News
Hizbullah shoots down helicopter in southern Lebanon
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 12.08.06, 23:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
65 Talkbacks for this article
31. ALLAHOU AKBAR
grisso (ex jews)   (08.13.06)
the story with only 4 IDF dead is FAKE?there was mauch more soldiers.......to be continued.
32. The Future - PART I
Hanna ,   Lebanon   (08.13.06)
I beleive what is happing now is new for the Israeli society . You have not seen what war can do, you have only seen glimps of what you are doing to the Lebanees people, humany, infrastrcutre, and most of all and most derest to the heart, our children. You have doased the Lebanees society in one month, what you have done and still doing the Plaestinian people since the second uprising (much more Palestinian infrastrcutre, homes, and lives have been lost by your killing machines and their MAN operators over the past six years). Though on the other hand you have lost more IDF lives and powerful offensive capability. The political echelon of Israel, and its people need to humble now after the ruthlessness expressed by you people of Israel, the media was drumming for war, no voice of reason managed to break in strongly, you poeple like war and pain, you are the offenders in every case, you are the stronger, you are the one who can impose war or peace, is not that obvious to you, people, did not you realize that already. The strong has all keys for a peacefull solution. What is happining now, and how the IDF looks and the bad show put down by The PM, the Minister of IDF, and Halotz, tell you that you do not have the same army generals used to run this country in time of war. As of now and for this day only you have lsot 16 IDF memebers and more than 100 injured, and a chpper with 4 miliray poeple with no info on their destiny. In Lebanon much more civilians are dead and few of Hizballa!. In the 21st centry Israel managed to show the civilization how ZERO respect for humany and civilians lives still alive and dandy, that barbarizm still exist and you can see the bright example of Qana (Take II) and and this whole uglu war you wajed agianst helpless people. The NEW MIDDLE EAST: The all the losses and defeat you feel deep down in your heart, the sourness you feel, the anger that make you send your army in a war they did not choose (chosen by you Army without asking your opinion in the only democracy). Even Bush took the decision to go to an illigal war, but you guys are just like cowbody with the indians YEEEEEHAAA. This mind set is not acceptable in the M.E. anymore, you people must question your ethecal base, do not start comparing yourselves now to the "BAD PEOPLE AND GOVs of the rest of the ME" becuase if you do, then we know you have really lost it, By comparing yourselves to the worst performing GOVs in the History of Humanity (UN studies available), you are bound to be doomed like the rest of the M.E. Let me tell you how Arabs feels, we feel storng, we feel deep in our heart that we won by breaking the fear factor, this is, accodrding to the Yakee civilization, the first step for humany to be in the path of success, we feeeeeel gooooood. tanatanata I feel gooog .. so gooood ta tta tttata tenaaa. Do you understand now that this is only the begining, the Booogy Msn is not a Boogy Man after all. Accept what the Bierut Summet in 2002 (before Sharon orders his war against the palestinians) managed to give, this is the minimum common denominator that could be achived for now and may be for the next 50 years if you are willing to go for it. Resolve this issue now before there are 100 Nasrallahs, I wourld rather a different peacefull solution.
33. The Future - PART II
Hanna ,   Lebanon   (08.13.06)
Accept the 1967 and do not get technical on me and say " from 'LANDS' and not 'THE LAND' that was not intended ponto. Humbel and stop the expansionest mentality, and accept what you got. You, and as of the short term, have the keys for a lasting peacefull solution by accept what eveybody elase accepts. Do not be hard headed and land grabers, distory the walls as part of that solution, even in the long term, but start building peace, before our area becomes the spark of the THIRD WAR WORLD, let us all stop now. You can stop now and declare the peace of the brave, and you will be forgiven, if not for you, for your, children and youth, the beatifull clear little minds, who should have no momory anymore of the smell of powder, cluster bombs, and death. Beleive in peace adn you will achieve it, your deterance capabilities and the search of your Gov for illusions to reverse this really in only killing more of you. Imagine those dead and permanently disabled, if they are still alive among us, how much happiness there would have been, weddeing, new borns, new families, your irrogant Gov decisionsssss, have deprived these people the right of life.
34. ceasefire + 2 soldiers ?
chad ,   usa   (08.13.06)
israel will use the release of 2 soldiers to prolong this conflict. truly, all they had to do was trade soldiers under the table. how the hell else could lebanon/hesbollah get one of their prisoners back without taking a couple israelis as prisoners? both sides are wrong but israel needs to take the high ground and do a swap anyway. and yes, you can "negotiate with terrorists." terrorism is bred by a sense of injustice and an unheard voice.
35. Why is the media acting like its a big deal?
RA   (08.13.06)
This is a goddamn war, and in 30 days the only helicopter they managed to get. The US lost 2 helicopters in a 1 day mission in Somalia. The media needs to stop sensationalizing. The IDF is winning and will win like it always does, casualties are a part of any war.
