News
IDF: Qana building fell hours after strike
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 30.07.06, 20:44
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
363 Talkbacks for this article
61. mothers died holding their childs
bassam ,   lebanon   (07.30.06)
Still, you can call this a proactive action; maybe childrens will grow up to become terrorists, right? IDF is loosing skills, last time he had 110 vs. 60 this time. hard luck. IDF, beginning of the end!!!
62. North Korea Responsible
Saud ,   Saudi Arabia   (07.30.06)
I think what had happened is that North Korea had attacked this building to blame Israel for it. Some one had told me something more possible that one of the kids was wearing explosive belt, so he blew himself and the others, Ist that a good justification IDF, Use it better
63. For G-d sake stop lying
abc ,   EY   (07.30.06)
The building collapsed when it was hit, but the rescue services did not get to it till 8 hours later.
64. All Arabs must recognize Israel
MARK ,   USA   (07.30.06)
If the Arabs really cared about the innocent people in Lebanon, they would pressure Hizballah to stop shooting rockets into Israel. The Lebanese do not care about civilians because the prime minister of Lebanon thanks Hizballah. He does not want peace.
65. #56; They should stop using Zionist technology like computer
Daisy ,   USA   (07.31.06)
http://www.israel21c.org/bin/en.jsp?enPage=HomePage http://www.shamar.org/emet/analysis/boycott.htm
66. Arabs prove once again the depth of their depravity.
Daisy ,   USA   (07.31.06)
Using women and children as human shields is a war crime and should be severely punished. The IDF has nothing to apologize for especially since it probably wasn't an airstrike that brought the building down.
67. one more evidence
Evgeniy ,   NYC, US   (07.30.06)
http://ws.giyus.org/points/point?id=70
68. Attention!!!
Evgeniy ,   NYC, US   (07.30.06)
I urge you to post a link on this page around internet, so as much as possible people will see it.
69. Blame Lebanon!
Hassan ,   Lebanon   (07.30.06)
Stupid Isrealis blaming everybody for everything! You kill the victim and march in his funeral!
70. to 26
(07.30.06)
Were you there? you're one of those idiots that no matter what, you blame Israel. Your hatred is blinding you. The facts are there so you can rave on as much as you want. Funny comming from an American whose country waged a war on terrorism as well. Here Israel was attacked first. What would any country do if attacked?You're not mentioning the fact that Hiz. wants to eradicate Israel, along with all the other barbaric terrorist organizatgions, who one of them also struck your country. Remember 9/11? it's the same kind of people. Maybe you're one of them so what am I wasting my breath on? A true American
71. to 25
(07.30.06)
Is that right? It seems like you already made up your mind. Typical.
72. #59: that would be stupid
Joshua ,   Pittsburgh, PA   (07.30.06)
For one basic reason: fallout would inevitably blow onto northern Israel.
73. Hizbulla murdered them themselves...........
Avraham ,   Netivot   (07.30.06)
74. Another case of Arab Bulls#it baffling brains
Alan ,   SA   (07.30.06)
75. u know what
mohamed ,   palestine   (07.30.06)
it is believed that u did tell the citizens to leave, but how could have they left knowing that the IDF have bombed all roads and bridges leading into qana, electricty was cut, and there were 60 people inside given so little time to leave, plz i am asking for an immediate cease-fire, b4 khizbolah retalliates heavily
76. WHERE ARE THE MEN?
Where are the MEN? ,   UK   (07.30.06)
If only they would love their children more than they hate Israel!
77. IDF shame on you for u murders+shame on you for your lies
Franck ,   PARIS france   (07.30.06)
Mad people, go away from mideast you are going to ruin all the earth WE WANT PEACE NOT LYING BANDITS , ISRAEL POLITICIAN AND MANY OF YOU, YOU ROT UP TO THE MARROW
78. Best Excuse for Israel!!!!!!!!!!
Al ,   US   (07.30.06)
The building collapsed by a bomb made by Al Qaeda because we all know how Sunnis HATE Shitties and since Hizbollah is Shittie they got bombed by Al Qaeda. Ok let's start thinking of another good excuse for our next massacre!
