Jewish Scene
Study confirms: Nazis made soap from human bodies
AFP
Published: 10.10.06, 09:09
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
70 Talkbacks for this article
31. #10
AJ   (10.10.06)
"human life is a human life" You should kept that sentiment in mind the next time your fellow muslim brethren decapitates a innocent human being...regardless of that victims' religion.
32. Adam #29 to Ali
Rustum ,   London, UK   (10.10.06)
What an erroneous conclusion you draw from Ali's post. He spoke of common humanity, of equality, or understand your pain, of reconciliation. You responded "choke hard and die slowly you dirty little racist scumbag." I wonder if you response to Ali has any connection with your hatred of non-Jews and Arabs in particular? Thank god I'm not a Palestinian living next door to you. I think that the language barrier would be the very least of the barriers to understanding your stuck-in-the-shtetl semblance of a mind.
33. Sick of hearing the same statements
Ali ,   Lebanon   (10.10.06)
First of all, I didn't question what happened in the holocaust. God bless all those who died but what I meant is that the Israeli media should become liberal and stop being biased and pro-the Israeli goveernment in their crimes against the Lebanese and Palastinian people. 2nd of all, for all those replying and saying shit about hezbollah and our soul Narallah, the war was not started by us. You guys still occupy Shib3a, have hostages and don't want to give us the mine maps. If Israel, wanted to destruct hezbollah then why did they leave 100,000 gifts for our children in South Lebanon. This shows the level of hateret you people have and if you guys want I can give you a long list of examples. (maybe, the pic where Israeli kids were signing missiles to Lebanese children)...really sick!!! Third, it is really funny when someone reads your comments about arabs being antisemist and all this crap since he can feel the effect of the American/ Israeli Propaganda. First of all, arab cannot be antisemist becaus we are smist in the first place. Second, for all those who are attacking Islam and especially thos ignorant Americans, Islam never asks people to kill or commit terrosim. On the contrary, Islam is the Religion of forgiveness and kindness. It is a Religion that looks at equates Humans. Islam neevr says that you are judged based on ur race, color, or Ethnicity. You are only judged on your good and bad dees. Islam never says that muslims are the Chosen ones and all the other should be slave for them...Stop hating others and to do, each one should start from himself and should understand that we are all humans
34. hate v. anger
Isragirl ,   NJ, USA   (10.10.06)
I can understand the hate expressed by the Arabs and the Israelis - it's a result of anger and pain caused by this bloody conflict. But why do Europeans, personally unaffected by these events, show so much hate towards Israel? Shouldn't they be the wise sages looking on from afar and giving thoughtful, insightful advise? Or are they the descendants of the same people who used soap made of the fat from Jewish bodies and lampshades made from the skin of the same source? That's not barbaric?
35. Adam, grow up.
Lina ,   Qiryat Yam   (10.10.06)
Your attitude doesn't reflect well on the rest of us.
36. #15 - YOU ARE SO RIGHT!
(10.10.06)
