News
US General: Strikes on Iran possible by 2007
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 12.10.06, 14:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
105 Talkbacks for this article
1. ultimate hypocracy
(10.12.06)
its better to strike israel first who have defied the international community...or is israel immune when the men in power are a bunch of hyporcrites.
2. He is right, there is nothing we can do alone.
Bechor   (10.12.06)
The sad truth is that even if we COULD mount an effective attack against Iran without help from the U.S., Israel would face enormous civilian and military losses. Iran's army is, in fact, larger in size than the entire Israeli population. If the other Arab states were to join with Iran in case of such a war, Israel would be forced to use its nuclear arsenal, and the international community would CONFISCATE ALL OF ISRAELS NUCLEAR WEAPONS as soon as the war was over. I read on ynet often of how everyone mocks and ridicules Iran - but I'm telling you now that they are no joke. Jews Unite www.globaljewishcommunity.com
3. to retired general
hayssam ,   ccanada/ottawa   (10.12.06)
how easy to talk like that...and talking is just talking...bush adminstration should leran few lessons from iraq and afghanestan and lebanon...i dont think israel or us need another swamp to fall in but to be honest with u i wish u dear guys and attack iran cuse thats going to be end of israel and end of american takeing over the world...
4. Strategy
Brod ,   USA   (10.12.06)
Good strategy. But it should be kept away from the media.
5. #1
avi ,   tel aviv Israel   (10.12.06)
There is a difference, Israel does not call for the destruction of any other country, Iran does.
6. #1 We dont hang people in public for being gay
(10.12.06)
or if you are a rape victim http://www.iranfocus.com/modules/news/index.php?storytopic=5 FYI, we dont finance international terror groups such as Hizballah and Hamas who blow up buses or shoot rockets, who teach their children death is more worthy than life.
7. Air wars
Stephen ,   Arizona   (10.12.06)
We have not yet realised that an air campaign will not win a war. Bombing targets in a country will not destabilise any regime, even one as despicable as the Iranian regime. It unites a people behind their government and gives them a sense of personal resolve and sacrifice. Unfortunately, I think we're in a real tough situation by having expended our military ability and diplomatic equity in other areas, so a real threat like Iran is not so easy to handle.
8. to "ultimate hypocracy"
Dan ,   Tel Aviv   (10.12.06)
Well, if by "defying the international community" you mean not succumbing to the demands of the arab/muslim block in the UN, then you are right... But my friend, ultimately, Israel is on the side of good which is against an evil force that you are cleary as of yet unaware of. Open your eyes buddy, and become aware of what is going on around you...
9. Iran/Israel
Stephen Bukstein ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (10.12.06)
Israel should just take Iran, Lebanon and Syria out all at the sametime. I don't understand why we have to wait for the U.S.
10. a lot are saying that if israel didnt have wmd..
lior ,   haifa   (10.12.06)
so iran would`nt try to get them but the aim of iran is to destroy Israel and they know that if they would attack Israel they would disappear of the map so i wonder how stupid are them to attack israel. about offensive against nuclear reactors I belive that the USA should attack if they dont Israel should attack with a guarantee from the US that in case of a strike back from Iran the US will join the fight. by the way if israel strikes from air it is almost impossible it is not the same as it was with iraq nuclear reactor though israel has Dolphin submarines which can launch cruise missle (even with nucleaer heads) that can hit the target this is an option that is more worth checking and i belive the IDF has plans about using this option. and for those who say how can israel even talk about disarming Iran`s nucleaer instituations while having their own. well lets not look at this that Israel is a democracy and Iran has all its power in one man`s hand. lets look at the fact that Israel would not attack any other country with wmd unless it is attacked by wmd or it is destroyed by conventional weaponery and I dont think that anyone of us belive that israel will be destroyted by conventional weapons (even if u arabs say u will).
