News
'Have fewer children' says Israeli millionaire
Tani Goldstein
Published: 24.01.07, 09:32
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
59 Talkbacks for this article
1. 'Have less children' says Israeli millionaire
Jouni Suonsivu ,   Finland   (01.24.07)
Mr. Landa is wrong, totally wrong. Children are the future of Israel (as of any country). Outside Israel everywhere Jewish death rate exceeds birth rate, furthermore, neighbouring Arab states all have an extremely high birth rate. Don't compare with slowly diminishing European nations, for lack of births we have problems and they grow more difficult constantly. Mr. Landa's point of view is solely economic and precisely therefore he errs: economy is for humans, humans not for economy. To be corrected: Sweden's population exceeds the one of Israel.
2. only the one who can nick money can have children
a.v ,   london.uk   (01.24.07)
where is money came from ?
3. What a fruitcake!
BigE ,   Israel   (01.24.07)
4. Dumb, Dumber & Dumbo
Po Boi Roscoe ,   israel   (01.24.07)
This arrogant bastard should be sharing and donating some of his cash horde in order to help Israel's poor, instead of complaining about their needs. It appears the sight of poor jews makes this cretin feel angry because of his own lack of empathy toward them. Or maybe in his elitist "Neo-Philosophy", he's simply jealous of simple, normal people trying to eck out a living and raise their families in this hostile country.
5. the time has come for the freeloaders to start working
(01.24.07)
6. birth rate
amar ,   france   (01.24.07)
He has never read french economist Alfred Sauvy who demonstrates that birh rate is the ground of the growth
7. NEWS FLASH...NOT EVERYTHING REVOLVES AROUND MONEY!!! end
(01.24.07)
8. millionaire = someone with lots of money
wise guy ,   Israel   (01.24.07)
wait one second...so if there are less people in Israel ..who will have a better economy.?.. doest someone have to live to enjoy it? "Yiladim Zeh Bracha" Kids are a blessing. "More money more problems" You dont need to be a millionaire to know this.
9. We Need More Jews, Not Less.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (01.24.07)
Does the gentleman think there are too many Jews? I have the opposite impression - we are a miniscule percentage of the world population. We need political, economic, & educational reform - that's for sure. But lowering our birthrate is not the answer to improving our economy.
10. Sir stay in hi-tech leave the child bearing 2 us!
(01.24.07)
11. Landa and population
jerry ,   USA   (01.24.07)
This is the most superficial piece of reasoning I have ever heard. Brain power is not given to all and procreation is a crap shoot. Where is he going to get the next generation of people to do the creative work that has been Israel's strength. Not everyone can do mathematics and physics. Moreover, who will he get to do the standard work of the country. Will he import cheap Arab labor, which is how the country got into trouble in the first place. Moreover, looking at the population change in Europe, how can he possibly suggest that a declining population translates to political stability. Moreover, what is it that he expects people to do - party and consume. Raising children is a worthy occupation for humans. Moreover, in the extreme case having no children is the way to become really rich, since generation x owes nothing to generation y, since there is no generation y. However, this is not a worthy manner to spend one's limited time on the planet. People have chosen that route as well, but then their genes - no matter how worthy - are gone. Mr. Landa counts wealth in terms of trips to Europe instead of Friday night dinners with the family.
12. Why Israel is not as rich as Sweden
Kate ,   London, UK   (01.24.07)
The reason that Israel is not as rich as Sweden has nothing to do with birth rates. It is everything to do with military expenditures. Israel is compelled to spend over 8% of its GDP on the military. Sweden on the other hand which has not fought a war in two centuries spends only 1% of its GDP on the military. Ditto, more or less, Denmark and Ireland. In addition, Ireland's wealth is to a large degree based on a huge tax dodge. Ireland unlike Israel actually invents and creates very little.
13. pru urvuu
P. Almoni ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (01.24.07)
Pharaoh also thought there were too many Jews. Until the mitzva to "be fruitful and multiply" is abolished (if it ever will be), I will have to ignore the advice of the esteemed gentleman.
14. Benny
Sefardita ,   Stockholm   (01.24.07)
Benny is a rich fool...Is ideas go against the principles of Judiasm. Furthermore, Swedish population is larger than Israel
15. What about demography?
Matthias Roth ,   Switzerland   (01.24.07)
Every once in a while we hear how necessary it is for Israel withdraw to the Auschwitz borders and relocate the settlers inside the green line in order to secure a Jewish majority. And now Mr Landa calls for a limitation of the birthrate. How illogical! Doesn't he know that children are the future of every society, and especially Israel's?
16. NO TO BIRTH CONTROLL
NO TO BIRTH CONTROL ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (01.24.07)
I'm sorry. This Mr. Landa may be a millionaire, but he is very unintelligent!! Birth control is no solution to a National debt. By going forth and being fruitful, we garuntee our Nations future. Also, Many couples who can't concieve have just been insulted. The birthrate in the Israeli-Arab & Palestiniane communites are soaring sky high. What will that add up to when we are faced by an outright majority Muslim Israel. In no way am I saying that in a racist way. I'm just saying life will be even more difficult for the Israeli Nation, if that scenario would take place. If Israel has a low economy, Then build an economy. Mr. Landa should be ashamed of himself. My message to everyone. Go forth, be fruitfull and multiply.
17. How did he become Billionaire?
Gerard ,   LA   (01.24.07)
Strike it lucky! nothing to do with your brains. Irland, Denmark and Sweden are not surrounded by 22 hostile countries, nor they pour all their resources into defending their country from murderous terrorists. If Israel was given a break, it could easily cope with the birthrate ensuring the existence of the Jewish state. And guess what? also doing economically well by all world standards.