37. TO MY FELLOW JEWS.
ERETZ HAKODESH!   (10.10.06)
ADAM - YOU ARE RIGHT IN EVERY WAY. TO OUR NATION: NEVER STOP DEFENDING OUR COUNTRY AND KNOW THAT WHEN THIS NATION BEGINS TO DO WHAT HASHEM DEMANS ISRAEL WILL FINALLY FIND ITS PEACE. JEWS ARE THE CHOSEN PEOPLE BY G-D. THIS STATEMENT IS KNOWN BY EVERYONE. THE HATRED DIFFERENT RELIGIONS HAVE FOR US REALLY DOES NOT MATTER, HASHEM IS CAPABLE OF DOING ANYTHING!!! BECAUSE THE MINUTE THIS NATION BEGINS TO DO ITS DEEDS ISRAEL WILL FIND ITS PEACE -BE'EZRAT HASHEM - WE CANNOT TURN TO ANYBODY ELSE BUT HASHEM HIMSELF BECAUSE THE KADOSH BUROCHO CAN AND WILL HELP US! BUT IT IS ALL UP TO US, THE JEWISH PEOPLE TO DO WHAT WE MUST DO: THE TEN COMMANDMENTS! "VE AHAVTA LEARACHA KAMOCHA" WE MUST START BEHAVING WITH RESPECT TO EACHOTHER. WE MUST BE STRONG AND STICK TOGETHER BECAUSE BE'EZRAT HASHEM EVERY WAR THAT COMES OUR WAY WILL BE DEFEATED BY US, AND ILL SAY IT AGAIN: IT'S ALL UP TO US! ITS NOT HARD, HASHEM DID NOT DEMAND FROM US THINGS THAT ARE IMPOSSIBLE! YOU WILL SEE WHEN YOU GO HIS WAY YOU WILL RECOVER FROM ALL THE DIFFICULTIES YOU HAVE IN YOUR LIFE. TRUST IN HASHEM AND DO WHAT YOU MUST DO. AND WE CAN FINALLY FIND PEACE.
38. Thanks 37 for proving my point
Ali ,   Lebanon   (10.10.06)
No more comments....Although, I know that not all Jews think that way but it is unfortunate that most of them have this kind of mentaility (number 37) May Allah guide you to the right way and bless you....Peace 4 ever
39. to # 21
Rida ,   Tlemcen, Algeria   (10.10.06)
I dont't know if I have half a brain, but I know this soap story is a... story.
40. to # 27
Rida ,   Tlemcen, Algeria   (10.10.06)
I'm not ignorant enough to ignore it's just a tale.
41. to # 30
Rida ,   Tlemcen, Algeria   (10.10.06)
I'm a Semite, that's the difference between me and you.
42. Nazis left Unpunished. They should be all executed
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (10.10.06)
Not those Nazis who are obliged to do or act like Nazis. Under such a regime there might be really unvoluntary associates in crime. But what about those lead and know What they did. Except for a few at the very begging of their defeat, Most of them are not sentenced to what they deserved. Capital punishment I mean. Instead Your are given ISRAEL in exchange and innocent Arabs for revenge.
43. Antisemites are insidious liars
Michael U ,   SF,CA   (10.10.06)
I read all the antisemetic posts here and I weep. What is wrong with a people who take pleasure in killing others. The Arabs are soulless people, their only commandment is to decieve the righteous. They have pulled the wool over their eyes and disobeyed every commandment from the L-rd G-d. To them life is cheap, and their redemption is death. So sad are those who subscribe to that ideology. Judaism is superiour to the cult of death which people like Nasrallah and the Iranian jerkoff lead. Their fate is already sealed, the righteous know that Hashems fury rages against heretics like Nasrallah and his ilk. Their Idolatry is self evident, they have built a wall of hatred and they will live in their own filth. As all of the Jewish peoples oppressors have been smited, so shall these half-twit Arab leaders be swept into the trashbin of history. They will join Pharoh, Haman, the Greeks, the Romans, and the Nazis. Each of them rose against Hashem, and HE smacked them into oblivion. The righteous of Israel will stand tall above the ruins of Lebanon and Syria, the hellfires will burn the cursed bodies of the Arab heathen for their sin. May Hashems will be carried out in our day, and may his Glory be known to the upright. The time of redemption seems to be near. Remember 4/5ths of the Jewish nation was left in Egypt during Exodus. There is no room to waver to the left or to the right, wake up Jewish people, look our enemies in their squinty eyes and understand that it's either them or us. Do not harbor hatred in your hearts, for this is not righteous. But defend your land with all your heart and soul against barbarians who have no regard for innocence. I am a victim of 9/11 and although I don't hate, I live by the command to not sit idly by as my brothers blood was spilled.
