kind of reporting.'Biased reporting' they'll scream at you, so watch it you guys. Find four or five items that show the reverse, or they'll cry...
9. #2
(06.20.06)
Some have fixations about hareidim, sme have fixations about 'ell. Both categories are complimentary to the reciprients and a self goal to the scorer.
10. #5 Who's talking about races you idiot
(06.20.06)
11. Pals win "Oscar"(best acting)+"Nobel Prize"(best Surgery )
Alan ,   SA   (06.20.06)
12. don't bark dog number 5...
stephane ,   france   (06.20.06)
you are upset cause you wanted so much that all was caused by tsahal,but now you're disappointed cause you see that the bad comes one more time from your dear islamikazes!i have read in the hebrew ynet website,that the israeli doctors found many parts of the body of the wounded sewed before the islamikaze "doctors" give the wounded to the real doctors in israel.it means that islamikaze "doctors " wanted to hide the truth before leting the israeli doctors do their job:the pals put out the shrapnells of the PALESTINIAN mine from the body of the wounded because they didn't want the world to see that the inquiry of tsahal was the truth.
13. to#5
(06.20.06)
it seems to me you're a hate monger accusing people of racism.. there is no Israeli race. i fart in your general direction, you're mother was a hamster and your father smells of elderberry
14. to Mike #1
Rafi   (06.20.06)
IDF morally superior. Are you kidding?Didn't you hear about the collective rape at IAF base. 52 IDF soldiers have raped a 13-year old Israeli girl and you are talking about morality. Please shut up... Read the disgraceful histroy of IDF. You will be chocked. Any way IDF committed a genocide at Gaza beach no way to deny this fact.THe body of the wounded girl from gaza is clear from shrapnels .What does this mean. May be Pal doctors have removed it for some (medical ) reasons.Read, analyse, try to get out with results and then you can judge. Don't be stupid.
15. #14..."rafi"
stephane ,   france   (06.20.06)
do you think you convinced someone with your "comedia" about this rape case?? so what,big deal,this rape it's sad and bad for the image of israel;but i remind you that israeli soldiers are human being,and in the human nature sometimes men do mistakes and bad things.but you,before telling other to think;you should think first:the americans raped viet women during viet nam war,russian did the same in chechenya,portuguese in angola,french in algeria,germans....etc,etc...but in more than 60 years i have never heard of palestinian women raped by israeli soldiers! where can you find such a moral army ?? ha where rafi!? i can be wrong in many things in life,but i was in the idf,and i can tell you that israeli are the most human soldiers in the world.i will even say that pals are licky that their ennemies are israeli.pals complain but they know very well the difference with their arabs brother for exemple.remember what the jordanian army did to pals in september 1970!about 15000 pals dead in less than 1 month! ok rafi,i stop here cause i don't want to ridiculise you more than that...shalom haver!
16. #14 You're the one who's stupid, blaming the whole IDF...
Yonatan ,   USA   (06.20.06)
You can't accept that the whole Gaza beach thing was staged. YOU'RE the one who needs to read and anylize. Did you not read that there is NO medical reason to remove the shrapnel? I learned this when I was in Desert Storm. YOU have no room to thow insults because YOUR facts are so distorted.
17. Its Been Proven Its Not An Israeli It Was The PLO
(06.20.06)
But nothing will stop your anti Jewish hattred
18. it's amazing what pali doctors can do nowadays
(06.20.06)
19. to Stephane #15
Rafi   (06.20.06)
Arretes stephane it is no a comedia, it is a fact and you can't deny it.Of course IDF soldiers are human beings but with this act and others they are immoral.I assure you that I think before I judge , don't worry. Iam talking here about Israeli soldiers raping a poor and innocent Israeli little girl don't forget.For your information, apparently you don't follow all Israeli news,four months ago a high rank Border Police officer working in Ma'ale Adumim settlement have raped and abused a 22-years old Pal girl .O.K stephane and I will not stop her even if this rediculise you .Read the flashnews on Yediot , 20 minutes ago IAF have killed 2 children in Gaza. A 6-year Old boy and an 11-year old girl and you come here to say that Isr soldiers are moral, stop it , I have more.