11. 2#
lior ,   haifa   (10.12.06)
the iranian army is about 1.5m people, israel`s population: 6.9m, israel army size (with reservists): about 1.2m
12. Ultimate Hypocracy
Joe ,   Reading   (10.12.06)
The trouble I have with your argument is that unlike Iran who has clearly and demonstrably threatened Israels very existence, Israel has never ever threatened her neighbours. There is no apology anyone can make for Israels right to defend herself from this overt aggression. It is up to Iran.
13. How to stop Iranian revenge attacks
Steve G ,   Kew Gardens, NY, USA   (10.12.06)
A few things: 1) Israel's forces are not built to take out an entire country like Iran. 2) The U.S. has the firepower and planning to do this. 3) The U.S. has 130,000 troops and airbases within minutes of Iran. 4) It should be made clear to the Iranians that if they try to strike back after having their nuclear capacity eliminated, that their oil infrastructure will be totally destroyed. 5) Iran without oil is just another collection of mountains and deserts. Overthrowing the mullahs is essential to this, of course. Unlike Bush's adventure in Iraq, this one has to be well planned.
14. World-wide Appeasers
George ,   Atlanta, GA   (10.12.06)
is the biggest threat to the Western civilization. Face it: Islamists are effectively at war with us - they make no bones about it. But we are still long ways away from convincing our complacent majority that we must defend ourselves. If we do, there won't be a problem to win this whole thing decisively.
15. I BELIEVE THAT USA DON´T ATTACK IRAN NEVER
Jackson   (10.12.06)
it´s i think
16. #5 israel does not call but acts for destruction of all
fadi ,   lebanon   (10.12.06)
its neighboring countries.... so u have a point there is a basic diffirence.
17. #9 idiot ... u were not able to take hizbollah in 33 days ..
fadi ,   lebanon   (10.12.06)
the last two days of the war saw the highest casualties in israeli soldiers and highest number of rockets showering on israel ... Even till last day of war hizbollha were firing missilles 400 m away from border opposite to muttila settlement (video recorded on israelian tv) so wake up u idiot !!!! ur IDF clowns are the biggest joke of the 21st century !!!
18. To 17
(10.12.06)
Your obviously not that clever, instead of going into mass detail I'll put it like this. In southern lebanon Israel put about 10-15% of it's military strength. That strength was commanded EXTREMELY poorly. Think about this for a second, imagine if this same strength was commanded better or just doubled. I hope the realistion comes quickly, because it's not nice to write checks with your mouth that your ass can't catch.
19. To US general : shouldnt u deal with korea first !!??
fadi ,   lebanon   (10.12.06)
its so easy and simple just to brag and open ur mouth to say such foolshness... the plan is very nice on paper but in real life ...hmmm: 1. iran is not iraq which was devastated in 1991 gulf war then 12 years of embaargo 2. striking iran will lead to a missile shower on all israel and belive me shahab3 missile is not a katuysha 3. striking iran will lead to an all out war with iraqi shiaa population (60% of the population). So far the US has been fighting only sunni fighters (30% of population) and the result is a complete tragdy for US forces and will soon lead to defeat of US in iraq. 4. Military strike to iran will lead to a global war with russia and china. Iran is the major market for russian weapons. And iran is the main gas and oil supplier for the continuosuly growing and steaming chinese economy. China will in no way allow the US to take control of its main strategic oil supplier. 5. 24- 36 hours is fictous and deusional. Striking iran will lead to a war that will last for years and lead to oil prices of 120$ or more a barrel 6. Iran will block the persian/ arabic gulf for all oil shipments 7. Irans supporters will lead a world wide attack on all american interests. You call it terrorism we will call it self defense. 8.Syria and lebanon will join the war and will strike israel and american interests As long as the idiot Bush and his gang are in charge .. they will lead the world to complete destruction and armagedon.
20. Just Like Iraq
Peter Clark ,   Cambridge, MA, USA   (10.12.06)
Notice that the same group of people who sold us the Iraq war, with almost the same arguments (they are about to get the bomb; they are Israel's existential enemy; they are worse than evil; etc) are brazenly using the same arguments about Iran. It's ludicrous that we, as Americans, should allow our foreign policy to be hijacked!
