News
Lebanon: Dozens killed in IDF strike
Ali Waked
Published: 30.07.06, 10:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
120 Talkbacks for this article
61. Sad, but,...
Suzanne ,   Netherlands   (07.30.06)
""On a regular basis terrorists tend to run dozens of meters into the building, sometimes with the launchers themselves, and hide there," he said." Who makes that more guilty of an alleged war crime?
62. Another Qana?
Joe ,   Oman   (07.30.06)
I have always been astonished by the IDF capability and strengh over the years. I wonder if the IDF is going to add todays achievement as part of their years of glory & shame. U only prove to us that U R really soooo powerless.
63. THE PEOPLE OF QANA WERE WARNED!
Siegel ,   Karmiel, Israel   (07.30.06)
THIS IS ANOTHER SET UP! THE HIZZBULLAH ARE HIDING BEHIND WOMEN AND CHILDREN AND THE WORLD BLAMES ISRAEL! WE CANNOT DEFEND OURSELVES! NOW CIVILIANS ARE HIT AND ISRAEL WHO WARNED THEM, IS BLAMED! THIS IS SOOO OLD! IT WILL BE USED AGAINST ISRAEL IN THE MEDIA, AND THE WORLD SWALLOWS IT EVERY TIME, HOOK, LINE AND SINKER! NO OTHER COUNTRY WOULD EVER TOLERATE WHAT ISRAEL IS FORCED TO TOLERATE YEAR AFTER YEAR! HYPOCRITES! ALL OF YOU!
64. #18
liora ,   yerusalem israel   (07.30.06)
thank you thank you!!! i am so glad someone finally has a sense of reality! i coulnt agree more to what you said!!!
65. #19
LIORA ,   JERUSALEM ISRAEL   (07.30.06)
YOU TOOK THE WORDS OUT OF MY MOUTH!!!!! BRAVO!!! I COULDNT HAVE SAID IT BETTER MYSELF!!!!!
66. DA DUDE
JERUSALEM ISRAEL   (07.30.06)
I REALLY LIKE YOU!!!!!! I AM VERY PROUD OF YOU!!! I COULDNT HAVE SAID IT BETTER!!!!!!
67. #35,pauvre jack...
stephane ,   france   (07.30.06)
so you don't believe that arabs use their own people as "inhuman" shields? so you don't know what are the arabs.(maybe you don't have enough of them in france to understand)...if you're in france,you can buy the 3 movies from pierre rehov :CONTRECHAMPS. you'll see there what the french media can't show you because you're an hostage in your own country so full of arab that the media are AFRAID to tell the truth.you'll see the pictures of how arabs use their people as inhuman shields.jack,don't worry there is thousands of proves of what we know about the cowards terrorists.CONTRECHAMP is good for a "débutant" like you who talk without knowing who israel is dealing with.see the movie,learn,and come back.
68. What a moral army ... you have never seen any abjective news
To #28 ,   Lebanon   (07.30.06)
Your moral army asks the innocent civilians to flee the villages, then your plans will be charged to kill them in the roads ... and the one who cannot flee, they will charge to kill him in his own house ... yah, you have the right...you are more civilized...poor dump people...your IDF is the big liar...actually I'is the only thing that they gained from all this war: loose of credibility...wake up
69. You are fooling yourself man...just think a little bite dump
To #31 ,   Lebanon   (07.30.06)
Do you really think that that this pilot is the only responsible of this carnage when your glorious IAF palns drop tons of bombs of the head on the civilians there, don't you think that the day will come to commit a big carnage like that...It's your PM, your Perez and your Halutz who should be condamned for this new war crime.
70. Open your eyes
Rabih ,   Beirut - Lebanon   (07.30.06)
1- Ehud Olmert is now claiming the IDF had warned the civillians to leave Qana before bombing it : IDF is openly targeting any moving object on what is left of roads, including AMBULANCES, HUMANITARIAN AID CONVOYS, PRESS VEHICLES (all of which are clearly marked), and even MOTORCYCLES!! This has happened before in Marwahin when the IDF told the residents to leave then bombed their convoy when they did. Civillians are simply trapped in southern villages, awaiting their impending doom. 2- Did the IDF warn the 120 civillians that were sheltered in a UN base in Qana in 1996 before bombing them? 3- The IDF claims this war is against Hizballah, yet they still have to show us a single rocket launcher or an ammunition storage being destroyed. The IDF and the IAF are clearly and blatantly attacking civillians to pressure the Lebanese to ask for a ceasfire under israeli conditions. The IDF and IAF are using phosphorous, thermobaric, and cluster bombs against civillians. This indicates the failure of the IDF as an army. 4- Israel claims this is not a war against Lebanon, but only against Hizballah "terrorists", yet they attack infrastructure, communications, Lebanese Army bases (which they ask to deploy along the border). Israel is obviously not interested in having a prosperous neigbour that will challenge her economic and military superiority in the region. This campaign is solely aimed at the destruction of Lebanon as a nation. 5- Any mistake by the part of the IAF is ruled out, since Lebanese territory is being monitored by surveillance drones around the hour, and the IAF is using GPS, Radar, and LASER-guided munitions to bomb its targets with "surgical accuracy" (Thankfully provided by the USA). I don' t think the israeli and American taxpayers are spending billions of dollars yearly for the IAF to make mistakes.
