Opinion
Time to talk peace
Shulamit Aloni
Published: 24.09.06, 00:28
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
149 Talkbacks for this article
1. Talk Peace
Craig ,   Western Australia   (09.24.06)
So when do we start?,end
2. Shulamit Aloni .. You are really great human, and justified!
Semon ,   Niece FR   (09.24.06)
i swear, hoped to meet you.. just to kiss you head ! :) the problem is that the whole world knows the truth, but denying and changing history for the sake of some settlers (the terrorists) even thier controlled media (like Fox news and CNN) are trying to change facts, and show that palastinians are terrorists while they defends thier OWN home land !! and thier holy Aqsa Mosque, and thier jeursalem.. the same media wich says Islam is bad, in order to attracked Christians in thier row, against Muslims, (they may attracked UNLEARNED people only) they faild to attrack people with mind all the world suffers because USA government is backing those settlers, but i'd like to tell you something good : they will disappear soon. again Shulamit , you are great.. go on and continue.
3. |srael can live in peace, but it doesnt want that,
(09.24.06)
Because it hates Humanity
4. Fact
Fern ,   Colombia   (09.24.06)
Is she right? "Aloni became minister of education under Yitzhak Rabin but was forced to resign after a year due to her attempt to require religious youths to be indoctrinated in Leftist, and anti-Torah philosophy." Wikipedia
5. UN
Albert ,   Panama   (09.24.06)
The UN is represented by clowns like the Venezuelan President and others, will Jewish People put their future on their hands? If the author of this article wants that, please move closer to Caracas!!!
6. Injustices can exist in 'both' camps.
marilyn   (09.24.06)
Is this true? I do not doubt that individuals and groups are capable of great injustices and errors. To err is human to forgive divine. But one can not deny the great hostility that does exist in Arab religious beliefs, and I believe these have not been addressed here.There has been present from the beginning of Israel this attempt to drive Israel into the sea, and I don't believe it was all Israels doing.
7. When was she ever right about anything?
Sidney ,   USA   (09.24.06)
Never.
8. DECLARATION OF WHINNING,SELF AGRANDIZING ARABIAN PRINCESS
p HENRY ,   longmont U S A   (09.24.06)
THE PALESESTINIAN CULTURE OF HATE AND DESTRUCTION IS PERSONIFIED IN THE LITANY OF OBFUSCATION AND INNUENDOES SPEWED OUT BY THIS FRUMP,FRAZZLED FRUSTRATED FEMALE.
9. WORLD WAR 2 AGAIN ALONI ????
p HENRY ,   longmont U S A   (09.24.06)
ANOTHER(BEND OVER GRAB YOUR ANKLES) LIBERAL WITH HER CULTURE OF BLAME.JUST WHAT ISRAEL NEEDS ANOTHER BLAME GAME SARCASTIC MEALY-MOUTH. BUT IT MADE YOU FEEL GOOD,ALONI SUREEEEEEEEE
10. This is the TRUTH that every Israeli needs to know !!
Salam ,   Ramalla   (09.24.06)
I do wish that every Israel would read this article because it tells what no one is able to tell because he is afraid from the US government that is protecting Israel up to the bones !!!
11. Time to talk peace
Jukka Moisio ,   Nacka Sweden   (09.24.06)
Talk about tunnelvision. This woman really shows, how it is to think with only one side of the brain. You know-that side... Just cut the Meir-commentary eg.in half, and that's it! Guilt, guilt, and more guilt. Who cares if the content of Meir's commentary got lost somewhere in the haste. What has peace to do with this. Peace is about righteousness and justice. About freedom and love. And about mutual understanding relating to human rights and respect. I do not think the jews alone are guilty of the opposite. About that land: last week the juridicial instances in Australia deemed in favour of aborigines regarding the ownership of the city of Perth. According to same principles, the jews would indeed have a good chance to claim the ownership of whole ofPalestine plus East Bank, too. What would ms. Aloni say about occupation in that case?
12. All this space wasted on a "peace now" failure
ilana   (09.24.06)
Shulamit, who are you do decide your (luxurious?) home in Tel Aviv IS a part of Israel but certain portions of land do not "belong to us"? Indeed, no portion of Israel belongs to a traitor! This is a woman who had many failed attempts as a viable member of parllement. She founded the RATZ party and was moved out mainly due to her radical contempt fot the RELIGIOUS members. She devotes her time to appeasing the Arabs and muslims as a huuuummmman rights activist. Move out Shulamit, Israel is NO place for you. Take your propaganda elsewhere!
13. The most blatent words of treason written here!
Josh   (09.24.06)
Why is this woman not deported as enemy activist? Someone tell me why? There are laws against such encitement. What are our leaders doing????
