News
Indyk: US must not speak to Assad
Yitzhak Benhorin, Washington
Published: 04.08.06, 09:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
33 Talkbacks for this article
1. Hurray for Indyk
Joseph Kaufman ,   Oakland/Jerusalem   (08.04.06)
A World War's defining moment is, historically speaking, French surrender. For all those who fear this to be the beginning of a world war, wait for the French to arrive as part of a multinational force, and let's see what they do when confronted by Hizbullah. Let's see what they do when confronted by Syrian refusal to cooperate. To hell with Syria. Get guts. Time for the West to learn from Israel and confront Islamofacism, before it's too late. Hizbullah , Hamas, Iran, and Al Queida are wake up calls. The phone is ringing off the hook. Smell the coffee.
2. who are you trying to fool here?
john ,   us   (08.04.06)
"I am a diplomat and a man who believes in dialogue, but at this stage I believe it is forbidden for the United States to hold direct talks with the Syrians," Indyk said yeah like they havn't been doin it for the past 10 years.
3. Yeah, Surprise, Surprise...
Almustapa Hitam ,   KL, Malaysia   (08.04.06)
Little surprise that Jewish Americans like this one and Dennis Ross who were supposed to be 'neutral' in the Arab-Israeli conflict, are now blantantly anti-Arab.
4. Agree!
Evgeny ,   NYC   (08.04.06)
5. Wise move.
Tunisian   (08.04.06)
" He added that the Syrians need to understand the current crisis between Israel and the Hizbullah is very dangerous and therefore they should work on calming the situation instead of worsening it " ... Is this guy is talking about the smart bomb express shipment ? Yes Sir, whatever you say Sir,shame on Syria!!!!!!!!!!!
6. #3 Indyk is Australian
proud Australian   (08.04.06)
pls get ur facts right...for him to say he doesnt think we shud talk to Syria makes him no more anti-arab as it makes u pro-Jew. Syria helped start the war (by supplying weaponary etc) they shud now help to put an end to it. Its pure common sense..nothing else..u are reading more into it!!
7. WE'LL JAW JAW AFTER THE WAR WAR
TD ,   London   (08.04.06)
Israel should only talk to a government democratically elected by the Syrian people, which can only happen once Assad is gone; Hizbollah is disarmed; and all of Syria's WMD stock is neutralised. Syria have started a fire that they now cant control. It will be put out once Assad is gone, whcih should be soon. You arabs just never learn, do you?
8. Baby Sad. No talk talk. Not smart enough to talk to.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Santa Monica, CA   (08.04.06)
9. indyk is clueless - he's part of the reason we are in this
(08.04.06)
10. #3 Why would'nt they be "Anti-Arab"?
Ertok   (08.04.06)
Your Islamic Arab brothers have proven time and again that they are irrational and led by stupid religious dogma calling for Israel's destruction. Living peacefully and with Israel is not on the Islamic agenda. Maybe you're like them too?
11. !
thr ,   ep   (08.04.06)
Hezbollah and Nasrallah must realize it is impossible to participate in the Lebanese government and at the same time organize armed attacks in the territory of other countries. Nasrallah must choose: is his organization going to adapt to the new situation in Lebanon with free democratic elections or is he going to hold on to the old and destructive tactiqs with guerilla warfare in south Lebanon. It is clear to everyone the old tactiq is leading nowhere; it brings death and destruction; more poverty because of decline in tourism, trade etc. Lebanon could prosper and become what it once was if Hezbollah chose the path of dialogue and reconciliation.
12. Yes he's an Aussie - Sydney - Smart bugger too.
Colonialist Aussie   (08.04.06)
13. no syria no peace
ali ,   damascus,syria   (08.04.06)
since long time and us policy did not reach any where for peace pross why,syria out and it have to do what us and israel want why they do not tray other way,with out syria no peace with syria you can get peace but are us and israel want peace?
14. Ur right Almustapa
Muhammad Ghazali ,   KL Malaysia   (08.04.06)
I strongly agree with ur statement. Hidup Malaysia!
15. right speech
m ,   lebanon   (08.04.06)
don't return us to the worth nightmare we was deep in,mr martin indyk is talking right,we want to live free with peace
16. Syria Doesn't Give a Rat's Fart About Talking, It'sGiggling
Maxine Jolie ,   Dallas, USA   (08.04.06)
17. Agenda
To 10 ,   LA   (08.04.06)
Giving Palestinians a country is not in the agenda of extremist jewish religious people, they also want an occupation of Lebanon. What's the difference between Israel denying the existence of Palestine and the Arabs denying the existance of Israel?
18. When you inflame fire, you don't know where it will spread.
Descartes ,   FRANCE   (08.04.06)
19. Indyk can say what he likes...
John Corish ,   Dublin, Ireland   (08.04.06)
...but he's not privy to the plans of the so-called neo-cons in Washington who are pulling Dubya Bush's strings. They've always stated that it's their ambition to "re-fashion" the Middle East and a proxy war fought by Israel against Syria (and eventually Iran) may very well be part of their immediate agenda.
20. Indyk
David ,   The Galilee, Israel   (08.04.06)
Hey you Aussies, Indyk is a son of Israel from birth, and belongs to Israel by faith. Don't claim our sons and daughters just because they were born in exile in your countries. Indyk should be humble because he was born into the Nation of Israel, not "proud" of a secular citizenship. Sorry, this ain't about surfing, barbeques, the outback, or that New York boy Mel Gibson's in-you-face hollywood Aussie machismo. It is about the Hebrew Scriptures, the Land of the Covenant, G-d Almighty, and the resemption of Israel and all mankind. Watch that pride, friends!
