Jewish Scene
Religion, tolerance and gay parade
Rabbi Jeremy Rosen, Daily Jews
Published: 09.07.06, 13:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
43 Talkbacks for this article
31. Heterosexuals parade?
Confident ,   USA   (07.10.06)
If homosexuals feel so confident about their sexual lives why do they need to parade? Who are u trying convince yourselves or others? Does it matter? Do heterosexuals need to parade too? When we are confident about our lifestyles we don't have to parade them. It is very offensive to bring Jerusalem into it!!!
32. yuck
hanina ,   usa   (07.10.06)
And in the end, the earth grew dark and kinky.
33. islam= jewish ultra othodox
darryl ,   israel   (07.10.06)
34. Get your facts Str8 Brauner
Lucas Beno ,   Atlanta, GA   (07.10.06)
If you are going to use science to speak out against gay people, at least get your facts straight. you said "Animals, plants and other organisms simply do not have this as the norm." Homosexuality does in fact exist in nature--in lions, sheep, penguins and apes........and many types of plants are hemaphroditic.....a simple google search might assist you in getting your facts straight
35. Darryl = Close Minded
Isi ,   USA   (07.10.06)
Darryl = Close Minded For Darryly to say something like that prooves that she has no understanding of her own religion and has never tried to understand the orthodox way of life, tolerance and liberalism includes understanding and being tolerant to orthodox Jews, and the same people who shout out freedom of expression and the first to call for a ban on Jews going onto temple mount for fear of upsetting the Muslims.
36. unnecessary provocation
LB ,   USA   (07.11.06)
The homosexual community demands sensitivity, but doesn't seem to want to give it. I support Gay rights, but of all the places to hold a parade; this is nothing more than an un-needed insightment and insult to the religious community. Why don't you hold it in Mecca and see what happens?!?
37. Paqid Yirmeyahu ,is a messianic xtian
DACON9   (07.11.06)
CALLING HIMSELF A JEW. BEWARE OF THE DANGER THAT LIES WITHIN THIS MANS MIND. DO NOT ASK HIM FOR EXPLANATIONS OR INTERPRETATIONS OR FOR LAWS OR ADVISE.. DO NOT ASK HIM TO EXPLAIN EVEN MICKEY MOUSE TO YOU. YOU HAVE QUESTIONS.? .GO TO YOUR LOCAL ORTHODOX ?ASK FOR YOUR LOCAL CHABAD.THEY LIKE TO HELP YOU
38. ANCIENT PARADES
Arik Silverman ,   Milwaukee USA   (07.11.06)
Let's to back 2000 years to the Jewish philosopher Philo of Alexandria. In "Special Laws III.40ff" he writes: Certainly you may see these hybrids of man and woman continually strutting about through the thick of the market, heading the processions at the feasts, appointed to serve as unholy ministers of holy things, leading the mysteries and initiations and celebrating the rites of Demeter. Those of them who by way of heightening still further their youthful beauty have desired to be completely changed into women and gone on to mutilate their genital organs, are clad in purple like signal benefactors of their native lands, and march in front escorted by a bodyguard, attracting the attention of those who meet them. SO WHAT'S NEW? Oh, and remember the Jews were eventually expelled from Alexandria, so maybe the lesson is that what the world needs is TOLERANCE.
39. ATT:12. Paquid is a former Baptist preacher...
DACON9   (07.12.06)
IT IS FORBIDDEN TO PRAY FOR A MISSIONARY.Deut. 13:9 IT IS FORBIDDEN TO BE KIND TO A MISSIONARY,Deut. 13:9 IT IS FORBIDDEN TO SAVE A MISSIONARY.Deut. 13:9 YOU SAW HIS DECEIT. PAQUID IS ATTEMPTING TO BLURR THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN JUDAISM AND XTIANS.. THE WORLD IS CALLING FOR YOU AND ME TO SHOUT TO THE OTHERS THE EVILS OF THESE PEOPLE.
40. A rabbi???? what room for tolerance here?
Pinhas Cohen ,   Jerusalem   (07.12.06)
If someone has moral weaknesses, as all of us have, he should be treated with pashion and tolerance, but when he makes a flag and demands recognition for his immoral behavior he should be eliminited Just as Pinhas did and saved the people with this deed.
