News
Olmert: Qana used for launching rockets
Ronny Sofer
Published: 30.07.06, 13:13
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
129 Talkbacks for this article
1. legally speaking, the civilian deaths are HIZBULLAH'S fault
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (07.30.06)
the ones who use human shields are the ones who are to blame for their deaths. i like the way that fact is conveniently buried and forgotten.
2. Let do the Math!
Ehud ,   Hiroshima, JAPAN   (07.30.06)
Hezbollah killed 30 civilians and 30 soldiers. IDF killed 30 HEzbollah members and 700 civilians. Who is targeting civilians? Mr. Olmert, for GOD's sake and for the love of Israel, let our army come back from Lebanon. STOP WAR NOW!
3. Olmert, you are a big big big lire
Khalil ,   Dubai   (07.30.06)
4. our lips are sealed
ADDIS ,   Ein KAREM   (07.30.06)
but the response is comming on its way to Tal Al Rabaiaa (TA) IN THE NEXT FEW HOURS. YOU WILL SEE
5. this is not a war crime. period.
(07.30.06)
6. this is not guernica its hezbollah.
(07.30.06)
7. SHAME ON YOU !!!! LIAR!!!
fadi ,   lebanon   (07.30.06)
When will you israeli people wake up to the lies of this Terrorsit called olmert and his boss bush !?? everyone remembers that after missiles to Afula you showed the bombing of the Launchers!!!! If that was true why u kill children now!!?? This will just increase and direct all the anger of the world to israel!!!!
8. Beilin:Where’s the Outcry For All Rockets Sent to Israel
H ,   Jerusalem   (07.30.06)
Just because we have special protection by our Father in Heaven - as we openly see - does not mean there should not be an outrcry by Beilin, Leftists and anti-war individuals? May Hashem keep watching His children and protecting us. There should be no reason for an outrcry that Hizballah civilians were killed. Apparently, they're part of the Hizballah army. If anything, it's the Hizballah that should be blamed for using unarmed children as part of the army.
9. STOP WAR NOW!
Ehud ,   Hiroshima, JAPAN   (07.30.06)
I just watched the video. There is only one thing I want to say. Thank you IDF for making it impossible for Israelies to live decently. Everyone in the world hated us because of your actions and now they even hate us more and more. I should be seeking a Japanese citizenship, and maybe changing my religion... IDF, you made me feel shame for being a Jew. STOP WAR NOW! stop this misery which is leading no where.
10. Its a dirty War
Abu Jude ,   London   (07.30.06)
the IDF is responsible for the killing of these kids
11. OOOOLD tactic!
Siegel ,   Karmiel, Israel   (07.30.06)
Of course the deaths of those civilians are on the hands of Hizzbullah who hide behind women and children like cowards! But the world will ALWAYS blame Israel. Israel warned the people to leave and now they are dead. NO other nation would ever tolerate what Israel is forced to. Israel is never allowed to defend itself! We are to lie down and let ALL the terrorists kill us!! The world hates Jews! But just wait till the GOD OF ISRAEL RISES! The whole world will be severly judged!
12. TO SIEGEL
LAURA ,   VANCOUVER CANADA   (07.30.06)
siegel..yes it does appear that the media blames israel but any rational person who has the intelligence to look at the situation can clearly see what the israelies have and are up against we in the west are facing the same enemy...unfortunately most of us haven't figured that out yet i am not jewish but i support israel with all my heart god bless you all laura in vancouver
13. Hizzbollah's plan to use their children as martyrs worked.
Daisy ,   USA   (07.30.06)
The IDF sent leaflets warning the residents to leave because Hizzbollah was launching rockets from the buildings in the area. The terrorist group refused to let the civilians leave because they knew what was going to happen. The most pathetic thing about this is that some Jews and Christians actually believe this propaganda. Idiots!
14. Ehud I mean Ahmed; No believes you're a Jew so shut up!
Daisy ,   USA   (07.30.06)
15. No apologies
Art ,   Sydney, Australia   (07.30.06)
I've said it before and I'll say it again: Israel owes no-one any apologies. The only "ugly crimes" are those committed by the satanic and evil Hisballsup and their equally vile allies, Syria, Iran and Hamas. CIVILIAN DEATHS ARE REGRETTABLE BUT THEY ARE NOT OUR FAULT. If the Leb Govt wants to apportion blame, go to the satan Nasrallah. If 40 israeli kids were killed, the moslems would be celebrating in the streets and calling it "legitimate resistance". Sorry, this is "self-defence"
16. to Siegel #11
slawomir ,   poland   (07.30.06)
This is very funny!!! hahahaha First IAF has destroyed roads and bridges and now IDF is calling these poor people to leave???? How??? With some kind of magic??? Cars on roads are under fire by IAF. I don`t know what is a better solution - to be killed in a home or to be killed on the road???? But dont`t write I am anti-Semitic. This kind of argumentation is just boring.
