News
JA head: Hizbullah, Iranian threat won’t hurt aliyah
Dan Bentsur
Published: 09.10.06, 14:53
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
68 Talkbacks for this article
1. Best Way To Make Aliyah - Nefesh
(10.09.06)
http://www.nbn.org.il/ Aliyah Radio Shows http://www.aliyahrevolution.com/ http://www.jr.co.il/aliyah/index.html Baruch Hashem
2. The Mitzvah To Live In Eretz Israel - Free Book
Israel ,   Israel   (10.09.06)
Compilation of various authors and sources regarding the importance of living in Eretz Israel: http://www.israel613.com/books/ERETZ_ISRAEL_SHORT.pdf
3. Real Link To Aliyah Radio Show
(10.09.06)
Sorry about that Here its called The Aliyah Revolution http://www.israelnationalradio.com/aliyah-revolution.htm http://www.israelnationalradio.com/
4.  Aliya is for losers
Rachel Foreman ,   Somerest   (10.09.06)
If you're a Jew who wants a fresh start in a new place do yourself a favor and come to Australia!!!! Aussies rule ;-)
5. Judaism Is ReligioNational
(10.09.06)
Hashem instructed us to live and practice his Law in only one place, Eretz Yisrael.
6. how about the 750,000 who emigrated back to europe and US?
fadi ,   lebanon   (10.09.06)
any news from those who left over the last 10 years ??? Are they coming back ??? probably he just "forgot" talking about this issue. Another delusionist !!!!
7. Previous imigrants experiance says stop Aliah
hanzalah naji ali ,   AL - SHAJARA   (10.09.06)
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3311519,00.html Previous imigrants experiance says stop Aliah, read the above article and see how israel treet newcommers
8. Israeli Immigrants
SAM ,   USA   (10.09.06)
I heard that these immigrants wanted to immigrate to Israel few month ago but their paper work was strategically delayed!!!???
9. Unfortunately, JA can't stop secular Yeridah!
Johnny ,   Miami   (10.09.06)
10. and read this about reverse emigration
hanzalah naji ali ,   al-shajara   (10.09.06)
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3309557,00.html this article is a sample of a lot of Jews who is Leaving Israel. Check the foreign embassies in Israel reports, Facts Talk.
11. To 6
Shai ,   Israel   (10.09.06)
1) Get your facts straight. 750,000 is probably an exaggeration, but it represents those who left over the last 60 years, not the last 10. Not insignificantly, it's about the same number that were sent packing by the bigoted Arab countries that Jews were residents of when Israel became a state, leaving homes that were theirs even before Arabs arrived in their country (e.g., Morocco, Egypt, Iraq). People leave for all sorts of reasons, and it may be that their leaving had nothing to do with disatisfaction with Israel. 2) As a percentage, the total who left is not much different than a country like France, which also has a high percentage of expatriates. People are free to come and go as they choose here, just as they are there. It says nothing about us that it doesn't also say about every other free country on earth. That said, how many people are immigrating to Lebanon lately? When you can open your eyes about your own Syrian/Iranian/Shia controlled country, who hasn't got enough of a backbone to defend its sovereignty from takeover by Islamic fundies and Palis, then you can claim to be clear minded enough to judge whether anybody from Israel is delusional. Until then, tishtok Fadi.
12. Fadi , who are you to call the kettle black?
Judah ,   Golan Heights,Israel   (10.09.06)
Fadi, from Lebanon, loves sending emails to ynet knocking the Jewish State. Now he comments on the Israelis who have left over the years to other countries. He fails to mention three important facts: 1) That alot more Jews have immigrated to Israel than have left. 2) Israels population is now 7.1 million and growing. 3) Lebanon has lost a much higher percentage of its population to emigration, especially its Christian citizens. Fadi should take a trip to Dearborn Michigan. He would be shocked once he saw how many Lebanese live away from their homeland.
13. To 6, 7, 8, etc.
David ,   St Louis, USA   (10.09.06)
Notice the article you reference is from this paper. No one is hiding anything.
14. #7 ... al-shajara-hara
(10.09.06)
Perhaps one day the apartheid walls that surround each and every arab country prohibiting jews/christians from immigrating into an arab country will come down and we can see what life in an arab country is like.
