News
Families of Oct. riots victims: Israel worse than Nazis
Aviram Zino
Published: 15.10.06, 12:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
49 Talkbacks for this article
31. #29 You also speak from ignorance
Kate ,   Jerusalem   (10.15.06)
Until today there is little consensus on the definition of Facism. Prof Robert Paxton (Columbia U) defines it as: 1. a sense of overwhelming crisis beyond reach of traditional solutions; 2. belief one’s group is the victim, justifying any action without legal or moral limits; 3. need for authority by a natural leader above the law, relying on the superiority of his instincts; 4. right of the chosen people to dominate others without legal or moral restraint; 5. fear of foreign `contamination." 4 & 5 might well describe several Ultra-Orthodox groups in Israel. 1, 2, & 3 clearly define Hamas, much of the PA and most definately Hizbullah. But that is just one definition among several. Your definition, Jimmy of Glasgow, is a bit too thin to really describe anything.
32. Nazis used Muslims in WW2. Also great allies of MuftiHusseni
Alan ,   SA   (10.15.06)
33. # 7 - Absolutely
Israel   (10.15.06)
There is such a thing as a quiet orderly demonstration.
34. I think people forgot how the nazis were
Suzanne   (10.15.06)
35. #16 fadi
v. n.y. ,   usa   (10.15.06)
when you have something intelligent to say. when you can make sense and improve your broken english so all of us can understand you, when you start saying something smart for a change, then......we'll publish your comments. until then, crawl into your destroyed lebanon and read some history books and literature to sharpen your empty mind and increase your limited intelligence.
36. Straight forward
Miriam   (10.15.06)
One 12 years old palestinian in Jenin, throws a stone on IDF, he gets shot and killed. Gaza Settlers, throw stones, paint, chemicals, and beat IDF... they try to carry them to move them by their hands. Is this double standard and racism? Yes
37. #29 - I'm ready to learn - please explain
redmike ,   tel aviv & london   (10.15.06)
'A political philosophy, movement, or regime that exalts nation and often race above the individual and that stands for a centralized autocratic government headed by a dictatorial leader'. Forgoing is from Websters. Sounds close to Islam, rule by Sharia and Muhammed (the leader) to me. Please explain how you see Islam as different? thanks Michael
38. JANE-30
US ,   USA   (10.15.06)
and has your house with children in it been BULLDOZED- has a group on immigrants on US tax dollars swooped down on you land and kicked you off? Has your family been tortured in jails for years ? Have 25 meter walls been built around your town and your travel restricted-?/ YOU miserable old cow-- shut up. We ARE talking NAzi here.
39. Rioters and police self-defense
The Raccoon   (10.15.06)
When Islamistic rioters, screaming their desire to genocide the Jews, charge at police officers, I expect these officers to defend themselves. And frankly, I would expect the police to use live ammunition or anything else they have to survive. And then every rioter involved should have been arrested and tried for attempted murder, assaulting a police officer, incitement to murder, etc. These people are openly enemies of Israel and Jews - they call themselves Palestinians, they openly declare their hatred of Israel and their desire to have it destroyed. Why should we treat them as anything other than enemies?
40. #36
Rustum ,   London, UK   (10.15.06)
Well, Ms Jane, as you said "none of you have ever been burned in ovens", this begs the question "have you?". Obviously not - you are in the same boat as everyone else and co-opting the horrendous oppression to be part of only YOUR personal experience. In a world of sentient beings, we are all equally capable of understand the horrors of the holocaust. If people want to refer to that to describe present day activities - be they the actions of police in various countries, the army in varies countries - then sobeit. It is simply suppression of freedom of speech for you to disallow other people from expression their opinions. Your last line "freaking shut up, you miserable pigs" could well be a line spoken to POlish Jews by Nazi officials. See where suppression of freedom of speech gets you?
41. Islam is a Imperialistic Political Movement+a litle religion
Alan ,   SA   (10.15.06)
42. #40 - refers to #30. correction.
Rustum ,   London, UK   (10.15.06)
43. #38 ignorance
jerome ,   basalt, co   (10.15.06)
the house of a terrorist that just cilled innocent children should be bulldozed! Immigrants my ass Jews have been in Israel 3000 years plus before Islam was a so called religon of peace. Have you been to these jails where you claim they tourted somebody's innocent family? I didn't think so! I wonder why these walls have been built around the townand travel restricted?! Might have something to do with the sick murdering culter of homicide, suicide murders. No Islamic , Pali terror no wall, any fool can see that. Who's the miserable pig-cow? You know the anwser you low life.
44. Dumb thing to say
Jasmin ,   Haifa   (10.15.06)
By saying that Israel is "worse than the Nazis," People lose credibility. They either have *no* idea about the Nazis or just hate Israel so much they'll say anything.
45. They love to compare Israelis to Nazis
Elle   (10.15.06)
They think they are being clever with this unorigina,l far from reality comparison. BORING!
46. Trade in the "Israeli" arabs for gush etzion and be done....
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (10.15.06)
with this BS.
47. #35 at least we have history? can u tell me of US history?
fadi ,   lebanon   (10.15.06)
was ur great great great great great grandpa a crimnal? a prisoner? a thief? a rapist? who was freed from prison and sent to america to take part in the crusade to annihilate all the american indians !!!! or was ur father a slave who was sold to american whites? and til lthis day ur stil suffering from discrimination and trauma !!! Between the two options ill go for the first one as u have the arrogant idiotic spirit of yankees!!! Speaking of "broken english" ... is that a right phrase to use u idiot !!??? that shows how much ur intelectual and good at english urself .... Stupid moron !!!!
48. fadi U R an idiot
jerome ,   basalt, co   (10.15.06)
49. Here we go again
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (10.17.06)
If Israel were really like Nazis there wouldn't be any Arabs left in Israel to complain about Israel being "Nazis."
Previous talkbacks
Back to article