News
Indian immigrants: Israel is our home
Miri Chason
Published: 21.11.06, 14:08
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
52 Talkbacks for this article
1. ynet, why don;t you show the video? pls, show the video
(11.21.06)
2. All the sudden, it is their land
atmawi ,   Historic Palestine   (11.21.06)
But, I lived here and my grands, grand grands as well do not have the right to travel from one village to another, What Justice is this.
3. look where they house them.not near tel aviv of course
tal   (11.21.06)
and only 1.5 million allocated to program.... you realize how little that is?
4. WELCOME
Megan ,   Israel   (11.21.06)
to you all.
5. sacrifice of safety for idiological fooloishness,
observation   (11.21.06)
6. Poor almawi
Arie ,   Afula   (11.21.06)
seeing his 'leadership' destroy what could have been a free and prosperous gaza. You have no one to blame but your fellow anarchist quranists.
7. #3 -
(11.21.06)
8. Bnei Menashe - A Warm Welcome
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (11.21.06)
The first good news I read in weeks. All 7000 of the Bnei Menashe are welcome as far as I'm concerned. Everything possible should be done to bring the rest as soon as possible.
9. #3 What a Kvetcher
(11.21.06)
It didn't say that $1.5m was allocated but that $1.5m was donated (by private donors). It is a beautiful thing that they were brought to Israel. Why look at everthing through S@%! colored glasses. BTW - How much did you donate?
10. INDIAN IMMIGRANTS ( FUNNNNY )
Justice ,   Palestine   (11.21.06)
You said indian immigrants , who believes that these belong to this land ? it's the same fake story of etheupian black jews , they arrived to live in Palestine land , in our Arab villages and cities . The black jews became slaves and hookers in Israel , also the same bright future will face those INDIANS.
11. VESHAVU BANIM LIGVULAM
(11.21.06)
Good for them. They are our brothers whose ancestors were exiled from Israel almost 3000 ago along with the other 9 tribes. They are coming back to historic Israel, the land of their forefathers. WELCOME HOME!
12. To # 3 and #10
Ilan ,   The world   (11.21.06)
Perhaps you should ask the parents and grandparents of the 1million Arabs who live in israel why they stayed and why your families screwed up and left. And then ask your leadership why they are continuing to screw you today. Just think if you were given the whole of Palestine instead of just Gaza. You'd burn the whole lot down in no time and have an even bigger problem-nobody to fire any rockets at. Then you might actually have to take some resonsibilty and do something for yourselves for a change instead of whining at everyone else. And then you can impliment your own law of return, expediting Palestinian returnees, but of course nobody who has been out of Palestine for too long like Lebanese or US Palestinians would be allowed in, because after such a long time, claims to return "home" are no longer valid.
13. #2 Yes this a the home of the Jewish people..
Yehuda ,   Israel   (11.21.06)
with its 3000 year long Jewish history in contrast to your fake 40 year old PLO-"Palestine" propaganda lies.
14. #2
eugene ,   israel   (11.21.06)
your palestinian tribe lost this land in 48, by trying to eliminate jewish state, by being senseless violent fools back then you lost the right for this land...and desperately trying to turn the clock back..which is not going to happen. all that was asked back then was to live in peace with the jews, you failed at that simple task and suffer to consequences.
15. Welcome home,brothers and sisters
trumpeldor ,   eurabia   (11.21.06)
16. #11 Snap out of your biblical illusions
Hani ,   Montreal, Canada   (11.21.06)
Has it not occured to you that Jewish ghetto life is a threat to your existence? Has it not occured to you that this small land has native people (Palestinians?). Where do you intend to house the Indians, employ them, feed them, etc? Their fate is that of the Russian immigrants: Acute identity crisis, criminal future, and a shameful return to their respective countries. STOP running away from your problems and address the conflict in the Middle East - because we all know this kind of immigration is only buying time in your lizard-size brain.
17. Stop lying to your Children
Hani ,   Montreal, Canada   (11.21.06)
No matter the size of this illegal Jewish immigration to historical Palestine since 1948, it will be futile to run away from your corrupt history founded on eviction of natives and the destruction of Arab towns and life. This flock of Indian Jewery will not add worth to your terrorist state. In the contrary, they will be treated just like the Ethiopians whose volunteered blood was TRASHED by hospitals recently. Get with the program, and start immigrating back to Europe or Uganda where the weather is fairer!
