News
Lebanon: Soldier rescues friend, both die of wounds
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 09.08.06, 07:04
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
40 Talkbacks for this article
1. Stop the war!
Jam ,   Montreal, Canada   (08.09.06)
I'm really tired of this war..i'm lebanese so I don't really care about israeli casualties but I'm concerned with the crazy number of innoncent civilians killed in Lebanon.. All you people saying that hezollah hide behind civilians have never given any proof of this thing; if this is what the idf says, then it does not mean it is the truth. Furthermore, the video circulating online showing rockets being launched from a residential area can be totally fake.. It's true I've never liked Israel, and I'll never will.. but I don't have any problem with an israeli country in the south as long as this country doesnt interfere in our politics and leaves us alone.. whether we like it or not, Israel is a legitimate state for the UN so we have no choice but to accept them as neighbours.. But tell me, is what you are doing in Lebanon right now going to help people accept you as neighbours! All the world watching treats you as baby killers; you are attacking lebanon without any permission from the UN or anybody; Is the capturing of 2 soldiers the reason behind this war? I don't think so, Israel's goal was clearly to turn the clock back 20 years in Lebanon; so the war is against Lebanon in general..And this is totally unjustified.. even though hezbollah captured the soldiers, u have been violating our lands since 2000, why didnt we reply with a ''self-defence'' attack.. Just give us back the prisoners, withdraw from shebaa, give us the map for the mines planted in lebanon, stop violating our lands and u wont hear of us for a long time.. It is very easy, but you guys don't want peace.. Hezbollah is considered as a terrorist group by USA, Canada and GB, which shows that the resistance is legitimate as long as there is an occupied land in lebanon.. And if the fighting continues more and more, you , the reader, might be the next person hit by a rocket.. And to finish, long live Lebanon and its resistance as long as there is one inch of occupied land ..
2. Cursed war! 675 SOLDIERS we buried in 1982. And in 2006?
Proud Grandpa ,   www.KingArik.net   (08.09.06)
This war is a DISASTER FOR ISRAEL. Lebanon soil drinks the blood of our best sons and wants more. Give me more, Olmert. And Olmert indulges it.
3. Haaretz reporting 20 Hezb killed in the firefight
RA   (08.09.06)
RIP to the slain and condolences to the families. God bless the IDF.
4. Right On #1
Peter Morris ,   New Zealand   (08.09.06)
There are four factors which don't seem to given enough exposure with regards the atrocity being committed against Lebanon. 1. A built in hatred of their Arab neighbours by Israelis and various US Jewish groups . 2. An unadmitted jealousy of any neighbouring Arab country thriving economically or appearing to be prospering. 3. A desire to use all the new technology toys to encourage further development. 4. The necessity of downgrading Hezbollah as a prerequisite for bombing Iran and Syria not necessarily for any nuclear or military threat but because off reason 2.
5. I'm really tired of this war too...
Brian Adams ,   Canada   (08.09.06)
I'm not a Lebanese so I don't really care about Lebanese casualties but I'm concerned with the crazy number of innoncent civilians killed in Iraq
6. Demolish Bint Jbail
Richard S. ,   Miami, USA   (08.09.06)
I don't understand why we have to keep sending ground troops to search Bint Jbail. We have lost dozens of young soldiers because our leadership does not wish to do what is necessary: To target every single building from the air. Take out all buildings. There will be no need to scour the place because it will cease to exist and Hezbollah guerrilas will not be able to shoot from the top of these structures into our soldiers who are being forced to search house by house for the terrorists. Why search? Just blow up all the buildings. We have enough F-16s and enough bombs to take out all the buildings. Whatever ruble is left, leave it to the D-9 bulldozers to finish. No more Bint Jbeil. No more casualties. Then to the next village.
7. What should we do?
Dima.K ,   Israel   (08.09.06)
You are living in a peaceful country which didnt know war dor long time... Imagine yourself in our situation. Imagine your naighbors killing your family for years... We act as every other country would, we had to act much before. Its not a secret that hizzbolah hides behind the citizens. IDF found weapons and terrorists inside many of citizen houses - you know, if there is a criminal who kills people and then hide in somone's house, that somone concodered as a criminal too. For example the "Dah'ya" neighborhood in Beirut... 90% of it is for hizzbolah. Look, its not we want this dmn war. We only want peace, but they didnt give us, the kidnaped our soldiers, killed more in OUR TERRITORY! THEY ENTERED ISRAEL HITED AND RUNED BACK! Then started shooting rockets on us, what the hell should we do?! You tell me, sit and watch how people die?! Dont you see hizbollah targeting civillians, we are targeting hizbollah.
