News
Tibi in Cairo: Israel committing war crimes in Gaza
Roee Nahmias
Published: 03.11.06, 01:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
44 Talkbacks for this article
31. Extra omnes!
Bancor ,   Genoa, Italy   (11.03.06)
Oh, yes, it's time to tell it clear and loud: extra omnes! What are these people doing, here? Is this land their home? They say: yes, it's their home! Arabs who live in Israel, who are Israeli citizens, say that this land is their home! At last, we may even agree (we are a reasonable people), but in this case, where their celebrated traditional arab hospitality did end? If we are at their home, their host's duty is TO GO AWAY, so we'll become the sole master of their land. Isn't it? Sorry, I'm caught by a sudden doubt: not that I'm wrong? Where is the error?
32. How to deal with MK who gives aide and comfort to enemy
bob ,   kiryat ata, Israel   (11.03.06)
Tibi gives aid and comfort to the enemy. In most countries this is a crime. What if the Syrian or Iranian or even the Egyptian MKs took it upon themselves to ally themselves with Israel and make trips here giving their insights on the workings of our government and supporting our policies against our enemies? How long would they be MKs? In fact, how long would they be alive?
33. Shin Beth best agent
Dr D ,   Jerusalem   (11.03.06)
Tibi is yes a spy but don't be mistaken . He is working for us and he is one of our best infiltrated agent. I am happy he is still alive as he always putk his life in danger to help the Shin Beth.
34. My comment was censored twice already
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (11.03.06)
Non-Muslims must have the right to speak out for freedom and human rights for Jews and other non-Muslims.
35. Yes, right!
NTI ,   Red Chili   (11.04.06)
“We dealt mainly with the IDF activity in Gaza,” Tibi told Ynet. “Kaddoumi described it as war crimes, and I agreed with him.” All criminals (muslim terrorists) detest those policemen (Israel) who brought them to justice.
36. WHAT A POLITRICIAL MESS THIS IS NO MOSES EITHER THIS TIME ??
M. Segal ,   Mpls America   (11.04.06)
I realize if the Arabs had any brains Israel would face a serious military situation fortunately the Arabs lack modern warfare technology but still even a idiot may make a nuclear weapon but it seems at least this once in Lebanon to some degree in Gaza too whatever the Arabs got may be contagious the Israelis may be catching this no know how wage war plague too who has it worse NOW ??? THANK YOU... M. Segal
37. God is watching
Raffy ,   England   (11.03.06)
How much more injustice can be allowed to go on in the middle east before people speak up? How can one side kill 4 times as many as the other side, occupy, steal more land, violate human rights, keep millions virtualy prisoners and still claim to be the victim? God is watching, do you honestly think you are good guys? deep down I think you know what is wrong and what is right.
38. My comment was censored three times
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (11.04.06)
39. war/peace
michael hall ,   Peru,USA   (11.04.06)
When a soldier has a foot across your throat, and he orders you to lick his boot, how can't you comprehend that the he glares at you with hate?
40. conflict
michael hall ,   Peru,USA   (11.04.06)
Are you not supposed to love your enemy as you love yourself? Isn't it written;"Thou shall not kill?" Whatgoes around comes around and in virtually 60 years, are we any closer to peace? Obvioulsy violence is not a tool that is effective.
41. My comment censored four times -Freedom of speech in Israel?
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (11.04.06)
42. To Raffy #37. Your Crocodile Tears.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (11.06.06)
In the 1920s the name ' the West Bank' was introduced for Judea and Samaria. So, the name ' the West Bank' did NOT exist before the 1920s. Judea and Samaria has been part of the Jewish Homeland since MORE than 2800 years. So, Raffy, when Israel recovers its own land, i.e. Judea and Samaria, it is NOT called "occupation", NEITHER is it called "stealing land". You write :"God is watching ..". God has better things to do than watching your crocodile tears. Hope everything is well with you.
43. To Michael #40. SOLE Monopoly For Using Violence.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (11.06.06)
You write :".. love your enemy as you love yourself". It is the DUTY of the Government of any state to protect its OWN citizens. In order to do that - the Government has at its disposal the Army and the Police force. THE Army is meant to protect the country from crossborder attacks. THE Police is protecting the citizens by going after criminals and thieves - inside the country. So, during Government service there is NO question of loving your enemy. Only AFTER leaving Government service for good - only THAN can the Government servant practice 'love your enemy'. BTW the Government of ANY country has the SOLE monopoly for using violence. When others use violence - it is illegal and thus they ARE punishable. Hope everything is well with you.
44. Tibi
Geoff ,   Bristol UK   (11.20.06)
After reading the majority of the talkbacks on Tibi it's easy to see why Israel is regarded with revulsion the world over.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article