News
New in Gaza: Priest, nun human shields
Ali Waked
Published: 22.11.06, 16:17
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
189 Talkbacks for this article
1. Great
Neo ,   Czech   (11.22.06)
I am too against violence, but there is violence and violence. Have any peace activist ever tried to shield (not only) Israeli women with children in bus or at market against suicide freedom fighter? This is different kind of violence. Israelis lose because they are civilised and value human lives. IDF should use the latest hi-tech dispersion means and then bomb the house. Or does anybody have any better idea?
2. Idiots!
Nora ,   Israel   (11.22.06)
3. the world is opening its eyes to see the truth
fadi ,   lebanon   (11.22.06)
4. the truth: of israel's ognoing crimes, massacres & onslaugt
fadi ,   lebanon   (11.22.06)
of unarmed palestenian civilians .. like the beit yahoun massacre!
5. Why doesn't she stand on a field in Sderot
LeoP ,   Moscow   (11.22.06)
If she is so adamant about protecting civilians from collective punishment why doesn't she stand in Sderot's school yards?
6. Pacifists
Mike ,   Atlanta, USA   (11.22.06)
If Jews had to rely on these people during the Holocaust, no Jew would remain on this earth. And they talk about "arresting" bombers. Unsurprisingly, Shimon Peres feels the same way. If Jews had to rely on Peres during...
7. the truth of israel's inetentional destruction of palestenia
fadi ,   lebanon   (11.22.06)
properties... houses, orchards etc... in order to drive palestenians out of Gaza and west bank!
8. the truth of world media manipulation, twsisting facts and
fadi ,   lebanon   (11.22.06)
covering up of israelian crimes against humantiy !
9. the truth that israel can get as barbaric as it wants but
fadi ,   lebanon   (11.22.06)
still it can not and will never be able to cut the palestenian peopel from their roots, their land or kill the palestenian resistance spirit !
10. shields
gil ,   ashkelon   (11.22.06)
Come and act the same way in Sdérot.Yu are welcome,and if yu could be hurt,we shall mourn on yr graves.
11. the truth that israel is a criminal terrorist state covered
fadi ,   lebanon   (11.22.06)
up by US veto at security council !
12. fadi crapping out his keyboard again
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (11.22.06)
13. If she is so concerned about the kassams
Ivri   (11.22.06)
She should go to sderot and form a very christian human sheild to protect jewish children.( and then go protect terrorists in Aza)
14. WHO ARE YOU FADI???
MIKE ,   UK   (11.22.06)
If you despise this so-called inhumane, war crime committing, racist, country so muc then why do you read its internet sites???
15. They're No Longer Considered Civilians: Kill Them
Yishai Kohen ,   YeShA, Israel   (11.22.06)
No matter WHO they are, no matter WHAT they are, if they are protecting terrorists, then they are fair game according to international law and according to simple logic and morality. OUR civilians- who ARE civilians, cannot pay a price for this perfidy. Kill these terrorist-supporters NOW and save our civilians.
16. human shields
charles ,   petach tikva   (11.22.06)
a new tactic ? The IDF should not give warnings anymore ! Maybe one general : Stay away from terrorist ! We will surely be condemned by UN and "human rights ? " organisations . so what , we have already a bad name .
17. things don't change
dana ,   ny   (11.22.06)
Deport them to Berlin!
18. # 14,,coz Fadi has no life(and no water..electricity etc)
Ivri   (11.22.06)
19. YNET HAS BECOME FADI'S NEWSPAPER
DEBRA ,   USA   (11.22.06)
WHY IS THIS JEWISH WEBSITE PUBLISHING HUNDREDS OF FADI THE LEBANESE NON-JEWISH TALKBACKS? I COME TO THIS SITE TO HEAR FROM JEWS. IF I WANTED TO HEAR FROM LEBANESE, I WOULD GO TO THEIR NEWSPAPERS. PLEASE, YNET STOP WITH FADI. HONOR THE JEWS WHO ARE TRYING TO TALKPACK AND READ YOUR NEWSPAPER.
20. Collaborators (Human Shields) of Terrorists ARE TERRORISTS!!
H ,   Jerusalem   (11.22.06)
Who are they to "instruct" the IDF what to do? IDF must show power once and for all. Instead of destroying their homes, they should kill them all. They're all the same group of terrrorists.
