News
Palestinian terrorists issue ultimatum
Reuters
Published: 03.07.06, 09:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
80 Talkbacks for this article
31. Israeli life not equal Pal terrorist's
JohnIs Lalor ,   Tel-Aviv   (07.03.06)
Isn't it always so refreshing when you see that the Pals demand literally a a few hundreds of their own, in exchange for a handful of Israelis? it just goes to show how little the Pal "leaders" themselves value the lives of their own. They will never want peace because they want to die far, far more than Israelis want to live.
32. We are not terrorists, and not thugs
Historian   (07.03.06)
Simply, we want our rights back. We are not using religion to justify anything. Simply, we want our rights. Jews are using religion to recruit Jews from all over the world. Palestinians are just fighting a nationalistic war. Make no mistake, if the war becomes extremely religious, and Palestinians use religious means to recruit muslims from all over the world to come and fight in Palestine, Israel will loose with no single question. I think zionists hijacked Judaism, and Jews are the only loosers in all this. Israel cannot survive this stnce with all countries around it feel of it as a totally strange entity. Simple rules of biologoy and physics will easily tell you the Israel is a loosing project! Palestinians are the most native population to the Holy Land. They are descendants of all civilizations who lived on this area from prehistoric times including Israelites themsevles!
33. #15
Linda   (07.03.06)
And what are the pals doing? Fighting only soldiers? They have been killing kids in disco's and old people in buses and the street for years!!!! It is payback time!! No more soft jew, nice guy! The rest of your post is more BS and Jews never made problems in any country, they help to build it, not like your Arab friends who are trying to distroy it with there religion and hate against the west and Christianity. When I was still living in Europe I heard Muslims say 20 years ago "we will be the boss here in Europe" and that is what they want all over the world!! So stop your BS post habibi!
34. to #15 - John
jennifer   (07.03.06)
You are totally right the kidnapping was not a terrorist act - lets call it what it is , Invading another country and kidnapping soilders- I do believe thats classed as an Act of War- and you forgot to mention the kidnapping and murder or Asheri last week a civilian- we don't raid Gaza and shoot children in the head. You should be blaming Hamas for the civilian casualities - they put their women and children in danger. And finally do you remember when Clinton was president and they could have taken out Bin Laden, and Clinton didn't becasue Bin Laden was hiding out next to a kindergarten? Should have gotten him them and saved lives - surely people have learned not to underestimate jihad terrorist - Their nationality doesn't matter their goal does and that you and I dead. Do not forget this.
35. Will someone please respond to that load of crap from 15,16?
Tahl ,   Israel   (07.03.06)
Shouldn't be too hard, as his arguments are all simlistic, one-sided, and retarded. I would certainly appreciate it. I would do so myself, but I'm in the middle of work, and frankly, I'm tired of spending so much of energy over hate-mongering anti-zionist provocateurs in here. Wouldn't be surprised if this "John Sullivan" is actually Ellen/Olivia in disguise.
36. #12 WHAT???
LEV ,   Tel Aviv   (07.03.06)
PAUL, It is very easy to make comments like yours from the outside. You should think twice though. You should visit Israel and realize that this is not the "nightmarish part of the world." WHAT A REDICULIOUS STATEMENT you made! Israel is the land of DREAMS with beautiful people, land, and aspirations! I think a plane ride somewhere outside of your wonderland Austrailia would do you some good. I welcome you to Israel. LEV Why do some of the stupidest comments come from Australia and New Zealand??
37. To John Sullivan
Yisraeli   (07.03.06)
Your post is full of verbal diarrhoea or more bluntly full of shit. One thing Im sure of that the world does not see it the way you do, unless their muslim. Go and play with your rubber duck because clearly you dont know anything about whats going on in Israel or the middle east.
38. John Sullivan - Your Gov Has Killed Ten of Thousands...
Rob ,   UK   (07.03.06)
...In the past 4 years alone. Quit your crocodile tears for the "Palestinians."
