News
IDF leaves Bin Jbeil area
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 29.07.06, 17:08
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
73 Talkbacks for this article
31. Great job
Ana ,   Spain   (07.29.06)
Congratulations to the IDF. Keep up the good work, boys. I love you. The world is now a little better, with 200 terrorists out .
32. Successful Battle?
Joe ,   Canada   (07.29.06)
First, the goal is "destruction of Hezbollah". That is not going to happen. Then, there was going to be a "security zone up to the Litani". That idea changed. Then there was going to be a "security zone of a couple kilometres". Now that has changed to "we left the village after a successful battle". Does anybody really believe this? Either everyone in Bint Jbeil is dead or Bint Jbeil will be used to launch rockets again very soon. By leaving Bint Jbeil, Israel is not sure if there are any Hezbollah left there or not.
33. 14Mr Palestine
Ana ,   Spain   (07.29.06)
Why dont we look at true facts and what's going on in the world today? The fact is that Hizbollah attacked Israel, not the other way round. Israel is fighting for its survival, against the jihadists, who want to kill us all, Jews, Christians and anyone else, in the name of their religion, so to spread the Umma worlwide.
34. to everybody
(07.29.06)
IDF has left for continuing into other places in south of labanon, and it got out, for leting IAF finish the job... that's what is going to be with every terroists support villages.
35. Why go into Bin Jbeil? They should rase it to the ground.
Jeremiah ,   Israel, Jewish Land   (07.29.06)
36. 22 T: Victory
Ana ,   Spain   (07.29.06)
The disappearence of Hizbollah will mean a victory for Israel and for lebanon alike. This war is not against the Lebanese but against Hizbollah, which attacks Israel and keeps the Lebanese people hostage.
37. Bint Jbail
D.P. ,   Canada   (07.29.06)
Israel declares victory and leaves Bint Jbail. Is the IDF going to hold a victory parade to celebrate the event?
38. TO: Hanan Greenberg
Walid ,   Lebanon, Bint Jbeil   (07.29.06)
Let me rephrase this for you properly: Few ground forces successfuly withdrew following an overnight battle in which 33 paratroopers were killed and 87 injured by Hizbullah fighters in south Lebanon town of Bint Jbeil; IDF preparing for additional raids to take revenge of the rocks,soil and houses where the mentioned battle took place. KEEP UP IDF "Israel Deteriorated Army".
39. 24 Jack: Congratulations!!!
Ana ,   Spain   (07.29.06)
nasrallah deserves nobody's respect. He is a chief of terrorists. You say lots of civilians have perished. The blame for all of this is on Hizbollah. I dont see the popularity of Israel has decreased because of this war. On the contrary, more people know israel is fighting terrorism and the decent people is for Israel. The only thing is that you the terrorists supporters are making more noise, but that's it. The hizbollah thugs are not soldiers but terrorists, unless you mean, "allah´s soldiers", since the terrorist organization name means "the party of allah".
40. Dialogue on the cards?
sher   (07.29.06)
Hizbullah won as soon as we slammed into Lebanon. Even if Lebanon is reduced to a rubble pancake, the moment there's a cease-fire Hizbullah will be back, as near to our border as they can get. The type of rockets supplied to them will be different to compensate for whatever distance they need to travel, that's all. The government will have to find other, as yet unexplored ways of ensuring quiet borders. It will have to start cultivating subtlety, a quality not usually found in these parts. Olmert now needs to take his army boots off, put his thinking cap on and look for much, much better advice than he has been getting from the IDF's top brass or George W and crew.
41. victory
jose ,   usa   (07.29.06)
i think we misunderstand the IDF, i think nowadays it is a victory to retreat alive.so it is a victory, see they dont lie, i only feel sorry for the israelis, that they have such a leaderes, "civilianes" , they would send their kids to die in war and keep 2 milliones undergraound without mencioning the image of israel cuz the killing and destruction in lebanon, all that cuz 2 stupid men want to prove their manhood, dont u people see?,
42. New Weapons.
deepee ,   canada and israel   (07.29.06)
This is a new tactic in the war guerilla warfare is being done.. Israel now does the same in the methods of warfare... strikes hizbullah target and moves back.. the hunted Israel now becomes the hunter of Hizbullah...
43. Victory for Lebanon
deepee ,   canada   (07.29.06)
You should be embarrassed talking like that coming from Canada.. the land of freedom of speech and religion.. stop and think about what Canada really means to you and the people in the past that gave their lives so that you can have freedom of speech and religion...
44. Ha!
Chris   (07.29.06)
They failed for 18 years to beat Huzb Allah and they'll fail again.
45. GO GO IDF
Mohammed ,   Gaza   (07.29.06)
GO back if you can
46. The solution is so easy
Mr. M ,   Lebanon, Bekaa   (07.29.06)
Israeli People, I dont know how the heck u always get yourself into troubles. The solution is so easy, give us the countries that u raped before, give us our people in ur prisons, and dont cross our borders by air, sea and ground and get out from our life. But if You dont want to give us our right, we have to resist and stand against you and take it by our hands it is obvious guys ;-)
47. Israel should annex southern Lebanon
sk ,   USA   (07.29.06)
How many times have we heard that "We (Arabs) can lose 100 times, but Israel can lose only once." This is right only because Israel always returns land that is won in defensive wars. What if Israel had a policy of seizing and annexing (permanently) all land from which attacks are launched? In that case, suddenly, an Arab loss mean more than just dead Arabs (Arabs don't care about their dead) but lost land. And every acre lost is Muslim land that has been lost, making it a double tragedy. Yes, Iran would still want to support war against Israel, and, no, Israel could not now annex all of Iran without problems, but what Muslim will want to have HIS land become JEWISH land?