41. Thank You Paqid Yirmeyahu!
The Lion of Juda ,   Sweden   (07.22.06)
Your argumentation is like honey and Your conclusions like milk! Our G-d must have inspired You. Every person can do what they like, but there is a borderline. They (the perverted people) think that everthing is possible to do and they are fully right, but they don't think about the consequensees for the socitey and themselves in the long run. In my opinion they qualiffy for a life outside a normal healthy living society. I can understand that this type of persons want to defy the holy city of Jerusalem (Yerushalayim). If they ever will get an allowance to a parade in Jerusalem I would advice them to call it Shame-parade or Disgrace-parade, In Stockholm every party-leader are talking at the so called Pride-festival in July, but our PM Göran Persson will not come because "he is said to have holidays". The homo/bisexuel people make a mark and we see how they win more and more space in the Swedish society. They can even be a priest and be blessed, so a lot of peoples live very close to Gomorra. We have a law which states that we are not allowed to discriminate any homosexual.being at any level in the soceity. I feel like a stranger in my own country. I feel upset about this question and I think that sexuality and moral standards will degenerate. But when I read about a so called Pride-parade in the holy citfy óf Jerusalem I see it like an subversive activity. I think that they have democracy rights, but some authorities must say NO, even after the present situation of war. That's another war, but I hope that it will be NO in Jerusalem for the Shame-Parade. Don't let them parade in JERUSALEM! Send them to Tel Aviv or Haifa.
42. religion/tolerance/parade
Sergio Lepore ,   Tempe, USA   (07.24.06)
Religion, tolerance and the gay parade. In my neighborhood there are random gunshots heard being fired. It is not unlawful in the state of Arizona to possess firearms and it says we are allowed to in the U. S. Constitution. The problem may not be with the firearm or even the person who possesses it. The problem is accountability. Is such a person accountable for a neighbor’s dog, or any child out of doors in the event of being hit by the stray bullet? Can that person turn back the hands of time or immediately heal the wounded or make the pain go away along with any recollection of it? The problem is also responsibility. With freedom comes responsibility. Ok, I have a firearm and it’s the 4th of July, so to express my right to freedom of the life I want and the right to bear arms I am going to randomly fire my weapon in the sky or some such thing, regardless of what is around me. Oh, I wont let it hurt anyone, etc. This example deals with some uncontrollable factors. Where do bullets stop as soon as they leave the gun? Is there anyone within its range when it comes down at that right moment? I would have to be pretty omniscient to insure the safety of all the dogs and children, etc in my area during this time of exercising my rights to freedom. Can you see where this is leading? Is it ok for people to do what they want as long as it wont hurt others? How much control do we have of the effects of a thing? What if other unforeseen factors are involved? The Bible and the Torah, as well as the Koran(?) warn us about certain behavior choices. Until we can know everything about the cosmos and any other dimension and thus every effect for every cause we may find it beneficial to simply follow certain ‘instructions’ instead of testing God, all the time. Is it just coincidence that hurricane Katrina hit New Orleans just a day prior to the planned week of a big parade similar to the one now in question? The U.S was hit by many, many hurricanes at this time, as if to tell us something, not so much as to say homosexuality is wrong and that’s it, but that across the board our decaying morals in our society is simply getting worse. Things like making it almost a crime to read the Bible in class with others in our public schools, or firing an individual for refusing to remove a crucifix in a country that was founded by what the Bible teaches can serve as another example. Now Israel is being tormented by anti-Jewish demonstrations and is now at war-and still, when, yes, the Bible of the Christians, the Koran of the Muslims, and the Torah of the Jews all agree about sodomy, to name one thing, the parade will still go on. It’s like when your parents forbade you to go out past mid-night and you still do so anyway, thinking, as you crawl out the bedroom window, “ they’re no fun!” Are we collectively this childish, and shouldn’t a rabbi know better?
44. # 29 How DARE You Slander
A Gay Christian ,   USA   (09.08.06)
Jesus's name!!! People like you killed Jesus, because he was Gay. I hope Jesus forgives you, because I can't. I LOVE JESUS AND HE LOVES ALL HIS SPECIAL PEOPLE!!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article