News
Lieberman: The unfaithful cannot be citizens
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 10.12.06, 20:58
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
94 Talkbacks for this article
31. Lieberman is 100% correct
Darren ,   Tampa, FL USA   (12.10.06)
32. Mr. Lieberman is 100% correct!!!
jack aisner ,   new york   (12.10.06)
It's about time someone with some "balls" to tell it the way it is. His way is y the way for the survival of the state of Israel.
33. Neturei Karta!
Dovy ,   Toronto   (12.10.06)
Now there we go! The impact of a tiny group of anti-Zionist activists has Herr Lieberman all riled up! Amazing, no?!
34. Jews should lay claim to all of palestine...
Micha   (12.10.06)
We are the original palestinians. Yes, JEWS are Palestinians. I think it's time we adopt that name to correctly assert what is ours. We are the true Palestinians. We are, we are, we are. That's right. Time for you to let go of our land. Off now, off, off. WE ARE THE TRUE PALESTINIANS. AND I WANT THE ARABS OFF MY RIGHTFUL PROPERTY. NOW!!!!!! GIVE ME MY PROPERTY BACK. SYRIA MUST GO. IRAN MUST GO. JORDAN TOO. THEY ALL MUST EVACUATE NOW. YOUR LEADERS TOLD YOU TO EVACUATE 60 YEARS AGO SO THAT WHEN YOU RETURN YOU WOULD BE LIVING IN YOUR HOMES AND THAT OF THE JEWS. GUESS WHAT????? THEY WERE WRONG!!!!! THAT'S RIGHT. YOU LOST THE WAR. MOVEON.COM
35. here we are
toni ,   sabme   (12.10.06)
who is acitizen of any 'country' . tried to exspess himself as someone who is what? where is the exclamation points around that statemet. jounalism has no place for that . they report what they are told from sourcses. and a direct comment should be shown. but that being said it is still better than the alternative. what is the alternative??anyone?
36. He is 100% right
jay ,   Israel   (12.10.06)
He says that those who are not faithful to Israel cannot expect to have full rights ....................does this include Olmert?
37. #13 - democracy as we knew it has ended !
redmike ,   tel aviv & london   (12.10.06)
Perhaps we and others need to be less democratic If France maintains its present system then it will become a Muslim dominated country within 20 - 25 years and its democracy will be replaced by Sharia. And France is by no means alone and several other European countries will quickly follow unless they become less democratic. It is a joke (not a funny one) that in Israel we have MKs whose stated aim is the annihilation of Israel. They travel to countries that are at war with Israel and openly plan its destruction. They break laws that were introduced to specifically to prevent this behavior and as of now have suffered no consequences. It would appear urgently necessary for Israel and other countries that are having their democracies undermined and used against them to recognize that democracy is inherently flawed and therefore become less ‘democratic’. If we carry on with the present government there will soon be no country to govern. The left, in recent years have done Israel a terrible disservice.
38. then Lieberman and other Israeli leaders are illegal !
(12.10.06)
but how can he call Neturei Karta extrmists? are they Israeli citizens ?
39. Lieberman to diaspora: how much you pay for extracitizinship
(12.10.06)
40. Mistake
charles ,   petach tikva   (12.10.06)
To anon #5 and..... I read this to hastfully . He is not become crazy . No reason to thrust him anyhow . In other interviews he talked about "tranfer" , for us a very bad souvenir . Remember 40-45 , transfer nach osten .....
41. Lieberman
charles ,   petach tikva   (12.10.06)
And what is his solution for this situation ? And , all who support him , what is your solution ? Lieberman has not given yet how he will attain peace in this region . It's again saying :this is bad , Olmert go home , we need another one . And then ? doe's Lieberman have a magic formula ?
42. #38 Not really, they dont pay taxes and dont recieve welfare
(12.10.06)
So in reality, they are already non citizens, they dont vote, they dont pay taxes, they really have just an autonomony on Mea Sharim (thats the ONLY place they are located) and they stay there 24/7/365. They are an insane group that every single Jewish organisation in the world from reform to Chabad to Orthodox to everyone has signed that they are mostly "banished" from Judaism. There is no truth to their way of thinking. They dont recieve any stipends or any benefits from the state son on the dotted line, they are already non citizens, that ends that affair. Now, regarding Arabs........