71. Israel, you lost your bet!
Anthony ,   Junieh, Lebanon   (07.30.06)
You worked on creating fights between christians & muslims... I assure you : we CHRISTIANS are more united with our bro MUSLIMS more then ever against you!
72. You r a miserable sick person ... go and see a docotr
to # 38   (07.30.06)
73. to No.69
Mike ,   UK   (07.30.06)
Listen - any civilians killed is terrible on both sides. But I am fed up of the world jumping at Israel and accuses of war crimes without even thinking for one minute! Who started this conflict? Who hides behind civilians? Who thinks that martydom is more valuable than life? Who doesn't say anything when other despots around the world kill their own civilians? Who doesn't question the guilt of Syria and Iran in this conflict? Who doesn't call for war crimes when an Israeli civilian is killed by a Hizbollah rocket (is the life of an Israeli worth less?)...LET YOUR BRAIN THINK BEFORE YOUR MOUTH OPENS...ENOUGH OF THIS BORING BORING "WAR CRIMES" ACCUSATIONS AGAINST ISRAEL......It may be fashionable among the do-gooders and naive of this world but try and put some balanced thought into what you cry out
74. Shame on Isreal
Mohammd ,   Amman - Jordan   (07.30.06)
i think only smart poeple will understand what i am saying. 1- using a special kind of bombs like used to destroy buildings as used in Qana today showing that the idf targeting the building not any other thing . like rocket auncher which need another kind of bombs. 2- isreal have a very improved inteligent and spying eyes over all areas in the south . i think they can diffrentiate between a building and rocket launcher. 3- i think this masecar will make the diffrence in this war . and belive me today will be like hill on isreal the same as done on lebanon. 4- thousands of muslim will head soon to lebanon to fight isreal . this is real and will start today.
75. to No.71
Mike ,   UK   (07.30.06)
I don't think Israel was counting on this..its not a game you know. Its a fight for survival against Terrorist groups (Hizbollah, Hamas) and Iran/Syria who want Israel wipe off the map (by the way - do you think the world would care for 7 million Israeli refugees ????). Also I was always under the impression that Islam viewed Christianity as the evil crusador infidels?
76. DONT USE HUMAN SHIELDS
Ertok   (07.30.06)
Well done Hezbollah. You fire from rockets from the building and then what? Stop the people from leaving ? Is that how you do it? Everyone knows a building is condemned after a rocket is launched. EVERYONE KNOWS.
77. to Anthony
To Anthony ,   Lebanon   (07.30.06)
Dfntly united Lebanon is its church and mosques Lebanon is Anthony and Mohd Lebanon is us Lebanon is u and me Lebanon is ur family and mine Lebanon is Junieh and Tyr Cheers my friend Pray for the children Pray my friend
78. Answer to #4 !
dina ,   telaviv Israel   (07.30.06)
Its a war, civilians and soldiers are killed in wars! we do not have to act surprised. The difference is that Israel has worned civilians to leave and hezbollah instead targets civilians..it seems you know only what tv shows you which is a lot of misinformation..try to read about hezbollah (you will noticed that no negociation is possible with them) Make me a favour don't call hezbollah a " trained militia" its a terrorist organisation that has much more arms and rockets than you believe! and what do we care if the world is chocked? we try to defend ourselves, sometimes we succeed sometimes not, so come and help Israel instead of watching and being chocked
79. #38 and 72
Rod   (07.30.06)
Because millions people wanting destruction of Israel as only aim in their life for all generations are human... Let's finish work, I agree with #38...
80. To # 63 - Stop foolling yourself...wake up
(07.30.06)
Perhaps they could be warned by your moral army, but these people have seen what your glorious F-16 have done with other fleeing civilians in the last two weeks when they massacred them on the raods with phosphoric bombs, and your IDF finds always some layers to justify their mad work. Wake up
81. #34 Selective pity...
Rod   (07.30.06)
Are you moaning the same way for the dozens daily civilians deads in Iraq? I don't think so... Poor blind man...
82. excuses and blame
gijs ,   Netherlands   (07.30.06)
To the IDF; please stop making excuses and doing inquiries. You are not to blame. It is nasrallah and his bunch of mafiosi who started this. Nasrallah should be doing inquiries. Please please don't give in to so called "international opinion". International opinion is always against you whether you drop flowers or bombs.
