News
Wafa Sultan: I know they want to kill me
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 11.10.06, 22:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
109 Talkbacks for this article
31. This is a Heroine
DWOLF ,   california   (10.12.06)
I listened to Wafa with awe and respect when she was on Al Jazerra. The courage of her conviction is like Bar Kochba fighting for her own liberties and the people of the Middle East. Go girl!
32. 10 Personally, your opinion is nearly totally
freedom ,   canada   (10.12.06)
laughable.. You miss the real problem, militant Islam seeks to destroy or silence any moderate voice.. Waiting for you to prove me wrong...
33. 15 Assim when are those in the west bank going
freedom ,   canada   (10.12.06)
to personally apologize for the five christian churches that were desecrated in the territories.. Show me peace, because I can not see it anywhere...
34. Some REALITY on the ground!
RIB ,   USA   (10.12.06)
More REALITY that excludes the Leftist's, 'I'm O.K. - You're O.K.', B/S! Want to 'Buy the World a Coke and Sing - We Are the World' - then SKIP this! Go turn on 'Everybody Loves Raymond'! http://www.heritage.org/Press/Events/ev092706a.cfm http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rio8gpIAWEg&mode=related&search=
35. Islam's Peace Message
tinashkuli   (10.12.06)
http://www.thereligionofpeace.com/index.html#Attacks http://www.thereligionofpeace.com/attacks-2001-2003.htm http://www.thereligionofpeace.com/attacks-2004.htm http://www.thereligionofpeace.com/attacks-2005.htm http://www.thereligionofpeace.com/
36. #13 your are right she has more
tea man ,   marjayoun   (10.12.06)
balls than any man or woman that make her different in aweird way but i donot know why you insist on calling her moslem herion when she herself dosn'T CLAIM THAT SHE SECULAR NO GOD IS HER GOD SHE IS LOOKING FOR MONEY AND FAME AND SHE USE THE JEWS (since they have the media) for that purppoose wise up jews donot let the foolish fool ya
37. To Mrs. W. Sultan. Decisions About Life And Death.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (10.12.06)
You said:" .. some who want to kill me ..". You should always think of the Prophet Mohammed. As long as you think of him he WILL protect you -- that long. NO one is able to kill you -- without the permission of Allah. When you depend on Prophet Mohammed -- then whether you are alive or threatened -- you ARE in the best hands : in the protective hands of Allah. There is NO reason to be scared -- as you said. Decisions about life and death -- these are NOT in the hands of people of this planet. IT is all in the hands of Allah. Hope everything is well with you.
38. To Sami #10. If You ARE Convinced.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (10.12.06)
You write:".. she won't repeat herself any more, ..". If you ARE convinced about something - I do not think you will say it just once. And yet you are asking that of Mrs. Sultan. So, you are not a reasonable person !! WHEN one speaks - attention of others is attracted. It is unavoidable. BUT you are like a person telling someone:' make music - without making sound'. You are asking something irrational !! When one speaks the truth - people who have something to hide becomes angry. Those who have NOTHING to hide will NEVER become angry. TO practice religion is open for anyone and everyone. To practice religion is in your hands. If you do NOT want to practice religion - that is also in your hands. NO one can force you to practice religion. And NO one can prohibit you to practice religion. Hope everything is well with you.
39. An unstoppable storm
Kate ,   Jerusalem   (10.12.06)
Wafa's interview on Al Jezeera should make every muslim woman proud. She isn't afraid to stand up straight against tyranny. The UN should take lessons from Wafa.
40. A true heroine.
Adam Segal ,   Raanana, Israel   (10.12.06)
Standing up against the bastardisation of a religion, Wafa Sultan is a true heroine and is welcome in my home any day. Dr. Sultan, enjoy your trip to Israel, you are always welcome here.
