News
Former Meretz leader decries 1967 war crimes
Roee Nahmias
Published: 03.03.07, 14:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
52 Talkbacks for this article
31. 3,000 Egyptian captives were killed. This is a true statemen
Palestinian   (03.03.07)
Sarid knows what he is talking about. Arabs never massacred Jews as mentioned by some people here! Even when Israelie civilians are targeted. This has been after Israel repeatedly killed childrens and Women... How many Palestinian civilian died before 1987? There were no arms with the Palestinians before 1987? But yet, Israel have killed thousands of them! When the Palestinian uprising in 1987 started, Israeld killed hunderds of unarmed Palestinians.. It took the Palestinians 35 years after the 1867 war to fight back by attacking Israeli civilians in 1993. You need people to look in the mirror. There is not justification for oppression. There is no justification for occupation. Judaism cannot be used for Jewish Holy war "Zionism" on the Palestinians. http://www.ifamericansknew.org/
32. Rivera 1
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (03.04.07)
You know, in your mentality and in others like you, there's a blocked mind so insanely naive, so completely ignorant, that it seems impossible to penetrate. When this guy is quoted as saying: "When it comes on television all the Arabs are shouting and clapping and screaming with joy as they see a bus blown up, people dying. They are in our hospitals; we're treating them, and they are rejoicing because of the murder of Jews." Let me ask these questions please. Who are all the Arabs? As far as I last counted and assessed, not all the Arabs in the world were portrayed on TV. My other question is, have you ever met and reaslly known and understood any Arab or Muslim? What do you know about Arabs other than what you choose to hear? For your information, Jewish attitude to Judaism is like Muslim attitude to Islam.In fact, I never yet saw a religion whose people did not think their religion was the best and most truthful. Please, as I said earlier, when a Muslim puts a knife to your neck to get you to convert let me know. I am 100% against terrorists, and people who kill innocents indiscriminately. But at the same time, I know that terrorism is sometimes an extreme measure born of extreme agony The problem with you is that you are afraid, you are afraid of what you don't understand and don't want to understand. I have a question for you which I asked once before, but my TKBK was not posted. If I wanted to learn about Judaism, could you refer me to a good source? Why am I asking this question? Because if I was honestly searching for truth Id darn well be sure of where I looked for it.
33. If I remember correctly
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (03.04.07)
when Lebanese authorities admitted there were no chemical weapons used in the summer war (we'll leave the validity of statament aside) a lot of people said that it took a lot of guts to admit to a mistake. Everytime some person or the other admits to a flaw in Israeli tactics, he is a loonie leftie or a self-hater, or a jew hater, or all of the above. Immediately you start saying, "oh but what about in the year so and so when sos and so Jews were killed". You're missing the point entirely, and ur whole attitude is the psychological remnant of a post-holocaust era you have failed to cure urselves from. But this illness is making you hate everyone in the world. This sickness is making you see every single human's fault but your own. The Zionists on this website who have ever said a good word about speakers of this sort are almost non-existant. They will never see the truth, never see that there are always 2 sides to the coin. How can you not see that in ur fanatic pursuit of what u believe to be a holy right you are doing everything that is not holy. Where is it that you follow the 10 commandments, the most important: Thou shalt not steal, thou shalt not kill. Look to urselves first if u are so keen on being the exemplary nation in the ME.
34. Israel Cannot Survive the Left
Jerry ,   NYC, USA   (03.04.07)
The enemy is within.
35. why you are accusing him ??
(03.04.07)
It's the Israeli TV who showed this document film and he just confirmed it , why you want the people to lai for you ? everyone is free to say what his sole and his relegion and God asked him to say ... the man didn't lai he said the truth , he want to meet God with less sins like Jimmy Carter , till when you want to escape , your black history is withness against you , insted of attaking the others and asking everyone to lai for your favour repare your self and try to repare what you destroyed in the last 100 years ... when the day comes you can not say to God i am Jew can not be punish ... there we are all the same only who was good and who not ... and Sarid wanted to clean his hand and his sole before his day comes .
36. Sue Yossy SOB for slander!!!!!!!!
Rehavam ,   Israel   (03.03.07)
NOBODY care about scandrel Sarid in Israel. this way he get attantion! Moslims will love him... ;(
37. Dear old Yossi
mark ,   raanana israel   (03.04.07)
It's entirely incorrect to call Sarid self hating in fact he has been carrying on a passionate love affair with himself for years. Jew-hating Israeli hating? Yes but self hating...?
38. another major Erev Rav figure has spoken
Yisraeli   (03.04.07)
39. @31 lol Palestinians had no arms before 1987?
Suzanne   (03.04.07)
So I guess the Munchen attack in 1972 e.g. happened in a parallel universe where Palestinians had arms?
40. Sarid & His 'Victims'. Another Way The Left Plots To Destroy
Adina Kutnicki ,   US   (03.04.07)
The real war crime should be those Israelis who give succor to Israel's enemies. Whether or not these shootings are true, does any Jew think that Eqyptian captives shouldn't have been executed? Afterall, wasn't Egypt plotting to kill as many Jews as possible, Sarid included? War is hell. Deal with it!
