Jewish Scene
Entertaining gay Israeli troops
Leslie Bunder
Published: 19.08.06, 12:51
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
109 Talkbacks for this article
61. His more of a man than Hollywood Jews
David ,   Norway   (08.20.06)
You may like this or not, but I like the idea that even a Gay porn star is proud of being Jewish, and shows this by going to Israel. That is much more than the average Jewish Hollywood celebrity has the guts to do!
62. message to censor; gay IDF
sk ,   USA   (08.20.06)
To the Arabs who find gay Israeli troops a joke, I suppose you find Ancient Sparta's armies a joke too? (Assuming you know what Sparta was.) Do you snicker at Alexander the Great? Obviously, sexual orientation doesn't mean anything in terms of fighting ability. However, being Arab does, as the Arabs haven't won a war against a Western army since the Crusades. How embarrassing to be so warlike and yet so incompetent at war.
63. why does entertainmenet for gays have to be pornography?....
cookie ,   israel   (08.20.06)
but the rest of the straight world gets entertained by a music concert or something else and keeps the adult entertainment out of the news. you don't hear of any female porn star coming to entertain the straight soldiers.
64. Islam and homosexuality
Aeron ,   USA   (08.20.06)
As for those of you of the Muslim faith attacking the Jewish people for their progressiveness and tolerance, I would turn you to your own Q'ran - 52:24 "Round about them will serve, to them, boys (handsome) as pearls well-guarded." Homosexuality was and is still widely practiced in Islamic countries - its just been targeted more recently. Everyone deserves peace, we should all be willing to move toward it with compassion.
65. Barf! :(
(08.20.06)
66. #63 is right. All sexual immorality is wrong
Sarah   (08.20.06)
67. Brod's perversion (11)
sk ,   USA   (08.20.06)
"Perversions or any sinful lifestyle should not be allowed to contaminate the IDF or Israel." - Brod the Goy Really, Brod, you have already made a fundamental error regarding your belief in the Son & the Pigeon. Now you want to compound this error by lecturing Jews on what should or should not be "allowed" in the IDF and Israel? Incidentally, there seems to be consensus that the Second Temple fell because of hatred among Jews. Are you trying to increase it?
68. Such a country! Such a generation! Such a future!
earth ,   observer   (08.20.06)
69. #63
Sharon ,   Haifa, Israel   (08.20.06)
Men are generally the most sexual of the two genders, so put two together and the result is exponential. Further, they are equals, and so there is a relatively minimal threat of objectification (as would be the case for a female entertainer with hetero male troops). I share your disappointment, but I hope this helps.
70. #65 Very Eloquently Put!
Mark ,   USA   (08.21.06)
71. #69
TG ,   Boston USA   (08.21.06)
"Men are generally the most sexual of the two genders"....huh??..." so put two together and the result is exponential " What result? Sex? Exponential sex? Wow, sounds fun yet exhausting. I do agree with one point, the brouhaha this topic has spawned is disappointing
72. reply to cookie (63, 69) regarding porn as entertainment
sk ,   USA   (08.20.06)
cookie, I have a different theory than Sharon's, though the two are complementary. If you're gay, you have relatively little opportunity for gay-oriented entertainment. In the straight world, it's all around you, as nearly everthing is geared toward straight sexuality. Therefore, gay-oriented entertainment tends to be concentrated into short time span. Porn fits the bill. In addition, it so intrinsically outrageous (as all porn is, but even more so) that it serves political purposes as well. Finally, sex is profitable, even when directed at minorities. How's that?
73. Great! Show that Israel is strong!
Jeff ,   New York, NY   (08.21.06)
I'm a straight guy, but this is just great. Having this guy in Israel will show everyone that Israel is everything that Hezbollah is not: strong, open, proud and tolerant. Predictably, I haven't seen any of your films, but good luck, Mr. Lucas !
74. Enlist him in Pretty Sissy Division
(08.21.06)
75. gay israel
george ,   riyadh, saudi arabia   (08.21.06)
world gay pride in jeruslem and now this. What a nasty thing to be JEWISH AND GAY! I dont envy any of you losers.
76. Israel must Welcome All People.
Mark ,   USA   (08.21.06)
Ha-Shem loves All and so must we. We must welcome him to Israel and say: Thank you. Shalom Lucas! Shalom to all who come and visit Israel!! Todah rabah! Todah rabah!
77. #30, Careful who you call freeks!
Mark ,   USA   (08.21.06)
Say something nice or nothing at all!