8. To both #1 and #2
David ,   Karmiel   (08.09.06)
It’s very easy to stop the war. Believe me we don't like it either. Just tell Nasrallah to give back our soldiers, stop the bombing of our towns and villages and in general to stop killing Israelis. Maybe you could also ask him and the rest of the Arab world why everything they do, never mind in Israel which they hate, is with violence: Iraq, Afghanistan, Russia, East Timor, and so on. The sooner the Arab world realize that Israel is here to stay, the sooner all this will stop. Can you imagine what the Middle East, particularly Lebanon, would have been like if violence and hatred had not the watchword of Islam for the last 60 years? For this current debacle don't blame Olmert or Israel, blame that cowardly excuse of a Prime Minister Siniora who has allowed Hezbollah, Syria and Iran to rape his country. A country that was just begining to get back its old glory. You proud grandpa, although I do not see what you are proud of, don't realize that this war, like every other war involving Israel, is part of the daily struggle to keep our people safe. What do you want? Stop the war from Israel's side and let Hezbollah go on bombing us and say "naughty by don’t do that" or even turn the other cheek. May I remind you that the last time we did this we lost 6,000,000 Jews to Nazi hatred? If you can't see this then it is obvious that you are just another Lord Haw Haw.
9. #1 There will be peace when Arabs love their children...
RA   (08.09.06)
more than they hate the Jews. A paraphrased Golda Meir quote which is as applicable today as it was during her time as PM.
10. Jan in Canada
blackops ,   usa   (08.09.06)
Jan, no one likes war, but as in the past, as when the shebaa was taken, Israel was attacked first, just as they were this time. Your whining reminds me of a bully that throws the first punch and then cries because his nose is bleeding. But this is about something a lot bigger than Lebanon. Your country allowed itself to be a pawn for Iran and it is paying the price for being sheep. I notice you are not in your country trying to make things better for your countrymen. I am afraid the proverbial s**t is going to hit the fan and Lebanon is only the first step. Iran cannot be trusted to have nuclear weapons and the rest of the CIVILIZED world will not let that happen. Iran is ruled by a bunch of thugs using their religion as an excuse to try and achieve their own selfish goals. Or else they are just truly insane. War sucks no matter who it befalls upon. I am truly sorry for the innocents that perish in its wake, but rest assured, we in America will go full bore to rise to the fight to prevent a madman from attaining his manical nonsense. I am amazed that muslims fall for such nonsense. When America puts all its men and all its factories into the war machine, the middle east and its oil will no longer exist. And then they can continue to live in the 7th century and no one will care.
11. But the troops acted bravely,
Ali ,   SAUDI   (08.09.06)
What use?! two youg people killed in the operation, for what? no one knows, even Israel leaders. Stop that now, stop killing people, this is not a way to bring peace. No justice...No peace. Israel people have to understand that, dont keep your minds close 4 ever.
12. Remember the WORLD WAR II
Anna ,   USA   (08.09.06)
How can you justify the killing of all the innocent people, especially children who are living in Lebanon? If all the arabic world is against you it is because they have a reason. You, israeli people, should remember all the atrocities your parents and grandparents endured during the WORLD WAR II . What the germans did to your parents yor are doing now to your neighbours: palestinians, lebanese....You are always thinking selfishly of your richness and you do not realize that you become rich making the other people poor. You, who think of yourselves as being DAVID's descendants, don't turn yourselves into Goliath! Think of your jewish grandparents who suffered during the world war II and don't make the poor lebanese people suffer as your relatives did....
13. #7
Jamil ,   montreal   (08.09.06)
actually i moved to canada 3 years ago; I lived in Lebanon all of my life; my hometown was occupied by your army till 2000; so i know a lot about war and all the suffering that it bears.. ''We only want peace, but they didnt give us, the kidnaped our soldiers, killed more in OUR TERRITORY! THEY ENTERED ISRAEL HITED AND RUNED BACK! Then started shooting rockets on us, what the hell should we do?! You tell me, sit and watch how people die?! Dont you see hizbollah targeting civillians, we are targeting hizbollah'' There are many wrong things in this statement; its true that hezbollah entered israel to capture the soldiers, but they didnt do it bc they want to destroy israel, they did it bc they wanted to exchange prisoners.. and they had to do this bc israel does not (and never did) negociate with anyone; israel is above the law! so if the capturing was the only way to return the prisoners, u have to complain to ur government who doesnt want to release prisoners of war; secondly, ur saying they started shooting rockets.. this is also totally wrong, hezbollah started lauching rockets once the iaf started launching missiles and targetting civilians.. and plz, oh plz, dont say that you are targetting hezbollah! i dont think they were any hezbollah in a lot of christian areas in lebanon... The only reason why you guys feel are innocent is bc you are thinking as if the crisis started 4 weeks ago.. but no, israel has kidnapped a fisherman from lebanon after 2000, it still occupies shebaa farms, it detained prisoners of war, it violates our lands every single day.. so plz dont talk about self-defense when what you are doing is totally unjustified.. the first couple of days, the whole world, including myself, wasn't surprised with israel's reaction.. after all they were attacked and all this thing.. we all thought this was a kind of retaliation so nobody really objected.. but now after all the massacres commited and the total destruction of lebanon, I can see that israel has lost alot of its support worldwide, and by destroying lebanon, it has created a lot more hezbollah in the muslim world..