44. holocaust
American ,   USA   (10.10.06)
we've All heard enough of the holocost--- to the point of bordem. the CURRENT genocides of the earth is what we should be concentrating on- in Sudan- or Palestine- or Tibet. you jews are showing your true colors- more everyday and its not p[retty- get with the program- you are not 'chosen' like your little torah says- every human is created equal.
45. soap made from jewish dead bodies
moshe brown ,   brooklyn ny usa   (10.10.06)
Our father was liberated at the Mathausen concentration camp by the US army. The American soldiers openned the huge storage barracks for the inmates and they helped themselves whatever they pleased. They found hundreds upon hundred of bars of soap marked RJF. They used the soap to wash untill they discovered that the letters on the soap meant, "Reine Judische Fetten" meaning, Pure Jewish Fat. Father said it was smooth as silk. They consulted one of the surviving rabbis in the camp and he advised to bury the soap made from burning Jewish bodies. All this is documented by the US army in Mauthausen
46. Rida, you are DEEPLY ignorant
Paolo Ortenzi ,   Rome, Italy   (10.10.06)
there are PLENTY of documents, including the stenographic documents written during the Wansee conference. When, you Arabs, will start to accept the truth and stop hiding behind the lies that your Imams are telling you? These are really TALES, not the Holocaust. Shame on you!
47. Time to change the term "ANTI -SEMITE"
Alan ,   SA   (10.10.06)
I agree with all Arab contributors -they are certainly Semites. How can they be called "Antisemites " Its ridiculous! You see. when the word was first used in Gemany & Europe there were really no or few Arabs etc. living in Europe! The Jews were being chased around Europe and every so often slaughtered for killing Jesus or other reasons(like when the King didnt want to repay his loans) In order to use a polite word for good old fashioned Jewhating,the term "ANTI_SEMITISMUS" was coined by the sensitive who didnt like to say "Jewhaters/Killers" . Of course today with most of the prewar Jews Murdered, the now larger population of the other Semites (12-15 Million ) inhabit Europe ,sometimes sarcastically refered to as Eurabia. I always prefer to say "Jewhaters" rather than "Anti Semites " as some of the Jew haters best friends are indeed "Semites"
48. #6 is response to # 46
(10.10.06)
49. To #42, see post #25
Adam ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.10.06)
50. nonsense
chad ,   usa   (10.10.06)
I can't find the actual scientific study on this claim. It's based on one bar of soap from the Nuremberg trial. I think there were also lampshades at this trial claimed to be made of human skin that was later found to be of a goat. I'd like to see the actual scientific study. As far as I know though, holocaust historians (not deniers) today do not seriously make the claim of jewish soap and lampshades anymore.
51. #44 shows his colors
Michael U ,   SF,CA   (10.10.06)
This antisemite doesn't open his eyes and see. Her in America the genocide in Darfur is a BIG BIG HOT issue in our synagogues. I have donated money and time to support the cause of stopping the genocide. If you are interested in saving the people in Darfur, you supposed American, just do so. Speak with your pocket book, like many many good Jews have. No Jew ever claimed that we suffered the only holocoust. It is just that the Nazi holocoust is unparalleled because of the supposed high society of Germany. Most Americans like yourself draw moral equivalence because you are uneducated. The violence in Darfur, Sudan is due to tribal and religious fueds. What happened in Germany was a well-planned eradication of the Jewish people. You use the world holocoust to describe the so-called palestinian situation. You too are deceived. The Israelis are protecting themselves from suicidal maniacs, and have EVERY RIGHT to kill those who want to kill innocent Israelis. This in no way is similar to how the Nazis rounded up Jews and put them in gas chambers. No way bucko! You have shown your antisemitic colors.