17. listen to both sides !!
nazir ,   india   (07.30.06)
let's see: israel claims it's hizbullah fault.. why? because israel calims so ! but lebanese people living there; victims, injured people and all say that this is all silly and no hizbullah rockets were there.. so whom should we believe? THINK !!!
18. "Moral Justification"
George   (07.30.06)
It is very ironic how Israelis always find the justification for commiting crimes against humanity. They never make "mistakes", it is always the fault of the others. Pure Racism and arrogance. Moral decline will lead the IDF and the state of Israel to disasters only!
19. Stop This
Abdallah ,   Gaza   (07.30.06)
Stop killing all people every where, we want to live in peace its not equivelent war to kill womens and childs
20. ONLY DECISIVE ACTIONS of IDF and IAF can stop the war
Vittorio ,   Toronto, Canada   (07.30.06)
The guilty side in every death - Hizballah. The guilty person - Nasrallah. The guilty country - Lebanon, because it sheltered Nasrallah and Hizballah. Israel has no other option as to resist and to retaliate. ONLY DECISIVE ACTIONS of IDF and IAF can stop the war.
21. Let's not delude ourselves
Shlomo Avner ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (07.30.06)
C'mon, let's please stop kidding ourselves here. We've screwed up enough: rockets hitting our cities, our land operations failing and our media is struggling to keep its head above the water. This latest act on Qana is the icing on the cake: our hands are now covered in blood, and we've got a lot to answer for. G-d help you, Israel.
22. Rice & Lebanon
Ali ,   USA   (07.30.06)
Rice is not allowed to visit Lebanon. It is a very good step by the lebanes government.
23. The Decadence and Fall of the once great IDF!
walter ,   Planet Earth   (07.30.06)
24. It's incredible
Dave (YG) ,   SA   (07.30.06)
What do you expect Israel to do? The amoral Hizbollah people use civilians to hide behind, so Israel cannot attack them. But, Israel has a moral obligation to defend her citizens, and that unfortunately incolves civilian deaths. I don't know if anybody noticed, but nearly all attacks on Israel have been CIVILIAN targets. Any comments on that? Any apologies by Nasrallah? If people stopped for a moment and reasoned logically, instead of being blind sheep following the world's biased media, perhaps people will see Israel has been doing it's best not to hurt civilians, while Hezbollah has been doing it's best to harm civilians.
25. HEZBOLLAH WAR CRIME #23243536
Ertok   (07.30.06)
26. HEZBOLLAH
LAURA ,   VANCOUVER CANADA   (07.30.06)
IF LEBANON CAN'T OR WON'T DISARM HEZBOLLAH, ISRAEL WILL HAVE TO DO IT FOR THEM
27. Very nice news
serurier ,   France   (07.30.06)
Terrorists always used Qana launching rockets , now they must know no safe house for them !
28. Now that is how you do business.
Adam ,   Raanana, Israel   (07.30.06)
Its about bloody time they stopped playing games and showed these idiots that if they don't get out of their villages, they will die as Hizballa with Hizballa. Ehud, if you are ashamed to be a jew, go to hell. Don't speak on behalf of the Israelis because I am living in piece BECAUSE of the brave soldiers in the IDF
29. What Shield?
Jane ,   France   (07.30.06)
These where civilians hiding from the Israeli attacks. They couldnt leave thier place as there is no place to go. not to mention that israeli army is targeting every moving object. They chose to stay at thier houses and to die in thier with dignity that your kind does not know. where is hizballah? can you see any hizballa body? Watch the Video ? does your conscience move ? Hizballah is fighting away from civilian and they have thier own Bunkers and own place! You could not dare to gight them you are heros in killing childreen only. Bravo Israel.
30. The Hizbollah & Iranian warmongers must be eliminated
Avi ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.30.06)
Next talkbacks
Back to article