41. Thanks Poster #2
Joe ,   Ohio USA   (10.12.06)
I saw a you tube clip about this woman earlier, but wasn't able to find out the content of the interview. From what I had heard, the interview was more a ambush and scream fest by the moderator who tried to intimidate her into silence. We need more brave people who won't be silenced or intimidated. If someone could post the site so we all could view the 'interview" as it aired so we could see the moderators reactions and over all general tenor of the interview I'd appreciate it
42. Wafa Sultan for President of Iraq.
James ,   Toledo Oho USA   (10.12.06)
43. WAFA SULTAN? GREAT WOMAN
haim ,   mtl canada   (10.12.06)
she must be protected by israel and get israeli passport for sure her life in in danger we know islam is a religion of peace but why give a chance to terrorists shalom
44. people enjoy her while she last
farah ,   tora bora afganistan   (10.12.06)
she said she not moslem and her life was hijacked while she pretend to be moslem now she is free and ready to join non-moslems grab her becuase in the next few years may be she turn on you too after al this is the mode for flip flop trust me nobody wanna harm her
45. Wafa Sultan.. You're definitely not my hero..
BouSameer ,   Beirut Lebanon   (10.12.06)
She's making it look as if she defected from communist Soviet Union to the West. Dreaming of toppling the "evil religion"? I know that islamists in Syria are constantly prosecuted. If you have a large beard for instance, you could be interrogated and hassled for hours at Damascus Airport. So I don't understand what she is talking about when she says she's been abused by islamic society in Syria for over 30 years. Maybe she had an abusive family.. The issues about Islam are often debated in Lebanon. The issues of reforming Islam are constantly heard, and I haven't seen threat on anyone's life. Wafa has some points, but none are new. Unfortunately her message, which may have valid points, is exploited by the far right wing who constantly aim at demonizing Islam. So I am not sure Wafa, what your objectives are? There are others like you asking for reformation of Islam, with clear proposals. Yet they don't get the same publicity, maybe because their rethoric is not based on hatred and anti-islam slogans. Maybe because they show that you can be a reformist, and yet not be wanted dead or alive. So in short, Wafa you are not a reformist. Other than your anti Islam chants, I see no valuable message. Your message is simply being exploited and mediatised because you make the point of certain radical political movements, who couldn't care less about reforming Islam. As to learning from Israelis, yes, but what? Learning how to oppress those of other religions than yours?
46. to 45 - two small points
NL ,   Israel   (10.12.06)
1. You say Islam is being attacked by the right wing. Placing Islam as left wing? Doesn't this seem discordant with the treatment of women in most Muslim countries and the fact that most Muslim countries are not democracies? 2. You claim there is no religious freedom in Israel? Firstly, Arab men are allowed to vote in Israel, unlike in many Muslim dictatorships. Secondly, mosques are not destroyed or targeted (even in the territories) and people are allowed to attend without restriction, even though the pulpits are used for anti-Israeli incitement in many places, including inside Israel. Thirdly, under Israeli rule, all three religions live and practice freely in Jerusalem, which was not the case when the city was in the hands of other religions.
47. Attn: Joe, Ohio (#41)
Parkek ,   Hong Kong   (10.12.06)
Here is a link to what I think you are looking for: http://switch5.castup.net/frames/20041020_MemriTV_Popup/video_480x360.asp?ai=214&ar=1050wmv&ak=null I hope this helps!
48. VERY BRAVE LADY
ISRAEL   (10.12.06)
SUPERB COMMENT. I AGREE 100%. KEEP IT UP
49. WAFA SULTAN
JERUSALEM   (10.12.06)
WELCOME TO ISRAEL AND SPREAD THE GOOD WORD!
50. A Courageous Lady !
Ivo Jacome ,   Ramat Gan/Israel   (10.12.06)
Mrs. Sultan should be commended by human rights group and be invited for lectures in schools and universities. A brave lady indeed ! May G-d bless her and keep her unharmed.
