Opinion  Others
Was Shakespeare Jewish?
David Verveer
Published: 29.09.06, 20:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
53 Talkbacks for this article
31. Everyone important is Jewish
Cato the Younger ,   USA   (09.30.06)
This fact is based upon ROGER PEYREFITTE's hilarious anti-anti-semitic book originally printed in French several decades ago. The title: "LES JUIFS" It is also available in English--"The Jews". Peyrefitte manages to hilaruously "prove "that Charles De Gaulle , Charlemagne, King George of England, etc, etc were Jews.
32. Was Shakespeare Jewish?
James ,   Glasgow, Scotland   (09.30.06)
Perhaps not as silly as it appears because well into the late 19th century many Jews converted to escape the persecution on them by the Vatican. Shakespeare himself was a closet Catholic but if his parents had converted for the same reason that would explain a lot. It is known that he wrote to favour the ruler at the time so perhaps his over the top depictions of Jews was confirmation of his parents abandonment of that religion. Many prominant British families can be found to have in the past converted, Princess Anne's husband's being one.
33. Reply to Michael - 30.
James ,   Glasgow, Scotland   (09.30.06)
Abraham on receiving the promises was instructed to circumcise all the males of his family as a sign of the promise. Hagar and Ishmael were not part of the promise but Ishmael being himself circumcised knew and understood what they meant. Because he was not and because his father loved him, God promised to make him a great nation. Since purity of blood is important both to Judaism and Christianity it is therefore impossible to declare that Ishmael is Jewish simply because the " seed " or Saviour had to be of pure blood and Ishmael's is not pure. That is another reason that Mohammed's claims are rubbish.
34. Jews bashing jews
Jose Nigrin ,   Guatemala   (10.01.06)
If William Shakespeare had jewish roots, its hard to comprehend, his antisemitic remarks on his Merchant of Venice.
35. to be jewish
Jose Nigrin ,   Guatemala   (10.01.06)
You feel proud being a jew, but not when there is discrimination, antisemitism or exclusion from work, because of your religion.
36. to #15
(10.01.06)
Thank you so much. You sound like a wonderful human being. G-d bless you.
37. to #16
(10.01.06)
Jesus was Jewish.
38. WORLD HERE WE COME
jerremiah ,   gomorrah   (10.01.06)
Da Vinci, Michellangelo, Archimedes, Newton, Gauss, Byron, Dante. Goethe, Dryden, Copernicus. Keppler, Aeshilus, Sophocles, Euripides, Leo Tolstoi AS EVERY JEW KNOWS IN THE SOUL OF HIS SOUL WERE JEWS BECAUSE ONLY WE ARE PREDESTINED TO BE THE GTREATS OF THE WORLD
39. spoof
johanna ,   tsfat   (10.01.06)
this is a spoof article. satire is a know form.... and very popular and understood in england. eg jonathan swift and "a modest proposal" where he suggested the answer to the irish famine.. was to export irish babies for the delight of the english dinner table. this idea of the cannibalism of the english was greeted with horror until people realised he was being satirical.
40. Praise the Lord!
MarlĂȘne ,   FRANCE   (10.01.06)
As a Christian, I acclaim & praise his Jewish heritage. Why it was kept a secret, the answer lies in his works...but it started out with his Mum, didn't it....his greatest mentor. The truth always wins an comes out doen't it.
41. To the losers of # 9 up and down
MarlĂȘne ,   FRANCE   (10.01.06)
You know the saying :"once a nut always a nut" - look at yourself in the mirror and ask yourself: what planet am I on? I know you're seeing a plonker. Plonkers be, darling. Good night, boy, and leave S to us.
42. There was a rumor that Elvis was Jewish.
Daisy ,   USA   (10.01.06)
I'm not kidding.
43. If Adam and Eve were Jewish then we're all Jews.
Daisy ,   USA   (10.01.06)
44. shakespeare
asdlkj ,   lljk   (10.01.06)
what a crock of @#$%. your evidence is nonexistent and your reasoning is b.s. why dont you look into which serial killers were jewish instead of trying to take credit for Christian genius? you are a nation of bureaucrats / administrators. you have no great artists, painters, mozarts- or shakespeares- to your credit.
45. creativity above racism
sami ,   west bank   (10.02.06)
focussing on his creative humanity is much greater than focusing on his identitiy. he goes beyond all that, as he intended to enlighten every man interested in poetry and literature regardless of his/ her ethnical background. poets and great men like him mustn't be bound to a certain group or religion. their ideas and thoughts are universal
46. #43
Dorothy Friend ,   Tel Aviv   (10.03.06)
They weren't. There were not Jews before Abraham.
47. Actually, he wasn't Jewish, but he was American
David ,   Marietta USA   (10.05.06)
48. I am a Marano!
Marano ,   Toronto, Ontario,CA   (02.07.07)
Who cares if he was a Jew. All that matters is that he was a great writer. I'm catholic, Re-suching my family genolegy I have found out that my family derived from the Jews of Spain. Does this make me any less or greater I don't think so. What it does, it makes me who I am, an ItaloCanadian Catholic with a Jewish background. I'm still great at what I do, and still love my family. So move forward and see him for what he is. GREAT!
49. Converso reading of the Merchant of Venice
A secret Jew ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (11.10.07)
So where can I get the Coles notes on the Converso reading of the Merchant of Venice? Check out the Wikipedia article on the Merchant of Venice...they've totally miss the point. Shakespeare wanted to be free to be Jewish, but he was forced to be a Christian...that's ok he could still make Aliyah because it wasn't his choice. They'd probably put him into an Intelligence unit.
50. shakespeare
guliver ,   Paris   (01.11.09)
Not bad David, you were just a few inches away from the historical truth. I have found a proof dated 1569 that Shakespeare's father was indeed Jewish. But his mother was catholic, therefore William himself was not Jewish. Happy new year.
51. Shakespeare's daughter
Caroline ,   Exeter   (07.30.09)
He called her Judith which means Jew
52. The author barely grasps English.
Aguy ,   Los Angeles, CA   (07.29.10)
53. @#16 Jesus?
Lenya ,   Australia   (04.02.12)
Excuse me? Jesus was a bona-fide Jew born of Yosef and Miriam and descended from the tribe of Judah. Thats why He is named "The Lion of the Tribe of Judah. In the New Testament Jesus frequented the Synagogue in Jerusalem and even read from the Torah in the pulpit.
54. Untermenschen or American?
Fox ,   NC, USA   (09.07.12)
it seems like many Americans of European extraction didn't even bother to hide their names because they had already done so in Europe. Our people sometimes mixed to half or better forged and fought the nation to where it is, this is the promised land and since almost everyone from Bill Gates to Bush to Cheney to Slim Pickens and Norman Swartzkopf and Clint Eastwood and Jobeth Williams are passing themselves to other heritage (many who are part Jewish) I'd say the cat was out of the bag
Previous talkbacks
Back to article