News
Lebanese website blames Hizbullah for Qana deaths
Roee Nahmias
Published: 01.08.06, 07:53
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
136 Talkbacks for this article
31. Re: 3: Ha!
Max ,   LA, CA, USA   (08.01.06)
Chris - you're in denial - just like your buddies #1&2. It's OK - truth hurts and no amount of your denial will change the truth that Hizballah hides its weapons within the civilian areas all over Lebanon.
32. Nothing about the Arab terrorist can surprise anyone
Anne ,   USA   (08.01.06)
They are the masters of deception!
33. to 1,2,3,4
ash ,   gush etzion   (08.01.06)
Firstly, all are agreed that the people seeking refuge were low down in an underground basement, so how did the israelis know they were there to "murder" them? Murder requires intent. If you can find one shred of evidence that supports your assertions that Israel deliberatley murdered these people then i will personally call for the bombers to be tried in an international court. and as for conspiracy theories and believing the ridiculous why is the "Protoclos of the elders of zion" being sold in high numbers across the arab world. and why when anything goes wrong in an arab country it is always blamed on zionist elements. still to this day more arabs believe 9/11 was perpetrated by the mossad than bin laden?!?!?!
34. It must be a though dissonance
to previous posters ,   Israel   (08.01.06)
Don't you wonder why us stupid Jews allow you to expose the organized propaganda? We must be so cowards, that we don’t even have the guts to censor your posts. I'm 100% sure that you scratch your heads over this. My friendly advice is to stop ignoring this dissonance or you’ll learn nothing about the enemy.
35. Shoddy Shiraz #2
Truth Watcher   (08.01.06)
Hey Shadi, its the Lebanese who outed this story, not Israel. So, sorry, your comment is irrelevant.
36. I KNEW IT!
Siegel ,   Karmiel, Israel   (08.01.06)
Well, Nassrallah's plan worked! How QUICK the world was to jump upon it and rail agains Israel! NO ONE is horrified that Hizzbullah planned this. And, as predicted, no one believes the true story, they WANT to believe that Israel did it.
37. we r sure 100000% hizbullah is responsible
m ,   lebanon   (08.01.06)
hizbullah is responsible of qana,saturday night nasrallah was bagging the lebanese people to stay one hand,he know he is a looser, and what a coincidence in the same day Mrs Condolezza was coming and we wasn't far from peace, he did his massacre to stop everything,for all ARAB and LEBANESE who believe that israel did that i say: people without brain THINK if israel want to kill civilians we wont be alive now, THINK u selfish,stupid,idiots,open yr eyes and yr ears dead bodies....
38. 4 - legally, the one using human shields is guilty
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (08.01.06)
the legal ruling. according to international law, was not created in a moral vacuum. your example is unrealistic because israel struck the building 1) because of the rockets being fired from there, and 2) it was not known that children were packed inside as human shields. why do you think israel's jails are full of suicide bombers who didn't get to blow themselves up? israel could have shot them on the spot, but didn't. i suggest you rethink your unrealistic moralizing hypothesis and stop trying to find ways to smear israel instead of the ones who create the entire 'human shield' situation.
39. Nasrallah & Khizb-Allah Guilty of Widespread War Crimes
Paqid 16, Netzarim ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (08.01.06)
My heart goes out to the Lebanese victims of Khizb-Allah's war crimes in Qana and throughout south Lebanon, as well as to our own victims of Khizb-Allah's act of war in crossing the internationally recognized border to attack Israel and kill and abduct Israeli soldiers, as well as Israeli civilians targeted and killed by Khizb-Allah. But it was wrong for our PR-illiterate Israeli leaders to apologize for Khizb-Allah's and Nasrallah's war crimes instead of being vocally outraged at them on behalf of the Lebanese victims. Israel did what we had, and must continue, to do to defend ourselves. I am outraged and furious with Khizb-Allah. Worst of all, Nasrallah and Khizb-Allah, like Hamas and other Islamic terrorist organizations, pervert religion to imply that the Creator, Whom they perversely claim to reflect, is a war criminal like them. There can be no more depraved and obscene blasphemy than this. It is widely known that Khizb-Allah routinely uses human shields, particularly women and children. These are all war crimes for which Nasrallah and every guilty party in Khizb-Allah must be prosecuted in The Hague. Paqid Yirmeyahu Israeli Orthodox Jew Advancing Logic as Halakhic Authority Welcoming non-Jews www.netzarim.co.il
40. Hezbollah that smart?
M ,   USA   (08.01.06)
I'm as pro-Israel as they come but I don't really believe that Hezbollah is smart enough to behind such a sick conspiracy. (Of course, I never believed 9/11 could happen either. ) I'm more inclined to think that the building didn't collapse initially so all the civilians stayed inside. When the building did collapse (due to Hezbollah bombs or the initial Israeli strike), they were caught inside. It's tragic but it's what happens in war.
