News
Abbas: No to state with temporary borders
Ali Waked, Ramallah
Published: 11.01.07, 14:48
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
35 Talkbacks for this article
1. Now He'sOfficially Qualified to get a gov. ministry post
concerned citizen ,   nyc   (01.11.07)
Or at least a VIP dinner invite with Blo Mert. Plus he'll collect travel expenses & accomadations in ramalah.
2. Fatah Ralley
Eve Nissen ,   Rehovot, Israel   (01.11.07)
Ahmad Tibi, as a member of Knesset, The israeli Parliament, Should be charged with treason and jailed for supporting an organisation that expounds the destruction of the state of Israel. No other sovereign country would tolerate any member of its own parliament who pushes for the destruction of that country.We must be mad for allowing him to walk around freely and encourage those who are bent on our destruction. Israelis, Jews and all others who are loyal to the state of Israel, Wake up!!!!
3. How can this man belong to Israel's Knesset?
Keren ,   SP-now in Israel   (01.11.07)
Can somebody explain to me ,please?
4. Traitors like tibi will soon be compensated
Arie ,   Afula   (01.11.07)
for their treason!
5. When will he be stripped of his citizenship ! Enough already
redmike ,   tel aviv   (01.11.07)
He talks about 'we say to the Israelis' .. 'them' and 'they' etc - he obviously feels Palestinian and not Israeli ! He should be granted his wish - NOW!
6. tibi!!!
fish ,   t-a   (01.11.07)
Here we go again! Tibi, an Israeli MKs openly calls for an enemy entity to fight Israel, the country of which he's a parliament member! If this is not HIGH TREASON, I don't know what else is. Will he be prosecuted? I doubt very much. Though it was okay for the police to prosecute Liebermann after he said something about a police chief in his inner circle. Sometimes I fell like screaming - WHERE DO I LIVE? WHY HAS THIS COUNTRY ABANDONED ME? Calling for release of Bargouti, prepsenting himself as a Palestinian, despite the fact that he holds Israeli citizenship, how long else will it go on? He wants all "Pal-s lands to be freed'? But that means openly calling for war with Israel! Send him to live to Ramallah, strip him of his citizenship, do something! This is so sick!
7. Declarations of war and treason
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (01.11.07)
How much more proof do you need that 1) Abbas, just like Hamas, wants Israel completely destroyed and 2) Tibi is a traitor who belongs in jail. That's right, keep watching the "settler" video, a Jewish and Arab woman catfight is so much more "threatening" to the peace of the country than PEOPLE WHO WANT TO FREAKING MURDER US.
8. SO WHAT DOES JIMMY CARTER HAVE TO SAY - APARTEID ???
Andrew ,   miami,fl   (01.11.07)
9. tibi
fish   (01.11.07)
This punk Tibi is so unhappy about everything in Israel, he attacked border policemen several times, he serves a s a rebel -rouser for local Arab community, he praises Arafat on every corner, and was his personal adviser, now he openly calls for war with Israel. As his actions directly and indrectly are translated into more terror against Israel and her citizens, will he be ever punished by the country which he fights against with such a zeal?Or he'll get away defiant as usual with merely a slap on his wrist? I can't stand it anymore.
10. Palestinians need to learn how to ....
DR ,   Florida, USA   (01.11.07)
COMPROMISE!!! I don't believe that world is in their vocabulary and it always seems that its either everything or nothing at all with them. Their false claim to the land and their violence and terror do not show anything even close to compromise and peace.
11. a matter of definition
tom ,   toronto, canada   (01.11.07)
what is the israeli definition of "treason" and is it different for arabs and jews? (the "liberation of palestine" is the arab euphemism for the destruction of israel. celebrating fatah's 42nd birthday "gives away the game", because fatah, the movement to "liberate palestine", was founded 3 years before the six-day war - in other words, before the "occupation" even happened! it is an absolutely classic case of the jihadists' confusion between cause and effect.)
12. Moot Point: They Won't Get ANY Kind Of State
Yishai Kohen ,   YeShA, Israel   (01.11.07)
Not here in OUR land. So who cares what these terrorists say?
13. "No to temporary brders", and I say ..
Connie ,   VA, USA   (01.11.07)
no to giving away Jerusalem.
14. Tibi is a traitor....jail him now!!!!!!
freejay ,   Israel   (01.11.07)
15. Where oh where
israeli racist ,   Judea   (01.11.07)
are the commie-bolsheviks, michael steiner, and the haifa reds with their comments...... oh I forgot their on the Hevron talkback worrying about their friends in the hamas city of arab hevron............go tell BTSELEM ABOUT THESE PICTURES
16. No To Any State Except State of War
Terry ,   Eilat - Israel   (01.11.07)
We should forget the whole idea of peace. I'm getting tired of even hearing the word. All I want to hear from our gov't is how are we going to win the war.