43. #41 You are a smart man
(12.10.06)
Look at the way from the beginning of the newest formation of Israel (48) to now, its all about "peace" and containing the terrorists. We and you and the rest of the Israelis KNOW where the terrorists are, we KNOW where they are getting their arms, we know SO MUCH. BUT BUT BUT, we dont act, we are always in every situation trying to remain status quo, to contain, to put a bandaid. We have NEVER said "we have a right to this country and thats final", we have never done a all out full war against the PA to liquidate the terrorists, just the same blowing up empy houses with bombs in it. You want peace, get rid of your enemies, stop calling the terrorists to leave their houses, STOP APOLOGIZING, stop kissing up to the goyim, do what must be done and do not regret it, stop acting as if Israel is a colony of the US of A. First things first, one must preach these sentiments. The world will never ever no matter how many Jews win nobel prizes, no matter how many discoveries/inventions/etc we create, the world will always be against us, and fine, who needs them. Reclaim This Land As Your Own, Be A Proud Jew, A Proud Israelitte AND YOU WILL HAVE PEACE AM YISRAEL CHAI!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
44. 100% true
Natan ,   USA   (12.10.06)
I agree 100% with Lieberman. It is not about territories, it never was. If this was the case, why wasn't there peace prior to 1967??? PL was established in 1964, what were they trying to liberate???
45. The NEXT PRIME MINISTER
Richard ,   Los Angeles, CA   (12.10.06)
Finally, someone gets it!!!
46. #34 Here's your prescription...
Hani ,   Montreal, Canada   (12.10.06)
A Reality Slap on the face 1 Good history book 1 set of binoculars (look towards what is left of Palestine) 1 Good night sleep .... Feeling better?
47. What Lieberman suggests
Vitaliy ,   it's immaterial   (12.10.06)
Charles and others, who don't know what Lieberman essentially suggests. His plan is not to transfer Arabs out of Israel, but instead to... 1. Move the border so that settlements (the big blocks) become Israel and the area of the Triangle becomes "Palestine". 2. All citizens (Jews and Arabs) must give an oath of allegiance to the Jewish Zionist state of Israel to have voting rights. (those Arabs that do not support Israel as a Jewish state can't vote, those who decide to visit Damascus or Lebanon before peace agreement are traitors). 3. Those who do not pledge allegiance become residents (with no voting rights).
48. Jews from USA
Elokim ,   Israel   (12.10.06)
You speak without knowing the outcome or results of the decisions made. You state #22. "If some Americans acted like the Israeli Arabs they would be locked up for treason. Richard" If this happened they would have given this persona seat in the White House, not a cell in prison. and #23. "Lieberman is 100% correct. The Arabs get benefits from Jews and they still want to destroy them in their own land. Barry". The Arabs get benefits from Israel. A country that stole the land from beneath their feet. It would not be called benefits...it's more like compensation. If Israel is looked at like a foe in the eyes of the US. Will the same Jews move out to live in China? Will the US kick them out? I think not...so why think the same in Israel. It is the 51st state of the US....
49. "American (15)," we call you a David Duke Anti-Semite.
sk ,   USA   (12.10.06)
50. #12 and others - the US is doing many good things in Iraq !!
redmike ,   tel aviv & london   (12.10.06)
http://www.yearinbrazil.com/misc/iraq.txt
51. The Arab world is pitiful, terrorist and hateful
Don ,   USA   (12.11.06)
52. The Jews of Israel stop giving the Arab haters of Israel
Barry ,   USA   (12.11.06)
what they cannot get in their tragic Arab states: First rate medical care World -class education and all other benefits. Let them get it from their Arabs brothers. They will never be satisfied with anything the Jews/Israel give them.
53. The Jewish land of Israel will expunge the enemies
Diana ,   USA   (12.11.06)
regardless who they are.
54. Long Live Lieberman! G-d Bless him!
Michael ,   USA   (12.11.06)
55. charles (40, 41), you have to get over misapplied
sk ,   USA   (12.11.06)
Holocaust comparisons. The Arab killers, who have a direct connection via Arafat (a relative of the Mufti of Jerusalem) to Hitler himself, want another Holocaust. Recognizing this, and treating "Palestinians" on both sides of the Green Line as what they are, makes perfect sense. Your desperation for peace makes no sense, as it has led only to war. You need to learn this, charles. Israelis seem to have no problem transferring Jews; they should have no problem transferring Arabs. Indeed, the so-called "Israeli Arabs" (who overwhelmingly see themselves as "Palestinians") really are, by and large, a Fifth Column. I agree though that Israel should start with transfer of the official "Palestinians" to their proper homes (Egypt, Jordan, Syria, etc.)
56. Lieberman for Prime Minister of Israel!
Daisy ,   USA   (12.11.06)
57. YES, u are right natan
Carlos Rojas ,   Honduras   (12.11.06)
YES u are right Natan! Liberman is 100% right
58. CITIZENS CANNOT BE UNFAITHFUL OR EXTERMINATED
NEW RULES ,   ..............DACON9   (12.11.06)
59. 90% of US Jews will be deported
truth   (12.11.06)
If we follow this racists logic we should deport 90% of American Jews who put Israeli interest ahead of US interests.
60. LIeberman is a racist thug
Greg ,   USA   (12.11.06)
LIeberman is nothing more than a racist thug. Shame on Olmert for putting him in the government, and shame on all those who support him.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article