41. Hezbullah killed the children
Michael S ,   Chicago   (08.01.06)
Readers should remember how during the Iraqi-Iranian war how both sides used children to detect the presenc of land-mines which killed the children. Hezbullah's MO is to use human shields, and I believe a forensic examination of the building will show that Hezbullah blew the building up as a Public Relations ploy. Hezbullah routinely hides behind skirts and children when conducting warfare, and that is because they are cowards who use dangeous weaponry. They will be defeated soon! If they were a real army, they would use the battle field and not the cities to launch their weapons. They are pathetic -- as everyone knows. That's why they are terrorists who deserve to be beaten.
42. Yes, It's Moral to Kill the Human Shields
Abu Daoud ,   Al-Quds   (08.01.06)
43. and look at this !!!
Mike ,   France   (08.01.06)
about shock value photographs for propaganda http://eureferendum.blogspot.com/2006/07/milking-it.html
44. Hizbullah
Shalom ,   Israel   (08.01.06)
I hope this story gets the attention it deserves in the world media coverage but unfortunately, I doubt it will. After all, if it doesn't put Israel in a bad light, it's not newsworthy.
45.  to Proud Grandpa, hizbolla blamed for qana,
david ,   tel aviv, israel   (08.01.06)
1.- You finally understood !!!!! !!!!, only nasralla would strap himself with 10 children, and he is doing it !!!, that is the question, !!!! is nasralla a moral person.... no he is not !!!!, just let me know one thing.... what did he achieve by crossing the border and killing 4 soldiers+ kidnapping 2 soldiers.... as a result of the action of this piece of garbage there are almost 1,000 dead on both sides ( and it is not finished yet).. thousands of wounded, billions of dollars in damage ,,, and all for what >???, so that Nasralla and friends can pump up their ego.... what is the morality of all this... so before you start critizing use your brains to see what caused ALL THIS DESTRUCTION... only one person... NASRALLA with his friends... are you saying they had the interest of the Lebanese people in mind when he did what he did. Nasralla this time miscalculated the reaction of Israel... and who is payinf for this.... not the Syrians,,, not the Iranians..... only the Lebanese people.
46. Did I not told you so
John ,   NZ   (08.01.06)
47. pure hatred
janette ,   u.s.   (08.01.06)
the point that many appear to be missing is, that the israeli air force were not informed that children were being housed in the building. it is not like nasrallah tying jewish kids to his body and israel having to make a decisison. all israel was shown were the rocket launchers on top of the building. to those who simply hate israel, anything will seem like israeli propaganda. why was no effort made to ensure that it was obvious that children were being hidden in the building? why does israel not have a right to defend itself? all those who do not want israel to defend itself simply hate jews and would hate them no matter what israel did or did not do. please be clear when you write your responses in the article. it doesnt matter what israel would do.... you would hate it and blame it for everything bad in the world. israel expressed sadness and sorrow for having mistakenly killed children. Why does no one apologize when israeli children are killed? do you realize that by not caring when a jewish child is killed you are showing israel that they must take all steps necessary to ensure survival... because if not... all you jew haters will come for the kill. so say it like it is, and then israel needs to do what it needs to do to ensure its survival.
48. IDF ..
Jeff ,   Australia   (08.01.06)
IDF in the eyes of Muslims has always been a coward force which either kills un-armed civilians or shoots from planes/tanks. When will we ever see IDF fighting fighting on the ground like a man. Answer: never.
49. Grasp at straws much?
Kevo ,   Miami, USA   (08.01.06)
I would say ynetnews has now officially hit bottom. Welcome to ZERO credibility.
50. The truth is comming out.
Avraham ,   Netivot   (08.01.06)
Why is everyone so surprised. What do you expect from a bunch of crazed islamic terrorists. Islamic fundamelist terrorists have no value for human life, they are worse than wild animals & should be wiped off the face of the earth.