78. Stay home...Israel doesn't need garbage!
Miriam ,   Israel   (08.21.06)
79. GAY ARAFAT
melech ,   AMHERST USA   (08.21.06)
Actually,Arafat started off straight.He just found it convenient to mess around with his nice young bodyguards.Seriously...After taking a close look at the lovely SUAH(Sooooeeeee!) ....Wow..and to think that there are 70 more of those beauties waiting in your paradise.
80. Re: No. 19 Visit Also Lebanon
Egyptian Tiger ,   Egypt   (08.21.06)
One month away from women is not a long period for true worriers with strong believe in what they are fighting for and are willing to give their lifes for. Throughout the period from 1967 to 1973, we were there on the sides of the canal, with only one goal to defeat and return back our land. Having sexual relationship with women was the last issue to ever to think about, because our prime goal was believed by us to be the most that requires sacrifices among which was giving up women. And beleive me, any one who goes for war, will not be thinking at all in sex. His prime goal will be to preserve his life to fight more and more.
81. What is "she" going to perform?
James ,   Toledo Oho USA   (08.21.06)
How about lap dances for those palastinian prisoners you have in jail. Release the kidnapped solders NOW or we turn the qweer loose on your terrorist friends!
82. Great, Please stop on Lebanon
Khalil ,   Boston, MA   (08.21.06)
Ok, this is the second story I read from this website. Some remarks are againts Jews, while others are against Arabs. Most Arabs and Jews agree on one thing, prosecution of Gays and that Madonna is evil. Could they agree on a few more important issues like peace? Is there a pattern of hate that might explain the middle east's collective bad karma? I say make love not war. Lucas would be wlecomed by lebanon's gay soldiers too, in addition by the UN troops.
83. Shocked at the level of Homophobia and Ignorance
Khalil/Kevin ,   Lebanese in Boston   (08.21.06)
Some nasty hateful comments!Gaza, Jimmy, Brod and George! Sinful lifestyle should not contaminate the IDF!!!! You guys have a lot in common! Check out helem, a gay NGO in Lebanon. Apparently, it served as the center for refugee help during the July war. FYI gay people have participated in wars throughout history. Jimmy that also includes greeks. Gay israelis sacrificied their lives and gay lebanese helped their countrymen. There is nothing wrong with sleeping with someone from the same sex. Killing or hating in the name of religion is most sinful.
84. Gays ???
Mohamed ,   Egypt   (08.21.06)
Israel and USA army are full of gays hahahahaha...that's why they are afraid for land wars..they keep their asses for bed heheheheeh
85. thank goodness we aren't in arabia
bobba fett ,   eisham, israel   (08.21.06)
To all you haters and ignorami, The truth is ... Israel is a vibrant, strong, evolving parliamentary democracy, and culturally speaking, we do not prejudicially discriminate (by law) against Gays or Lesbians, nor should we. I am not gay, and I applaud the guy for visiting Israel and doing whatever he's doing. He is travelling to Israel at a time when most Jews in the U.S. aren't willing to visit. He is standing up for Israel, against the terrible brutality of Hizbullah, which is even more dangerous than simply a terrorist army. From what is reported, Mr. Lucas is not espousing any violence or hatred. So why should his actions, even if they are merely good PR and opportunism for his business, be subject to scathing and ignorant commentary from hateful people? Even if his views are totally different than mine, it is his right to do what he plans to do, and by granting him that right and respecting it, we strengthen the country. To all you critics of Mr. Lucas: If you don't appreciate the strength of peaceful diversity in Israel, then maybe you would prefer to live under the likes of Hizbullah, which would kill you just for being Israeli or American, or just for not believing in their exact perversion of Allah.
86. Arab men have say sex too
Khalil ,   Boston   (08.21.06)
Mohamed; we both know that Arab men have man on man action more often than Americans and Israelis put together. Except they do not call it gay sex! I doubt that is why they are "afraid of land wars".
87. #84 Go back to the Hammam, Mohamed...
Harissa ,   Argentina   (08.21.06)
88. #84 Oh Mohamed, thank you for showing us
Rick ,   Ocala FL USA   (08.21.06)
Mohamed, thank you so much for showing us your sophisticated wit and charm -- or was that YOUR ass? Oh well, I'm sure you aren't armed for a battle of wits, so we'll ignore you. Be quiet please, adults are talking.
89. #78 Please do not call him garbage
Mark ,   USA   (08.21.06)
That is not nice. Everyone deserves respect. Everyone.
90. desecration of holy land
Miller ,   Jeruselam   (08.21.06)
This gay guy should not be allowed to touch foot on the holy land of Israel. Sins and diseases he spreads are not needed by the heroic IDF...Go home where you belong and it is definitely not Israel!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article