17. Expel him from the government and strip his citizenship
Dawn   (01.11.07)
Let Mr. Tibi be in the Palistinain government!! I can't belive he is still here. We are such floor rags.
18. But a 'temporary hudna' is OK!
Arie ,   Afula   (01.11.07)
19. tibi,abbas, hamas
fish ,   t-a   (01.11.07)
Now all the cards are open, and all the masks are torn off.Does anybody need any proof who Israel is against? Tibi, Abbas, Hamas - they're all enemies of this country and as such they have to be dealt with. Frankly, if I ever hear the words "peace negotiations", "land for peace", "peace camp", " enemies of peace ( meaning people in their sound mind)" " painful concessions in the name of peace ( this is particularly disgusting, as it means -Some Israelis will be killed, maybe tens, maybe hundreds, maybe several thousands, in the name of peace"), I'm gonna kick somebody's ass, nice and hard. It's time the legal system of this country stopped serving left-wing idiots, and protected its rank-and-file citizens.
20. (on homepage)I love that Abbas Picture
Mike ,   Israel   (01.11.07)
He looks like he's giving birth to nation. Fists clinched, pushing, pushing, telling Arafat that he'll never let him touch like that again. Classic.
21. abbas? might as well negotiate with Krusty the clown
aaron ,   ra'anana   (01.11.07)
both have the same influence on the palestinians and on the terrorists.
22. The myth of palestine
Chaya ,   Bat Yam, Israel   (01.11.07)
Palestine Liberation Organization executive committee member, Zahir Muhsein said the following in an interview 1977: "The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct "Palestinian people" to oppose Zionism
23. ISRAEL MUST END IT's OCCUPATION TO THE WEST BANK
Michael ,   LA   (01.11.07)
Israel MUST withdraw to the 1967 boarders and leave the Palestinian people to build their state on this land. THAT IS IF ISRAEL IS REALLy SEEKING A LONG LASTING PEACE. But, I personally doubt that Israel is seeking for peace. Israel is always talking and complaining about violence but they never wanted to think about the source of violence. Yes, it's wrong shooting qassams at Israel, it's wrong to blow up resturants in TelAviv, BUT it's also a CRIME to continue occupying 3 million Palsetinians in the west bank because of 200,000 Israel idiots that were pushed by the Israeli Gov to settle in the west bank !!!!
24. And we ok'd sending Abbas 2000 rifles, 1Mil rounds ammo?
Yacov ,   Ashkelon   (01.11.07)
Olmert just approved sending 2000 assault rifles and 1 million rounds of ammunition to Abbas. When is he going to approve sending mortars, anti-tank grenades, and assault rifles to Tibi? Both Tibi and Abbas support destroying Israel and our hack politicians apparently wil help them.
25. Treason
Caroline ,   London   (01.11.07)
Surely this is treason???How sick can it be that this man is even allowed to be in Israel?I suggest that he stops abusing the Israeli welfare system and moves to Ramallah to live with Abbas.ISRAEL-WAKE UP AND KICK HIM OUT!!!!!!
26. #17..Dawn
Barry ,   Canada   (01.11.07)
I agree..he has no business sitting as an MK when he is supporting the enemy..thats called treason.
27. michael from la
fish ,   t-a   (01.11.07)
you ,punk, is an idiot, not 200,000 jews who live in judea.It's "wrong" to blow restaurants with kids in Tel-Aviv? Such a nice word - "wrong"!Thank o very much! How about a Kassam on your head, will you call it "wrong" or will start screaming blue murder in LA? As to yours "MUST" - you yourself live on the occupied land, grabbed from Mexico. I don't seek any "peace" ( this word has already lost it meaning for me), I only want to live in the country where I feel safe, but never for the feeling of safety I'll agree to give away chunks of my land. "If you don't give me your lands - I'll kill you" - this is your " land for peace" formula. It's called blackmail, silly.
28. A house divided....
ilana   (01.11.07)
need I say more?
29. Treason? No Other Country Would Allow It?
Tony ,   Israel   (01.11.07)
That is the price of democracy. You want to say you are a free country with free speech don't you? As for another country allowing such a situation? Gerry Adams of the IRA was a member of the British parliment.
30. to 29
fish   (01.11.07)
yes, Adams was an MP, no wonder UK is going to the dogs.
Next talkbacks
Back to article