39. I do not know
atmawi ,   Historic Palestine   (07.03.06)
Even though I will not gave up to kidnappers if I am in your place, still thinking of the Solder family makes me rethink. That is where the boss seat really counts. Olmert should know better, he is responsible of this solder life, at least from the solder family point of view. It is not the first tiome Israel negotiate with the fighters, Long history of conflict. I think saving this solder life will temporarly boost Olmert popularity. If you really value this solder human life, then you may reconsider releasing Palestinian kids and women prisnoers. They have nothing to do with Intifada, they are held, and locked up only because there relatives are freedom fighters. So basically, no threat to Israel security what so ever. If you really value this solder life, then please show that in tangible ways.
40. Excellent stuff, Gabrielle Golwater!
John Lalor ,   Tel-Aviv   (07.03.06)
41. JOHN SULLIVAN (#15 &16) SMOKES CRACK!
LEV ,   Tel Aviv   (07.03.06)
Get real bro! How's the weather in Minnesota? It's hot here in Israel, and there's a war going on outside. I suppose you would prefer to see us Jews lay down and make easy targets for the Arabs. Please tell me one good step the Palestinians have taken towards peace in the last year since the disengagement of Gaza. More rockets fired, a certified terrorist government, more hatred being taught????? Smoke some more crack and stay up all night writing these ridiculous comments!
42. Giving in is not an option, Flattening Gaza is
John ,   NZ   (07.03.06)
43. To: Rob, UK; Kate, London
John Lalor ,   Tel-Aviv   (07.03.06)
You both equate US military action with Islamic terrorism?? So, taking down the Taliban, Saddam, nullifying Milosovic when the EU sat pathetically waiting for Uncle Sam (as always), fighting Communism in Nam & Cambodia when the rest of the world sat quietly waiting for the Red Army to capture from Ireland to the Phillipines, fighting Nazism, Fascism, tackling the Ayatollahs, etc, etc, etc, is the same as beheading, blowing up train stations, pizza parlous, ice cream stores, buses with school kids are the same????? The West's biggest enemy is people like you. Just like Lenin's useful idiots, the anti-civilisationists depend on you to eat Western society FROM THE INSIDE.
44. In name of Allah....
Alena Kutkoskski ,   Canada   (07.03.06)
If the terrorist and Mullahs continue the way they do, soon there will be rule of barbarians. They will rule world, torture women, kill children, impose laws - All in name of Allah. Can they challenge www.faithfreedom.org. Israel- Wake up. None of these muslim countries are really your friends. Make organisation of non muslim countries , like Russia and India, and stop terrorism. Problem is - In these countries too, many ministers are Muslims, and they strongly favour terrorism. So carefully organise the team. The main source of terrorism is Interpretation of Koran. Fix the imams who preach violence.
45. HUTZPAH!!!
Chaya ,   Bat Yam   (07.03.06)
Giving in to this demand will only bring about future kidnappings. Of course, we want our soldier home; but it shouldn't be at the expense of future kidnappings and attacks. And if they do kill him, we will make them pay a very very very high price.
46. #13 - he's not a racist
Rustum ,   London, UK   (07.03.06)
You latest call to demolish every single stone in Gaza gives the lie to your idiotic claims that you are not a racist. I seem to remember you said you have lived with Arabs and you speak out of experience - well that is what a lot of Germans said about your brethren and they, and you, are big big big big wrong. You moronic statement deserves no less than total condemnation and contempt.
47. to sullivan
jason white ,   afula,israel   (07.03.06)
How about the soldiers that followed the iraqi woman for a week.Then they raped her and killed her,her child and two other family members.Or the marines that killed 24 civilians.You are probably some sand crab using a mick name as a ruse. If they kill Gilad,then we should kill all palis in our hands and destroy every building in gaza without warning.
48. to # 12 dont let # 28 fool you !!!