36. #16 You spelled "warned" wrong, dumbass
RA   (08.13.06)
If S Lebanon is a graveyard for anyone its Hezbollah. 600 killed at least, on top of the rest of Lebanese "civilians." How long will you lie to yourselves and tell yourself you are winning when you have taken immense casualties. I hope you keep "winning" like this more often.
37. #13 - Good. Leave. Israel doesnt need your kind
(08.13.06)
38. Send more IDF troops into South Lebanon
Arab ,   in the USA   (08.13.06)
Hezbollah is enjoying the target practice, and would appreciate more sent in.
39. The shocking truth
Venom ,   Lebanon   (08.13.06)
Israeli Soldiers killed: 343 Israeli soldiers injured: 617 Mirkava Destroyed: 167 Other vehicles destroyed: 96 Other casualties: US marines, they reported to their families that they are killed in iraq... This report is published from the United States.....Time will tell the truth...
40. Proud Grandpa is our Tokyo Rose
Jonah ,   Philadelphia, PA   (08.13.06)
"Proud Grandpa" is on this site every single day, always writing negative and defeatist comments. Either he is a 1960's peacenik still fighting against the Vietnam War with a heartfelt, but naive view of this conflict, or is a disguise for a pro-Arab anti-Israel propagandist. In any case, his comments do no service to the soldiers for whom he claims to have such concern. We support our "boys" and wish them the best in their vital work for the defense of Israel and the Jewish people against these forces of pure evil, hatred and terrorism. May our people stand united in these difficult times.
41. Hizbollah are liars
Olmert,olmert,olmert ,   Lebanon   (08.13.06)
Well, Hezbollah just claimed that they would not disarm and wouldn't leave their posts and won't release the Israeli pows unless their pows are released. And the lebanese gov keep ballshiting around saying that they agree to 1701.It's all lies, i say israel should bomb the lebanese goverment and saniora cause he is a damn liar
42. #26 To Vit- No rights for Israel :)
Sam   (08.13.06)
1. Lebanon WILL get back the prisioners. (ISRAEL lost, remember) 2. Israel will not protect its people (Rockets still falling, remember) 3. Israel will retreat from lebanon just like it did in 2000 (remember) 4. IDF will never come back again (they lost remeber) Sorry vit, no rights for losers :)
43. proud grandpa is ehud olmert
(08.13.06)
44. To Voova, #28
Jonah ,   Philadelphia, PA   (08.13.06)
Voova, you've confused the parties. Hezbollah has been planning this fight for six years and crossed the international border and killed and kidnapped Israeli soliders to provoke this war, with no consideration for the Lebanese people or new democracy - in fact, to cause the fall of that democracy and garnish world sympathy for the deaths of their human shileds. Israel ignored several severe provocations over the last six years, including rocket attacks, cross border raids, ki;;ing of soldiers, attempts at kidnapping other soldiers, etc. Enough is enough. Hezbollah is the rapist of Lebanon and you, as a Lebanese, betray your own country and people by supporting these agents of Iran and Syria who have made your nation a battlefield. What effort did Lebanon take to prevent this terrorist group from making Lebanon into Talibanist Afganistan? Blame your own government, not Israel.
45. Eye for Eye
Hassan   (08.13.06)
This is for air-bombarding Tyre
46. to vit # 26
voova ,   lebanon   (08.13.06)
As I read your absurd " Chart of Repugnant Rights" I can see how much anger, disappointment, animosity, coward ness, pure hate, racism, radicalism, terrorism etc.. a primate like you can express. Sick people like you should be locked in cages. P.S. I would love to send you bananas
47. Russian S300 Downed Chopper
Pavel ,   Moscow, Russia   (08.13.06)
Moscow is now supplying the S300 in addition to the RPG29 and Kornet missiles, beware Israel as Hezbullah has the covert backing of a superpower and it's victory gets more complete with every day - down with self righteous USA & Israeli arrogance!
48. Perplexed about IDF control of area
Ricot ,   Cambridge   (08.13.06)
A senior Air Force officer referred to the incident: "The helicopter was hit by a missile fired at it, hit the ground and caught fire. Helicopters are fired at a lot in all regions. The operations we are doing are dangerous, but there are also successes." "The place where the incident occurred is under our control. But in spite of the incident, we are continuing with our operations as usual, providing forces and rescuing the injured," he said. So, how are Hizballah able to down helicopters, destroy tanks if the IDF 'controls' these areas? A controling factor must be factored into this equation.