21. #5
(10.12.06)
what about the State of Palestine.
22. #6
(10.12.06)
What about the 10s of thousand of kids killed by the IDF in the last 40 years? They didn't even have a chance to become sometone in life.
23. Lost of memory
(10.12.06)
Do not misuse the name of God. Do not murder. Do not steal. Do you remember this people of israel?
24. Just eliminate the threat
Duglarri ,   Canada   (10.12.06)
It seems that Iran, Syria, Lebanon, and beyond them, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Yemen, Indonesia, and who have I missed... are all overdue for regime change from the air, as all of these countries have the capability to pursue nuclear weapons and will at some point in the future. I look forward to Isreal dealing with all of them in turn. Who knows? Bomb enough people and maybe someone will like you.
25. # 20
Albert Bakker ,   Veendam, Netherlands   (10.12.06)
You as Americans have nothing to say about such things. Your politicians are bought and paid for, and where your youth will kill and get killed, lose minds and limbs is up to demented Fox generals to say. A public suffering from mad cow disease is merely allowed to applaud, that is if they can figure out where them damn hands went.
26. 20#,19#
lior ,   haifa   (10.12.06)
20# true but this time the whole world knows iran is building nuclear facilities not like in iraq. and to fadi u really belive china will strike the US? wow ur damn brainwashed. syria will probably help Iran with the US inavsion because they know that getting Israel into the war will make it harder to win (not that they can push back a Us invasion). heozbollah may attack israel from lebanon but this time israel learned from the last lebanon war and knows how to deal with heozbollah. and ready the whole article he said that 24-36 hours should be the first attack that will stop iran navy ,anti aircraft weaponery and etc... "7. Irans supporters will lead a world wide attack on all american interests. You call it terrorism we will call it self defense" didnt they already done that? "2. striking iran will lead to a missile shower on all israel and belive me shahab3 missile is not a katuysha " true this are not katyushas so "The Arrow" can fire them down and by 2007 israel will probably have the MITHEL system that can fire down katyushas. so please fadi dont delusion your self or others.
27. # 16
avi ,   tel aviv Israel   (10.12.06)
We do not attack countries that do not attack us. Example: we have peace with egypt and jordan. In reality Iran is the country that caused destruction of Lebanon by ordering the pointless aggression across an internationally recognized border. WAKE UP. The islamofascists have your brain.
28. Off his rocker!
PG ,   Boston, USA   (10.12.06)
Lieutenant General Thomas McInerney should stick to spending his retirement collecting stamps or whatever he does. Flaming the fans of war with Iran, will ultimately lead to Israel's destruction and will put an end to the United States as we know it if his "vision" comes into play. It is Israel who threatens Iran with over 200 nuclear weapons! Not the other way around. Attacking Iran is a suicide pact between the US and Israel. In the end, the warmongers will wail in agony when their house of cards falls upon them.
29. Peter Clark is talking about Jews
George ,   Atlanta, GA   (10.12.06)
here, but is too full of bullsh*t to spell it out. Meet the New Democrat-Soros-DailyKoz-Moveon.com-Jews Did It-left. If this is not big enough reason for the Jews to vote against Democrats, I don't know what is.
30. Iran will prevail!
Mohammad Panahi ,   Wichita, KS USA   (10.12.06)
No matter how evil the leaders of Iran are, this is no longer about politics. If Iran is attacked, all Persians (and other minorities) will unite and the US and Israel will experience hell like never before. We are tired of the US and Israel bullying the world around. It's about time, someone stands up. It would be a big mistake to attack Iran. If Israel is allowed to have illegal atomic weapons, why can't Iran have nuclear energy? Israel's government is just as evil and violent as the mullahs in Iran. Atomic energy is our national right!
Next talkbacks
Back to article