News
Paris: Jewish youths suspected of hate crime
Shirly Sitbon
Published: 11.01.07, 00:10
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
48 Talkbacks for this article
31. Meir of Arad
charles ,   petach tikva   (01.11.07)
What was Jay doing there ? walking as a tourist , taking pictures as all tourist do everywhere , is this a reason to be attacked ? You are as this Charidi child , begalut , i was talking to in Yddish , and who asked me if i was Jewish because i do not wear a kippa . And even a non Jew , has he to be attacked ? Is this what you teach your children ? With your ideas you do not promote tolerance towards you . I think , and hope , you are an isolated one with such disgusting ideas .
32. Stephane in France
charles ,   petach tikva   (01.11.07)
Lets say you are right . That the JDL youth protect the rue des Rosiers . But is this a reason to insult a Mauritian driver ? Is this a reason to attack a peacefully tourist ? And finally , i'm sure , that for the French police it's no problem to have some flics in this street on sunday . This is not dangerous for them ,as in other parts of Paris . In other countrys of Europe , no more pro Jewish as in France , There is police presence and protection . No JDL needed everywhere .
33. I can't believe some comments I'm reading here...
Uriel ,   Europe   (01.11.07)
There are people here who ACTUALLY CONDONE ATTACK ON A PERSON whose ONLY crime was that he had ARAB LOOK! So, can anybody, like that Kyle (who lives cowardly in USA, and not in Israel, although he is "very big Jew"), tell me one thing: if there were news like "A guy attacked in the middle of Paris, just because he had Jewish look", we would all be up our toes! And if somebody would say "So what, hey, it's just a Jew" "It's not much, he just compared him with..." "it's good that there are people like that guys, Jews wouldn't enter our neighbouhoods", we would scream our asses out! And asked for explanation why they think like that, eveybody would say "It's O.K. that this Jew is beaten, THEY beat Arabs, so..." If WE are in first rows crying out that NOBODY SHOULD GENERALIZE, that one rotten tomatoe does not constitute WHOLE BOX OF ROTTEN TOMATOES, why do we not put it in practice? How come that I see people crying their asses out when it comes to THEIR human rights here, but totally ignoring some INOCENT'S right? Remember, that driver IS NOT HAMMAS! That driver is A GUY WITH MOUSTACHES! Nothing else! I dare Ynet to post this...
34. How come that majority of racist remarks come from Diaspora?
Ari ,   Tel Aviv   (01.11.07)
Been reading comments for some time now and most of the hard-core racist and hate-based remarks come from galut. Dear all, please, gather your guts and make allyah, don't give me the crap about "sitting in back, cheering and supporting" - come here and take the heat like rest of us.
35. Hooliganism in amy form
philippa ,   South Africa   (01.11.07)
Holliganism & thuggery in any form should be kept weher it belongs - in prison.
36. #3 and ' 15
Rustum ,   London, UK   (01.11.07)
What a load of drivel you write on a daily basis. The dreamworld of Southpark has produced one dimwit of stellar proportions. Give it a break lad. Everyone is sick of reading your moronic comments, day in day out. You are sick.
37. The usual crowd of talkback crybabies
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (01.11.07)
Muslim gangbangers in France have burned thousands of cars, burned down entire "estates," there are whole neighborhoods where the gendarmes are afraid to enter. However according to #33, #34, #35, #36 making fun of some guy's mustache is a far worse "racist" crime.
38. JDL & Beitar
NYC Girl   (01.11.07)
So, according to this French shopkeeper, it's only the Jewish youths who come in groups every week that are frightening the clientele. But, seemingly, the people who are described as belonging to a "black anti-Semitic supremacist group" don't scare anybody? One would certainly think that a bunch of black Nazi thugs would scare the hell out of a lot of people.
39. rustum
charles ,   petach tikva   (01.11.07)
Well DO NOT READ THEM . If Kyle is sick , what are you ? Your tb : return to sender .
40. #36
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (01.11.07)
People log in to YNet just in order to read my excellent talkbacks. You are just jealous.
41. kyle your # 40
charles ,   petach tikva   (01.11.07)
And you believe this ? Exellent ? let me laugh .
42. @Kyle
Jonas ,   SAD   (01.11.07)
Remind me that when sombody in Europe spits in some Jew's face and says that he stinks, and you start your "great comments here", that I remind you "Oh, there are people dying all around the world, what's the fuzz about some spitting and some smell-comments". Jerk.
43. Southpark
Rustum ,   London, UK   (01.11.07)
Actually, your comments are the perfect mirror image of the classical anti semite - I believe someone here mentioned that your unwholesome drivel could come straight from the pages of the Protocols of the Elders of Mekka. What you cannot distinguish, dear man, is the difference between anti-goy hatred with exudes from your every pore, and anti-Semitism. They are simply two sides of the same coin - both as odious, both as damnable. There is no simple statement that matches your philosophy such as "anti-Jewish hatred is bad" but "anti-goy hatred is okay because they are asking for it". The simplistic level of historical ignorance, or the racist arrogance which your posts display time and time again, mark you out as a bigotted, ignorant red-neck of the knee jerk variety which not one whit of learning but one hellofa big mouth which spews out parastic and prejudiced faeces at every single opportunity. Your track record in defending the Jewish youths who beat up a Mauritian drive ("I love the smell of burning Citroens") really shows us taht your posts should be immediately trashed in that big can marked "racist garbage, ignore".
44. Spitting and smell comments
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (01.11.07)
"Spitting and smell comments" are so much worse than car burning, gang rape, torture-murders, burning down whole neighborhoods, and waging war against the entire police force, please explain exactly how much worse it is. SAD=Sorry Ass Dimwit
45. Kyle your # 44
charles ,   petach tikva   (01.11.07)
No those are not much worser than the crimes you cite . But , out of one they were not antisemite . Jews have suffered enough in history for having to refrain to be racists . And those laughing because this guy looked as saddam , were acting as racists , and that is disgusting .
46. #37 Kyle..
Lynne   (01.12.07)
burning cars is a violent action yes.. but it is not racist!! insulting someone for his Arab looks is not violent (though I'd catedorise it as verbal abuse) but it definitly is racist!! Muslims who were burning cars in France were doing it in order to obtain their rights as French citizens (not that I agree with the irresponsible method they used) where is the racism in this? in fact the racism is from the French government that mistreats its citizens according to their ethnicities.. but a racist remark is racist whoever said it!! and the fact that Muslims have burnt cars in France does not justify the fact that those Jewish boys said a racist remark!! so please don't try to use other people's mistakes as a veil that covers the ugliness of your own mistakes!!
47. Q: What do Irv Rubin...
jjohnson ,   Turks & Caicos   (01.12.07)
...Earl Krugel, and Meir Kahane all have in common? A: They're all dead, kaput, murdered, suicided. These JDL clowns can't even defend themselves much less the 'Jews.'
48. is that Anti-Semetic since Arabs r Semites.
!.5 Billion Muslims   (01.12.07)
Reality Check , World
Previous talkbacks
Back to article