News
First refusenik in current war: Armored Corps officer
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 30.07.06, 23:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
51 Talkbacks for this article
31. 15.Israel
alberto ,   florida,usa   (07.31.06)
to 15.Israel Please go and wash your burka... SMELLS horrible !!!
32. I wouldn't trust this Refusenik
Drew ,   soon in Israel   (07.31.06)
to protect Jews anywhere.
33. #12 Ehud in Spain ?
Misha   (07.31.06)
What happened to Japan, you moved already? I suspect you go by the alias "Ehud "b/c Ehud (Olmert's first name) is probably the only Israeli name you know. You probably live in Syria or Iran and never even met a Jewish/Israeli person yet are obsessed with Israel. So much so that you even need to invent aliases to come on here and talk to you. We Israelis know that you are human. Why can't you accept that we are human too. Come on here with your real name, we will be happy to have a discussion with you.
34. KICK HIM OUT OF THE ARMY!
ls ,   israel   (07.31.06)
We really don't need these kind of people in the Army and better yet, let them leave Israel and reside with the Nations. They don't belong in Israel. IF THESE YOUNG PEOPLE DON'T UNDERSTAND THAT WE ARE UP AGAINST ANOTHER "HITLER" AND THIRD REICH, THEN THEY BETTER GO STUDY HISTORY AGAIN. BUDDY, IT IS EITHER THEM OR US.
35. If he won't fight when Katyushas are falling, when will he?
Zionist   (07.31.06)
He doesn't deserve to live in Israel.
36. What's a Traitor
(07.31.06)
He is a hero: ordinary man doing an extraordinary thing. Lambast him all you want, his conscience will be clear. I bet if he had been in an infantry division he'd've gone.
37. amir your are a hero in the eyes of the free
gail ,   united states   (07.31.06)
world and a brave man.
38. traitor
thom ,   USA   (07.31.06)
In 28 days, he will return and be a "hero" to other traitors. Better he should be shot, then he can be a dead "hero."
39. To All TALKBACKERS IN ISRAEL
Proud Lebanese   (07.31.06)
I BELIEVE EVERY ISRAELI HAS SERVED IN THE ARMY AND KNOWS HOW TO USE A WEAPON. MY QUESTION TO YOU IS INSTEAD OF CALLING HIS SOLDEIR A TRAITOR AND A COWARD, CHICKSHIIIT AND ALL OTHER WORDS, WHAT ARE YOU DOING ON THE NET? IF YOU HAVE THE GUTS YOU WOULD BEEN AT THE BORDER NOW!!! CHICKENS
40. Sons of Abraham has only one path
Ali ,   Libya   (07.31.06)
Sooner or later, sons of Abraham will live together in peace. How long would it take? no one knows, but they both have to live together in peace and harmony. Peopel like Amir from both sides will help establishing that.
41. The nature of conscience
Fabia ,   Haifa   (07.31.06)
If Captain Pastar states that "participating in the war contradicts the values [he] was brought up upon,." then one needs to question those values. Does it accord with his conscience to leave Israeli civilians (including children) undefended? What is the preferred outcome of those who praise Pastar's refusal to defend his country against those whose stated objective is its destruction and the annihilation of its people?
42. #11 you ignorant ho
Scott ,   Dallas, Texas   (07.31.06)
My g-d. What do you know about bravery?? Your biggest challenge in life is deciding whether or not to honk your horn when a plano soccer mom steals your parking space at Neimans. Why don't you get in to your leased Mercedes and go home to the house you can't aford and take shut your mouth. G-d knows the rest of Dallas is sick of hearing your shit. And yes you do look fat, yoga is not working for you. Try cutting off your head, ofcourse your ass is still huge. I'll be looking for you since I'm also in Dallas...
43. With Israeli's like this...
A Price ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (07.31.06)
we don't need enemies. what a shame! to refuse to serve your country in its dire time of need. the word traitor is too good to use at a time like this. i agree with the person above who said to put him up against a wall and shoot him. or indeed, the person who said to trade him in for one of the other three soldiers who were captured. bloody shame that we not only battle hamas, hizbullah, the international community but also self-hating jews as well!
44. Kol Hakavod
Phkl ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.31.06)
I hope more and more soldiers will refuse to serve and be the hand of the stupid politicians who "govern" us. The army brass are taking this country hostage. "War are to decide who is left is right....".
45. SHAME , SHAME ,SHAME !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
AVINU   (07.31.06)
ENEMY USE HIS CIVILIANS TO KILL JEWS AND AMIR PASTAR REFUSETO DEFEND HIS OWN PEOPLE ????????????????????? ISRAEL SHOULD NOT OPERATE INSIDE LEBANON , BUT LEBANON CAN FIRE MORTARS HUNDREDS ROCKET PER DAY TO KILL INNOCENT JEWS ???????? THAT HE CALLS PRINCIPLES ????? WOWWWW , HOW NICE HE SERVED HIZBULLAH !!!!! WOOW, HOW ENEMY IS PROUD AND HAPPY NOW !!!!!!!!!!!!! SHAME !!!
46. Smart man, didn't wanna die by FRIENDLY FIRE...!!! LOL
observer ,   Canada   (07.31.06)
47. THE LAW
Yohanan ,   LA   (07.31.06)
As long as such mollusc becomes a hero in Israel - No wonder Israel is loosing its deterrence.
48. He should be stripped of his rank
jason white ,   afula,israel   (07.31.06)
. Why didn't his soldiers beat him for being a cowardly dog? I am happy that all my officers in the I.D.F. were leaders and would never desert us in any situation.They led us and made sure we had everything we needed.They were an example to follow and not a shame to Israel. The yesh guval gang should be tried as an enemy organization.
49. #39 proud lebanese
Alex ,   Israel   (07.31.06)
You know what tzav-8 is, you kuku? IDF is not like some Hazbollah gangster club. You can't just "take arms and fight". But don't worry, there are millions of israelis who are ready to defend their country, unlike this piece of chicken.
50. 5 Kyle <-- complete Idiot
(07.31.06)
51. What have u done with my Ehud?#12
confused ,   Israel   (07.31.06)
Where is Ehud? I just got off from writing him a response in Japan, how did he get to spain so quickly???.. Ehud ur confusing me, cud u have an identity crisis going on or this Ehud an alias in disguise..i guess we will never know??
Previous talkbacks
Back to article