15. #12 and Fadi
michigan   (10.09.06)
judah is right, we have about a million muslim arabs that have left the middle east living here in michigan, an entire city right here in michigan where you need to know arabic to read the signs above the stores instead of english. Oh, I almost forgot the nearly 200,000 christian arabs living here in michigan that have fled iraq.
16. SHOW ME AN ARAB IN FAVOR OF ALIYAH & PEACE W/ISRAEL
DAVID P ,   SANTA CRUZ, USA   (10.09.06)
17. #11 7.1 million and growing ! huh growing with arabs :)
fadi ,   lebanon   (10.09.06)
18. #11 idiot !!!!
fadi ,   lebanon   (10.09.06)
1. The jews that left the arab countries left on their own cause they wanted to be part of the attrocities of the state of israel. If it was for us we would have loved to keep them as hostages 2. The figure of 750,000 is taken from a recent article in Ynet posted 1-2 weeks back. so shut up 3. Lebanese are leaving lebanon: nothing new about that .. this way we will spread around the world and spread our seed everywhere :p who knows u might be a lucky one. Lebanese started leaving lebanon since 1910. Now theres 14 million of lebanese origin all over the world ... from the US congress to australian congress to the Middle east advisor of the new south american hero ... Chavez :) 4. Again the figure of 7.1 million includes all arab israelis ... the main reason why israel will one day fall to pieces because of the hge demographic bomb which is growing inside israel ... the huge increase in number of israeli arabs compared to jews who again i tell you are leaving israel for good.... 5. Now just lets wait and see what the results of the last war with lebanon would have an effect on the israeli north settlers :D
19. Ignore Moslems On Ynet Especially
(10.09.06)
You know exactly what they will say, you know their arguments and "reasons", IGNORE THEM
20. Fadi ,will you ever give it a rest?
Judah ,   Golan Heights,ISRAEL   (10.09.06)
Fadi, why did you NOT respond to the fact that it is Lebanon and not Israel that has lost such a high percentage of its population? Instead you send a new email implying that Israels' growth rate is due solely to its Arab citizens. Sorry to be the one to inform you, 1) Jewish birth rates are stable. 2) Arab birth rates have been dramatically declining for years. 3) Immigration is increasing ,including returning Israelis. Fadi, Israel, the Jewish State , is here to stay and all your foolish emails will not change this fact.
21. lebaneses
lina ,   brazil   (10.09.06)
we have here 8 millions of lebaneses.And we like them very much.ALL the most popular schools and hospitals is for them.They are very intelligent.And I ask them what did they think about the lebanon war;they told as that now they feel safe to live in lebanon;in the past israel soldiers stay in lebanon 20 years;and nobody can do anything about it;but now we have hezbollah to defend us (they said);It's true that israel destroy most of the houses;but it's more better than israel sit in our land;and now they are afraid to get back in lebanon;we saw their fotos coming back from the war crying;heheheheheheheheheheh;(they said)I am not a lebanese ;but I have many lebaneses friends here;bye.
22. #20 Fadi is just mad that Israel is a Jewish state
(10.09.06)
while Lebanon WAS a Christian state and now it is ruled by the #1 mad mullah, sheik hassan Nasrallah and his lovely turban.
23. Fadi in lebanon
KAPARA   (10.09.06)
Fadi habibi, My family left iraq because grandpa was pulled out of our home, beaten and then executed during the muslim pogroms against the jews of iraq. Now the arabs of "palestine"....they actually did chose to leave palestine of their own will after the arab world chose war instead of peace in 1948. Not all of them left, but many did.....OF THEIR OWN CHOICE. I guess the jews did a worse job of ethnically cleansing the arabs than the arab world did of ethnically cleansing the jews that had been there for thousands of years. You win the ahabal award habibi.
24. #fadi
linda   (10.09.06)
Go back to your storybook and lies. I do not believe the storybook no more and know people like your are all big liers
25. Fadi
(10.09.06)
Your views on Jews making aliya to Israel is inconsequential--I'm sorry, was that too big of a word for you? How about "not important"? You are irrelevant in this matter.