14. Get rid of this witch, her words are like poison
Elle ,   USA   (09.24.06)
15. YNET, aren't you ashamed to print this on Rosh Hashana?
Jenny   (09.24.06)
Or did you do it on purpose knowing it would receive a million negative talkbacks from religious Jews interested in Israel's future? This article is a disgrace full of exaggerations, half-truths and NOT ONE mention of Hamas or Hezbollah terror. "No wonder they hate us'" says this disgraceful individual, Shulamit Aloni. No wonder Hitler hated us, no wonder Stalin hated us, no wonder Mussolini hated us, etc. Yes, I guess it was b/c of the occupation. Anywhere a Jew lives they are occupying another's land. We get it. We should just commit suicide and save the Jew-haters the trouble. After all they are the natives and we Jews are natives of nowhere. We are not allowed to live anywhere in peace and according to Aloni it is all our fault. Shulamit, on this New Year, I beg you to leave Israel and take Beilin with you.
16. Shula's fulla sh*t's more like it ...
(09.24.06)
17. they "hate you" because they hate themselves
(09.24.06)
18. Legitimizing the Enemy
Lindon Richards ,   Milpitas CA ,USA   (09.24.06)
The psyshology of this writer gels nicely with those Jews who supported the Naziz in WW2, if indeed there were any!
19. Time to talk peace
Oleg ,   Milwaukee, USA   (09.24.06)
Some people leave in the ideal world too far from reality. They try to spread their utopia ideas and if these ideas prevail the catastrophe and tragedy become enormous. You need a partner on the other side first who also is willing to have peace (not just talk). There is no partner to talk to. Israel is a country non-grata for Muslims. No matter what you do even if you lick their backs they will try to exterminate you. How long time it should take for you to understand this?
20. time to talk peace
Dr.Joji Cherian ,   Aluva india   (09.24.06)
too late. israel missed the boat.arrogance and peace will not coexist
21. stupid article
19 year old Israeli ,   Somewhere on earth   (09.24.06)
We must elminate all radical muslims and people who support them NOT only militarily but financially and ideologically WHY NEGOTIATE WITH PEOPLE WHO THINK LIKE HITLER AND WANT ANOTHER HOLOCAUST !
22. Why to put Arab propaganda today?
Alex ,   LA, USA   (09.24.06)
This rasist and pro-Hizbullah/al-Quade individual is probably the only one you enjoy putting on your site.
23. i beleive
banan ,   Palestine   (09.24.06)
its just so good to hear and see Israelis still beleive in peace. it just make me as a palestinian appreciate being a moderate even if by words only. we share one land, history and future, please listen to the voices of peace, we all should support moderates on both side. i beleive in peace and beleive that we can do it. we can prospor and flourish but only if we accept each others differences. i salute you shlomete
24. MYMESSAGE TO YOU
David ,   USA / ISRAEL   (09.24.06)
"GO TO HELL" Shulamit Aloni
25. Now is the time to talk peace.
Mark ,   USA   (09.24.06)
Let us start the new year with peace!!
26. Daughter of a killer?
monk ,   USA   (09.24.06)
Is Shulamit Aloni the daughter of a killer? She sympathizes with terrorist murderers. She love those who decapitate and mutilate innocent Jews. She enjoys walking amongst the dead and mutilated Jews after a suicide bombing. Shulamit Aloni is a bloody woman is she not? Happy New Year!
27. what an IDIOT!
Simion ,   Irvine, USA   (09.24.06)
I think she lives in the la-la land.
28. A typical leftist...absolutely contemptable
Craig ,   USA   (09.24.06)
You are truly pathetic... Why is it you liberals can't grasp the simple fact that not all 'situations' can be solved by talking? What does it take for your ilk to understand that you are at war with a religion? A religion which teaches it adherents that their God (Allah...actually Satan), wishes you DEAD!!! Israel has been appeasing since leaving Lebonon...the first time, what has it gotten you? Where is the Israel of 30 years ago? If Israel continues down this mis-guided path, led by liberals who are willing to continually attempt to trade land for peace, who think they can talk their way to security, who don't believe their own Scripture...you will eventually make a deal with the devil himself...and of course be betrayed in the end.
29. The Real Tragedy
Mark ,   atkanta, USA   (09.24.06)
The human in me wants to agree with many of the things you write, but the realist in me knows better. You miss one very big point: They hate us with every fiber of their being because we are Jews in the land of Allah. It's that simple. They wouldn't accept a Jewish state before Israel even had an air force. Their society fails because they are wrapped up in a melodrama of hate and victimhood. Their situation could change this year if they took the Ghandi approach, but instead they'll teach their people hatred and violence. Golda also said "There will be peace when the Arabs love their children more than they hate the Jews". One day, I hope they do. If not they're going to continue to tear themselves, and the rest of the world, apart. To all of you, L'Shana Tova.
30. Best of Luck in the New Year!
RIB ,   USA   (09.24.06)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_nnbmVtZ0QY&mode=related&search= http://pnews.org/art/10art/ROOT.shtml Scroll down to History.
Next talkbacks
Back to article