waeL ,   palestine / kuwait   (07.03.06)
to # 28 what kind of information is that ?? you said (( The area of Gazza strips. 20000 people were pulled out of their beautifyul homes (they bought and did not take from any arab) all their agriculture was destroyed and the little left to the palestinian was destroyed by the palestinians))) Okay , that's right its really true they did evacuate this land BUT !!!!!!!!!! what ABout the 600,000 palestinian people that left palestine in 1948 ? dont you think those are innocent people that you have scared them to leave there lands ? MAn do i have to remind you what happend back then ? from your troops ( HAGANA ) ?? do i have to say about der yassin ? man no matter what you said i am 100 % sure that you are wronge and we are right , WE are making so many mistakes in solving it but WE pals are right WE pals were living in peace WE pals ( muslims & cristians ) were living in peace until YOU juish came causing problems taking lands terrefying safe people ? But we PAls addmit that You juish are so clever and powerfull that you can controL the world media and news so that a poor italian senator cant even say a world against you juish ,,, and that Germany still pay for you million of dollars for what hetler did befor . You juish are geneuses in tekhnology , scinece , maths , chemists , we addmit that , if just you were living some where els We myabe loved you and admire you for what you are doing to the world . BUT the problem that your country is living on the bodies of another poeple called PALestinians >
49. #39 Atmawi
Jane ,   UK   (07.03.06)
The women and youths aged under 18 years in Israeli jails are there because of terrorism related issues. They are not innocent and have everything to do with the intifada and violence against the Jewish state. Arabs have a long history of hostage taking in relation to Jewish men, women and children and have slaughtered a large number. At Ma'alot they threw hand-grenades amongst a group of kidnapped Jewish children and machine gunned the rest. The barbarity and mind-set of these Arab actions is demonstrated in how they even take body parts of the wounded and dead Jews to use for political capital and to obtain the release of others of a like mind. Indeed, a number of Israeli hostages kidnapped in the early 1990's are still held by their Arab captors. Time and again we hear from the likes of Atmawi that if Israel values the life of Gilad Shalit it would cooperate with the terrorists. Such a move would encourage more such kidnappings - The Israelis know it , the Arabs know it and Atmawi knows it. Giving in the demands of murderers justifies and condones their atrocities and encourages them to do the same again. As the Palestinian leadership broadcasts the plight of it's own people in the midst of their kidnapping of Gilad perhaps the real question that should be asked is that "if the Palestinians care about their own people they will release Gilad Shalit, recognise the right of Israel to exist and return to the negotiating table instead of pursuing their agenda of destroying Israel".
50. Gilad
nell ,   switzerland   (07.03.06)
Sullivan and Slammer's comments are not naive, they are plain stupid. And if Gilad goes down Israel is right to do whatever.
51. I think I am mistaken
John Sullivan ,   Minnesota US   (07.03.06)
Being an american based in the US I would like to apologise for my previous comments below as follows: 1) not only is my spelling appaling as I am a bit ignorant and didnt pay much attention at school. But my words are often vitriolic and hurtful. I am sorry I dont mean it. 2) Of course I dont mean it when I call the Isaeli Defense Forces the Israeli Offense forces, because that would be absurd, everyone knows that the Israeli Army is one of the most moral in the world, and that they are only there to protect Israeli citizens, usually from Arab terrorists. My previous comments were short sighted as I know and am fully aware that Real problem here is the moslem Arabs, as it usually is, who unfortunately still insist on occupying sovreign Israeli Land. I hope and pray from my little world of Minnesota that the lord blesses the Jewish people, as he has promised and expels the thorn in our sides from that land. As an american, I am totally ignorant about Middle eastern affairs and would probably do better to go eat a big mac or perhaps some nachos. Whilst supporting a country and government that occupies arab lands such as Iraq. Being an american I like to put my "two penny's" worth in where its neither needed nor asked for. In fact I even take the trouble sometimes to find Israeli websites, such as this, in order to spread my hate and mindlessness. For that I am sorry that I am so misguided and that I have actually started beleiving the Arab moslem propaganda as truth. I will try to keep my ignorant opinions to myself from now on and apologise profusely and in no uncertain terms if I have caused any offense to any Israelis. You are the victims, you are the ones who are blown up at will in your buses and on trains. Its a pity I havent learnt my lesson as an american from 9/11 but then again, I was busy watching a movie and drinking a sprite. Sorry Israel, I hope that the arab moslem enemy occupying your land gets their just rewards, sooner rather than later. John
52. 27 Palestinian Fake: watch it - You are going to choke
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (07.03.06)
53. haaaaa haaaaa haaaaa
Palestinian ,   Hebron   (07.03.06)
haaaaa haaaaaaa haaaa Gaza will stay the mother of heros. haaaaa haaaa haaaaa haaaaaaaaaaa ha ha ahah ahaha haah ah hhh immmmmmmmmmmmm haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
54. had you ever lived under occupation?
