Culture
Offer: Publicly circumcise Gibson
News Agencies
Published: 03.08.06, 12:40
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
97 Talkbacks for this article
31. #3 he was drunk!!! How convenient
(08.03.06)
How convenient for people to hide behind alcohol and drugs and justify their bad behavior. I guess that everything is justifiable when you are under the influence and it is so easy to use those excuses for your irresponsible behavior. He was drunk so he did this, and he raped, and he killed. Everything is allowed under the influence. Bravo Gibson! Good excuse. Your father was anti-semitic too, it is in your blood.
32. To No. 9
NYC Girl   (08.03.06)
Mel Gibson IS an American. He was born in a suburb of New York and later moved along with his parents and siblings to Australia, although I'm not certain what that has to do with the fact that he's an anti-Semite...in addition to being a misogynist and a homophobe. And when his idiot Nazi father revealed himself to be a Holocaust denier, Gibson's response to his father's comments was "My father never lied to me." Drunk or sober, Gibson is a racist scumbag.
33. A people of mercy
Jane ,   Atlanta, USA   (08.03.06)
I am shocked at the "tolerant" being so unforgiving and unwise. This man grew up in stew bath of resentment toward Jews and probably felt that same hatred. He did precisely what a godly person does with his sins: he inhibited them. You know you have them too. Then he got drunk. Drinking removes ones inhibitions, which is why any right thinking woman does stupid things when she drinks too much. He realizes what an idiotic thing it was to say and how ashamed he is of harboring that sin. Where is that famous sense of Godly forgiveness and mercy to the undeserving? I guess you have to have experienced it to offer it.
34. ?Villa de la Rosa???
anon ,   anon   (08.03.06)
No such thing in the Bible, but there may be such thing in the movie, or was it, Villa de los Greenbacks, for Mel? Learn your Bible, hon. Nobody here is "persecuting" Mel. You might want to learn what the word means, and what it has entailed thorughout history, before you use it? Forgiving tends to be a good thing and I highly recommend it. That does not mean that anybody is obligated to become Mel's soulmate or bosom friend or even business partner. I sincerely wish Mel well, of course humans have flaws, and I believe him when he says he is sorry. But, just as in the case of the movie, it is NOT up to those who have NOT been slandered to decide whether or not his actions are blameworthy. This too is not too difficult to grasp.
35. Probably already cut
Kate ,   USA - California   (08.03.06)
FYI - Americans don't need to be Jewish to be circumcised. Actually, I have only seen one uncut member in my entire life, and he was an Italian. It was an incredible shock for me. Although only one of my 2 sons is circumcised and he made that decision on his own at about the age of 8 or 9 years old because he didn't want to look 'different' than the other boys. Perhaps, I am taking this public circumcision joke a bit too literally.
36. Mel is an Ass
Maurice ,   NYC   (08.03.06)
This guy is such a Asshole....
37. Title in very bad taste
anon ,   wash, dc   (08.03.06)
We should be above using this sort of language. So puerile.
38. Gibson's drunk tongue spoke his sober mind.
Joanna ,   Stanford   (08.03.06)
He is an anti- semite and an idiot to boot. What's new?
39. Mel Gibson
Larry ,   St. Paul, USA   (08.03.06)
He's just another in a long line of Hollywood Idiots!
40. What's the truth?
Cathy ,   Pensacola USA   (08.03.06)
Hmmmm... could there be any truth in what Mel said? Israel is wrong to kill innocent folks and America is wrong to support and arm these zionists. Have you ever heard of Benjamin Freedman (1890-1984)? He was a successful Jewish businessman who became a Christian and spoke often of the Jewish tyranny he believed was enveloping the United States: http://www.iamthewitness.com/DarylBradfordSmith_Freedman.html
41. #4
Jane   (08.03.06)
Jews don't turn the other cheek, Andrew.
42. #11
Jane   (08.03.06)
That's why we're bombing Lebanon now. So many Hezbollah supporters and Jew-haters.
43. Circumcision?
Mike ,   Jerusalem   (08.04.06)
With a rusty chain saw and then held down in the mikveh for a half hour
44. lighten up
James Rich ,   USA   (08.04.06)
Lighten up. Mel is our hero even if he is Aurtralian. O yeah by the way, Duck, incoming!!!!! Why sooooo unreasonable???? There's another, Duck.
