News
PRC: We are ready to keep Shalit for years
Associated Press
Published: 09.01.07, 13:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
16 Talkbacks for this article
1. Israel must admit that it has captured 10,000 Pals
Nashvel ,   Boston   (01.09.07)
No one including kidds would beleive that ALL 10,000 Pals are terrorists !!! Israel needs to release prisoners and most important is to END it's long lasting occupation to the west bank.. ENOUGH BLOODSHED ISRAEL..
2. Don't believe anything from these animals
Tam   (01.09.07)
3. Come on Israel
Atilla karagözoğlu   (01.09.07)
for one time, you also forgive your prisoners. Let Them Go. If you catch them with wrong again, do what ever you want. Let Them Go, Israel. MAKE A NAME FOR WORLD. and make Shalit's mother happy with other mothers. Come on Israel. do that.
4. We're Wasting Our Time.
Terry ,   Eilat - Israel   (01.09.07)
Negotiations to free Shalit are a waste of time. The right strategy is to begin arresting Hamas & Fatah political leaders including Haniyah. No negotiations & no prisoner release - let the Palestinian leaders rot in prison until Shalit is released. And I'm sure we could think of other means to apply pressure & keep increasing the pressure. This is all a sham - Hamas knows where Shalit is & so does Abbas & we are being taken for suckers.
5. #3 atilla (the Hun)
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (01.09.07)
The prisoners held by Israel are TERRORISTS and MURDERERS, like the uber-bitch, Amuna Mona who cold-bloodedly plotted and lured a 16-year-old Israeli boy to his death. Releasing them will not only give them the opportunity to KILL and KILL again, but will guarantee MORE KIDNAPPINGS now that hostage taking is proven to be an effective method of getting what you want. The fact that Hamas has refused to give any proof of life and has not allowed Red Cross access to visit the hostage ACCORDING THE INTERNATIONAL LAW THEY WHINE SO MUCH ABOUT, makes me believe that Shalit may already be dead.
6. Mind games
Israel   (01.09.07)
They don't care if they never see one of the prisioners in our jails. They are playing mind games with us, a mental torture if you like because they know we care about life and our soldiers.
7. we have to wait for mr abbas
Ure ,   Tel-aviv   (01.09.07)
If Israel signs the deal now it means it will have to let free all the tens of Palestinian Hamas Ministers and MPs it kidnapped following the capture of Gilad. This will surely not be good news for Mr Abas and Dahlan. Therefore, unfortunately, Gilad and his Family must endure more of this "unnecessary waiting even if this means putting Gilad's life in danger" until the time is right for Abbas and Dahlan!
8. #6 you're weird.
Khalid   (01.09.07)
"They don't care if they never see one of the prisioners in our jails. They are playing mind games with us, a mental torture if you like because they know we care about life and our soldiers." Umm, did you ever think that maybe they care about their prisoners just as much as you care for yours? Woulnd't that make more sense than your strangely complex "mind-games conspiracy" logic??
9. release Shalit
tma   (01.09.07)
It's been done in the past and there's no reason why it shouldn't be done now. I dare anyone who has a son in the army to keep insisting Israel shouldn't release prisoners for Gilad. He's been prisoner long enough. He's only a kid for G-d's sake! Have a heart! Do anything to release him. Let's give him a chance to start living again. Who knows what he had to endure and is still enduring with these monsters!! RELEASE GILAD SHALIT!!!
10. #9 Think again
(01.09.07)
If they really cared about their prisoners as much as we do, they would gladly return one, prisoner in exchange for one prisoner, isn’t the fact that we traditionally do everything possible to get our boys back, and they don’t, proof enough? Is one Israeli soldier really worth 1000 Palestinians? (In the eyes of the Palestinians?) They, themselves make the world think little of them, they should say, that every life has the same value… but they don’t, they are outright stating the obvious, Israelis are worth more than Palestinians, actually in a 1 to 1000 ratio… What do you think about that?
11. Die if you must. But, dont ever get captured.
Johnson ,   USA   (01.09.07)
12. KIDNAPING SHALIT SHOWS REAL FACE OF HAMAS
AN MARIA ,   LATIN AMERICA   (01.09.07)
HAMAS ARE NOT A POLITICAL PARTY BUTA TERRORIST GROUP.
13. # 10 I will tell you what I think about
Rami ,   Ramllah   (01.09.07)
Have the Palestinans obtained 1/100 of your millitary arsenal and I will change the whole ratio for you ; one Pals for one millions Israelis. So stop being silly and get the hell out of here..
14. Isn't It Obvious: Shalit Is Dead
emanon ,   USA   (01.09.07)
Don't you get it? Any pretense about negotiation of a release always breaks down. Then new series of proposals are made, the sma old one actually. Fact is, the terrorists have nothing to bargain with! Remember, the goal of terrorism is to spread terror. One of the first roads to terror is anarchy and the shortest path to anarchy is through uncertainty. By driving this wedge of uncertainty into Jews everywhere, the road to anarchy is being paved. Admit it, Shalit and the other kidnapped soldiers are dead. Now lets move on and unite against the terrorists. Fatah, Hamas and the related factions have no place in Israel, no place in the Middle East. Let's keep it that way.
15. #8
Hilda ,   USA   (01.09.07)
Of course they care. They want them so they have a new supply of suicide bombers.
16. #11 die or get captured, isn't there another option ?
(01.10.07)
Back to article