News
Iran: Hitler was a Jew
Dudi Goldman
Published: 02.01.07, 09:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
234 Talkbacks for this article
61. Excommunicate Hitler makes no sense
William ,   Takoma,United States   (01.02.07)
Hitler was not a Roman Catholic, so the Pope could hardly kick him out of that church. The Pope doesn't have any authority over non-Catholics and not that much over Catholics. It would have made about as much sense for Jewish leaders to expell him from that faith, and I don't recall reading about that either. Further, Hitler might have been raised as a Christian, but he certainly didn't end up as one.
62. hitler a jew
burton poole ,   columbia city   (01.02.07)
so what,it"s a moot point people who cant get there ass out of the past have no vision for the future and are therfor a moot person
63. Amadinedjad
Charlie ,   NY, USA   (01.02.07)
He is definitely a strutting little psychopath with his sights set on destroying much of the sane world outside of Iran. And I doubt that Adolph Shickelgruber(aka Hitler) intended to do anything positive for Israel or the jewish people. But inadvertently or not, Hitler's new government in the 1930s did begin a program of deportations to Palestine with the cooperation of England. The true intent and scope of this program may not yet be fully revealed or discussed.
64. Ahmadinejad
Bill Henderson ,   Austin, TX USA   (01.02.07)
I think he was Jewish just for the jokes.
65. He thinks he discovered this???
Imhotep ,   Netherlands   (01.02.07)
Sorry fellows, this is very old news and it aint even right. Hitler's father was a jew he srewed his mother and the divorced her, then adolf got mad ad his father and the jews. The american's helped adolf to get the power of germany, by giving him money, they also wanted to get rid of the jews. Then when the war was going for 3 years, and he got to powerfull, the americans came to europe. offcourse the damage was allready done.
66. SO?
Cris ,   Indianapolis, USA   (01.02.07)
OK, we all know that Ahmadinajad will say anything to brainwash his people and motivate them to hate Israel. But I find this latest comment of his to be very odd. So what if it's true? It doesn't change anything!! I don't care if Hitler was a purple, one-eyed alien from Jupiter...that was over half a century ago! The reality is that TODAY Israel is a vaiable, stable democracy in the midst of a bunch of unstable, unviable thug dictatorships. Long live Israel!!
67. We are all Jews
Splash Laptop G4   (01.02.07)
1. Genetically, everyone alive today has some connection to Mohammed, they say. 2. Arabs and Jews all descend from Abraham, and therefore are all related. 3. Judaism and Islam have common roots, because there was a time before either existed, wherein the roots of their religions were growing. 4. The day whill come when Sunni and Shiite Moslem's will see themselves as different religions and begin to be in conflict. 5. Oh, wait. they already are. 6. So isn't it patently obvious that: a. we areally are all brothers and sisters; b. violence is incredibly stupid and short sighted; c. religion and government should never mix; d. and it matters not one whit if Hitler was a jew, because he was likely certifieably nuts also, a characteristic he shares with far too many iranian (et al) leaders.
68. Christians behind Israel
S. Hoover ,   USA   (01.02.07)
This nut from Iran is starting to breakdown mentally. He has gone so far off the deep end no one can safe him now. I will always support Israel and it's people, not because I am a Christian but because I am a human being and it is the right thing to do. God bless Israel.
69. Power
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (01.02.07)
Isn't it just great to know that two words - "Jews" and "Israel" - give 1.4 billion asshats horrible nightmares, while they sleep, and the cold sweats, while they're awake? That, my Jewish friends, is real power.
70. Iran PM
JK ,   NYC   (01.02.07)
He is a crazy insane from a thoughtful intelligent western point of view on the level with Saddam Hussein but Hilter was, from a psychological understanding could have thought himself Jewish and like so many converted and self hating Jews seek to destroy the Jewish people, look at Robert Novak and all those Opus Dei crazies, look at the Jew for Jesus nuts or Israel's own Chareidi haters who want to blot out Torah and its observers as surely as Hilter. Saying Hilter was Jewish certainly lends clearer understanding to cutting off Teman peyes but supporting the Kibbutz Bar Mitvah festivus (pagan and Hilter Youlth-like) and denying funds to Yeshivas while funding Yoga. Yes Hilter was a Jew hating Jew.
