News
Ahmadinejad: Why so sensitive about Israel?
Ynet
Published: 21.09.06, 11:16
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
62 Talkbacks for this article
1. COZ usa is the pupy of israel .
Semon ,   Niece FR   (09.21.06)
2. it all makes sense...
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (09.21.06)
just take your brain out of your head, twist it into a pretzel, then throw it away because you won't be needing it. then iran boy makes sense.
3. You have the Right to have NUKES and you wil have them.
God bless Iran   (09.21.06)
4. Iran
YMS ,   Kuala Lumpur   (09.21.06)
The questions that Ahmadinejad addressed mostly seem to be very valid and should be answered properly. But I think most of the people here would prefer to attack his personality and throw names rather than having a good debate.
5. #1 what is a COZ and a PUPY?
Saul ,   Barcelona   (09.21.06)
Is Europe the pupy of Arabs? Or is it the poopy of Arabs? Or maybe the popie?
6. MYOB ahmed
John ,   NZ   (09.21.06)
Your own country economy is in a mess. Your ppl are jobless. Why do you have to worry whether Israel should exist or Holocaust ever existed. You are nothing but a pain in the ass... and your lap dog Chavez is barking all over the UN assembly.
7. "Palestinian" Grand Mufti Helped Plan Final Solution
Rob ,   UK   (09.21.06)
"The Mufti was one of the initiators of the systematic extermination of European Jewry and had been a collaborator and adviser of Eichmann and Himmler in the execution of this plan... He was one of Eichmann’s best friends and had constantly incited him to accelerate the extermination measures. I heard him say, accompanied by Eichmann, he had visited incognito the gas chambers of Auschwitz." - Adolf Eichmann's deputy Dieter Wisliceny, Testimony at Nuremburg He was the leader of the "Palestinians," ergo they are partly responsible for the Holocaust and should be paying reparations as the Germans are still doing.
8. Not being a fan of Bush and conservative Republicans...
Saul ,   Barcelona   (09.21.06)
...I have to say that his UN speech sounded like the epitomy of reason and moderation, when compared to what followed from the mouths of Ahmadinejad and Chavez.
9. Adolf A. failed to mention that close to a million Jews were
gerd schulz ,   germany   (09.21.06)
Adolf Ahmadinejad failed to mention that close to a million Jews were made refugees when they were forced to leave their homes and communities behind in the Arab and Muslim world since Israel's establishment.
10. not the issue of talking tough its the nerve to fight ...
ken ,   california   (09.21.06)
11. Finally what?
seema ,   Canada   (09.21.06)
All said and done, these muslims - want to prove their holy book correct, and want to destroy Israel. Their holy book says Sun revolves run Earth. How can they correct that.
12. To 4
Shai ,   Israel   (09.21.06)
There is a big difference between "asking questions", about which people debate, and "saying questions". Nobody seriously believes that people like you and Ahmednajad are open-minded enough to be convinced fo anything - if you were, you'd not be bringing the matter up as though there is serious dispute about which way history looks at assertions like his.
13. To Semon (post 1)
David ,   London   (09.21.06)
If the US is the puppy of Israel, France is the puppy of Iraq / Iran. Chirac, your anti-semetic / anti-Israeli leader is a good friend of the insane Ahmadinejad who threatens world peace. Chirac built and supplied the nuclear reactor to Iraq in 1980/1 (but was destroyed by the Israelis - what a shame!!). So you need to look a bit closer to home before making comments about the US's close ties with israel.
14. anti zionists like to pretend sephardic jewry didnt exist
eric shoenberg ,   NJ USA   (09.21.06)
an incovenient fact, when your trying to argue israelis are european colonialists
15. And this Iranian Jerk Isn't Biased Against Israel?
stude ham ,   outremont, canada   (09.21.06)
16. # 4, YMS, Kuala Lumpur
Shlomzion ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (09.21.06)
The fact that those questions have been asked, answered and the historic evidence recorded but neither you nor Iran's president do not know the information says somthing about you two. But, perhaps, just perhaps, the motive here is different; one of trying to negate the right of a people, of the Jewish people, to live in its own historic homeland. Have you ever thought about it?
17.  "Mahmoud" is gematria 95, the same as "Haman"!
RAJB ,   UK   (09.21.06)
Ahmadinejad spoke at the UN last night. He was focussed, cogent, zealous, animated. He spoke of "righteousness", "equality", "honesty", "virtue", "service of God", Adam, Noah, Moses, Isaiah (+ Jesus & Mohammed!), of the "God- given rights" of the Palestinans, and of the coming righteous world ruler, the "12th Imam" -the Muslim Messiah! In comparison the Israeli Tzippi Livni spoke poorly, unconvincingly, in a typically Israeli semi-phased and semi-zombified death drone, did not mention the Tenach or Hashem, and looked slovenly, unkempt, even dirty - a real slattern, like a refugee from "Desperate Housewives"! "This People I created for Me that they may relate My praise" (Yeshaya 43). The Jew is meant to be the bearer to mankind of the existence of Hashem and of our G-d given write to Eretz Yisrael, and of the future Jewish Moshiach world ruler, not the Mohammedans. "Whenever the gentiles act more piously than the Jews, a Heavenly kitrug (Accusation) is aroused against them" (Sefer Yaaros u'Devash). The Talmud relates of other wicked men like Balaam, Balak, Nebuchadnezzar, Eglon, Haman, Herod, Vespasian etc who did just one virtuous act that was sufficient for them to be granted destructive power over the Jews. Zi gleiben in sheker mit'n emes - mir gleiben in emes mit'n sheker!" (Lubavitcher Rebbe) - "The goyim believe in lies but with a true belief - we believe in the truth but with a fake belief!". With an atom bomb, let's pray that Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has not acquired some similar "zechus" from his "Kiddush-Allah" speech! (PS Ominously "Mahmoud" is gematria 95, the same as "Haman"!)
