News
12 killed in rocket attack near Kiryat Shmona
Sharon Roffe-Ofir
Published: 06.08.06, 19:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
166 Talkbacks for this article
31. to #1 and others
Haim ,   Israel   (08.06.06)
We are not naive and clearly understand that we can’t achieve long term solution with only military actions. We understand that we can’t totally destroy guerilla’s ability to strike. We are just doing the best we can. What is the alternative? Wait until Hezbollah will possess weapons of mass destruction? What will we do when they use them? Nuke Lebanon? Iran? We are just doing our best. We will weaken Hezbollah and it will take them years to restore there abilities. This is minimum we can do for self defense. The solution is not in Israel or in Lebanon. It is in hands of international community. Virtually all countries, once experiencing terror attacks, declared war on terror, protested double standards and stated that only international cooperation will allow winning this war. However, Russia and EU refused to include Hezbollah in their terror lists and there is endless list of actions international community could do and didn’t done to stop terror. International community fails to oppose terrorism when it is not directly aimed on their countries. The recognition of real danger is coming too slow and too late. Terrorism is not about religion or ideology; it is about means of achieving whatever political goal. It shouldn’t be tolerated at any place and in any form. If international community will fail in this war it will bring destruction of entire mankind. Whenever any state, political party, organization is using terrorism it should be opposed by overwhelming power of entire world independently of economical or political interests. Enough playing with fire. This it the war for survival of mankind.
32. #15
(08.06.06)
Speaking of morons you'll probably be ACE.....He came from their land alright but who put Him to the cross? moron.....JESUS is on OUR side
33. to little Kate in London
A.C   (08.06.06)
listen to the news dear it tells everything. 12 soldiers killed by a rocket attack fired by the uncivilized people, while ur VERY civilized army is slAughtering more women and children all over Lebanon. I wonder what is so civilized in bombing children with F16 warplanes. I can assure u that when it comes to fighting real wars (not video games) it will take more than 24 hours.
34. 10 KILLED IN KIRYAT SHMONA
MARLENE   (08.06.06)
TO NO 7 JESUS WAS A JEW, SO HOW CAN HE BE WITH YOU???
35. olmert, olmert,
olmert ,   olmert   (08.06.06)
36. #7 By the way...
magrudis ,   Houston, TX   (08.06.06)
Jesus was a pacifist and a jew. You should not let your beliefs be tainted by those of hate filled fanatics.
37. Da Dude = Hizbullah propagandist?
magrudis ,   Houston, TX   (08.06.06)
You must be Hizbullah masquerading as an Israeli sympethizer since your comments only further the goals of the terrorists. Unless this is true, try not to be such an idiot.
38. 1938 Redux - Confront the islamofascists
Ashan ,   Israel   (08.06.06)
Right on the button with "arrogance" - the arrogance of the islamofascist, goosestepping, sieg-heiling Hizbonazis. Israel has the right to confront the islamofascists wherever they can be found on their well-publicized intent to not only massacre Israelis and Jews around the world, but to carry out a second Holocaust.
39. # 23. da dude. i completly agree with your first remarks
gerd schulz ,   germany   (08.06.06)
but deleted the last part (i've got your permission? toda toda raba!) da dude, you have all the right in the world to defend yourself. and to retaliate. NO DOUBT ABOUT THAT! the short version: 23. To 6 YES!!!! The fact is that every war Israel has fought and will continue to fight has been a war about Israel's existence. Unlike Arab countries where they are only fighting for their armies survival and to ensure that their army isn't damaged to heavily and they don't suffer to many losses. The fact is that wars will end in the mid east when countries understand that fighting agaisnt Israel is a war that will include your existence as a state aswell. Da dude (08.06.06)
40. to the armenian guy #28
tired from haifa   (08.06.06)
i have never in my life seen such a meaningless sequence of words. are you just probing the internet for the second time? or doing your English HW online? in that case, u get F on grammar, F on humanity, F on brains, generally. oh the things that they can see from Yerevan.... pathetic.
41. Must See, WWW.IsraelIndanger.com
Dave Berg ,   New York, USA   (08.06.06)
see how a rocket falles in haifa live!