83. when IDF cant face fiters , they strike civilians . BRAVO
Sabra   (07.30.06)
84. No 3 says it all so stop the hysteria!
Laura ,   London   (07.30.06)
war is war - always dreadful no matter who is killed and maimed but no 3 says it all. So lets stop all this knee-jerk reactionism and keep in mind that Hizbollah are hiding amongst women and children. The IDF would prefer to confront Hizbollah on a battle line, face to face, whereas Hizbollah prefer to operate in residential areas, with a clear conscience regarding all the innocent civilians their tactics slaughter. In fact the more Lebanese civilians that are killed the better for Hizbollah who can then rely on the world media to print the resulting carnage. This is a war of bleeding hearts rhetoric and one that Islam is truly capable of winning unless we keep them in our crosshairs and point the finger at the source of all this evil.
85. Chosen people of GOD !!!!
(07.30.06)
Chosen people of the devil , God never support killers ..... congratulation Israel today you won a new millions of haters . to the one who wrote before the report with tittel WHY THEY LOVE TO HATE US .... now you know why or still you ask ?
86. the definition of "terrorism"
Shai ,   Israel   (07.30.06)
Israel is not "redefining terrorism". There is no need to. DEFINITION: Reference: Title 22 of the US Code, Section 2656f(d): "premeditated, politically motivated violence perpetrated against noncombatant targets by subnational groups or clandestine agents, usually intended to influence an audience." This describes most of what Hamas, Fatah, Al Aqsa Brigades and Hizbollah do. I am sure that Libya, Cuba, Russia, HIzbollah, Hamas, PA, China, Venezuela, Iran, North Korea and similar countries would define it differently to exclude their misdeeds, but the definition is well-established in law. There is, by the wya, no internationally agreed to definition that is DIFFERENT from the above definition because the United Nations can't find one that includes everything Israel does, but excludes everything Arabs do. But the definition in use by most of the free world is fairly clear, and it does not include Israeli actions, even if those actions are "terrifying". Israel is a sovereign state, not a subnational group, protecting its interests under rules of war. Its actions are to achieve clearly defined military goals, which are to protect its citizens and boundaries, and these objectives are guarded priviliges of nations under the UN charter. Israel gives non-combatants and civilians ample opportunity to leave an area of heavy fighting. Any protection of interests under rules of war are by definition NOT terrorism. Moreover, Israel does not INTENTIONALLY target non-combatants, much less civilians. The definition of "non-combatant" and "civilian" are maintained clearly by Israel within its own borders, clear enough that any of Hizbollah's and Hamas' aimless volleys of missiles qualify as being outside the scope of "legal targets", and kidnappings, suicide bombings and the like, even within the West Bank, are clearly within. At the same time, HIzbollah and Hamas undermine the clarity of the definition by not wearing uniforms at times, by hiding behind civilian (houses for example) targets and non-combatant targets (such as transporting arms in ambulances), and even refusing to allow civilians to escape a war zone because they are desired as a shield. That non-combatants and civilians are killed by Israel's army does not mean they've been intentionally targeted. The evidence is always overwhelmingly against this assertion, and when it is not, the soldiers are punished after a trial. Generally, those who make the claim that Israel's injuring of non-combatants and civilians is intentional, are biased as they have no way of immediately proving based on the evidence that the targets were intentionally hit. They assume it to advance their own interests and world view.
87. Israel is Justified
Fouad ,   Lebanon   (07.30.06)
You see that girl in the picture? She was seen firing Katyushas that hit an Israeli balcony. Israel had every right to defend itself against these chidlren. Way to go Israel. I bet your peace-loving people are proud. We counted on you to get rid of Hezbollah, instead you killed our children, Red Cross volunteers, press correspondents, UN observers, not to mention destroying our couuntry. Oh and Hezbollah is still standing, firing rockets into the depth of Israel. Shame on you!
88. #6, We need more Israelis like you.
Fouad ,   Lebanon   (07.30.06)
89. Picture "Injured Evacuated"
Tariq ,   qana   (07.30.06)
why you always have to twist the truth. be professional once in ur lives. The picture in this articles labeled " injured evacuated" should be innocent dead child carried by her father!!!"she is dead, murdered, not merely injured!!
90. No need for US definition of terrorism- USA is terrorist
Agop ,   Yerevan   (07.30.06)
citizens of world do not need US definition of terrorism. USA is world's number 1 terrorists state. Israel is world's number second terrorist. USA killed 3 million in Vietnam, USA killed 250 thousand in Iraq. USA killed 30 thousand in Afghanistan. USA killed thousands in Nicaragua. USA killed and slaved thousand of Arfican AMerican and indigenous Indian. So, Terrorists cant define terrorism.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article