News
No shrapnel found in Gaza victim's body
Meital Yasur-Beit Or
Published: 20.06.06, 18:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
46 Talkbacks for this article
31. I am still ashamed...
Yair Lappid ,   North Tel Aviv, Isra   (06.20.06)
32. PALLYWOOD
Chaya ,   Bat Yam   (06.20.06)
More reasons why the pals shouldn't be believed. http://www.seconddraft.org
33. Answer to 23, Nothing new
Andy ,   London, UK   (06.20.06)
I assume you are an Arab. The biggest demage Israel will receive from EU if the Arabs manage to kill one of their leaders. We like strong people. If the Arabs kill leaders of the Kadima, Labor, or Likud then the public oppinion will shift in Arab favor. The people of EU hate Arabs and other people from ME because they invaded us. But if they kill Jews then they may gain some respect on the street.
34. #17
(06.20.06)
it's also been proven that the IDF did it. stop your arab hatred, you antisemite.
35. It doesn' matter what really happened I am ashamed...
Yair Lapid ,   T-A, Israel   (06.20.06)
and my daddy too...
36. No shrapnel in the body
Jerrold Cohen ,   Seal Beach CA USA   (06.20.06)
Since Israel chooses to lie about killing seven members of Huda Ghalia's family, the Palestinians need every shred of evidence they can get. Leave those shell fragments in the victim's body and even if they were stamped "155 mm shell made by Israel to kill innocent civilians" Israel would deny it when they removed those fragments. I trust the IDF as far as I can throw a lead brick.
37. To #29; please educate me....
Cynic ,   USA   (06.20.06)
In my country you put up or you shut up. Where is the evidence,i.e.shrapnel, that proves it was an Israeli shell?
38. Jerrold Cohen
Alirahman ,   Mogadiscio & Somalia   (06.20.06)
And you are Jerrold Cohen as far as I can spit
39. Don't u know, the IDF is the army of the chosen ppl
Muhammad-Ali ,   Montreal   (06.21.06)
40. Didn' t Israel airlift the people from the beach?
Illogocal ,   who cares   (06.21.06)
41. #40 I don't think so.
howard ,   pacific coast,usa   (06.21.06)
42. #23 arik silverman
kapara   (06.21.06)
You are by far the stupidest person I have ever had to read posts from. "let the terrorist slip by and wait for another day" .... you deserve the rachel corrie medal of honor for stupidity. Why would you wait and give a terrorist an opportunity to strike at you and kill jewish civilians with intent? "Oh ... but europe may not like us anymore..." you are a moron.
43. to Arik from Milwaukee
yelena ,   usa   (06.21.06)
Would you recommend to allow terrirists to slip by and bomb Milwaukee? So Europe will have good opinion of Americans, as they had after 9/11? For the whole 3 days.
44. after thousands kassams on Israel towns
lena ,   usa   (06.21.06)
IDF should appologize, that they do not kill Arabs. No country and no Army would appologize for collateral damage under these circumstances, not would try to avoid this collateral damage to the extent IDF and Israel do. It is a war and if Arab children are killed no matter by what weapon, it is a fault of Arab terrorists who started this terror campaign. It is those who use civilians as human shields are guilty if human shields are killed. And here they murdered their human shields themself. Not that after free and democration election of Hamas, there are a lot of innocent civilians among Arabs in Gaza. By the way, what happen to the green houses American Jews bought for these hard working Arabs?
45. to 31
haim ,   mtl canada   (06.21.06)
ur still a traitor to me and i am not ready to change my mind
46. No Shrapnel in the Body
Curious Visitor ,   Kansas City, KS USA   (06.21.06)
A Few Things: First: Is it morally defensible to cut this woman unnecessarily in order to preserve 'evidence' against the Israelis? If so, why not risk further injury to her by sending her to France or somewhere else that can validate the shrapnel's origin? Why get rid of it? Alternately, why not invite one of the many media people into the operating room to film each piece as it is pulled from her body? THAT would be proof. What we have here is destruction of evidence. Second : OK, how long do we wait for the 'doctors' to produce the shrapnel before we call BS on your theory. My guess: it will never appear because it was from their own stockpile. Third: And while you're at it, please explain why it is OK for Hamas to target Civilians but NOT OK for Israel to do so? This is a logical fallacy. In this Case, there are only two options: 1. If you condemn Israel for Civilian deaths, you must also condemn Hamas for it. 2. If you refuse to condemn Hamas for targeting Civilians, then you must also refuse to condemn Israel also. That is, if you believe in the Moral Equivalence of both sides... If you don't, then because of their admitted goals, Hamas is obviously the evil side and worthy of condemnation outright.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article