News
Negotiator: Fox newsmen's conversion to Islam helped win freedom
Associated Press
Published: 29.08.06, 09:33
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
20 Talkbacks for this article
1. Truly Brave
Braveheart   (08.29.06)
...are you kidding me, these are reporters, they have absolutly no sense of dignity, I guess they don't have a beleif system either
2. This scumbag White could have told the IDF where they were.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Santa Monica, CA USA   (08.29.06)
3. Associated Press
NYC Girl   (08.29.06)
Holy shit. The Associated Press actually used the word "terrorists" to described the Palestinian kidnappers. It's probably safe to assume that's because fellow journalists were the victims, since slaughtering innocent Israelis only seems to rate the label "militants."
4. way to make islam look peaceful
(08.29.06)
what these people are doing to the image of their religion is beyond me... i remember learning about islam in our high-school after 9/11..yes, they had to teach us so we would be aware that it was a religion of peace not of terrorism.. i think i might need a refresher course because i'm a bit confused again..
5. Circumcision
Fereydoon Larijani ,   Larijan Mazandaran   (08.29.06)
Conversion to Islam means that both christian men were cicumsized against their will. The media should report on this touchy subject.
6. Maybe our 'El'
(08.29.06)
helped with the conversion, or Mel?
7. pathetic
ari ,   israel   (08.29.06)
no backbone losers. they had the chance to honor God and spit back in the face of evil. Instead they cupped their balls and bent over. there are times when you must give up your life for the sake of God....this was one of them. Shame on theses reporters. They are no better than the filth that kidnapped them.
8. Freedom
Maggie ,   Israel   (08.29.06)
Canon White a christian in faith,suggesting the conversion to Isam ought to be ashamed and defrocked; not take the glory of his words WAKE UP ALL, to the dangers of these Islamic extremists, or one day we all might have a gun held against our heads to try to make people convert to Islam. All of us in democratic countries must treasure our freedom and speak out about terrorism in all its forms incuding the abduction of people . Where are the Israeli soliders taken from their own land ,not long ago? Well ,they are not jornalists are they !!!!!!!!
9. BBC freed them
(08.29.06)
10. Good move but what are the consequences?
David ,   Karmiel   (08.29.06)
Are Mr. Wiig and Mr Centanni going to abide by their "conversion" to Islam? If they don't then they have made total fools of their captors. This could jeopardize any hostage release in the future at the Islaminization thing would be a farce. Also, these two gentlemen stated that they want to continue the story of the "warm hearted" and wonderful Palestinian people. Warm hearted and wonderful people do not kidnap journalists, do not commit bus bomb atrocities, do not kill people as part of their "Jihad" and don’t elect terrorist organizations into government. I only hope and pray that these “warm hearted” and wonderful people will release our Gilad and their “warm hearted” colleagues in Lebanon will do the same for Eldad and Udi!
11. Forced Conversion
Daniel Jackson ,   Boulder CO USA   (08.29.06)
So if I understand the logic here, converting to the religion of ones captives is enough to trigger release, then perhaps this will revive the practice in the West. Maybe the prisoners in Cuba should convert to Christianity for parole. Maybe, all the Muslim prisoners in the US (the ones the newsmen's captors wanted to free) should be forced to convert to Christianity to gain their release. The sheer lunacy of the logic of the conversion requirement is staggering--the kidnappers demand the release of US Muslim prisoners (guilty of some secular crime) are FORCED to release their own Muslim captives. "You can't hold these newsmen because they are Muslims." These guys are too stupid to be stupid.
12. Centanni and Wiig are terrorist supporters.
Daisy ,   USA   (08.29.06)
And they should be treated as such in Israel.
13. Survive
Eric ,   London, UK   (08.29.06)
Listen to all the hard guys out there. You do what you must to survive. After all, the Koran states that no one should be forced to convert to Islam. But we all know that it is a religion of peace. What a friggin' joke! The Palestinians only did themsleves harm with this action.
14. It is indeed a bizare world
Ivri   (08.29.06)
These so called jornalists,after shedding their religion,their herritage,dont waste a minute as soon as they are in the safe haven of Israel,They start giving us the same old line about how wonderfull these palestinian kidnappers and murderers are. World Media+ Hammas+ Hizballa=A united front against the world as we know it.
15. Gun point conversion
Johnson ,   USA   (08.29.06)
I doubt if these two are going to be praying to Mecca five times a day. However, I would have liked to have seen some backbone from these two once they were safe. Then again they should have waited a few days or weeks before giving any statment to let their programing wear off a bit.
16. #7 don't judge till you have walked
Egyptian Jew. ,   Israel   (08.29.06)
To #7 do not judge till you have walked a mile in their shoes. I think that they made the wise decision. You have no idea what it is like being a prisoner in a moslem country under moslem rule. You are in control of nothing, not even of the smalest part of your body. May you, or any Israeli ever have to suffer that fate. Amen.
17. BeUTIFUL, LOVING, KIND-HEARTED pALESTINIANS
Edwin ,   NYC USA   (08.29.06)
18. Conversion
Angel ,   Orlando USA   (08.29.06)
I am happy the men are released but I hope they still have Christ in their heart.
19. Compare to the murdered Italian in Iraq
rick ,   ny, USA   (08.30.06)
I remember the Zar-coward "insurgents" took an Italian hostage in Iraq some two or three years ago. He was shot dead but not before he spit in the face of his abductors. He was probably the bravest guy I have read about being abducted by terrorists. I can't blame these Fox guys as survival is survival but this "kind, gentle palestinian people " nonsense is laying it on rather thick. They are terrorist scum and nothing more.
20. circumcision
Bettie Brando ,   Retroland, USA   (09.01.06)
This is a reply to the original comment made: If they had been circumcised by their captors, a) they probably would have a serious staff infection & would be ill in hospital, b) wouldn't have been able to speak, let alone make those fugazi conversions to Islam, c) would've been in too much pain to have walked anywhere or urinated. It's as ridiculous as the conversion itself.
Back to article