21. #17
M ,   Belgium   (08.04.06)
1. the fact that the extremist do not rule in Israel, as opposed to Palestinian Authority, Iran, Syria, etc etc etc... 2. The fact that Israel exists as a country recognized by the UN, which as far as I know is not the case for Palestine Plus, giving Palestinian a country is in the agenda of the Israelis as long as the Palestinians can guarantee security for Israel, which isn't even remotely close to happening now. So oust your extremist govt, allow the moderate people to get to power, take control of your extremists and then we'll talk. Until that happens, Palestinians will never get anything. And both people will suffer.
22. Indyke is a threat to Israel
Munther   (08.04.06)
Mr. Indyke, you have any self respect you should declare your Zionist agenda before you open your mouth. Stop selling yourself as an impartial American expressing his professional opinion. You don`t fool anybody. Everybody knows your history and agenda. Zionists like you are more a threat to Israel very exitence than ALL the Kassams and Katyushas!!!
23. INDYK IS RIGHT
ME ,   UK   (08.04.06)
PLEASE LET THE USA BOMB SYRIA AND IRAN LIKE THEY DID IN IRAQ AND YOU ARE SURE PEACE IN THE MIDLE EAST !!!
24. Talking? Deeds not Words!
Mark ,   San Antonio   (08.04.06)
I tend to agree with the former ambassador. In fact, neither Israel nor the US should talk with any Syrian representative. Syria is complicit in the trouble in Lebanon and Iraq. The US should just introduce Damascus to a 40kt device. Maybe after the flames subside, the Islamic world will understand how their Kytusha fire can escalate to nuclear fire. "Fire" to which they will be on the receiving end.
25. Syria
Johnson ,   USA   (08.04.06)
I cannot talk, or make deals with dictators like Assad, and expect they will honor it.. History proves that.
26. #1 Joseph
Yitz ,   Israel   (08.04.06)
Joseph, what the French cheese eating surrender monkeys will do is raise their hands up to hizbollah , show off their tanned armpits and wave their white flag.Most of the so called international forces will be retirees who have served in WWll so they have plenty of practice surrendering, the others will be collaborators from muslim countries who will join hizbollah like the UN observers who have been videotaped halping terrorists escape in their ambulances!
27. INDYK IS AUSTRALIAN DESERTER
Arik Silverman ,   Milwaukee USA   (08.04.06)
He received expedited US citizenship to serve in the government. He and Dennis Ross have sabotaged peace talks with Syria and the Palestinians. Read Clayton Swisher's book, "The Truth About Camp David." Best for the US and for Israel would be to revoke Indyk's US citizenship and expel him back to the outback.
28. INDYK TWICE A DISASTER FOR ISRAEL
Arik Silverman ,   Milwaukee USA   (08.04.06)
On Syria, I again say read Clayton Swisher's book. Rabin had made it known he was willing to give to Syria ALL of the pre-1967 land in a peace similar to Begin's peace with Egypt. This informal offer was known as the "Rabin deposit." The US used Prince Bandar of Saudi Arabia as a go-between to Syria to send the message that Ehud Barak was willing to offer the "Rabin deposit," i.e., give back ALL the Syrian land of pre-1967, and Assad responded positively. Indyk and Ross convinced Clinton to suspend peace efforts with the Palestinians and instead work on Syria, claiming that could be done easily and quickly. Assad rented 135 hotel rooms in Geneva for a very large staff to conduct serious final negotiations with Israel. When he got there, he was told that Barak would not offer the Rabin deposit after all, but wanted to negotiate how much land it would actually give back, particularly keeping land on the west of Kinneret. Assad was understandably upset that he had been deceived by Indyk and Ross, and packed his bags and went back to Syria. Except for the deception of Indyk and Ross, Israel could today have the same peace with Syria that it has with Egypt. And peace with Syria would mean NO HEZBOLLAH and NO ROCKETS.. INDYK AND ROSS ARE TRAITORS TO ISRAEL AND TO THE UNITED STATES.
29. AMERICAN JEWS HIJACKING U.S. FOREIGN POLICY
Jim ,   Los Angeles, U.S.   (08.04.06)
IN"DICK"- Well, just another example of American Jews lobbying and lobbing their bombs from their position of safety in the U.S. They have already hijacked U.S. Middle East foreign policy to the detriment of the average American. Just look at the Cuban exiles in Florida (who are mostly white by the way). They are screwing over their own country and the poor Cuban blacks (who descended from slaves) because Fidel finally wielded some justice and took away their dirty wealth.
30. Indyk is a slime, as is his mentor, James A. Baker III.
sk ,   USA   (08.04.06)
Indyk is one of Baker's "Jew Boys." You will remember James A. "F**k the Jews" Baker? Indyk is no friend of Israel or of Jews. He pushed the whole Oslo catastrophe that did indeed bring Israel to this point. (Not to minimize the role of the foolish and incompetent Rabin and Beilin.) Indyk doesn't like Jews, but he isn't an idiot like Armitage, and talking to Syria does NOT serve American interests.
Next talkbacks
Back to article