49. Pavel #47
X   (08.13.06)
It's true that the IDF has taken casualties as a result of coveert Russian interference. However, it must come as a rude shock to the Russians that tneir state of the art weapon sysytems that have been supplied to the Islamonazis have not produced the massive casualties they desired. Instead, the Israelis have killed 10 times the number if terrorist criminals than deaths suffered by the IDF. Iguess that Russian R& D could stand some improvement
50. Olmert ur soo sweet
Ibrahim ,   Kuwait   (08.13.06)
we love u olmert , u gave us the chance to see how weak is IDF, i just hope that one day all the arabs become hizbulla then we will treat u the same why u treat the poor palastinians ..its very soon dont worry ,palatine was taken from us many times and each time we were able to bring it back , specialy now we saw how weak is the IDF ,, good boy ,Olmert
51. #47 To Pavel
Jonathan ,   Palo Alto   (08.13.06)
Let me give you an advise: shove your S300 up your russky zad. Your ignorance know no limits. You also seams to be enjoying news of every Jewish soldier death. Just remember: the same people that threaten Israel, will take over Moscow sooner than you think. Where are you going to run?
52. #47
Yaha   (08.13.06)
News for you, the Soviets (aka commies) lost the cold war...they're yesterday's news no matter how great you still believe they are.
53. Arab #38 and all the others (and their pals)
BS meter ,   Canada   (08.13.06)
Eleven is a tragedy for the families involved and we grieve with them. But it is a small number from the thousands now inside Lebanon and killing scores of Hezbollah and their supporters. We rejoice in each of your deaths, just as you rejoice in each of your own people's deaths. You don't know how to grieve, only how to thirst after blood. Anybody's blood. So I rejoice with you in all those being "martyred." Let's hope they haven't run out of Muslim virgins in hell.
54. catastrophy
wff ,   l.a., ca   (08.13.06)
out of the ashes, a phoenix has risen. because of oomert's continued stupidity HA can now claim another victory having killed 18 israeli soldiers and wounded anothe 84. and they managed to bring down an israeli military helicopter which should add to their bragging rights. what a stupid srategy employed by israel in this war. they killed innocent civilians, destroyed a country who's majority of people didn't want this war and emboldened a HA that will now define the whole arab street. this is not a defeat. this is a nightmarish catastrophe.
55. shrink wrap
dev ,   nyc   (08.13.06)
maybe Olmert can disengage from Kiryat Shmona
56. bye bye hector lebanon would love you there
Mike ,   Israel   (08.13.06)
57. #5 Dont Write Off The IAF Just Yet.
Ertok   (08.13.06)
I agree with some of your comments . But dont forget that as strange as it many seem - the IDF has learned a significant amount too and will be applying the lessons - you will see. as far as the IAF being useless - well yes at low level , helicopters have some worries - but jets will just fly higher and will use multiple war head ordnace to deliver the goods. Additionally, IDF has learned HEAPS about the Hez too - as well as their own shortcomings. We're going to see a much better IDF in future.
58. #13 Good...
Pat ,   USA   (08.13.06)
I'm glad you are leaving...no need to come back!
59. #47 Superpower?
Pat ,   USA   (08.13.06)
The American state of California already has twice as much power and influence as Russia. Russia is becoming more of a rag head oil producing country than they are anything else. If it wasn't for oil, Russia would be even more backward than they already are. I wish the US would flex some economic might regarding Russia! I have no say in the matter, but it would be rather easy for the US to create Putin the Pauper...
60. #2..Why Israel Suffers
Craig ,   USA   (08.13.06)
I agree totally, that had Israel attacked in force, aggressively, then things would have gone much better and Hezbullah would have been on the ropes, reeling and stunned. This is what we all expected, instead we see a new Israel which appears weak and reticent....how exceptionally sad. I question where you place the blame. From what I read, the Israeli military had a plan for a vigorous attack and it was their weak appeasing liberal Prime Minister (who has never been a soldier...I believe) who is responsible for this debacle. My impression is that President Bush wanted the Israelis to kick ass (and I am no fan of Bush or Condi Rice), but Olmert totally over-road the military and squandering the element of surprise, basically wasted 4-weeks. I DO think Bush and Condi were in favor of the withdrawl from GAZA (another obvious mistake). But don't blame the Americans because the Israelis elected an appeasing, land for peace, liberal instead of Netanyahu..(a man who knows how to deal with terrorists). This fiasco is an absolute disaster for Israel and it will propel Nasrallah to even greater levels of popularity and power. The window of opportunity has closed, Israel has unfortunately been dealt a stunning political and public relations defeat...if not military. All because of a bunch of pathetic politicians who want to wage a "proportional" war...God, do they ever learn? The only good which can come out of this is if the Israeli people rise up in fury and throw Olmert and his ilk out of office...and stop trying to trade land for peace, it doesn't work!! The Arabs want to KILL the Jews - Period!! They don't want peace and they only understand force. Wake up Israel!! You have the power, you must find the will to use it. Make no mistake, when your enemies finally have the power...and it won't be long, they will use it without hesitation. May God bless and rescue the Jews and all Israel.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article