20. 14even if all you say is true, israel STILL morally superior
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (06.20.06)
israel at least TRIES to not target civilians. that says it all. and every culture, unfortunately, has rapists (yes, even the palestinians too), so what is your point? are palestinian rapists better than israeli ones?
21. #11 and...........
Bambi ,   רחובות   (06.20.06)
worst 'continual' act play in all of history! Strange, no matter how low they go the world still insists on supporting them. Tells you what the world thinks of us Jews, hah?
22. To #4; Injuries must be from the flying sand
Cynic ,   USA   (06.20.06)
Obviously the life threatening injuries were caused by something, and I doubt it was flying sand.
23. NOTHING NEW
Arik Silverman ,   Milwaukee USA   (06.20.06)
This is nothing new, so why is it being "hyped"? One of the earliest stories I saw, right after this happened, said that the bodies received in Israel's hospitals didn't have any shrapnel. It's a little hard to believe that doctors and hospital personnel are engaged in a conspiracy to blame IDF. If they're going to do that, why didn't they simply kill the child and perform one of those next-day burials to cover up the evidence and blame Israel for the death? Moreover, we have today's IAF strike. Are people going to complain that the dead bodies of those children don't have the right kind of shrapnel, so IAF didn't do it? It's very simple: IDF and IAF do far more harm to Israel by these mistakes than by letting a few people slip by and waiting for another day to get them. One thing that has happened in recent months is that European opinion has become more favorable to Israel: these events will turn it in the opposite direction. IS IT WORTH IT?
24. 14 Rafi : What do you smoke again ? Sober up
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.20.06)
25. Arabs kill Arabs, what's new?
Yariv ,   Tel Aviv   (06.20.06)
Today the 2 guys that were unfortunately not killed shoot their own while escaping. Why they shoot bystanders? Because shooting is fun, as Arabs say. Next time we will get these 2. Congratulations for killing the rest of guys in the car.
26. To #22- Or just maybe
Arie   (06.20.06)
It was a qassam that fell short. Why else would the palis have been in such a hurry to remove the shrapnel before the girl arrived at the hospital?
27. palis killing palis?
Arie   (06.20.06)
Wouldn't be the first time little girls were killed by their arab 'families'
28. to 19 rafi.
stephane ,   france   (06.20.06)
you prove me one more time that you can't find nothing to say about tsahal,because you repeat the same story about this teen in 2 talbacks(14 and 19).and you know very well that someone who have nothing to say repeat like a parrot all the time the same old story.and now about this soldier in maale adumim,that's all what you found? since there is roadblocks millions of pals women are checked by israeli soldiers,and only one of these "women" COULD have been raped? and what do you know about this 22 years old pal girl? i won't be surprised if SHE abused our soldier.(when she look at the faces of her barbarian people and then she see an israeli soldier....).and finally about the heroïc raid of this aftenoon,please report to my talkback in the article about the raid in this same website.rafi,if you need any other help to understand how good the israeli are,you can still send your stupids talkbacks and if i have time i will answer you...
29. 22 Cynic, Yes, Intelligent NO - get educated before you
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.20.06)
Post total BS - study details
30. Why Are Israeli Medical Resources Used on Palestinians?
Daniel Temkin ,   USA   (06.20.06)
Why should Israel provide medical care to Palestinians, when Palestinian leadership opts to pool its resources together for the construction of Qassams, use Red Crescent vehicles to transport terrorists/weapons, and indoctrinates its people towards the violence and insanity that create these problems? Why should the Israeli taxpayer be held accountable for Palestinian misappropriation of funds and humanitarian relief?
Next talkbacks
Back to article