45. Gibson the bigot
Phil ,   US   (08.04.06)
What has been lost in the Mel Gibson incident is how his vile speech is spoken everyday by sober Europeans. If I recall, a European poll taken several years ago identified Israel as a major threat to word peace. How is that different from Gibson spewing that Jews are the cause of all the wars? How is it different from the vile attempts at boycotting Israel by Church and academic institutions while these pious hypocrites, antisemites and antisemitic Jews? I wonder if these fools would use an Israeli drug that cures their illness or would they compromise their boycott just that one time. What is the difference between Gibson's remarks and those of the French Govt. that described Iran, a hateful and barbaric racist country sworn to annihilate Israel, as a stabilizing force. while we're at it, what is the difference between France and the Vatican condemn Israel for not using a "proportionate" response against Hamas and Hezbollah while rockets were being launched against Israeli citizens and the Palestinian Authority and Lebanese Govt. supported attacks against Israel? So you see, Gibson's remarks, as hateful as they were, are the same words uttered in slightly different form by non-alcoholics and so-called cultured, religious, and respectable people?
46. #8 Talula
moish ,   israel   (08.04.06)
why are you all upset talula, he hates Jews the same way you hate religious jews! He is no different than you!
47. 8- well said!! :]
Orli ,   Israel   (08.04.06)
48. Gibson - merely speaking what Catholic church taught me
David ,   Palm Harbor, FL. USA   (08.04.06)
Growing up in a Catholic school, I was taught that the Jews crucified Christ...as if we were suposed to hold that against them the rest of our lives. Of course the Bible teaches that our sins put Him on the cross, so that we could have redemption with the ultimate Lamb sacrifice. Praise be to God and His Son Jesus Christ forever and ever!!
49. Racial slurs
Robert Carey ,   Brisbane Australia   (08.04.06)
Lior, just how many, in your view, qualify to have a holocaust? By the way, were you around in 1941?
50. HOW DARE YOU SUGGEST A CIRCUMSION
DACON9   (08.04.06)
A PUBLIC CASTRATION IS MORE APPROPRIATE
51. Enough of Mel Gibson-Boycott his movies & that's it
Jenny   (08.04.06)
He will drink himself to death from depression and that will be the end of it.
52. Mel's next project: Blackheart - an autobiography
Daniel ,   Phoenix, USA   (08.04.06)
Let him confess with all the passion and means at his disposal. With a title like that it's bound to make millions.
53. Shame on you ALL for picking on an alcoholic!
Mary Callaghan ,   Texas   (08.04.06)
Just because the man has a drinking problem! Shame! Mel, I love your movies, especially What Women Want. When can we see more?
54. alcohol doesn't make you a racist
Sarah ,   Seattle WA   (08.04.06)
Alcohol doesn't make you hate jews or speak to female cop in a derogatory way, unless he hates Jews and women when he's sober. When someone kills their parents and then blames alcohol, I say cheap copout. Mel, face the music
55. To Kyle - #6
Norm ,   NYC   (08.04.06)
What does Kenny have to say on the matter?
56. Yeah what if??????
Buddy   (08.04.06)
"The Blacks started all the wars" "The Mexicans started all the wars" Would anybody have raised an eyebrow, not likely.
57. Gibson the bigot?
Robert Carey ,   Brisbane Australia   (08.04.06)
It's quite understandable for the Jews to feel as downtrodden as they so eloquently portray. It is also the same for the Palestinians and Lebanese. I wonder if the Israeli population would accept a few million Darfur refugees, donate a part of prime land and invite them to build their settlements on hitherto Israeli residential areas.
58. To No. 53
NYC Girl   (08.04.06)
He's not being "picked on" for being an alcoholic. He's being picked on for being an anti-Semite. And at a time when there's already too damned much Jew hatred around, a lot of us are losing our patience.
59. As a tick causes the itch...
Moshe Zion ,   Skokie, Usrael   (08.04.06)
So Jews cause the "disease" anti-semitism. By way of deception Jews conduct war. Sadly, Jews are a small but powerful minority in many of the US's most important political and commercial areas. Sharon himself once boasted, "don't worry about the US...we control the US," or something similar.
60. be nice Paul
adam ,   TN. usa   (08.04.06)
"For what do you need to apologize?" You understand the meaning. Be nice to those who may not be fluent in the nuiances of the language. adam
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article