48. #14 there is an old saying " a little bit of
michael   (07.29.06)
Knowledge is adangerous thing". Your out of context verses is a classical example of this wise saying
49. Brave and un-cowardice act from IDF side! GO IDF!
Al ,   US   (07.29.06)
50. Yes. Mr M. #46, the solution is so easy...
Roberto Gutierrez ,   Madrid, Spain   (07.30.06)
... but I think it´s not what you´ve said. The solution was given by Mrs. Golda Meir many years ago: "Peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate Jews". Is it so difficult to understand this?
51. To spanish Anna
Jack ,   France   (07.30.06)
Have you ever heard about hizbollah doing any terrorist attack outside Israel ? If you ever heard about something alike please tell me. Hezbollah since creating was only replying to Israeli's provoctions. Israel was and still occupying Lebanon. Israel killed lot of lebanese civilians, humilated lebanese, destroyed their homes. Lebanese people was humilated. All what Hizbollah was asking before this silly war started is to take back all lebanses territories back and prosoners back. Hizbollah is terrorist only into weak people's minds. Wake up people. Give Lebanon its sovereinety back and Israel will get peace in return.
52. 200 Hizbullah members!! r u joking!
Lebanese ,   Lebanon   (07.30.06)
do u really believe these kind of stories? wake up!
53. to Ana , Spain
Lebanese ,   Jounieh   (07.30.06)
Ana, seems to be not following up the events: 1- Hizbullah targeted teh Israeli Army at the border 2- IDF targeted Beirut Airport, houses of normal people, all bridges in Lebanon 3- Hizbullah lauched rocket to military bases in northern Israel 4- IDF targeted power station, sea ports, children and families (I chalenge anyone to say that this is not the right sequence of events!) so tell me who is the terrorist? so tell me again, who is the terrorist????
54. ALLLL PLEASE REPLY, IST TRUE!!
David ,   USA, Virginia   (07.30.06)
Am totally cofused, why would they leave bint jbail!!!! what does that mean, you got in there cus Hizbolla firing Missiles to Israel, and u want to protect the northern part, now u leave it to them again, ARE THEY SERIOUS, OR WHATS GOING ON, IST IDF LOOSING IN THERE, BBC AND CNN INDICATED THAT 7 SOLDIERS WOUNDED YESTERDAY, I NEED EXPLANATION
55. The Terrorists
MK ,   USA   (07.30.06)
Hamas, Hizbollah, Muslim fundamentalists, Al Qaeda, Israel's Ultra Orthodox Jews, Israel's fanatic settlers, George Bush's NeoCons, Israel's generals who target children and women, and the Poodle Blair. Everyone mentioned above is a Real Terrorist. All of the people above should be tried and punished.
56. To # 50, Plastine is our land
Ahmad ,   Qatar   (07.30.06)
My friend, you are mistaken, and totally wrong, we dont hate jew, but we dont accept a country called Israel living with us in the middle east, they had stolen our counry palastine, for religion reasons, and they keep killing them, they took more than 75 % of thier land and gave them 25 %, even if they accept this now, cus we all are so weak, but bieleve me, they will never stay, they are temporary here, and the time will tell the truth
57. RE: #14. Source of aggression isn't the Torah
Gary ,   Freedom, USA   (07.30.06)
The source of aggression comes from those who are fed lies and misinformation. You quote verses from scriptures from which you have no understanding. You are ignorant of why the Jews were at war in these biblical times and what their enemies were doing to them at the time. I suggest that you take in a little ancient history study before you compare what's going on today to what was happening then and why it was written as you quote.
58. 46 The solution is so easy
Ana ,   Spain   (07.30.06)
The Israeli people never get into trouble. The Arabs get them into trouble. It happens that Israel has raped nobody or stolen others' lands. It is the others, those on jihad, who want to rob the Israelis of their land. They are on jihad because Israel is Waqf, a land once occupied by Muslims, and so land of Islam forever. This in accordance to their charters, because for any sane person, the legitimate owners have the right to their land, not the Muslim occupiers. Here you have hamas charter http://www.mideastweb.org/hamas.htm As for Hizbollah, its goal is the same as the pal jihadists'. And besides, the chief of the gang has declared that Jews should be killed whenever they happen to be. It was Hizbollah who committed the attacks in Buenos Aires murdering many people, most of them Jews.
59. 53. Who's the terrorist? Hizbollah
Ana ,   Spain   (07.30.06)
The terrorist organization has no right to attack Israel and to murder Israelis. Since they have done it, Israel has the right to defend itself. The terrorists are in Lebanon, so Israel is attacking lebanon targetting strategical points. It happens that the terrorists shelter among civilians and have their caches in residential buildings. This is terrorism by Hizbollah too.
60. 51To French Jack: yes, I have
Ana ,   Spain   (07.30.06)
The terrorist organization committed the attacks in Buenos Auires which killed a lot of Jews. This terrorist gang also perpetrated the attack on the restaurant El Descanso, Madrid, some years ago, which killed a good number of people, mostly Spaniards. The dangerous lunatic who leads the gang says he will kill Jews whenever they happen to be. This is one of the gang' goal. Other_ the destruction of Israel. More: to impose the sharia law in Lebanon and in the entire ME; and then to spread Islam in Europe and all around the world. More killings by Hizbollah: a Frech ambassador , and a Spanish embassador and two of his relatives .
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article