41. Revolting Sarid is a Defiler of Jewish people and a traitor
Jorge ,   Tegucigalpa   (03.04.07)
It is revolting beyond words that an "Israeli" like Sarid can speak the way he does about the IDF and Israel, in 1967 Israel and the Jewish people were fighting for survival agains massed enemies bent on destroying Israel and all (I MEAN ALL) Jews Living in Israel, had they prevailed a second holocaust in a generation would have occured, and this traitor(sorry, but there is no other way to call a man bent on purpously harming Israel) could not go on without consecuenses harming Israel and by his utterances aiding the enemy. DEMOCRACY HAS TO HAVE LIMITS
42. we have our moonbats too
(03.04.07)
43. Passing judgement
DavidE ,   USA   (03.04.07)
Look, the Arabs planned to kill all the Jews in the State of Israel and bragged about it. First, there is no real evidence that such an event ever took place. There was no policy of killing Arab prisoners. No Israeli prisoners were returned after the 1948 war. Second, things happen in wartime. If you think someone is armed, you shoot. I am tired of this second guessing. Third, you have to stop thinking like those Jimmy Carter-worshipping Norwegians. What the hell has their focus on their own sins gotten them in the past 30 years. A bunch of Somali and Arab rapists running around Oslo just grabbing women off the street. Trucks being stopped by robbers. Its insane. Instead of defending yourself, you start focusing on your sins. Its sickening.
44. The Truth about Israel's Atrocities....
lala ,   Australia   (03.04.07)
1/1/2001 "The Zionist troops of occupation killed five Palestinians, including two children: 1. Abdul-Rahman Khaled (4 years), from Nablus. Shot in the neck. 2. Mu’adh Abou Wahdan (10 years), from Hebron. Killed when two shell shrapnels hit his head. 3. Tareq Ibrahim A1-Qat’ (30 years), from Tulkarm. Lieutenant in the PNSF. His body was mutilated. 4. Mu’taz Muhammad Sa’eed Srooji (37 years), from Tulkarm. Lieutenant in the PNSF. He was killed and mutilated. 5. Tahreer Suleiman Rizq (22 years), from Hazma / Jerusalem. Shot in the head."
45. Just what we needed....
David ,   Israel   (03.04.07)
Meretz.... why in the hell!?!?! When are we going to stop collectively screwing ourselves? It is high time we starting helping ourselves and each other, and worry less about our behavior 40 years ago against several armies that sought our destruction. It was only about 20 Get real Sarid - go live in Egypt you idiot, because that is what you are trying to turn Israel into.
46. Sarid wants to free Baghruti
Ilan ,   Ariel   (03.04.07)
Sarid doesn't seem to feel so strongly about war crimes when it comes to Palestinian terror against Israelis or else how to explain his facile rationalizations for freeing Marwan Barghruti? Rather this should be seen in the light of Sarid's contempt toward Rabin up to the moment that he accepted the Meretz peace plan. For Sarid, history is meant to be changed to fit his agenda.
47. Once a slanderer, always a slanderer
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (03.04.07)
48. Let Egypt ask, ask long as they're prepared for reciprocity
David ,   Rehovot   (03.04.07)
As long as Israel can demand compensation not only for soldiers killed, but also for the full costs of the war Egypt waged against Israel's existence for decades. If they're willing to do that, sure, we'll discuss compensation.
49. Egypt never forgets her blood
Masry ,   Nile   (03.04.07)
Egypt never forgets the revenge for her blood. Uncle sam salvaged you in Yum Kippor from Egypt's hand, but uncle sam will not intervene in the ME in the next 20 years! Egypt really should arm the 5 million palestinains and they will screw you big time!
50. 49/ ur ass is done with u
f'l 'ah ,   masri   (03.04.07)
cuz he's smarter than ur hatred.
51. is it difficult too!!!
AGABY   (03.05.07)
he says punishing war criminals after 40 years is difficult. well what about punishing the Nazis after more than 60 years is it difficult too!!! even an 'honest' man from Israel who dared to codemn the inhuman deed still have DOUBLE STENDARDS.
52. Will Sarid apologize for his lie. There was no massacre
Ken Jurist   (03.07.07)
Read this article, which goes into detail how this is the latest massacre lie by the Arabs. Go to google and type in. False Israeli "Massacre" Story Resurrected, Alex Safian. Even the director of the film says he never said Israel killed any Egyptian POWS. Why does Sarid continues his lies. It shows more and more how the left has become deranged and will believe any Arab lie. Sarid probably believes 4000 Jews didn't show up at the WTC on September 11th. If Sarid wants to investigate something, its the 19 Kurdish women they abducted from Iraqi Kurdistan during the Anfal killings in 89 to be used as sex slaves in Egypt. The women till this day have not been heard from.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article