51. NR - your two small points and Islam
BouSameer ,   Beirut Lebanon   (10.12.06)
1. Thanks for your remarks. Am not sure if it is "Far right wing" not "right wing as you mentioned"). I may be wrong. There is however a growing curent in the US who aims at demonizing Islam. They also tend to have particular political affiliations. Check jihadwatch.com and frontpage magazine for a feel. Whether "leftist" values are discordant with Islam, I don't think it is due to the essence of what you call left, or that it discords with Islam exclusively. If you mean Communism, it is discordant with all religions. As to women, yes 100%. These are some of the things that should be definitely reformed. But these are deeply ingrained cultural issues, not just religious. For instance, many Moslem families are secular, yet the women is still not as independent as she should be, even in this segment of society. 2. a. Yes, I agree. There is religious freedom in Israel. However non Jews, previously living in the land of Palestine/Israel do not have the right of return to Israel, as opposed to jews from the ex Soviet Union. To me, this make the "Religious Freedom" you mention somewhat fake. b. I believe that Saudi Arabia is the country where only Islam is allowed as religion. In all other countries, you can definitely vote irrespective of your religion. c. Under Islam, except for few historical instances, three religions were allowed to practice in "Relative" peace. This could not be said about the Catholic Church in relation to Jews. But to wrap all up, yes, the practice of islam should and must be reformed. But not the Wafa Sultan way...
52. Daniel 21. Should she represent the Moslem world, you say?
BouSameer ,   Beirut   (10.12.06)
Euh.. I thought she thinks that Muslims are sick to the bones, and mental retards.. Sure she should be representing them...
53. God protect this woman from the forces of evil.
Daisy ,   USA   (10.12.06)
We should all pray for this courageous and Godly women.
54. Waffa Sultan deserves a Nobel prize!
Sara ,   Israel   (10.12.06)
Waffa Sultan deserves a Nobel prize! She is the bravest lady in the whole world! If Muslims start listening to her, instead of to their fanatic leaders- there will be peace prevailing for eternity in the Middle East . She is most courageous and dignified fighter for the victory of Reason !!! Sweden should award her a Nobel prize- but the Swedes act exactly like Chamberlain cconcerning the fanatic Islam!
55. A million dollar question to Wafa Sultan..
BouSameer ,   Beirut Lebanon   (10.12.06)
Would you ever see a western TV station (or Israeli one) inviting someone just like Wafa Sultan, shouting out loud what he/she thinks about Judaism? I mean just like Jazeera invited Wafa Sultan for a debate... Probably not... Makes me wonder why?
56. She's a brilliant, smart and very aware woman
Israel   (10.12.06)
Good luck to her!
57. #55-u r an ignoramus and yo question
svietka ,   eli-shomron   (10.12.06)
is not worth even a $1 cause it takes 20sec of my time to answer it. If u have access to Isr.TV(which i doubt - since u r probably in a dark cave with a pot for pissing)and if u have ever watched CNN and BBC and some other "western tv" there r constantly interviews with Jews and/or Israelis who not only openly critisize Jewdaism as a religion and as a nation but openly and UNAFRAID for their life critisize Israel as a country,Isr.government, and everything and anything else they can find to critisize..... God forbid u should read anything-but do everybody a favor and at least watch TV- and spare us yo silly questions.
58. It takes bravery to be a peaceful Muslim.
D- ,   San Diego, USA   (10.12.06)
Countries are after her. She is probably not even safe in the US. The agents of Islam have a global reach now, thanks to evil US policies (i.e. allowing any Muslims to ever come here).
60. yah right #36, Al Jazeera is really controlled by the Jews
#13 responding ,   NY   (10.12.06)
your stupidity is truly astounding! She is spreading her word, but it is directed at Moslems like you, not the Jews. The very point she made in her interview with Al Jazeera was that the Jews were not in need of reforming their behavior because they do not resort to violence when criticized, unlike the Moslems. Given the ludicrously cynical remarks you have made, it is clear that a brave and intelligent Moslem like Wafa Sultan has her work cut out for her!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article