52. to #34 (''Europeans hate Israel'')
Euromediterranean ,   EU   (10.11.06)
Europeans don't hate Israel, but as you said our view of the conflict is less biased. When you look at the Israeli-Palestinian/Lebanese conflict, we see hatred, ignorance and fear from both sides. But one side has more power than the other, has a much wealthier economy and military, and uses this power in a way that is appalling, just as scuicide bombers resort to appalling means. We don't hate Israel, but we hate war. War comes from both sides, arab and israeli, but Israel is clearly the one dominating the other. Whether it's Israel or Palestine I don't care, it's ugly, it's sad, it's light years from the European dream of peace and unity(God bless it).
53. #47 WAKE UP ....
Marya ,   sacramento, USA   (10.11.06)
Being a "semite" has absolutely nothing to do with the term, "anti-Semite." It was coined by a man named Wilhelm Marr to precisely describe JUDENHASS -- hatred of Jews, moron! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wilhelm_Marr
54. soap
israeli ,   israel   (10.11.06)
This piece of news come from the Polish Remembrance Institute who analyzed the bar of soap. Nobody can even begin to hint that Polish scientists are part of some Jewish/Zionist or such conspiracy. In all honesty, people!
55. Soap’s tales
Anna ,   Canada   (10.11.06)
The article’s says: “Study confirms…” IF somebody puts any study to the dispute, this somebody has to be one whose education and knowledge can help to explore and investigate but not take the shortcuts in the argument by assuming the “facts”. Saying so I can tell you that people who didn’t leave through the WWII can’t even talk about these events but only listen. And to everyone who is trying to draw a parallel between Nazis and Israelis: Fascists killed Jews not because they committed atrocities, terrorist and barbaric acts against Germans but because of the racial hatred. They killed Gypsies and enslaved Slavs labeling them as lower race humans. Israel is in constant defense. Israel doesn’t kill to terrorize and to take the revenge. Arabs from Palestinian Authority are terrorizing, killing, stilling and abusing not only Israelis but also their own communities. Why shouldn’t you ask your leaders: where the money that UN and USA gave for the creation of your so wanted country? We quickly forgot what a wave of tears and yelling did PA Authority spill after Israel started to build the wall between Israeli and PA lands. As the result there are fare few suicide bombers could finish their missions. And for all you discriminated: who built you the Universities that you never dreamed about till creation of Israel? Check points is a shame and disgusting matter. But they save so many Israelis’ and Arabs’ lives that those intolerable checkpoints are the unfortunate necessity. To be loyal it means to be entitled for the benefits.Bankrupt governments’ political killings and soon to be suicide is your reality because you are not loyal to the democracy. Till today you are only blaming one side and never look into the mirror.
56. Euromediterranean
Anna ,   Canada   (10.11.06)
I am wondering why Israel has much stronger economy and military. Maybe thanks to the neighbors who constantly try to destroy it? Maybe because Europeans providing their political, economical and military support to the Israeli enemies? Maybe because the Nazi sympathizers still freely shaking their slogans and advertising their ideas in many European countries? How often did you hear from the BBC the positive news about Israelis’ achievements without any sad questionable attachments about poor Palestinians? The so called anti-war activists never gave any constructive ideas how to protect Israel from it’s neighbors’ constant aggressions but they always accusing Israel of trying to defend its citizens and borders.
57. I agree #47, let's drop the term "anti-semitism"
Sharon   (10.11.06)
Who the hell needs to hear another Arab saying they are a semite? I am sick to death of it. Call these idiots denying this article or the Holocaust JEW-HATERS b/c that's exactly what they are. Besides the originator of the term anti-Semite was himself a Jew-hater.
58. #52 - euromediterranean?
israeli ,   israel   (10.11.06)
Eurabian is more like it. http://www.frontpagemag.com/Articles/ReadArticle.asp?ID=15044
59. soap made of humans bodies
Yanina ,   Tel Aviv   (10.11.06)
Nice of Poles to admit it after 63 years. I was there and we knew it in 1945.
60. soap
Yanina ,   Tel Aviv   (10.11.06)
To #2,3,17 - disgusting? This is what you call it? Your comments are disgusting, soap made of human bodies is barbaric and even this is a understatment.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article