21. The truth according to Fadi
osdanman ,   BA, AR   (11.22.06)
The truth is that Fadi is devotee of Joseph Goebbels bad ways and an enthusiastic agitator.
22. To Neo from Czech
Paul ,   Phoenix, US   (11.22.06)
Does Neo stands for Neo-Nazi in your post? How can you murder children becuase their father is *suspected* of being a "terrorist"? This is kind of values Israelis represent? Well, good to know.
23. To H from Jerusalem
Paul ,   Phoenix, US   (11.22.06)
Now, nuns and priests are terrorists too, huh? Who is next?
24. # 14 are you stupid or just acting like one !?
(11.22.06)
what a silly question you are asking ! :)
25. #19 We come to this site only to hear from FADI
(11.22.06)
the rest are very boring.If they stop fadi's talkbacks,we won't come here no more. :P
26. Immoral To Give Terrorists Time To Block Mission
Adina Kutnicki ,   US   (11.22.06)
Let us be clear here - the warnings to the terrorists that a mission is about to take place is a complete violation of Israeli civil rights. Why? Because it allows the enemy and his family to remain alive even one more day to kill Jews. While they try and position themselves as a 'humane' and 'moral' army, this moniker is nonsense. They protect the guilty at the expense of the truly innocent. When one is merciful to the cruel, one ends up being cruel to the merciful. Tell me, is THAT moral and just?
27. New in Gaza: Priest, nun human shields
Ilya ,   Salem, USA   (11.22.06)
IDF would be stupid if they stop killings and destroying homes of HAMAS (and other terrorist groups)operatives. If there are idiots in this world ready to die for terrorists so be it. It does not matter who those people are - nuns or priests - they protect terrorosts and I consider them as such. With their twisted minds they do not belong here. Believe me, ones IDF kills couple of them they will dissapear like flies.
28. If they would stand in front of suicide bombers
Russel ,   Tlv   (11.22.06)
... but we know they won't. The IDF tells people they are going to be hit , while palestinians sneak into our cities to blow themselves up without regret. If only these priests and nuns had the courage to defend our supermarkets, restaurants and nightclubs as do our security services we could beleive they were for peace ... but I guess they won't be doing that soon, eh? True terror is a bit much for the do-gooders to handle? Go home and pray for peace!
29. Israel's actions unpopular, but inevitable
owl ,   boulder, USA   (11.22.06)
The situation surrounding the "Palestinian/Israeli" issue is not that at all, and to characterize it this way is what causes all the grief. Instead, this is the "State Bureaucracy/Arab pawns" issue. Israel is a "state," a political mechanism that operates as all political mechanisms do: toward it's own interests. Imagine this: in the USA, there is a small city, called Berkeley, it is next to a large city, called Oakland. Berkeley is filled with upper middle class intellectuals, who are predominantly white and chinese, Oakland is filled with underclass poor black people. Now, what if the black folks decided they'd "had enough" of Berkeley's basically racist, economically superior setup, and once every five days, another angry, disenfranchised black person rode a bus up to Telegraph Ave (there are only three major North-South streets in Berkeley) and BLEW UP. I GUARANTEE you that there would be a wall and some decidedly racist security forces manning it at 51street (the basic dividing street between the poor and the rich). Would it be the "whites and Chinese" vs the "blacks?" NO WAY: it would be "Berkeley City Government" vs "Oakland City Government." Sure, there'd be racists in the mix, but they are only secondary to the newly created situation based on a few individuals' earlier actions. The situation has quickly devolved from personal anger to one in which bureaucratic forces take over the bulk of the fighting, and the issues become entrenched on a political, not a social level. Until massive international cooperation to bring money, food and education to both the Palestinians and Israelis occur, this situation will continue indefinitely. As long as the USA, Iran and Syria embrace military solutions to intractable social issues, these wars will continue, committees on all sides will continue to authorize force, and good men and women will rationalize suppporting these policies on all sides.
30. idiots
DK ,   ATLANTA US   (11.22.06)
Not terrorists. Idiots. Too dim to understand that they are taking sides. I have been impressed with the restraint that the IDF has shown, however.
Next talkbacks
Back to article