79. Timisoara
ab ,   Paris   (07.31.06)
Remember timisoara in Romania : they took corps from coroner ... no dead there ... same manipulation here. Hezbolla is very good for Marketing ... but Israel can check fact and tell us what really happened! Thank you Tsahal!
80. To 16 I can't believe your my namesake
Da dude   (07.30.06)
"Is the IDF really trying to suggest that their firing of missiles and explosives" The IDF only fired missiles "on a building had nothing to do with that same building collapsing hours later?" Oh man, I can't believe how people eat up Hizb'allah garbage. Like if the building was badly structurally damaged why did people stay inside of it? Unless it wasn't that bad or at all damaged. Or let me guess the IAF used a 'silent' explosive and it woke no one up, and then poof 8 hours later the building collaspse's. Yup " I can't see Israelis being THIS stupid as to buying this bullsh*t. " I can't see terrorists sympathizer being THIS stupid as to buy this bullsh*t. We I guess you've proven that you guys really are that stupid.
81. Photos that damn Hizbollah
Nannette ,   London, UK   (07.30.06)
THIS is the picture that damns Hezbollah. It is one of several, smuggled from behind Lebanon's battle lines, showing that Hezbollah is waging war amid suburbia. http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/0,,19955774-5007220,00.html
82. What about UN:
MAGNUS ,   Norway   (07.30.06)
What are the UN soldiers doing in Lebanon. They have been in the country for years and they call themselves for observers. What is observed in all these years. May be they are supporters to Hisbolla......
83. joe = Achmed
(07.30.06)
84. Sorry, but... - WHO CARES?!
Michael Steiner   (07.30.06)
I used to care but I don't anymore. They started the war, now they have it. If every house in Lebanon has a picture of Nasralah and if 70% of the Lebanese support Khizbolah, then this serves them right. I know I sound callous but they've made me become indifferent to their suffering. GO IDF!!!
85. I´m afraid this is another movie from Pallywood factory.
Roberto Gutierrez ,   Madrid, Spain   (07.30.06)
Hmmmm.... strange circumstances. The strike is at midnight, the building collapses at eight o´clock... It seems a Pallywood movie. But now it doesn´t matter, the propaganda effect has been achieved. Don´t forget that whatever Israel does, it will be bad. As usual. Nothing new.
86. Qana
Ruth Kraus ,   London UK   (07.30.06)
Hope you guys get this to the BBc etc by Monday 31 July!!!!! We need some positive news!!!!
87. DO U THINK THE WORLD IS THAT STUPID!!??
fadi ,   lebanon   (07.30.06)
U make ur people look stupid and ridiculous!!?? If ur that blood thirsty and consider those children as terrorists who are worth being killed ... at least have the courage to admit it !! even by a mistake !!! but dont try to fool the world with that stupid story ..... its a ridicule of your IDF stupid excuses (you can do much better than this) and the world !!!!
88. Ain't they, 29?
Syd ,   Athens, Greece   (07.30.06)
You think that IDF is not responsible? Well, all Europe and all the world think that you are wrong...
89. to no. 13
(07.30.06)
in the act with un position ISRAEL took responsibility, beacuse it was realy hr. eve the officer of the un said that there were a lot of hizbulla missiles, that was shoot very close to it. so what do you want? when there is a nedd to take rsponsibility ISRAEL is taking it. but when it isn't it fault why should it take it?
90. It's OK
elalfy ,   alexandria / egypt   (07.31.06)
I dont know why we "arabs" are very sad about what happend in qana or what is happening in iraq or palasten aren't you our enemies !! it is your duty to kill us savagely as you can i wont be sad if israel attacked egypt tomorow or even acuse thim of paparic or any thing no .. we are enemies we kill eash other so dont be sad if i killed your brave idf solders when they come .. but i tell you something let thim come ..
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article