14. #8
Jamil ,   Montreal, Canada   (08.09.06)
Why is nasrallah supposed to give u back the prisoners of war when ur detaining lebanese prisoners? also, nasrallah said if u stop bombing lebanon and fight on the ground he'll stop launching rockets.. so the ball is in ur court.. but iaf doesnt really care about stopping from what we have seen so far.. Secondly, why everything is filled with hate, its bc muslims are being oppressed everywhere.. iraq, afghanistan, russia.. (i dont know about timor).. usa invaded iraq, so i guess its reasonable that iraqi are fighting them.. usa invaded afghanistan, so its reasonable that they are fighting them.. russia wanted to invade chechenya, so its reasonable that muslims fought back.. so, to sum it up, u can see that muslims dont like to be oppressed or occupied.. just leave them alone, they wont harm u.. Its true that hezbollah is still in lebanon, but its your fault! u gave him the excuse to stay.. alot of lebanese are against hezbollah, and if u withdrew from shebaa and fulfilled all othr conditions, there will be no need for hezbollah anymore.. but by starting this war, ppl in lebanon realized that hezbollah is necessary for leb and its survival..
15. @7
Simon ,   Lebanon   (08.09.06)
Don't we all want peace? One thing I want to make clear, we the civilians on both sides are the victims. We are the pieces of the politicians games, and they bargain with our lives in a cheap maner. Let me explain something about the weapons found in homes. When you invade someones land and destroy his life, that person becomes agressive wanting revenge no matter who is on the other side. Israel will find weapons in every home directed at its soldiers THIS IS WHAT"S CALLED AND KNOWN AS RESISTANT. HIZBOLLAH clearly stated, that when Israel will stop killing civilians, they will stop launching missles. I think it is fair. IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO ERASE HIZBOLLAH. TRUST ME!!!! ALL 4 PEACE AND HOPE SOMEDAY WE CAN VISIT EACHOTHERS COUNTRIES IN PEACE.
16. PLS. SEND MORE ELITE TROOPS
Lebanese ,   Lebanon   (08.09.06)
last ones already finished & Golani are cowards & weak
17. missing the point
omar   (08.09.06)
guys, its not that hard to read history and to see whats going on. its seems like everyone here started the clock 27 to 30 days ago, and you are basing everything on that, the war, and the reason behind it. Israel has occuipied lebanese land for the longest time. Hizbollah is the resistance, ofcourse there will be soldiers taken hostage, how else would you release the prisoners of lebanon and palestine? so please lets just stay very close the the facts at hand. Hisbollah did not launch one rocket on israel till israel bombed a civilian airfield, no matter how you put it, hizbollah reacted towards an agressor. if you wanted your hostages you would have negotiated, lets be honost you dont really care about your 2 soldiers. remember israel invaded lebanon before, we did not do anything to you, we kicked you out.. and thats all we did. now your complaining about what? tell me please i want to know. this as i see it is not a just world, you have no right to walk over people, and please dont use the holocaust as an excuse anymore, we feel terrible for your losses in WWII dont bring the hate towards your neighbors becuase they simply want to live in degnity next to the BULL dog that wonts stop his bitting.
18. #6 Richard, US
Alex ,   Israel   (08.09.06)
"why we have to keep sending ground troops" - are the US sending any troops to Lebanon? What r u talking about?
19. to 8
(08.09.06)
Don't even start me on Violence. USA/Israel/UK/Europe are the masters of violence. Have you forgotten UK Colonisation? Have you forgotten USA/UK invasion of Iraq Afghanistan. Have you forgotten Guantanamo? Have you forgotten Abu Gharib prison? Have you forgotten World War I and II? Have you forgotten Hiroshima and Nagazaki? Honestly, you are brainwashed. Poor you!
