News
'Renew animal sacrifices on Mount' says radical rabbi
Yaakov Lappin
Published: 01.03.07, 19:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
121 Talkbacks for this article
1. Let's start with the politicians
Marcell ,   Israel   (03.01.07)
2. This guy neeeds to resume taking his medication.
What a ,   Nut   (03.01.07)
3. good start
haim ,   mtl canada   (03.01.07)
until we rebuilD the TEMPLE WHO CARES WHT THEY SAY LET THEM GET HIGH AGAIN
4. Forget the moslems, wait till PETA hears about this.
Allan ,   US   (03.01.07)
5. Total idiots
Sidney ,   USA   (03.01.07)
6. THIS IS FORBIDDEN. NO QUESTION ABOUT IT.
Daniel ,   New York   (03.01.07)
7. Why all this blood and violence?
Allen   (03.01.07)
8. #1- Love your comment!
Arthur ,   S Francisco   (03.01.07)
9.  BUILD THIRD TEMPLE NOW & SAVE ERETZ ISRAEL !!!
AVINU   (03.01.07)
TO SAVE ERETZ YSRAEL BUILD THIRD TEMPLE NOW !!!!!!!
10. Is this radical Rabbi mad ? of Xtian Messianic like
ben ,   singapore   (03.01.07)
Benny Hin ? Appoint a King ? He still want to reject Ha Shem the Malik, and want another King ? Someone please teach him ! :0
11. slanderous fringe reporting
Nathan ,   Montreal, Canada   (03.01.07)
Your reporter shows either horrible ignorance or vile prejudice referring to the members of the Sanhedrin as "radical" & "fringe." Rabbi Steinsaltz, for example, is one of the most respected leaders of mainstream orthodox Judaism. Perhaps your reporter's bias makes him consider anyone who promotes Torah to be radical or fringe. Maybe it's time I realized Ynet is more radical left than I thought. If this reporting is representative, Ynet should no longer be my main source of Israel news
12. Why does Ynet publish stories about loopy backward ideas?
Pls. tell me they're ,   kidding, USA   (03.01.07)
If the supposed Jewish authorities have such retarded, antiquated views, they have no right to criticize the Muslims and call them backward. Religious zealots of any creed are harmful for democracy. Fringe group or not, Ynet should not give these weirdos a forum to inflame Muslim passions again. Enough is enough!
13. Animal Sacrifices !
Atilla Karagözoğlu   (03.01.07)
we have done all things right !!! now lets talk about the subject. I get angry on all stupid subjects. Why I am not a God. I dont know why I get too much upset on humanity stupidty. Maybe I am a God ! It must be a reason me to get that angry. Listen up, MY Humans ! you should better cut your thing ! instead having losing time for this unnecessary subjects. I feel hungry, now. I love beef. big piece and if I have a few cold beers also, look at me how nice I write. We were too poor family. 4 kids. My Father was a teacher. we use to not have even one kilogram meat for two weeks. I am okey now. I can buy anything I want. But I am, MY EYES always hungry about meat. what was the subject, anyway :) My Ynet : Do me a favor. Look for the writer her name ORIT. give her a job here. I want to read her. Thanks buddy. You know I love you. sure, publish this :) My Ynettttttttttttt :)
14. He isn't so "radical"
Abdullah ,   EuMe   (03.01.07)
He talsk about building the beit hamikdash at a time when muslims agree to this. That is not radical at all. In that he shows respect to muslims.
15. Not Unill the Moshiach is here!
Miriam ,   Yerushalyim   (03.01.07)
What kinda Rabbi Is this? the Temple can only be Rebuilt under certain conditions, and one of them Being thecomming of the Messiah.
16. Can you emagine the picture...
Oleg ,   USA   (03.01.07)
The messiah arrives and says: "Thank you for slaughtering animals. Follow me to the Paradise".
17. Why the f*** are all people here who support this nutcases..
Uriel ,   Tel Aviv   (03.01.07)
... some "canadian jews" or some diaspora "hardliners". F+++ off, come here, be here hardliners! It's quite easy to bust your chest when you are away from the danger!
18. THIS JEW IS DISGUSTED TO HEAR THIS - GET RID OF SDHRN
andrew ,   miami,fl   (03.01.07)
19. # 13
Rocky ,   Brooklyn, USA   (03.01.07)
is ORIT from II ? you know one of the Israeli news paper ?
20. #1 - Marcell - Good suggestion ! :-)
Tracy W   (03.01.07)
21. Better they should cut off their own hands
Steven ,   San Francisco   (03.01.07)
Rather than victimize animals in the name of superstition.
22. Menachem Begin freed religious Jews from military service...
Look at them today   (03.01.07)
Look at them today. Some talk about animal sacrifices, some support Ahmadinejad and all others smoke :-)
23. Rocky !
(03.01.07)
you are 100 % right. man. Atilla karagözoğlu :) Note: They used to call me as Rocky when I was in states. I love Israeli newspapers. specially one of them called as II, it means Israelinsider :))) it was my first love. we dont love eachother anymore. simple life :)
24. Miriam and Oleg, #15 & # 16
Atilla karagözoğlu   (03.01.07)
I am Him.
25. Reply to ben - 10.
James ,   Glasgow, Scotland   (03.01.07)
Ben, Christians know that the Temple is but a figure or type for the great temple in Zion that is God Himself. No longer needed the one you hope to build will not bring back the Messiah nor will animal sacrifice save any as it never did before. Why do you think God only ever kept a remnant from each generation? Simply because you rely on religion and law, the enemy of faith and grace, the only things that can save any. Zion is a heavenly place as is the hope of all the children of the promise. Why do you think Moses was not allowed to enter the land? Because he saw a better place and it is not an earthly place.
26. JUST LOTS OF FOREIGN IDEAS MEDIATED FROM CHRISTIANS!
HaDaR ,   Israel   (03.01.07)
JUST LOTS OF FOREIGN IDEAS MEDIATED FROM CHRISTIANS OR HINDUS OR BUDDHISTS... That's what all this hypocritical indignation is all about. SIMPLE IGNORANCE OF TORAH-TRUE JUDASIM... And, there are news also from Miriam in Jerusalem: it's ABSOLUTE NONSENSE WITHOUT ANY BASIS IN TORAH to say that it will happen only after Mashaich!
27. Rocky, Yes your honor. You are right.
(03.01.07)
28. ANIMAL SACRIFICES
tom ,   OGDEN UTAH, USA   (03.01.07)
PROOF AGAIN THAT THERE ARE NUTS IN EVERY RELIGION
29. PETA
Tracy W   (03.01.07)
PETA has flatly refused to even mention the annual Eid Al Adha Muslim celebration where hundreds of thousands of calves, goats, sheep and other animals brutally slaughtered worldwide. Although about three years ago they had a campaign against cruel Kosher methods in a particular American slaughterhouse, they now have totally refused to deal with this Islamic issue. Maybe PETA has persuasive financial contributors that don't want criticism. As long as no animal sacrifice occurs in Israel, I don't expect PETA to say anything, but It's been all over the news, CNN included. Animal sacrifices may be part of tradition, but many people realize that the way to honor G-d should be a constructive one, not one where the life of an innocent animal is taken to cleanse somebody's sins. By the way, I'm vegetarian.
30. will the 'new' Sanhedrin build on the 'old' ?
avi   (03.01.07)
if so, it would be better not to have reconstituted such a shame of an institution which excommuniated G.od in the trial of Eliezer Ben Hyrcanos (...) and gave weigh to the first exile for not reprimanding King Salomon, and so much more ...
Next talkbacks
Back to article