71. Eastern Wisdom Teachings
joe ,   tashkent   (01.02.07)
Actually.. according the Eastern Wisdom Teachings - that lie back of the whole New Age Movement.... Hitler and his "disciples"... were all reincarnated Jews. Engaged in the process of periodic culling of your race. Something that happens with regularity throughout your history... for SOME esoteric reason. Go ask your Rabbi or some Kabbala expert to explain why. I wonder when the next round starts... because you guys SURE haven't been working hard at making friends with your neighbors for the last 60 years.
72. kHOMAINY AND AHMADINEJED'S ARE JEWISH TOO.
rOBIN   (01.02.07)
OR MONKIES UNCLE?
73. give DinDin a rope long enough and he will hang himself
Squashy ,   Washington DC USA   (01.02.07)
I hope the Iranian people wake up and boot this bogeyman out of office. Hope they are not too chicken to stand up for truth.
74. Noone is a Jew unless they practice judaism
Gianni ,   Prague, Czech Rep.   (01.02.07)
Jews are not a race. Judaism is a religion, so if someone's parents are practicing jews and you are a christian or muslim in faith, you are not a jew. Its amazing to me how many people think jews are a race of people....most are Khazars and not true jews. Read more my friends
75. Jews ...
Bereleh ,   Canada   (01.02.07)
I also laughed when they said the Bolsheviks were Jews and murdered their own. If this article comes to be proven true sometime down the road, it looks like the Jews are the biggest enemies of the Jews. We don't have much to fear from Gentiles.
76. Michael3k, Shia , Jews and unclean things
Marhaba ,   Lebanon   (01.02.07)
***Does not his new religion, Shiite Islam, class the Jews with unclean things, like menstruation fluids and the sweat of camels, who must stay indoors during the rains, so the feet of the pure are not polluted? *** Come on Michael3, be real, I have never heard of such ridiculous things before. Can you please provide us with references, or did you just make that up?
77. Oui Vey
NoSmallStir ,   United States   (01.02.07)
... in the words of Rodney King, that great man from Los Angeles... Can't we all just get a long... in truth. God help us all... these leaders need brain surgery.
78. Get this guy a late night comedy show
Carl ,   Richmond, Virginia   (01.02.07)
79. Ahmadinejad aid/Hitler
(01.02.07)
This dysfunctional family warring has been going on ever since Abraham treated his first born son, Ishmael by Hagar, like a second class citizen, sending both away after Sarah's jealousy. Ishmael was half brother to Isaac, son of Abraham and Sarah, but Isaac was honored as true son. This set things up for all future jealousy/revenge hatred between the two groups and it continues til today. It's actually brother killing or hating brother. It's wedded to the psyche of these folks.
80. who is laugng now?
H ,   The Netherlands   (01.02.07)
Let's nuke Iran.. wipe them out.. and call our self Moslims...
81. Exposing the PM of Iran's disguise
Donald ,   Richmond, USA   (01.02.07)
Clearly the Iraqi Minister of Information, Muhammed Saeed al-Sahaf has given up his job as a TV talking head for Abu Dhabi TV and has reinvented himself as the prime minister of Iran. It looks like he got a pretty good plastic surgery job, but it doesn't fool me.
82. Job suggestion...
Ijustlaugh ,   Louisville, USA   (01.02.07)
Ahmadinajad should run for the Democratic Presidential nomination. He's just as lunny. Well almost.
83. ...
Jesse ,   Waikoloa, HI   (01.02.07)
If I remember his aunt was jewish, he was not born into judaism. One thing I am waiting for him to be all christians and muslims are jews also. Christians are praying to God which is from Judaism. Jesus was a jew. Christians are following a jew. Muslims are pretty much jews also they pray to the same god.