26. to 20 & 17
hanzalah naji ali ,   Al-shajara   (10.09.06)
All your Israeli stratigic planners are afraid from one thing, the demographic problem, the report of population for the new hebrew year says arab now 18%, in 1948 after they been forced to imigrate they were 12% only, that means all the aliyah didnt make any differance, the decrease in arab woman fertility will be average of 8 children instead of 12, still high for 1.5 child everage for jews woman, the problem is these arab population will be according to Israeli statistics 29% of the population in 2025, and over 54% in 2051, statistics says arab society at that time will be youth society, and israeli will be old, and the problem with israel who is trying to make them not educated, and crime spread, so they will find hard time to deal with them. world will not allow israel to force them to imigrate again, jews incoming will decrease as the bank of jews who is willing to come is nearly bankrupt.
27. But JAFI and histadrut can stop Aliyah...
Adam Adamati ,   Israel   (10.09.06)
and do so all the time. Most Anglos simply don't like socialism and the histadrut MUST GO. The Jewish Agency and the various ministries stop aliyah every day because of the interesanteem working there. Last month, JAFI stated, "Jerusalem, there is no such place." Why would they say such a thing? Because in their history, they have never knowingly hired a native English speaker to any job of importance. Their hiring is based on protekzia. Of course, they meant, "Jerusalem, there is no place like it," but no Israeli would ever catch the error, so 20,000 brochures were printed. Constitution, NOW. Real jobs for Anglos, and not just nbners!
28. #6
Israeli ,   Haifa   (10.09.06)
Listen you braindead arab: Aliyah has never stopped. People have been leaving/joining israel since it's first day. You have nothing to do with it. Numbers haven't changed because of hizballah, they may have managed to make kiryiat shmona residents to move south for a month, but that's it. It hurts you to see it doesn't hurt us, doesn't it? Well just so you know: Israel has a better economy than lebanon Israel has a better regime than lebanon Israel has better scientists than lebanon Israel has better education than lebanon Israel has better food than lebanon Israel has better/more resources than lebanon Israel has better high-tech than lebanon Israel has better people in lebanon. Israel has less crime than in lebanon. israel has a better army than lebanons Israel has better girls than lebanon (in every form kind and behaviour) Let's compare what we don't have and you do: We don't have suicide bombers We don't have terrorists (I suggest you go find a terrorist definition in a close-by dictionary as I know logic is not your strong side, (if there is such side)). Now, let's do small war statistics: At your side about 1200 were killed, our side about 150 At your side the damage caused needed billions of billions of dollars to fix and still isn't done or close to it. At our side, you caused millions of damage of shitty fireworks on steroids. Mostly to natural places like woods and such. (The only time we hit your natural resources was when we hit the power station and it leaked, yes, we have forseen the leaking, too. The mossad was on it.) Your side goals accomplished: 2 captured soldiers ambushing troops (gotta give you credit) Our side accomplishents: destruction of any desire to attack us again or (as you know the price) pay. Hizballah knows that after the first week their soldiers got killed on the left and right, running from battles and such. They know we are strong, even if you are in denial yourself. And we see them trying to attack us again, right? An international treaty that makes you stay at your side of the border. (which is what we wanted in first place). Now, disaccomplishments: ours, we didn't manage to free our soldiers yours: sheba farms are still ours and will keep being so. uhm anything else I'm leaving except reminding you how plenty of arabs from all countries including lebanon run to israel because it's shitty in their countries? And now fadi, I hope you can crawl under your rock again and leave this forum alone ashmed knowing how delusional YOU are. Another 'loss' like this and lebanon will be destroyed, you know it, I know it, hizballah knows it. you puppet.
29. IGNORE FADI, SHE JUST WANTS ATTENTION
(10.09.06)
30. #22 am sorry for you that it is mostly jewish !??
fadi ,   lebanon   (10.09.06)
who would want to live betwen you loool by the way lebanon is not ruled yet by Nasrallah but i hope it will be soon. May jesus have mercy on ur soul and fill u with peace and love instead of this anger and hate that is pouring out of you
Next talkbacks
Back to article