Fadi ,   west bank   (07.03.06)
to every israeli and jew all over the world: had u ever lived just one day under occupation????? -had u ever examined what occupation is???? this struggle has lasted for about 100 year and we are ready for another 1000 year and we will never never give up.
55. Palestinian's never bear any responsibility
Marcel ,   Florida   (07.03.06)
The communique says Israel will bear full responsibility for their barbaric actions. The seems to be true . The world always portrays the Palestinians as poor innocent vicitms and Israle has the bad guys. No matter what the butchers and suicide bombers do they are always held guiltless and Israel is blamed. Even when lemming Jews retreat and surrender to appease the unappeasable nations ,they are still blamed. The world will never be satisfied until Israel loses and that is why the jihadists of Gaza are protected and world humanitarian concern is so great for this cult of death who raise their babies with hate and intolerance and murder and death as noble virtues. Israel ,you should have defeated them long,long ago !!! Now the stakes are higher. Israel the world wants you to lose and this is why they protect the Palestinian terrorist Authority.. They work hard to help the arab world save their worthless face.
56. Savages crap demand
Brod ,   USA   (07.03.06)
Israel can tell the savages to go to Hell and wipe them off.
57. Wael: WHY did Pals flee in '48??
John Lalor ,   Tel-Aviv   (07.03.06)
Wael, you sound like a decent person, but your point: "what ABout the 600,000 palestinian people that left palestine in 1948 ? dont you think those are innocent people that you have scared them to leave there lands ? " is completely misguided. Once not one Arab country supported the 1947 UN Resolution giving the Jews a homeland, the Arabs living in British Mandate Palestine were advised (i.e. threatened) to leave by the oncoming Arab forces. Second, the Pals were huge supporters of Hitler. Their spiritual leader, the Grand Mufti al-Husseini, even went to Berlin, set up the "Nazi scouts" (to immitate the indoctrination used within the Hitler Youth), set up troops in Msulim Bosnia in 1940. Never, ever before have the losers - i.e. the supporters of losers - who were themselves the aggressors, been able to claim so much from the post-war era as the Pals have since 48. These two facts completely negate any "right of return" of Pals to Israel.
58. John Lalor from Tel Aviv - #43
Kate ,   London, UK   (07.03.06)
"You both equate US military action with Islamic terrorism?? " I find it touching that you would support a nation that consigned millions of Jews to death though its deliberate and calculated inaction before and during the Holocaust. Had FDR being a paid-up member of the SS he could not have done less for European Jewry. And yes, I think that America's conduct at Dresden, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, Vietnam, Cambodia, Serbia, Afghanistan and Iraq amounted to serious war crimes. Really, I see very little difference, for example, between Hiroshima and Auschwitz. And I also see virtually no difference in principle between the actions of the State Department towards Jews during World War II and those of the SD.
59. 12 Paul,Perth: You obviously did not follow history
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (07.03.06)
because you post utter nonsense. remember what terrorism hits Israel for over 77 years - or did that just did not hit you The Hebron Massacre of Jews in 1929 http://www.gabriellegoldwater.com/2004/jun/09_07.html Palestinian Authority political leaders advocated kidnapping-for-hostage policy: http://www.pmw.org.il/LatestBulletins.htm#b270606 Hamas: Islam will conquer US and Britain June22 http://www.pmw.org.il/LatestBulletins.htm#b220606 Hamas in its own words: http://www.pmw.org.il/tv-hamas.htm Kill A Jew and go to Heaven: http://www.pmw.org.il/KJGH.htm
60. Radical Evil
zvi ,   los angeles USA   (07.03.06)
Hamas is evil to the core It wants Jewish blood and to destroy us. If they murder Gilad -- which they may have already done -- Israel must respond with such punishing military might that these murderers will never forget what we did to them They are an abomination to the Lord our G-d Mr. PM: Let the IDF do what is necessary to teach our mortal enemies a lesson forever We are dealing with Amalek and we are enjoined to "Remember what Amalek did......" May G-d Bless His People and the Shalit family.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article