84. layin' the groundwork....
candheat ,   usa   (01.02.07)
Ahmadinejad has made several comments alluding to the destruction of the jews, which make no mistake is his intention. His rhetoric until now and this latest act is no different than what Hitler himself did, which is using propaganda to change the people's perception of the jews (a plan which is working- just ask mel gibson.) Painting Hitler as Jewish is simply another item on the list of a calculated, long term plan to alter the world's perception of the Jews before he carries out his final plans. He even said something along the lines of, "don't say you weren't warned," which is EXACTLY what Hitler did before he bagan exterminating. Hitler even offered to send the jews on luxury liners to other countries, including the U.S., but all declined. Ahmadinejad has already called for the Germans to give them land. It's as if he has the Hitler playbook. Also, Let's not forget the key role that Iran played in the starting of the last Israel/Lebanon conflict, and how Israel took a public perception beating despite being attacked first. Unlike other nuclear enemies we have, mutually assured destruction has kept peace. In this case, not so. If his last act on this earth is destroying israel, he'll press the button and get ready for the land of 72 virgins. He's no different than a suicide bomber, he's just looking for a bigger bomb.
85. Hitler
D Christie ,   New York   (01.02.07)
You wrote -- Just when you thought the Iranian leadership could stoop no further: A top advisor to Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad claimed in an interview with Iranian website Baztab that Nazi leader Adolf Hitler's parents were both Jewish and that Hitler himself was one of the founders of the State of Israel. -- We readers prefer to determine what's "stooping to a new low" for ourselves. We don't need you to do it for us. Looks like it's back to Journalism 101 for you. This time, do some homework.
86. Let me get this straight . . .
C. Layne ,   Houston, Texas, USA   (01.02.07)
Let's see if I understand. Previously, this "educated" college professor turned president of Iran denied the occurence of the holocast! That in and of itself seems a bit "uneducated". But now he's changed his mind and admitts the event. Further, he claims that Hitler was Jewish and that it was Hitler's self-hate of his lineage that led to the killing of so many . . . ??? . . . What a guy. Seems like a real rocket scientist to me. . . . . and to think he's actually running country.
87. Ridiculousness
Peter ,   My Town, USA   (01.02.07)
I'm still waiting to see anything truly negative produced against Ahmadinejad that is not propaganda. The propaganda express -- first on Iraq, now against Iran -- is clear and obvious. Why people buy into this nonsense is beyond me. Blind nationalism? Pride and arrogance? Plain ol' stupidity? I don't know. All I know is people don't think for themselves anymore. Most are born on a bandwagon and die on one, never thinking or discriminating for themselves. Ahmadinejad's writings are some of the most well-articulated I have ever seen. They beat out MLK Jr's. writings, in my opinion. Until real evidence (not war propaganda or the oft-parroted "wipe Israel off the map" out-of-context quote) can be produced to the contrary, I must conclude that the man is sincere and is NOT out to destroy Jews. If he was, then Iranian Jews would all have been in deep caca long ago. Israelis (Zionists, specifically), are, in my opinion, being the liars and instigators here.
88. Ahmadinejad's Lastest Assertions
Not given ,   Not given   (01.02.07)
These asertions about Hitler's mother and grandmother make me wonder about Ahamadinejad's assistant's mother and grandmother. Perhaps Ahamadinejad and his assitant are projecting their own issues onto this Historical figure. Maybe this fear of promiscuity is why so many muslims beat their women and force them to cover their faces. The threat of promiscuity makes them very insecure it seems. Maybe they all have tiny you know whats.
89. Late Night Comedy?
Donald ,   Richmond, USA   (01.02.07)
Richard - A terrific idea! I think this guy is really the former Iraqi Minister of Information. The plastic surgery works pretty well for him, but as the PM of Iran, there's no hiding the Minister of Information's ability to state the absurd with an absolutely straight face. Too bad he also now aspires to have nuclear weapons. Apparently they left him under the anesthesia a bit too long.
90. laughable but not for nuclear
2.4 Billion Christns ,   1/3 of all humanity   (01.02.07)
"trust us!" they say, "we know what we are doing!" they say. most outlandish things are said by them and stil they say to trust them with bomb! idiots!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article