18. #13 This is the home of the Palestinian people
Hani   (11.21.06)
19. Hey Atmawi
leon ,   Grand Rapids USA   (11.21.06)
Yes, you've been living in Yehuda and Shomron, and calling it historic Philistia. Now end your occupation. KAHANE CHAI.
20. #10
Yehuda ,   Israel   (11.21.06)
1) Israel brought the Ethiopian Jews to live in freedom in Israel. As a contrast the Arabs were and are still involved in slavery and it is common knowledge that the Arab shejks abuse blacks as their "private slaves". 2) You are nothing but a fake people who try to steal a fake name "Palestine". Israel existed long before you Arabs came and will exist long after you will go home to Arabia.
21. Lieberman want to Expel Arabs to make Room the new socalled
!.5 Billion Muslims   (11.21.06)
I did not now Isreal was like UN , I though Jew was homogenius tribe , now days u see Arab Jews < black Jews , chinese Jaws and now Indian Jew . All u have to say u r Jew and Isreal will well come u and give u land of Palastian people , if all The people in thw world become the lost jews People and move to Isreal ,Palastian People will not go any where : Isreali talk about Peace , they will never get Peice until they Allow Palastain right to return to their original homes. Reality Check , world
22. It is justice for Am Yisrael #2, #13
Noam ,   Boca Raton, FL   (11.21.06)
Whether they are biologically descendants of lost Menashe tribe can be discussed but they are undoubtedly committed to joining the People of Israel and following the Torah, of which a major part involves living and loving the land of Israel. They are part of our people and it is just that they are returning to their spiritual epicenter. You must accept this reality Atmawi and Hani and realize that this is Allah's will. Bnai Yisrael is returning home and you can't do anything to stop it. You will only see more of us come home and you must be prepared to acknowledge it or their will be only future strife. They aren't even moving to West Bank but to sovereign recognized Israel so learn to deal with the unpleasant facts and try getting along for once. And I will be joining them too, in the future God-willing
23. Hani, how dare you preach your fascism from Canada!
Franck ,   France   (11.21.06)
Go back to your hole and fight Israel. Wait... You are a political refugee, way too risky, isn't it? ;)
24. palestininan
dana ,   ny   (11.21.06)
Yes it is the home of the Palestinian people- THE JEWS! not the Arab interlopers whose colonization putrified the land.
25. Palestinians are here! They won't disappear!
Hani ,   Montreal, Canada   (11.21.06)
26. To Benei "Palestine" (#2, 10)
Abu Arba ,   Riyadh   (11.21.06)
Please return to your historic homeland of Arabia. We have many many dunams of sand just waiting for you to resettle.
27. Not 'Bnei Menashe', Indian converts to Judaism
Jake   (11.21.06)
Just a fact.
28. Hani, Russian immigrants returned?
Jake   (11.21.06)
Oh, I think not. They are the most numerous community in Israel. You are lying to yourself and everyone else, but that is in your nature after all, since 600AD. But in the end, the sons of Adnan and Qahtan will return to the sand dunes in the deserts of Arabia.
29. Hani, there is STILL no such thing as a 'Palestinian people'
Jake   (11.21.06)
Such a thing did not exist in history. There has never ever been a people, nation, country, etc. called 'Palestine', and there is not today. You don't even have the letter 'P' to spell it in Arabic. It's all one big fraud. You think 200 Indian immigrants converted to Judaism will make any difference to the lands of the Arabs, stretching from Mauretania to the Gulf? Or deter the Arabs from their murders and conquests and conversion of 'infidels' in Sudan and Chad? Don't worry!
30. Arabs know very well 'Palestine' is made up
Jake   (11.21.06)
'Palestine' is a complete fraud, and the Arabs know it. The Arabs stole Jewish history; they stole Jewish lands; they stole the site of the temple and cave of the patriarchs in Hebron to deliberately erase Jewish claims. They turned Abraham into an Arab and Muslim, even though it is known his ancestral region is in North Mesopotamia, modern Kurdistan Turkey, and he never set foot in Arabia, and Arabs never set foot there until 650 AD when they invaded it. Arabs are simply JEALOUS, and that's why they hate Jews and Israel.
Next talkbacks
Back to article