18. And he is supposed to be intelligent???
(01.24.07)
SO STUPID!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
19. Ha Ha ... elle est bonne !
avi   (01.24.07)
Merci Roi Dagobert
20. stop brining in so many foreign workers
zionist forever   (01.24.07)
The country should stop bringing in so many non jewissh foreign workers who then have children in Israel and alot the time are given citizenship as a result. Just like everybody else in Israel they need homes, food and to put strains on the health service when they get ill. They are the real burden to the country there are plenty of unemployed Israelis its time for the government to start encouraging them to take these badly paid jobs rather they benefit from it long term in many ways right now there is a culture of bring in foreigners to do the low paid manual work either palestians or from other parts of the world who either stay and settle in Israel or when they are ready to go home they te the money out of the country which damages the economy. They are all bad news for Israels economy and facilities So get rid of the foireigners not the jews we need jewish population growth.
21. Don't include the seculars in this speech
(01.24.07)
You need to speak to the Haredim.
22. Slowing down birth rate!!!??? Wrong attitude !
Isaac Haskiya ,   Roskilde - Denmark   (01.24.07)
No. Create more businesses and industries instead, both small and big. Promote local investors. Promote education. Promote business morals. Pay correct salaries. Encourage exports, even for low-tech goods. Trim the production apparatus. Think global. Be positive . Adopt a life philosophy with less money .Make babies too. Read the good book!
23. We still have not recovered from the Holocaust!
jason white ,   afula,israel   (01.24.07)
We lost a third of our people.And this brain wants to cut the birth rate? What should be cut is these moronic conferences. It is better that the political and business leaders in this country shut up and maybe we will not know that they are so stupid!
24. Economically speaking, he's half-right
Jeff ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (01.24.07)
Economically speaking, the wrong population has the high birth rate. Secular Israelis -- i.e. those as a class who are integrated into the economy -- have a lower birth rate than the dati, i.e. those who largely remain outside of the economy through fulltime "work" in the yeshiva, receive welfare, live off charity, etc. 10, 20, 30 years from now, the percentage of those who work and contribute to the economy will grow smaller and smaller, while the percentage of those who live off of others will increase. Interesting times ahead for Israel...
25. Just cuz you're rich doesn't mean you're ...
JPS ,   Efrat   (01.24.07)
...smart. If I were an HP shareholder I'd be worried about a guy who thinks like this running a company like Indigo. This is a guy who is stuck inside his box and doesn't appear to be able to think outside of it - not a good management trait at all. Cutting the birthrate will do nothing to solve the existing problem of a large population of young people who need to be integrated into the workforce. The education system in Israel stinks bigtime. Business has almost no connection to the pre-university education system, but Landa blithely ignores that key problem. He seems to forget that economies are driven by a complex mix of private and public interests, and Landa has to work with that whether he likes it or not. No matter how many factories you open, you still need roads, schools, sewers, hospitals, and other public infrastructure - and a major portion of the population works there. For a solution he should start at the bottom and work his way up - not start with what appears to be a desire to lower the number of people in his town who have less money than he does.
26. Act like Jews
Sidney ,   USA   (01.24.07)
End the corruption both in government and the private sector. Put the free loaders to work. Stop following the philosophy of Ayn Rand, which is also destroying the middle class in the U.S. . Then Israel will leave Scandanavia and Ireland in their wake.
27. Birthrates
JOhn ,   Amsterdam, Holland   (01.24.07)
He's mesjogge! Israel needs Jewish (rising) birthrates. The number of 2.86 as a fertility rate is not high enough if you ask me! I think I know what Mr. Landa means. But if we lower the birthrate he can say goodbye to his Israeli villa, since then, he'll be too scared living, surrounded by only Israeli ARABS. There IS a demographic danger, if we lower it. Can't wait having my own (big) Orthodox Jewish family! But I would like to serve the Israeli army and I hope my kids will do so, aswell! Lehotra'ot!
28. he obviously hasn't read the latest IMF report or Fisher's
redmike ,   tel aviv - Israel   (01.24.07)
to say nothing that raising the Jewish birthrate is considered almost a must according to almost 100% of research and even those who don't talk of raising it want to maintain it. This guy should go back to making money as he has a better grasp on it than reality, demographics or economics .. economics as against photography or hi-tech ..
29. Pharoh also wanted to limit the birthrate
Arty ,   Raanana, Isral   (01.24.07)
History is full of villians trying to 'limit' the size of the Jewish population. That Benny Landa can propose such an evil idea, denegrates him and any company that he is associated with.
30. Why be like Europe?
Matt ,   England   (01.24.07)
Europe is trying this already. They are being outbred quite rapidly by Muslims. Quite apart from that, they face the problem of a bigger tax bill every year (thanks to statist/socialist governments being elected year in, year out). So fewer people of working age exist to pay for the wants and needs of an ever-growing number of people who don't work. No wonder so many Europeans are leaving. Someone said "Don't include the seculars in this speech - You need to speak to the Haredim." Why do you think it is clever to have fewer children than the Haredim? If you think your way of life is worth preserving, you have to have enough children for it to continue. But instead, hand-wringing 'seculars' will maintain they've done the right thing by having one child, even as virtually the only young people they see are religious. 'Secularism' of this type is little more than cultural suicide.
Next talkbacks
Back to article