42. Strike back!
Aulis Kallio ,   Tampere, Finland   (08.06.06)
Israel should widens security zone up to Litani or over.
43. #42 Do you think they can but not doing it ? dont think so
Mike   (08.06.06)
44. Jews looking for their identity
Majd ,   Finland   (08.06.06)
To number 4, If you say that this land is for the people of Israel, I guess you do know that the people of Israel is middle eastern, therefore my friend, you are not western. And in case you are western, go live there... another ponit, please, be real, don't even fool your self by calling this a massacre... since 1982 till this moments thousands of lebanese killed by Israel, Qana 1 and Qana 2 are massacres.. this? nahhh
45. TO 7
SAUL ,   MELBOURNE   (08.06.06)
I agree that Israel has committed a big mistake by targetting christian area because they are good people & suffered a lot from terrorism but this should not make you supporting H.A. because his agenda is not serving Lebanon. Remember it calls itself islamic resistance not Lebanese resistance not even Lebanese islamic resistance.
46. UN
Human   (08.06.06)
#3 Why UN? Those soldiers were prepared to kill the lebanese. This is the pre-attack
47. To 39
Da dude   (08.06.06)
I completely accept your editing
48. It's very easy to talk from Texas, come here to Haifa
To 37   (08.06.06)
And then talk
49. we want to learn the names of vıctıms as soon as possıble
(08.06.06)
50. hizbollah supporter
HS ,   Dubai   (08.06.06)
I am an Arab and a Muslim, I'd like to clarify that I have nothing against Jews; I am just against Israel as a country because it's illegally occupying part of my country (Syria) and parts of other Arab countries. For the current war supporters and specially for Ze'ev (post # 17) who claims that Hezbollah are terrorists and that they consider killing Israeli civilians as an "achievement", I'd like to say that Hezbollah never started the war, they kidnapped the two Israeli soldiers to get back their prisoners who were kidnapped by Israel... it's their RIGHT to get them back. The Israeli government is fooling its people by claiming that is started the war to get back its two kidnapped soldiers because Israel has lost tens of soldiers in this war and civilians and this number is increasing, Israel could simply release the kidnapped Lebanese and Hezbollah would release the kidnapped Israeli soldiers... it's simple. Nasrallah is a national hero in all Islamic countries because he is defending his country from the Israeli occupation. Hezbollah had rockets since years but they never used them until Israel started the war. Hezbollah is targeting Israel just as a reaction for the Israeli aggression, I don't think your media is showing Nasrallah's speech... he said that he will stop targeting Israel with his rockets if Israel stopped its aggression on the Lebanese civilians so you can only blame your government for the dead civilians. Israel is the only terrorist here; its so-called army is killing hundreds of civilians on purpose just because they couldn’t beat Hezbollah warriors. Israel claims that Hezbollah warriors are hiding between civilians? Ok fine, where are their dead bodies? Where are their weapons? Where are their rockets?? All what we see after the Israeli massacres is dead women and babies or part from their bodies.
51. to #19
(08.06.06)
Israel, for Iran is a problem. What is their goal? to bomb it. and next? the world.
52. to 17
arabic girl ,   tunisia   (08.06.06)
"our soldiers are dying for our moral principles" are you kidding? i don t see any moral principales in killing only civilians! hezbullah is killing soldiers more than civilians but your coward IDF and IAF are killing only civilians. your IDF can t make a complete destruction not because of their moral principles but because they know that already the whole world ( except some countries who need her to do their dirty work) hate israel and will not stay silent anymore if the IDF make this kind of destruction. hezbullah is doing this war to defend his country and get lebanese prisoners out of israel's jails but why israel is killing all those civilians and doing all those massacres, for the 2 kidnapped soldiers? i don t think so. we didn t heard her talking about them since the beginning of the war what pushed their parents to ask help in other countries but not in israel ! so please dont talk about your moral principles because everybody who hear you will think you are crazy! if you want peace make your gvmt stop this war and return shebaa s firm and lebanese prisoners back then you ll have your 2 soldiers back and you will not have to be afraid about hezbullah s rokets. this is very simple but i think you are not clever enaugh to understund it. and if you want your comment to talk about facts correct the mistake and make it " our soldiers are dying for our immoral principles". and just to be honnest to the truth, there is 12 soldiers killed and 10 are seriously wounded ( your gvmt and media are never telling you the truth).