18. Rebutting YMS, Kuala Lumpur
Judahmaccabbi   (09.21.06)
I have rebutted Ahmedinajad here judahmaccabbi.blogspot.com
19. Wars...
Abdul ,   Egypt   (09.21.06)
Ever since the establishment of so-called Israel...how many wars has it been in? and why? Ever thought of hese questions? The existence of Israel is the prime cause of instability in the region, and nobody can deny that. your arguements that the Arabs have 22 countries, so why not Israel have just one small country is a disgrace. We didn't make a "muslim" country did we? We have all sorts of people and religions in the Arab countries..Most of the jews in the world are not, and are not intending, to be in Israel. So what's the point of creating the country? coz u claim God gave it to you? wow.. now THAT is very credible..is it
20. RE: No. 1 US = pupy (sic) of Israel
SR ,   NYC   (09.21.06)
If a major western power of 290 million people can be a puppy of small country of 6 million people, then black is is white, and white is black, and Semon is not anti-Jew, just anti-Zionist, and Jews drink Christian blood during Passover. Let me see whose "puppy" France has been in the 20th century: In the 1940s, Hitler's; In the 1950s & 1960s, Stalin's and Khrushchev's; In the 1970s, Brezhnev's; In the 1980s through now, the Arabs' And now, Chirac is trying to position himself, in a doggy-style position before the neanderthal Ahmadinejad and Persian ayatollahs. Can you think of any period after WW I when France was NOT somebody's whore or a "puppy"?
21. Palestinian Muslim leader instigated the Holocaust
Adam ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (09.21.06)
Hitler was ready to expel the Jews. Husseini said no. Send them to Poland and kill them.
22. WE CAME HOME - WE ARE NOT "OCCUPIERS" - WE ARE HOME
andrew ,   Miami, FL USA   (09.21.06)
23. impressed
megan ,   Israel   (09.21.06)
very impressed by Israeli ambassador to the UN, Avi Gellerman...he didn't hang around to hear that insane Hamans (ahmed......)nonsense. Basically gave him the finger up. He didn't miss anything...the same load of dribble and drivel that the nutcase has been spouting for a while. Did anyone notice ppl dozing off in the UN assembly? lol
24. Adam # 21
Nanker Phelge ,   NY, USA   (09.21.06)
Stop drinking that contaminated Jerusalem water. It's beginning to rot your brain.
25. and the world never learns!
oded   (09.21.06)
you can't appease a war mongor, you can't deal with a bona-fide sociopath, you can't reason with a homocidal, jew- hater, west- basher, lunatic. it is a great pportunity to hold this scumm accountable for crimes against the west , and send this garbage to gunatanamo , with the rest of the islamo-facsits!
26. #19...who started these wars?
DR ,   Florida, USA   (09.21.06)
Ever ask yourself that simple question? The Arabs and Muslims started every single war you speak of. Ever since the creation of israel, the only goal of these Arab states is to destroy it. All you know is violence and destruction, but then you ask why? Why does Israel defend itself with such strength? Why do our people die when Israel hunts down terrorists? Why? Because your whole culture is weak minded, brainwashed and hell bent on destroying Israel, that's why. Any more questions?
27. 30-40 thousand protested at UN
Johnson ,   USA   (09.21.06)
But, the "major media" did not report it. Go figure. We all know who's side they are on.
28. Ask the Citizens of the U.S.
Steve G ,   Kew Gardens,NYC   (09.21.06)
The people of the United States overwhelmingly back Israel. That accounts for what is puzzling the Putz of Persia. He and his mullah bosses never listen to anyone. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - The citizens of the U.S. have consistently voted and voiced their support of Israel. 1) Israel is a Western democracy. 2) Israel stands for the dignity of human beings and tolerance. 3) Israel is a 21st century country, not a reminder of a past most of the world is trying to leave behind.
29. answer to #19
Jay ,   Israel   (09.21.06)
To answer Abdul, yes, Israel has been in many wars but you missed the point that we had never instigated one of them. The instability of the region was there way before the state of Israel was created and why is it a disgrace for jews to have one country if arabs have 22? Mohamad did make these countries muslim by conquering them with the sword, and all other religions living there are treated very poorly. All the jews in the world could not live in Israel given the size of the country and where were the hundreds of thousands of jews displace from arab countries suppossed to go?. Jews were the original inhabitants of this land, not muslims, and have every right to have their own state and yes, G-d giving us this land is an extremely creditable arguement. I suggest you go back to school Abdul, and get educated properly as you seem to be rather ignorant to the facts.
30. anderson could have done better
(09.21.06)
I wasnt so impressed with anderson coopers interviewing skills. He was holding back and it was so obvious. My favorite part was when ahmadinejad asked him if these were andersons questions or if they were provided to him and anderson responded with "no we actually have freedom of press in our country" other then that sooo not impressed
Next talkbacks
Back to article