51. A sham
jay ,   Israel   (08.01.06)
The man you see in the picture carrying the dead child was photographed carrying the same dead body several times over a few hour time span by different media outlets. The bomb went off at 1 am yet no dead bodies were taken out till 8 hours later when the media came! .....why?.....because this is just another propoganda campaign by hezbollah.........They are losing big time and will use any ways or means to try and fool the lebanese into thinking they are there to help them...........the sooner this vermon is eradicated the better for the lebanese people and israel. Your doing a great job Israel, keep it up!!
52. Need some proof - look here
westbankmama   (08.01.06)
Look at the posts in this website - he asks the question how is it that the banner blaming Rice for the Qana attack was produced so quickly - maybe this whole thing was planned in advance? http://israelmatzav.blogspot.com
53. #8 Schultz
Mick ,   Australia   (08.01.06)
another stupidity of yours. the newspaper who promoted this pictures is Robert murdoch another jewish propoganda 2 of those pics are old I guess PLO and the one with fire in it is from the Israeli drone fell in lebanon and the guy in the pic is a Lebanese soldier get it right stop believing your own lies.
54. #11 Neil
Mick ,   Australia   (08.01.06)
what's happening in Iraq is also Made in USA and By USA agents obviously you don't know how your country opperate.
55. #14
Mick ,   Australia   (08.01.06)
what Lebanese websites the one who live in Israel who worked for IDF as dogs or the one you Govenoment arranged to go to Canada and Australia.
56. Lebanese Forces website agrees Hizbollah responsibel for Qan
Mary ,   Lebanon   (08.01.06)
http://www.lebanese-forces.org/vbullet/forumdisplay.php?f=18
57. chris
tony ,   PARIS   (08.01.06)
If this site is "Crazy " as you so ellegantly put it,and only when the articles suit you,what the F;;;k are you waisting your time writing for<,,<,?Are you shocked that there are "Christian Arabs in Lebanon,that are not Hizbollah members,Are you shocked at the fact that maybe what is being written here is TRUE?Are you appaulled at the fact that maybe this is the Fault of the Hizbollah,?Admit,its quite WEIRD that this "Incident " does fall on the Occasion of the first Qana Incident. Are you appaulled at the fact that there are Lebanese who think different,??and who want to live in their Land as free citizens,NOT ruled by a Phantome SYRIEN gouvernment..Who's strings are pulled by IRAN?Its all very shocking is'nt it???NO,I suppose you can't grasp these facts,I can only suggest that you forget about this site entirly,and find a "Good one like AL-MANAAR,to get the "RIGHT FACTS;;""
58. #53 Mick, Australia
gerd schulz ,   germany   (08.01.06)
you can't stand the truth. once again: "Photos that damn Hezbollah," Link, Chris, Herald Sun, July 30, 2006, http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/0,,19955774-5007220,00.html
59. Not Smart but Evil
John ,   NZ   (08.01.06)
Israel is fighting a clean high tech war while Hizbollah is fighting a dirty guerrilla war. Like in any sport, if you can't win, you resort to dirty tactics. Hit and run, hide behind burqa, manipulate the media and deception are all part of guerrilla warfare. Well, desperate ppl do desperate thing in desperate time. I can assure you, Qana 2 is coming to a screen near you.
60. #16 ....you should take breath
Tunisian   (08.01.06)
.We heard you loud and clear " No, in wars, the moral has no place but the international humanitarian law" I wonder if you have the slicest understanding of the international laws. You don't have to worry about " La Presse" it's for " stupid brainwashed muslim propaganda" .....again why should I be surprised? As for the money you are sending I beg you please stop sending it should we die god forbid from hunger or something.....As for the " terrorist" line you seem to remember I get news for you : it's expired product no body buys it anymore, go ahead and stock it (should I use a better word? ).....as for Sidi Bousaid it's so beautiful to let it slip into the Mediterranean............. one last note please spare yourself the sweat claiming Jews are Israelis, even some of them are, some are not....surprised again? get in touch with Tunisian Jews they might teach you something you don't know . The point is : Are you so desperate to go and find Haddad's thugs ( SLA) website as evidence of your innocence....it's evident : you can't handle the truth...it's painful no matter how you flip it.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article