53. All 10 killed are IDF Reserve Soldiers!!
Mark   (08.06.06)
Hizbullah killed IDF soldiers in this case, not children, unlike IDF does routinely!! It's outrageous that some idiots calling it a massacre whi8le Channel Teo already reported that at least 9 of the victims are soldiers!! This was a perfect attack against military concentration. A lawful target. Some guys in this forum should educate themselves to learn the difference between lawful and unlawful targeting in warfare!! Its shame that Ynet avoided reporting the fact about this particular attack by Hizbullah!!
54. From AP news
saleem ,   Levanon   (08.06.06)
"One rocket landed near the entrance of the communal farm of Kfar Giladi on the border, killing all 10 victims. Channel Two television reported that nine reserve soldiers were among the dead, and television footage showed a soldier holding his head in grief" Stop lamenting on innocent victims preparing For war !!!
55. to $5:
Shobbar ,   Saudi   (08.06.06)
if you dare, just think of destryoing Lebanon, Hezboullah will wake you up. Then, you won't dare to even look at Lebanon Map in your Geography class
56. To confused Michael #19
Alison ,   Israel   (08.06.06)
Michael - you seem a little confused....or at the very least misinformed. When you retaliate it means you were attacked first. In this case Hizbullah attacked first and we retaliated - so perhaps in this case your comment was very apt - the world cannot expect us to sit back and watch our country be destroyed without doing something about it. Secondly Hizbullah is not a country, it is a terrorist organisation. It is supported only by a minority of Lebanese people, a fact that should be obvious to you from one very simple fact - despite the fact that we are bombing Lebanon their army has NEVER gotten involved. Doesn't this tell you anything? Perhaps it tells you that despite all his shouting to the media the Lebanese Prime Minister wouldn't be too sad to see Hizbullah destroyed - otherwise he would have sent his army in to defend them. Hizbullah do not represent Lebanon, they are Iran's puppet and because of their offensive on Israel the Lebanese people are forced to suffer.
57. To HS Dubai
Alison ,   Israel   (08.06.06)
Even you must know that what you wrote is absolute rubbish. You must know that the first rockets were fired by Hizbullah. And for 100% sure you know that Hizbullah hide behind citizens. You must know that Nasrallah does not represent Lebanese people and probably doesn't even care about them - otherwise he would tell his "brave" fighters to be real men and stop hiding in their midst. And how exactly is hiding somewhere while others do your dirty work brave? And finally I would really like to hear you specify which land we illegally hold that is not Syrian. And don't me the Shaba farms because you must know that is Syrian. You must also know that Israel already tried to give this to Lebanon but cannot because Syria have to sign a piece of paper which will recognise Lebanon as a soverign state - which they won't. So all Syrias great concern for Lebanon seems a little "unusual" given that they refuse to recognise it as a country.
58. Add 2 - no 10 - more to the price of Olmert's Folly
Jay ,   Los Angeles   (08.06.06)
The predictable stupidity of Olmert's Folly now allows me to edit my previous subjects, which is what I did above. As for a comment, if you haven't seen the light by now, you need more help than I can provide.
59. #5 "Modern time Shimshon (שִׁמְשׁוֹן)"
SAM ,   USA   (08.06.06)
I think a more realistic solution is needed here. I don’t see what is the problem implementing it, is it arrogance? For Israel to: Withdraw from Lebanon Return Sheeb3a farms to the Lebanese Provide the map for the landmines And Exchange Prisoners And for Lebanon to take control over the whole country including hizbollah, which was discussed and agreed on at a Lebanese cabinet meetings few month ago.
60. Arabs WON"T give up
Mike ,   USA   (08.06.06)
i thought Olmert said that hizbollah infrastructure was destroyed!!! can we tryst this leadership any more? admit it, no peace any more without returning the land of the palestinians and arabs. ADVICE:" life worth more than that, give the land back to its people before you are forced to leave it"
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article