20. Lies
Muhammad Rashed ,   Dubai, UAE   (08.09.06)
“It was cleared for publication” I think this phrase in itself should be very demoralizing to the Israelis because it gives the impression (and in my personal opinion it almost confirms) that the Israeli military is sustaining very heavy losses that they do not admit.
21. #6 Richard S. Bint Jbiel is already demolished!
Arie   (08.09.06)
We saw that on Arab TVs . I dont know what the IDF is still doing there !
22. #1 AND #4
ED ,   US   (08.09.06)
Your harbor terrorists. And this is why you have a war. 1948-1978 you had peace. This changed when you let Arafat live in your territory. #4 , It is not enough to know how to count to 4. Your reasoning is poor. The arabs are killers. They kill others and they kill among themselves. It is hard to like them. As for arab countries theriving economy. You are kidding . Check it read the economist.
23. what about the settlers !!!
Hasan, not Nasrallah ,   Kuwait, but Lebanese   (08.09.06)
what about the Israeli settlers !!! they are armed up to the teeth, do you remember that Baroukh Goldstien or what ever his name was ?? who went to the Al-Aqsaa mosque and opened fire INSIDE on people while they were praying ?? remember him ?? was he a soldier in uniform ??
24. Re #0#0 re #0#######
#0#0#0# re #0 ,   Israel   (08.09.06)
I hope israel will keep her Army in Lebanon , and we will see the same senario in Vietnam and USA , and Napoleon Bonaparte in Russia , Both of armies were Strong but they were smashed by people
25. Israeli military is sustaining very heavy losses that they d
(08.09.06)
contrary to Arab & Islamic medai, Israelis never lie about the losses.
26. #7
Helen   (08.09.06)
"... Dont you see hizbollah targeting civillians, we are targeting hizbollah." Can u please tell me how r u targetting hizbollah? 1rst: half of the deaths in Lebanon (1000 killed till now) r children Are the Children Hizbollah? 2nd: people who died in the strike on casino, halat and madfoun bridges are as far from hizbollah than the moon from earth. 3rd the farmer's , 4rth the red cross, 5th yesterday u strike people mourning their son, 6th the whole family a father, pregnant mother and their child ... and so on. I can give u more and more example of what u call targetting Hizbollah. Stop being BLIND AND DUM. In all this war there is a few hizbollah killed and there is 1000 civilians.
27. Grandpa # 2, what a small mind you have
roberto ,   montevideo Uruguay   (08.09.06)
If you would be a businessman and someone comes over and tells you to invest 100 thousand dollars so that in 5 years time you could earn a million dollars, you wouldnt say "that is a bad idea because I really need this 100 thousand dollars know". Managing a country is like that, you have to be ready to invest KNOW to earn something big in the FUTURE. Of course 100 thousand dollars is a lot of money and of course some hundreds of israeli lives is a precious thing we are loosing in this war (and will still continue loosing in the next days and weeks). But the alternative is to loose MANY MORE in the future, if we dont act now. Whoever needs to be explained this simple fact either is stupid or is a collaborator to our enemies and wants to distract us from what needs to be done to protect ourselves taking not only the present but the future in consideration.
28. #26 Helen
Alex ,   Israel   (08.09.06)
"half of the deaths in Lebanon (1000 killed till now) r children" - The actual number of Lebanese casualties is around 500, of whom at least 300 are hizballa fighters. Even one dead civilian is a tragedy, but we should stick to the facts.
29. go out lebanon then no moe die
loubnani ,   roma italy   (08.09.06)
to#Richard S.Miami, USA,its enough to know how cowards you are when u sitting in usa and call your airforce to distroy lebanon village after village,its clear to know how cowerd you are, to see your solders killing cause they dont know how to fight,and you just gives commands from USA ,airstrike has never been winns a war not in tha past and not now,raise your voice to condaming this war ,to ask your leader to stop this nonsinn war and no body will die,i have never heard that a f16 can finde the solders was captured by hizbollah,negotiation is the way,the history repet it self 1976,1978,1982,1996,2000,all this wars between LEBANON and ISRAEL ended at least that IDF withdrowback and letft lebanon ,but do the dead solders also back????? to their family can u give them their sons back mr richard,why you dont comes and fight your self ?? if you taste the pain of war you would not talk like that ,you enjoy Miami and the young soldires killed here and more than 1 million israei escaped the normal life and living in shilters ,is that the solution mr RICHARD i dont guess that ,let us all bray for the peace GOD PLESS AND PROTACT INNOCENT PEOPLE ,no matter what nation they are
30. best solution
francesco ,   italy   (08.09.06)
israel and hesbollah please bye a playstation and stop this war
Next talkbacks
Back to article